Posts: 27,982
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Going on the cycle of England managers we’re due a fancy Dan foreigner who will be hounded out by the press because he doesn’t show enough “passion” before being replaced by Sean Dyche.
Posts: 1,065
Threads: 98
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(07-17-2024, 10:43 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'm not sure I expect to win a major tournament, I don't believe we have the adequate quality or the mentality of winners, but I do expect us to have a coach who has a clear game plan, brings an identity, is tactically astute and can change a game with his subs and in game management.
I think Southgate overall did a great job, and brought a lot of good things to England outside of the on field aspects, but he lacked nous to make a difference, and relied on ET, pens or individual brilliance to get results rather than his tactical management.
As for results, I don't think we can hope for anything better than 2 finals and a Semi in the next 4 tournaments. I think we'll we revert to QF also rans once we begin to face the top nations in the earlier stages, rather than the latter stages, of tournaments.
This isn't a criticism, but just a fact, and yes, winning groups and other Nations not winning theirs etc, affects this, but I can only think of Germany in 2020(1) that we beat in the 16/QF rounds, other than that we've had a very easy run and then lost in either the QF (France) Semi (Croatia) or final (Spain/Italy) the first opportunity we have to play against a side that is half decent.
We even struggled to beat teams we should (with respect) look to be beating comfortably, albeit they're tricky sides with talent i.e Colombia (pens), Denmark, (ET), Slovakia (ET), Switzerland (pens). Southgate has been a very fortunate manager, there can be no arguments there. But you earn your own luck.
We're not as good as most the fans and media think we are.
Sorry Bob, I disagree.
This has been one of my issues with Gareth Southgate and why I think he should have done better in his time as England Manager.
Back in 2017 this was the record of England squads...
Under 17s - World Champions
Under 19s - European Champions
Under 20s - World Champions
While I agree that GS has dragged English football from the depths, how he has not managed to muster a senior squad from those listed above that can win either a Euro or WC in the last few years is beyond me. Players from the above would be aged from 24 to 28 this year.
If we are to build on the work that led us to all those titles back in 2017, the FA need to find a manager that can win the WC in two years time. If we don't win, the potential we had only 7 years ago will be lost, and the rebuilding work will have to start again.
We do (or did) have the mentality of winners....we need the right person to rediscover this.
Sponsored by Bet365 - other betting sites are available
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(07-17-2024, 02:57 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: 10 world cup wins in a row wouldnt be good enough for some
Unless they were all 26-0 wins
I went to North Bromsgrove as a kid and we'd play matches against Sacred Heart in Droitwich who were dogshit at pretty much everything sports-wise. We beat them 26-0 one game and I think I was the only outfield player not to score. Next time we played them though players were taking shots from the halfway line, showboating and generally taking the piss and we ended up scraping a 3-1 win or something. So, even if you do win 26-0 it'll breed the wrong mentality is what I'm trying to say. I think.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
07-17-2024, 04:22 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-17-2024, 04:23 PM by Sliced.)
(07-17-2024, 03:05 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There's been plenty of fuss about the criticism Southgate's received, but it's nowhere near the level of abuse most England managers get before they move on.
The difference is that the criticism is disproportionate to how well we've actually done. In recent memory McClaren and Hodgson got more criticism towards the end of their reigns; but one of them failed to qualify for the Euros and the other lost to Iceland in the round of 16. Southgate has just lost in the last few minutes in a second euro final against one of the most impressive team performers in a tournament in recent history.
Posts: 8,082
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
07-17-2024, 05:10 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-17-2024, 05:15 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(07-17-2024, 11:57 AM)Fido Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: To improve on Southgate's record of 6 wins in 27 against teams in the top 10 globally.
Southgate took a team that was perennial underachievers and made them competitive in the final stages of tournaments for the first time in 50 years, and did it with consistency. That was a huge step forward.
What prevented us from winning a tournament was our failure to beat a top side in a competitive fixture. In GS's four tournaments the only two sides I'd argue we beat that were a match for us were Netherlands last week and Germany in 2021 but that was a much weaker than normal Germany. Had we come up against Portugal, France or Germany in the other side of the draw during this tournament I'm not sure we'd have made it through, so the objective for Southgate's replacement is to make us more competitive in these games as we will need to win them should we want to win a trophy.
