Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
(11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)HDerek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
Agree to a point but they were working with different tools and a different aim
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
We look like a side who are solid and well organised despite our defensive injuries who also seem to have every attacking player bang out of form. Not sure why it needs the inquest, let alone questioning of the best manager we've had since Hodgson.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-08-2024, 09:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)HDerek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
Agree to a point but they were working with different tools and a different aim
They were also working at a level far higher and with a much bigger disparity of resources between many of the clubs they were competing with. I don’t particularly see that as an argument as reason for the different standards we are setting for managers in terms of results.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-08-2024, 10:03 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-08-2024, 10:08 AM by Josh1873.)
(11-08-2024, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)HDerek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
Agree to a point but they were working with different tools and a different aim
They were also working at a level far higher and with a much bigger disparity of resources between many of the clubs they were competing with. I don’t particularly see that as an argument as reason for the different standards we are setting for managers in terms of results.
Like I said in the other Fred, I agree with your point. But it's not difficult to understand why CC is being shown more patience than a ridiculous, money saving appointment, that no one wanted and a poisonous horrible individual who we spent years disliking during his tenure at Stoke.
Also, CC is a better manager than Pulis and Irvine. We're also in a good league position and we're not looking like losing games. I also believe fans with more than one brain cell can see we're not far away from being a very good side. We need a bit of luck, confidence and players to find form. It's not as if we're being outplayed every week.
We don't need a complete turnaround. It's not as if our squad is rubbish and unbalanced. The players are, to a man, giving 100% every match. We need a slight tweak. Nothing more. Nothing less.
We're also WBA. We will go on winless runs. We're not Man City. If dominating and winning every week is what the brain dead booing brigade expect, then sod off and support City.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(11-08-2024, 08:41 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (11-08-2024, 07:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm not sure there should be an argument over a poster calling out the idiocy of 'fans' booing at FT last night.
It's Villa levels of arrogance and impatience. And yes, I'd call anyone that booed last night an idiot. It's not needed. It's not warranted. It's just ridiculous. Utter morons.
Do we really have a section of our fan base that expects us to go a whole 46 game season without a poor run of form? Give your heads a collective wobble. By all means criticise constructively, because it's far from perfect, and something needs to change or at least be tweaked, but let's have some bloody perspective, eh?
TBF Josh, I'm surprised it was even mentioned. Around 50 people I'd say. Many more either left quietly or applauded. Storm in a teacup I'd say.
That's not how it sounded on the telle box mate.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-08-2024, 10:03 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-08-2024, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)HDerek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
Agree to a point but they were working with different tools and a different aim
They were also working at a level far higher and with a much bigger disparity of resources between many of the clubs they were competing with. I don’t particularly see that as an argument as reason for the different standards we are setting for managers in terms of results.
Like I said in the other Fred, I agree with your point. But it's not difficult to understand why CC is being shown more patience than a ridiculous, money saving appointment, that no one wanted and a poisonous horrible individual who we spent years disliking during his tenure at Stoke.
Also, CC is a better manager than Pulis and Irvine. We're also in a good league position and we're not looking like losing games. I also believe fans with more than one brain cell can see we're not far away from being a very good side. We need a bit of luck, confidence and players to find form. It's not as if we're being outplayed every week.
We don't need a complete turnaround. It's not as if our squad is rubbish and unbalanced. The players are, to a man, giving 100% every match. We need a slight tweak. Nothing more. Nothing less.
We're also WBA. We will go on winless runs. We're not Man City. If that dominating and winning every week is what the brain dead booing brigade expect, then sod off and support City.
You’re going to have to explain how currently CC is a better manager than Pulis. Be objective and take the personal feelings out of this and compare managerial records of both managers and argue that CC is currently the better manager. You’re proving my point rather than arguing against it.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
Have any football fans ever been different?
Also, you are comparing three very different managers at three very different timepoints
It's almost pointless judging fan reaction to Allardyce, because the fans weren't in the grounds for all bar one of his games and I've always found a difference between online and in the stands.
A lot of the disenchantment around Pulis needs to be picked aside from the general dismay that we'd reached our ceiling as a club and there was no next level. IMO, a lot of the people who stopped attending from that point, may say it is the style of football, but really it's the increasingly common PL ennui for anyone outside the Big 6.
Of our recent managers, I would say fans turned on on Irvine, Moore and Ismaël very quickly, but the reasons for each go beyond any ideas of lack of cult of personality
Finally, Corberán will have credit in the bank with many fans for very valid reasons. He turned our form around, had us where most fans felt we should be in the table and never once publicly complained about our atrocious former owners. After the hit and hope Bruce period, he also felt like a breath of fresh air. On top of all this, he generally gets a tune out of players.
Of course fans are going to be more patient with a manager than has done that and not only that, has done so for two years.
