(10-18-2024, 01:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: You're quite enjoying being in opposition aren't you?
Arf. In principle I've been in opposition since about 1990 - to a greater or lesser degree.
This lot are craven incompetents who've had 14 years to prepare for government. Like the Tories they clearly lied through their back teeth about the £19bn of cuts already baked into Tory spending plans and doubled down with a farcical attempt to place a further £22bn Black Hole at the feet of the last government whilst spaffing £billions, Randy Marsh style - into the productivity black hole of public sector wage packets.
Morbid fascination is the order of the day when it comes to this Budget. How on Earth are you going to raise £40bn (which would be the biggest tax raising Budget in history) tweaking taxes on capital and Employers NI without incentivising all sorts of distortions and behavioural changes?
We can already see that the spiteful imposition of VAT on private schools may in fact end up costing the Treasury, higher Employers NI will reduce wages and disincentivise Employer pension contributions, higher CGT will reduce transactional activity, higher IHT will massively alter behaviour on housing, pensions and other assets, higher stamp duty will further distort an awful housing market costing FTBs more and disincentivising downsizers - all the while reducing the likely tax take.
This is what happens when you deliberately sew yourself into a straitjacket on income tax, NI & VAT and lie through your teeth in a "fully costed" Mainfesto.
If Britain wants European-style public services then they have to be paid for; and you do that by imposing taxes that are easily collectible, unavoidable, progressive and predictable. That's income tax (inc. NI) and VAT - and the replacement of Stamp Duty, IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax with a Land Value Tax.
Unfortunately Labour has been so cowed by opposition that it's terrified to do what is necessary to achieve its outcomes. I'm only trying to help though naturally I don't agree with their aspirations for an ever more bloated state.