Only one team can win a WC every 4 years, and the same with the Euros so success in this role shouldn't be defined purely on winning the tournament, it should be based on competitiveness and likelihood of winning a tournament. For all the good work GS has done, I never really thought he would bring one home.
This.
Yes, this.
Whilst it is of course super-trendy (not to mention very clever indeed) to either criticise the nastiest (and even, sometimes, more modest of) Southgate critics, and/or invert the criticism further by being critical of the critics for not being critical whilst wishing him well, it is perhaps a naively over-simplified question to ask what to expect the next coach to achieve when it’s not all constant. Not to mention that we don’t even know who he is yet.
But let’s stick with the first bit. It isn’t all constant, and the international game could improve a lot meanwhile. So whilst it’s obvious that we have no idea who will be fit, in-form etc. at the next competitive outing of note, what know even less is how our peers will evolve. I think - without any criticism of Southgate intended - we’ve faired well in recent times not so much because of easy runs but because the standard of the very best hasn’t been quite what it has in decades gone past. And - again - without saying that’s an ‘easy hit’ for Southgate or anyone else for that matter, it has perhaps been an easier one. The next couple of years may well see a revolution in success of teams who have underperformed in recent tournaments.
If we have underperformed in Euro 2024 and WC2022 - and that certainly is subjective otherwise we wouldn’t be having these continued debates - we certainly were not alone in doing so.
So - whilst the obvious answer the trendy seek/expect/hope for (delete as appropriate with claws at the ready) is probably along the lines of “Waaaah! I want to win something!”, which only the stupid should fall for, what I’d like to see is a continuation of the progression Southgate laid down, given, most importantly, the prevailing competitive context.
Or - inversely - it could suck even more, and we could see Potter or Howe lead us to silverware with a potentially worse brand of football. It really is impossible to say - even our best head coach of recent times failed embarrassingly. It really isn’t easy to call.
So whilst we should ostensibly (and to many quite obviously) have been getting more out of these players in an attacking sense, perhaps in doing so under the Southgate regime would have exposed other, unseen frailties he knew of but we the collective critic didn’t. Who knows.
Time will tell and expectation for me will be afforded to that. We will all judge the new guy as he goes along.
I hope whatever transpires isn’t at the behest of the good he’s done. What I would personally most like to see - and you can level this at ANY coach post-Venables (and maybe Hoddle) - is for us to really look to beat sides at the tournaments. Not play them into attrition or react to games. Again it isn’t only Southgate culpable, but since the late 90’s (and bar the odd exception) we have shown far too much respect.
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
(07-17-2024, 03:40 PM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: (07-17-2024, 10:43 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'm not sure I expect to win a major tournament, I don't believe we have the adequate quality or the mentality of winners, but I do expect us to have a coach who has a clear game plan, brings an identity, is tactically astute and can change a game with his subs and in game management.
I think Southgate overall did a great job, and brought a lot of good things to England outside of the on field aspects, but he lacked nous to make a difference, and relied on ET, pens or individual brilliance to get results rather than his tactical management.
As for results, I don't think we can hope for anything better than 2 finals and a Semi in the next 4 tournaments. I think we'll we revert to QF also rans once we begin to face the top nations in the earlier stages, rather than the latter stages, of tournaments.
This isn't a criticism, but just a fact, and yes, winning groups and other Nations not winning theirs etc, affects this, but I can only think of Germany in 2020(1) that we beat in the 16/QF rounds, other than that we've had a very easy run and then lost in either the QF (France) Semi (Croatia) or final (Spain/Italy) the first opportunity we have to play against a side that is half decent.
We even struggled to beat teams we should (with respect) look to be beating comfortably, albeit they're tricky sides with talent i.e Colombia (pens), Denmark, (ET), Slovakia (ET), Switzerland (pens). Southgate has been a very fortunate manager, there can be no arguments there. But you earn your own luck.
We're not as good as most the fans and media think we are.
Sorry Bob, I disagree.
This has been one of my issues with Gareth Southgate and why I think he should have done better in his time as England Manager.
Back in 2017 this was the record of England squads...
Under 17s - World Champions
Under 19s - European Champions
Under 20s - World Champions
While I agree that GS has dragged English football from the depths, how he has not managed to muster a senior squad from those listed above that can win either a Euro or WC in the last few years is beyond me. Players from the above would be aged from 24 to 28 this year.
