Winners, Losers & Reflections
#51
At least the whole affair has led to a period of calm inward reflection within the Tory party.

https://amp.theguardian.com/politics/art...ter-defeat
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#52
I'm not sure why you'd expect losing candidates and their staffers to respond with a period of calm reflection after that shitshow of a campaign?
Reply
#53
(07-06-2024, 12:50 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: At least the whole affair has led to a period of calm inward reflection within the Tory party.

https://amp.theguardian.com/politics/art...ter-defeat

Oh they will be looking inward alright. That's all they have done for 14 years rather than actually doing stuff for the population. It's all been a game to then.
Reply
#54
Definite losers were the Conservatives and SNP. Although I predict SNP will get back on track in the 2026 Holyrood elections.

Definite winners the Lib Dems, hard to see how things could have gone better.

Greens also, they won the seats They prioritised and doubled their votes total. Plus a decent number of second places.

I don't know enough about Welsh politics, but I suspect Plaid hit all their targets too.

Reform on the surface would seem also to be big winners, but I suspect there might be some frustration and disappointment. Yes they got 5 MPs, but the number of votes was similar to UKIP in 2015.
They have given themselves a platform for future success, but do their leaders have the skills, focus and stamina to build on it. Not sure. Farage likes the spotlight, does he want to do the hard yards.

Labour should be the big winners. And indeed they have a massive majority. But do they have a genuine mandate. Not sure they do. They have to be disappointed by their share of the vote and the number of votes they received. They are going to have to be better than just ok, if they want to win next time round.

On a general point, turnout was very disappointing. Part of the problem was the publics disillusionment with politicians. Which they need to regain. But I also think that the constant release of opinion polls suggesting a foregone conclusion, also depressed turnout. Also did photo id have an impact. Hard to know.
Reply
#55
I heard Labour's majority being described as "a mile wide but only an inch deep" which I thought was wonderfully poetic.

They still have the greatest mandate for their manifesto/policies since Johnson.

I can see Farage going the same way as the other populist MP desperate for a national role yet abject as a local MP - George Galloway. Big party leaders can do the national role because they have safe seats. Clacton isn't a safe seat. Are the people of Clacton bright enough to kick him out in 5 years because, I promise this, he will not give two fucks about the people of Clacton.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#56
(07-07-2024, 08:55 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I heard Labour's majority being described as "a mile wide but only an inch deep" which I thought was wonderfully poetic.

They still have the greatest mandate for their manifesto/policies since Johnson.

I can see Farage going the same way as the other populist MP desperate for a national role yet abject as a local MP - George Galloway. Big party leaders can do the national role because they have safe seats.  Clacton isn't a safe seat. Are the people of Clacton bright enough to kick him out in 5 years because, I promise this, he will not give two fucks about the people of Clacton.

Everyone knows the electoral rules. Labour played a blinder in widening the areas of their support to get the maximum number of seats. So did the Lib Dems and Greens who concentrated what resources they had to target the seats They thought they could win.

Under the system employ there is no doubting Labour's legitimacy to govern.

However I would baulk at describing it as a great majority, it is legitimate but brittle.

I sincerely hope Labour governs with integrity and helps restore the electorates faith and willingness to engage in politics.
If they don't,  what's coming down the track could be very scary indeed.
Reply
#57
(07-07-2024, 09:23 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-07-2024, 08:55 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I heard Labour's majority being described as "a mile wide but only an inch deep" which I thought was wonderfully poetic.

They still have the greatest mandate for their manifesto/policies since Johnson.

I can see Farage going the same way as the other populist MP desperate for a national role yet abject as a local MP - George Galloway. Big party leaders can do the national role because they have safe seats.  Clacton isn't a safe seat. Are the people of Clacton bright enough to kick him out in 5 years because, I promise this, he will not give two fucks about the people of Clacton.

Everyone knows the electoral rules. Labour played a blinder in widening the areas of their support to get the maximum number of seats. So did the Lib Dems and Greens who concentrated what resources they had to target the seats They thought they could win.

Under the system employ there is no doubting Labour's legitimacy to govern.

However I would baulk at describing it as a great majority, it is legitimate but brittle.

I sincerely hope Labour governs with integrity and helps restore the electorates faith and willingness to engage in politics.
If they don't,  what's coming down the track could be very scary indeed.
Very true, and I believe they will (under Starmer who appears a decent man). The shift to the right- across the world- is scary and I hope it gives a minority voice to those that have ignored the main parties in favour of those extreme parties. I genuinely believe there are enough votes elsewhere to keep them at bay in GB. Much depends on the knife edge that is USA as I fear for the world, especially Europe, if that big orange manbaby gets in.
Reply
#58
(07-07-2024, 08:55 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I heard Labour's majority being described as "a mile wide but only an inch deep" which I thought was wonderfully poetic.

They still have the greatest mandate for their manifesto/policies since Johnson.

I can see Farage going the same way as the other populist MP desperate for a national role yet abject as a local MP - George Galloway. Big party leaders can do the national role because they have safe seats.  Clacton isn't a safe seat. Are the people of Clacton bright enough to kick him out in 5 years because, I promise this, he will not give two fucks about the people of Clacton.

I’m not sure that deep down Farage even wanted the job. You could see that on his face during the result. Like all gobshites with no responsibility (see Johnson) when they suddenly have to walk the walk it’s a very different job indeed.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#59
(07-07-2024, 01:02 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Like all gobshites with no responsibility (see Johnson) when they suddenly have to walk the walk it’s a very different job indeed.

Let's hope that's how it turns out both for him, and the socially lunatic wing of the Tory Party.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)