What’s the expectation for the next England manager then?
#1
Following on from the Southgate Resigns thread I thought it pertinent to ask what would be deemed acceptable success given the criticism laid at Southgate’s door. If you are judging him fairly rather than simply because of your on bias what is the expectation for the next manager? Euro Champs? World Cup Winners? Those are the only two options the next manager has to deem them a more successful manager than Southgate.
Reply
#2
I'm not sure I expect to win a major tournament, I don't believe we have the adequate quality or the mentality of winners, but I do expect us to have a coach who has a clear game plan, brings an identity,  is tactically astute and can change a game with his subs and in game management.

I think Southgate overall did a great job, and brought a lot of good things to England outside of the on field aspects, but he lacked nous to make a difference, and relied on ET, pens or individual brilliance to get results rather than his tactical management.

As for results, I don't think we can hope for anything better than 2 finals and a Semi in the next 4 tournaments. I think we'll we revert to QF also rans once we begin to face the top nations in the earlier stages, rather than the latter stages, of tournaments.

This isn't a criticism, but just a fact, and yes, winning groups and other Nations not winning theirs etc, affects this, but I can only think of Germany in 2020(1) that we beat in the 16/QF rounds, other than that we've had a very easy run and then lost in either the QF (France) Semi (Croatia) or final (Spain/Italy) the first opportunity we have to play against a side that is half decent. 

We even struggled to beat teams we should (with respect) look to be beating comfortably, albeit they're tricky sides with talent i.e Colombia (pens), Denmark,  (ET), Slovakia (ET), Switzerland (pens). Southgate has been a very fortunate manager, there can be no arguments there. But you earn your own luck.

We're not as good as most the fans and media think we are.
Reply
#3
As astronomically high as always from the general fan. And whoever it is won't meet that expectation unless they smash every team 3-0+ and win every match going.
Reply
#4
Sexy football
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#5
For me success will look like us continuing to challenge at the very top end of tournaments, would be great to win one but as long as we remain consistently in the group of teams who can win then that's good. Only one side can ever win the cup.

I'd like to see a bit more tactical fleibility, especially in game - it always feels like the opposition are first to make proactive changes and we always have to react (or too many times not react). I'd hope the next guy is able to influence games much more proactively when they aren't going well.

Finally I'd like us to shed the inferiority complex we have. Always strikes me that we fear our fellow elite nations when really we should be showing that we belong amongst them.
Reply
#6
To improve on Southgate's record of 6 wins in 27 against teams in the top 10 globally.

Southgate took a team that was perennial underachievers and made them competitive in the final stages of tournaments for the first time in 50 years, and did it with consistency. That was a huge step forward.

What prevented us from winning a tournament was our failure to beat a top side in a competitive fixture. In GS's four tournaments the only two sides I'd argue we beat that were a match for us were Netherlands last week and Germany in 2021 but that was a much weaker than normal Germany. Had we come up against Portugal, France or Germany in the other side of the draw during this tournament I'm not sure we'd have made it through, so the objective for Southgate's replacement is to make us more competitive in these games as we will need to win them should we want to win a trophy.

Only one team can win a WC every 4 years, and the same with the Euros so success in this role shouldn't be defined purely on winning the tournament, it should be based on competitiveness and likelihood of winning a tournament. For all the good work GS has done, I never really thought he would bring one home.
Reply
#7
(07-17-2024, 10:48 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: As astronomically high as always from the general fan. And whoever it is won't meet that expectation unless they smash every team 3-0+ and win every match going.

Sounds like some Albion fans, tbf!
Reply
#8
I don’t know about expectations but under Southgate we have evolved, we have learned how to go deep in a tournament and how to take penalties under pressure. So the next England manager can hopefully take us up to the next step and win a tournament. Hopefully playing a more attacking brand of football.
Reply
#9
(07-17-2024, 11:04 AM)wba13 Wrote: I don’t know about expectations but under Southgate we have evolved, we have learned how to go deep in a tournament and how to take penalties under pressure. So the next England manager can hopefully take us up to the next step and win a tournament. Hopefully playing a more attacking brand of football.

Not much wriggle room then, which shows exactly how well Southgate has done.
Reply
#10
I said in another thread that we need to win a tournament playing sexy football.

I forgot to add that we also have to do that playing against the best teams in the world in each round otherwise it's not impressive. If you've beaten Switzerland and Netherlands to get to a final that doesn't even really count as a final
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)