£40bn Taxes & Spending Cuts in the Budget
#51
(10-17-2024, 09:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Strong rumours that more FTBs will be dragged into paying Stamp Duty as Labour refuses to extend the Tories increase in thresholds , another stupid tax which simply distorts an already horribly distorted market. Expect another spike in house prices as buyers race to complete.

God help them if she is stupid enough to do this.

She has kicked the old and the young.
Reply
#52
IHT increases are also on the block. How Labour will raise anything like what it proposes to from this voluntary tax paid only by the terminally stupid is anyone’s guess.

However I think I’ve seen their ruse; economic growth is going to be driven by a huge rise in the employment of tax accountants.
Reply
#53
"The UK has changed its fiscal rules more frequently than any other OECD economy, with the average lifespan of less than four years. That has contributed to instability and uncertainty. So I will end the practice of the Chancellor being able to scrap the rules at any time."

Said the current Chancellor in March.

She's now going to scrap the current rules.
Reply
#54
(10-18-2024, 12:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: "The UK has changed its fiscal rules more frequently than any other OECD economy, with the average lifespan of less than four years. That has contributed to instability and uncertainty. So I will end the practice of the Chancellor being able to scrap the rules at any time."

Said the current Chancellor in March.

She's now going to scrap the current rules.

You're quite enjoying being in opposition aren't you?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#55
(10-18-2024, 01:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: You're quite enjoying being in opposition aren't you?

Arf. In principle I've been in opposition since about 1990 - to a greater or lesser degree.

This lot are craven incompetents who've had 14 years to prepare for government. Like the Tories they clearly lied through their back teeth about the £19bn of cuts already baked into Tory spending plans and doubled down with a farcical attempt to place a further £22bn Black Hole at the feet of the last government whilst spaffing £billions, Randy Marsh style - into the productivity black hole of public sector wage packets. 

Morbid fascination is the order of the day when it comes to this Budget. How on Earth are you going to raise £40bn (which would be the biggest tax raising Budget in history) tweaking taxes on capital and Employers NI without incentivising all sorts of distortions and behavioural changes? 

We can already see that the spiteful imposition of VAT on private schools may in fact end up costing the Treasury, higher Employers NI will reduce wages and disincentivise Employer pension contributions, higher CGT will reduce transactional activity, higher IHT will massively alter behaviour on housing, pensions and other assets, higher stamp duty will further distort an awful housing market costing FTBs more and disincentivising downsizers - all the while reducing the likely tax take.

This is what happens when you deliberately sew yourself into a straitjacket on income tax, NI & VAT and lie through your teeth in a "fully costed" Mainfesto. 

If Britain wants European-style public services then they have to be paid for; and you do that by imposing taxes that are easily collectible, unavoidable, progressive and predictable. That's income tax (inc. NI) and VAT - and the replacement of Stamp Duty, IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax with a Land Value Tax.

Unfortunately Labour has been so cowed by opposition that it's terrified to do what is necessary to achieve its outcomes. I'm only trying to help though naturally I don't agree with their aspirations for an ever more bloated state.
Reply
#56
(10-18-2024, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-18-2024, 01:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: You're quite enjoying being in opposition aren't you?

Arf. In principle I've been in opposition since about 1990 - to a greater or lesser degree.

This lot are craven incompetents who've had 14 years to prepare for government. Like the Tories they clearly lied through their back teeth about the £19bn of cuts already baked into Tory spending plans and doubled down with a farcical attempt to place a further £22bn Black Hole at the feet of the last government whilst spaffing £billions, Randy Marsh style - into the productivity black hole of public sector wage packets. 

Morbid fascination is the order of the day when it comes to this Budget. How on Earth are you going to raise £40bn (which would be the biggest tax raising Budget in history) tweaking taxes on capital and Employers NI without incentivising all sorts of distortions and behavioural changes? 

We can already see that the spiteful imposition of VAT on private schools may in fact end up costing the Treasury, higher Employers NI will reduce wages and disincentivise Employer pension contributions, higher CGT will reduce transactional activity, higher IHT will massively alter behaviour on housing, pensions and other assets, higher stamp duty will further distort an awful housing market costing FTBs more and disincentivising downsizers - all the while reducing the likely tax take.

This is what happens when you deliberately sew yourself into a straitjacket on income tax, NI & VAT and lie through your teeth in a "fully costed" Mainfesto. 

If Britain wants European-style public services then they have to be paid for; and you do that by imposing taxes that are easily collectible, unavoidable, progressive and predictable. That's income tax (inc. NI) and VAT - and the replacement of Stamp Duty, IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax with a Land Value Tax.

Unfortunately Labour has been so cowed by opposition that it's terrified to do what is necessary to achieve its outcomes. I'm only trying to help though naturally I don't agree with their aspirations for an ever more bloated state.

And that's the point. They should have fully presented their plans and costs. They would have still won the election - because we were all fed up with an incompetent Tory Government.

At least the great British public would know what to expect.
Reply
#57
(10-18-2024, 02:30 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: And that's the point. They should have fully presented their plans and costs. They would have still won the election - because we were all fed up with an incompetent Tory Government.

At least the great British public would know what to expect.

And you can bet that the vast majority of those who voted Labour didn't even know that they'd promised not to increase income tax, VAT or NI - simply because the vast majority of people don't read a paper or watch the news.
Reply
#58
(10-18-2024, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-18-2024, 01:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: You're quite enjoying being in opposition aren't you?

Arf. In principle I've been in opposition since about 1990 - to a greater or lesser degree.

Arf indeed - apart from the membership and campaigning for them bit  Big Grin

Is this the latest historical revision in the same way that Brexit could have worked - they were just the wrong type of Conservatives
Reply
#59
(10-18-2024, 03:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-18-2024, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-18-2024, 01:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: You're quite enjoying being in opposition aren't you?

Arf. In principle I've been in opposition since about 1990 - to a greater or lesser degree.

Arf indeed - apart from the membership and campaigning for them bit  Big Grin

Is this the latest historical revision in the same way that Brexit could have worked - they were just the wrong type of Conservatives

Your blind faith of the Labour party is quite endearing.
Reply
#60
The difference between you and I B1, is that I consistently criticised aspects Tory policy between 2010-24, yet you can’t see the disaster unfolding in front of your own eyes.

It is possible to be a Labour supporter without the blind faith you appear to be displaying right now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)