If we are to build on the work that led us to all those titles back in 2017, the FA need to find a manager that can win the WC in two years time. If we don't win, the potential we had only 7 years ago will be lost, and the rebuilding work will have to start again.
We do (or did) have the mentality of winners....we need the right person to rediscover this.
It's a fair point you raise, however I suggest there's a lot less pressure playing in an U-17'/19/20's final, particularly as those age groups are more about development than winning trophies, than there is in the senior Euro's finals.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
The simple truth is expectation is to win something and win it quickly. On the whole, it's a reasonable bunch on this board, but the twats of TalkSport, The Daily Star and Twitter are a very loud bunch and will be the go to people when the media pounce on a bad result.
And the other thing, is England have to win with a bit of panache.
The next bloke will have to have a skin thicker than a rhino.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
07-17-2024, 07:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-17-2024, 07:44 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(07-17-2024, 05:10 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:57 AM)Fido Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: To improve on Southgate's record of 6 wins in 27 against teams in the top 10 globally.
Southgate took a team that was perennial underachievers and made them competitive in the final stages of tournaments for the first time in 50 years, and did it with consistency. That was a huge step forward.
What prevented us from winning a tournament was our failure to beat a top side in a competitive fixture. In GS's four tournaments the only two sides I'd argue we beat that were a match for us were Netherlands last week and Germany in 2021 but that was a much weaker than normal Germany. Had we come up against Portugal, France or Germany in the other side of the draw during this tournament I'm not sure we'd have made it through, so the objective for Southgate's replacement is to make us more competitive in these games as we will need to win them should we want to win a trophy.
Only one team can win a WC every 4 years, and the same with the Euros so success in this role shouldn't be defined purely on winning the tournament, it should be based on competitiveness and likelihood of winning a tournament. For all the good work GS has done, I never really thought he would bring one home.
This.
Yes, this.
Whilst it is of course super-trendy (not to mention very clever indeed) to either criticise the nastiest (and even, sometimes, more modest of) Southgate critics, and/or invert the criticism further by being critical of the critics for not being critical whilst wishing him well, it is perhaps a naively over-simplified question to ask what to expect the next coach to achieve when it’s not all constant. Not to mention that we don’t even know who he is yet.
But let’s stick with the first bit. It isn’t all constant, and the international game could improve a lot meanwhile. So whilst it’s obvious that we have no idea who will be fit, in-form etc. at the next competitive outing of note, what know even less is how our peers will evolve. I think - without any criticism of Southgate intended - we’ve faired well in recent times not so much because of easy runs but because the standard of the very best hasn’t been quite what it has in decades gone past. And - again - without saying that’s an ‘easy hit’ for Southgate or anyone else for that matter, it has perhaps been an easier one. The next couple of years may well see a revolution in success of teams who have underperformed in recent tournaments.
If we have underperformed in Euro 2024 and WC2022 - and that certainly is subjective otherwise we wouldn’t be having these continued debates - we certainly were not alone in doing so.
So - whilst the obvious answer the trendy seek/expect/hope for (delete as appropriate with claws at the ready) is probably along the lines of “Waaaah! I want to win something!”, which only the stupid should fall for, what I’d like to see is a continuation of the progression Southgate laid down, given, most importantly, the prevailing competitive context.
Or - inversely - it could suck even more, and we could see Potter or Howe lead us to silverware with a potentially worse brand of football. It really is impossible to say - even our best head coach of recent times failed embarrassingly. It really isn’t easy to call.
So whilst we should ostensibly (and to many quite obviously) have been getting more out of these players in an attacking sense, perhaps in doing so under the Southgate regime would have exposed other, unseen frailties he knew of but we the collective critic didn’t. Who knows.
Time will tell and expectation for me will be afforded to that. We will all judge the new guy as he goes along.
I hope whatever transpires isn’t at the behest of the good he’s done. What I would personally most like to see - and you can level this at ANY coach post-Venables (and maybe Hoddle) - is for us to really look to beat sides at the tournaments. Not play them into attrition or react to games. Again it isn’t only Southgate culpable, but since the late 90’s (and bar the odd exception) we have shown far too much respect.
The standard of tactics, fitness and technique of international standard players across the world is far higher imo than at any time. The game continues to evolve and I’m sure the next generation will improve further. I don’t think you can look back to previous generations 30 odd years ago because the game has moved on so much in that time. Even if you do there were plenty of matches where we squeaked past teams on penalties, extra time and late goals. I don’t think that’s England players showing too much respect but just the standard of the game has been raised further.