If you want to look at a recent manager with an unearned cult of personality, Bilic would be a more accurate choice, the E&D journalist was on the verge of tears talking about his sacking, that's how fervent it was. But...football management is also about personality and Bilic is clearly a very charming individual. Whereas Pulis has been viewed as duplicitous in two separate court cases.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(11-08-2024, 12:12 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-08-2024, 12:00 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (11-07-2024, 11:55 PM)Jacko Wrote: (11-07-2024, 11:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-07-2024, 11:33 PM)Jacko Wrote: Go on...
The Championship quality and squad depth’s are not great and ours is on a par or better than most bar those recently relegated. Go on…
We cut our wage bill by 30%, lost our two best players (Kipre and Yokuslu) and sold our top scorer and replaced him with a League One journeyman who looks every bit as shit as that makes him sound.
Yes the division is weaker, but so are we, our bigger (lol) signings largely haven't worked (yet I should add, they're mostly foreign so need to be given time to bed in) Diakite, Racic, Frabotta. Heggem is the obvious exception, but while he's an upgrade on Townsend, he's not an upgrade on Kipre. Players we know Corberan doesn't (didn't last season) really fancy are getting big minutes in Grant, Molumby and Ajayi (before injury). We're running with 1 striker in the squad until Dike is fit. We're albeit unluckily down to 4 fit senior defenders.
We got numbers in because we had no choice but to get numbers in and we did it on a very restrictive budget, I'm personally still very wary of Ian Pearce and would like Nestor to look to make a change in that position sooner than later, he's had more failures than successes and that's massively important part of the club that can be improved for a fraction of the cost of a half decent player. Good post Jacko. We are back in the top 6 with almost a third of the season gone despite, as you say, trimming our wage bill and losing our stand out centre half. Tonight we played a team that were in the Prem last season and currently have the best defensive record in this division. Yet a draw isn't good enough for many?
As I’ve said judge a manager on results and resources outside the promoted teams and Leeds the league is bang average. Other managers we’ve had would as mentioned earlier be criticised far more severely, I’m trying to avoid the cult of personality.
IMO the following have better squads than us (some of which are very much underperforming): Sunderland, Sheff Utd, Leeds, Burnley, Boro, Norwich, Cov and Luton so my expectations are based on this. You can question some of the recruitment certainly (even though on a tight budget), although bringing in several players from abroad means they are probably going to need longer to adapt.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(11-08-2024, 10:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-08-2024, 10:03 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-08-2024, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)HDerek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
Agree to a point but they were working with different tools and a different aim
They were also working at a level far higher and with a much bigger disparity of resources between many of the clubs they were competing with. I don’t particularly see that as an argument as reason for the different standards we are setting for managers in terms of results.
Like I said in the other Fred, I agree with your point. But it's not difficult to understand why CC is being shown more patience than a ridiculous, money saving appointment, that no one wanted and a poisonous horrible individual who we spent years disliking during his tenure at Stoke.
Also, CC is a better manager than Pulis and Irvine. We're also in a good league position and we're not looking like losing games. I also believe fans with more than one brain cell can see we're not far away from being a very good side. We need a bit of luck, confidence and players to find form. It's not as if we're being outplayed every week.
We don't need a complete turnaround. It's not as if our squad is rubbish and unbalanced. The players are, to a man, giving 100% every match. We need a slight tweak. Nothing more. Nothing less.
We're also WBA. We will go on winless runs. We're not Man City. If that dominating and winning every week is what the brain dead booing brigade expect, then sod off and support City.
You’re going to have to explain how currently CC is a better manager than Pulis. Be objective and take the personal feelings out of this and compare managerial records of both managers and argue that CC is currently the better manager. You’re proving my point rather than arguing against it.
A complete biased and irrational view based on my utter dislike of the person.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.
I don't think it is hypocrisy. I suggest Carlos has goodwill because of the terrible situation we were in both on and off the pitch and how he has turned it around. He lives and breathes the job and I reckon this is appreciated by our fans.
Pulis earned the wrath of the fans by never even trying to win a game. Our football currently is nowhere near the level of tedium. Further, the suspicion he was doing very nicely financially on the fly did not adhere him to many either inside or out of the club. I could go on but his record of getting us safe then switching off so as to not set any precedent for the future was an indication of his plans. A thoroughly dislikable individual.
Irvine was given a poisoned chalice, an unpopular appointment that showed no ambition he was the victim of an owner looking to maximise pickings. Other than being underwhelmed, I personally had no issue with him.
Big Sam? I was out on a limb there. First, no manager in Europe would have kept that squad up. I thought it was a half decent appointment and believe he could have made a fist of getting us back up but he wasn't interested as we couldn't give him the means to do so.
Carlos is popular because he has earned it. Simple.
|