I do think you can ask the question about expectations for the next four/eight years given how young the nucleus of the team is. It can be argued that you can’t judge a manager or the expectations placed on them by their predecessors record because there are so many variables out of his control like the quality of opposition etc. However is there a better way? If the aim of a manager is to win games and accrue points then whoever comes in, in whatever circumstances will do exceptionally well to eclipse those of Southgate.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(07-17-2024, 07:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-17-2024, 05:10 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:57 AM)Fido Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: To improve on Southgate's record of 6 wins in 27 against teams in the top 10 globally.
Southgate took a team that was perennial underachievers and made them competitive in the final stages of tournaments for the first time in 50 years, and did it with consistency. That was a huge step forward.
What prevented us from winning a tournament was our failure to beat a top side in a competitive fixture. In GS's four tournaments the only two sides I'd argue we beat that were a match for us were Netherlands last week and Germany in 2021 but that was a much weaker than normal Germany. Had we come up against Portugal, France or Germany in the other side of the draw during this tournament I'm not sure we'd have made it through, so the objective for Southgate's replacement is to make us more competitive in these games as we will need to win them should we want to win a trophy.
Only one team can win a WC every 4 years, and the same with the Euros so success in this role shouldn't be defined purely on winning the tournament, it should be based on competitiveness and likelihood of winning a tournament. For all the good work GS has done, I never really thought he would bring one home.
This.
Yes, this.
Whilst it is of course super-trendy (not to mention very clever indeed) to either criticise the nastiest (and even, sometimes, more modest of) Southgate critics, and/or invert the criticism further by being critical of the critics for not being critical whilst wishing him well, it is perhaps a naively over-simplified question to ask what to expect the next coach to achieve when it’s not all constant. Not to mention that we don’t even know who he is yet.
But let’s stick with the first bit. It isn’t all constant, and the international game could improve a lot meanwhile. So whilst it’s obvious that we have no idea who will be fit, in-form etc. at the next competitive outing of note, what know even less is how our peers will evolve. I think - without any criticism of Southgate intended - we’ve faired well in recent times not so much because of easy runs but because the standard of the very best hasn’t been quite what it has in decades gone past. And - again - without saying that’s an ‘easy hit’ for Southgate or anyone else for that matter, it has perhaps been an easier one. The next couple of years may well see a revolution in success of teams who have underperformed in recent tournaments.
If we have underperformed in Euro 2024 and WC2022 - and that certainly is subjective otherwise we wouldn’t be having these continued debates - we certainly were not alone in doing so.
So - whilst the obvious answer the trendy seek/expect/hope for (delete as appropriate with claws at the ready) is probably along the lines of “Waaaah! I want to win something!”, which only the stupid should fall for, what I’d like to see is a continuation of the progression Southgate laid down, given, most importantly, the prevailing competitive context.
Or - inversely - it could suck even more, and we could see Potter or Howe lead us to silverware with a potentially worse brand of football. It really is impossible to say - even our best head coach of recent times failed embarrassingly. It really isn’t easy to call.
So whilst we should ostensibly (and to many quite obviously) have been getting more out of these players in an attacking sense, perhaps in doing so under the Southgate regime would have exposed other, unseen frailties he knew of but we the collective critic didn’t. Who knows.
Time will tell and expectation for me will be afforded to that. We will all judge the new guy as he goes along.
I hope whatever transpires isn’t at the behest of the good he’s done. What I would personally most like to see - and you can level this at ANY coach post-Venables (and maybe Hoddle) - is for us to really look to beat sides at the tournaments. Not play them into attrition or react to games. Again it isn’t only Southgate culpable, but since the late 90’s (and bar the odd exception) we have shown far too much respect. The standard of tactics, fitness and technique of international standard players across the world is far higher imo than at any time. The game continues to evolve and I’m sure the next generation will improve further. I don’t think you can look back to previous generations 30 odd years ago because the game has moved on so much in that time. Even if you do there were plenty of matches where we squeaked past teams on penalties, extra time and late goals.
I do think you can ask the question about expectations for the next four/eight years given how young the nucleus of the team is. It can be argued that you can’t judge a manager or the expectations placed on them by their predecessors record because there are so many variables out of his control like the quality of opposition etc. However is there a better way? If the aim of a manager is to win games and accrue points then whoever comes in, in whatever circumstances will do exceptionally well to eclipse those of Southgate.
If they win a trophy and don't qualify for the next euros they still would have done better than Southgate.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(07-17-2024, 07:43 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (07-17-2024, 07:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-17-2024, 05:10 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:57 AM)Fido Wrote: (07-17-2024, 11:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: To improve on Southgate's record of 6 wins in 27 against teams in the top 10 globally.
Southgate took a team that was perennial underachievers and made them competitive in the final stages of tournaments for the first time in 50 years, and did it with consistency. That was a huge step forward.
What prevented us from winning a tournament was our failure to beat a top side in a competitive fixture. In GS's four tournaments the only two sides I'd argue we beat that were a match for us were Netherlands last week and Germany in 2021 but that was a much weaker than normal Germany. Had we come up against Portugal, France or Germany in the other side of the draw during this tournament I'm not sure we'd have made it through, so the objective for Southgate's replacement is to make us more competitive in these games as we will need to win them should we want to win a trophy.
Only one team can win a WC every 4 years, and the same with the Euros so success in this role shouldn't be defined purely on winning the tournament, it should be based on competitiveness and likelihood of winning a tournament. For all the good work GS has done, I never really thought he would bring one home.
This.
Yes, this.
Whilst it is of course super-trendy (not to mention very clever indeed) to either criticise the nastiest (and even, sometimes, more modest of) Southgate critics, and/or invert the criticism further by being critical of the critics for not being critical whilst wishing him well, it is perhaps a naively over-simplified question to ask what to expect the next coach to achieve when it’s not all constant. Not to mention that we don’t even know who he is yet.
But let’s stick with the first bit. It isn’t all constant, and the international game could improve a lot meanwhile. So whilst it’s obvious that we have no idea who will be fit, in-form etc. at the next competitive outing of note, what know even less is how our peers will evolve. I think - without any criticism of Southgate intended - we’ve faired well in recent times not so much because of easy runs but because the standard of the very best hasn’t been quite what it has in decades gone past. And - again - without saying that’s an ‘easy hit’ for Southgate or anyone else for that matter, it has perhaps been an easier one. The next couple of years may well see a revolution in success of teams who have underperformed in recent tournaments.
If we have underperformed in Euro 2024 and WC2022 - and that certainly is subjective otherwise we wouldn’t be having these continued debates - we certainly were not alone in doing so.
So - whilst the obvious answer the trendy seek/expect/hope for (delete as appropriate with claws at the ready) is probably along the lines of “Waaaah! I want to win something!”, which only the stupid should fall for, what I’d like to see is a continuation of the progression Southgate laid down, given, most importantly, the prevailing competitive context.
Or - inversely - it could suck even more, and we could see Potter or Howe lead us to silverware with a potentially worse brand of football. It really is impossible to say - even our best head coach of recent times failed embarrassingly. It really isn’t easy to call.
So whilst we should ostensibly (and to many quite obviously) have been getting more out of these players in an attacking sense, perhaps in doing so under the Southgate regime would have exposed other, unseen frailties he knew of but we the collective critic didn’t. Who knows.
Time will tell and expectation for me will be afforded to that. We will all judge the new guy as he goes along.
I hope whatever transpires isn’t at the behest of the good he’s done. What I would personally most like to see - and you can level this at ANY coach post-Venables (and maybe Hoddle) - is for us to really look to beat sides at the tournaments. Not play them into attrition or react to games. Again it isn’t only Southgate culpable, but since the late 90’s (and bar the odd exception) we have shown far too much respect. The standard of tactics, fitness and technique of international standard players across the world is far higher imo than at any time. The game continues to evolve and I’m sure the next generation will improve further. I don’t think you can look back to previous generations 30 odd years ago because the game has moved on so much in that time. Even if you do there were plenty of matches where we squeaked past teams on penalties, extra time and late goals.
I do think you can ask the question about expectations for the next four/eight years given how young the nucleus of the team is. It can be argued that you can’t judge a manager or the expectations placed on them by their predecessors record because there are so many variables out of his control like the quality of opposition etc. However is there a better way? If the aim of a manager is to win games and accrue points then whoever comes in, in whatever circumstances will do exceptionally well to eclipse those of Southgate.
If they win a trophy and don't qualify for the next euros they still would have done better than Southgate.
Let’s wait until that scenario happens before using a hypothetical situation to judge the last manager by.
|