WBAUnofficial
Winners, Losers & Reflections - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Winners, Losers & Reflections (/showthread.php?tid=34292)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


Winners, Losers & Reflections - Protheroe - 07-05-2024

Congratulations to Keir Starmer and the Labour Party. You can only ever win a British election from the centre.

The ming vase strategy worked. Labour has won a stonking majority to govern as it pleases having barely altered its vote share from 2019. Voters are rightly furious with the Tories, but they did not move wholesale to Labour. Unlike previous elections however, Labour's vote has been spread very efficiently across hundreds of constituencies rather than being stacked up in safe areas as it was in 2019 & 2017. However the general level of enthusiasm is reflected in some appallingly bad turn out figures everywhere.

Worryingly for any liberal (and certainly a liberal Tory like me) a huge number of people saw fit to vote for populist right charlatans. Within minutes of the first Erdington box being opened at the count last night it was clear that the Tories would be beaten into 3rd place, a pattern repeated in far too many places elsewhere. It is truly horrifying that Nigel Farage will take a seat in Parliament, and the Tory Party is singularly guilty of not taking this fantasist to task. It's also telling that several of the Labour activists I spoke to last night were also wringing their hands about Labour votes going to reform. I was horribly wrong in underestimating their appeal.

In the West Midlands I was delighted to see Jess Phillips see off the filth in Yardley, and through gritted teeth even Liam Byrne doing the same. Gary Sambrook was completely defenestrated by a lamentable turnout and huge swing to Reform (Labour lost vote share too), James Morris suffered the same way in Halesowen. I was surprised to see the utterly useless drunk stack up so many votes in Stourbridge, but happy to see Cat Eccles elected rather than Gaza Pete who fought the last 2 or 3.

Great work by the Lib Dems across a swathe of the south. A very efficient use of meager resources. I look forward to the opening up huge tracts of land for housing development as I've often been promised on here.

Reflections?

Well, Labour has a huge majority. Is that a blessing? Will it be a curse? Within eighteen months I expect them to be exceptionally unpopular. What happens within the PLP then? 

The Tories are at a crossroads. Do they let themselves be led by the nose to the right on social issues? That direction leads to oblivion and an inevitable accommodation with lunatics. In that event I would actively campaign against them.

Overall those of the electorate that bothered to turn out has shown itself to be increasingly volatile. Parties of government have been punished in England, Scotland (Independence is stone dead) and Wales. The electorate has also, incomprehensibly, seen fit to elect 4 single issue Gaza fetishists. What possible value will they be in Parliament?

Anyway. #Change it is. Let's see how that turns out.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Spandaubaggie - 07-05-2024

As ever Proth, an intelligent post. I feel genuinely sorry for the good moderate conservatives like you. Hope many will see sense and get the party together before it becomes a Republican style basket case farce.
It’ll get worse before it gets better for your party.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Protheroe - 07-05-2024

(07-05-2024, 09:11 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It’ll get worse before it gets better for your party.

I expect so. But getting worse from such a low base is existential.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Ted Maul - 07-05-2024

Interesting post Proth - hope your daughter enjoyed her work experience!

Locally I was disappointed to see Sutton stay blue but really pleased for Cat in Stourbridge, she will be a great local representative I think.

For the Tory party how do they win back the votes now? You say they're starting from such a low base and there are over 6m votes gone to Reform where you'd anticipate a lot of those would be Tory and Brexit voting people who've had enough. Who comes in as leader? Do they make a deal with Farage? And if they don't what happens to the Tory party? Aside from praying for a Labour implosion.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Fido - 07-05-2024

(07-05-2024, 09:47 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Interesting post Proth - hope your daughter enjoyed her work experience!

Locally I was disappointed to see Sutton stay blue but really pleased for Cat in Stourbridge, she will be a great local representative I think.

For the Tory party how do they win back the votes now? You say they're starting from such a low base and there are over 6m votes gone to Reform where you'd anticipate a lot of those would be Tory and Brexit voting people who've had enough. Who comes in as leader? Do they make a deal with Farage? And if they don't what happens to the Tory party? Aside from praying for a Labour implosion.

Would be interested to know who would even be a possibility here. Don't follow it enough to know who potential candidates might be but some of the more prominent lost their seats last night.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Ted Maul - 07-05-2024

(07-05-2024, 09:53 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 09:47 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Interesting post Proth - hope your daughter enjoyed her work experience!

Locally I was disappointed to see Sutton stay blue but really pleased for Cat in Stourbridge, she will be a great local representative I think.

For the Tory party how do they win back the votes now? You say they're starting from such a low base and there are over 6m votes gone to Reform where you'd anticipate a lot of those would be Tory and Brexit voting people who've had enough. Who comes in as leader? Do they make a deal with Farage? And if they don't what happens to the Tory party? Aside from praying for a Labour implosion.

Would be interested to know who would even be a possibility here. Don't follow it enough to know who potential candidates might be but some of the more prominent lost their seats last night.

First name I thought of -shudders- was Braverman, however that would indicate the aforementioned lurch further to the right to try and appease Farage. From a purely vote winning perspective you'd have to say it would be smart, it would kill Reform although it would probably also see Farage as potential Shadow Chancellor leading into the next election. It's an absolute dumpster fire, hence why I'd be interested to hear the Proth line on who the more 'moderate' option would be, knowing they've got to win about 4m votes back from Reform.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Spandaubaggie - 07-05-2024

As a very middle ground guy surely wouldn’t Jeremy Hunt be the sensible choice. Seems his big mistake was voting stay over Brexit as think he’s clearly the most sensible bloke at a senior level at the moment.
Can only speak for myself but I would probably have voted for a party ran by him that had avoided the Liz Truss farce. To me that deluded cow was the worst calamity of all the years of calamities.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Derek Hardballs - 07-05-2024

(07-05-2024, 09:59 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As a very middle ground guy surely wouldn’t Jeremy Hunt be the sensible choice. Seems his big mistake was voting stay over Brexit as think he’s clearly the most sensible bloke at a senior level at the moment.

He did a great job with the NHS…


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - PatelsPlatoon - 07-05-2024

(07-05-2024, 10:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-05-2024, 09:59 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As a very middle ground guy surely wouldn’t Jeremy Hunt be the sensible choice. Seems his big mistake was voting stay over Brexit as think he’s clearly the most sensible bloke at a senior level at the moment.

He did a great job with the NHS…

The NHS has been in a total mess for years- an unwieldy beast of bureaucracy and mismanagement. Pinning it on him seems as stupid as blaming Darren Moore for our relegation in 2018.


RE: Winners, Losers & Reflections - Ted Maul - 07-05-2024

(07-05-2024, 09:59 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As a very middle ground guy surely wouldn’t Jeremy Hunt be the sensible choice. Seems his big mistake was voting stay over Brexit as think he’s clearly the most sensible bloke at a senior level at the moment.
Can only speak for myself but I would probably have voted for a party ran by him that had avoided the Liz Truss farce. To me that deluded cow was the worst calamity of all the years of calamities.

I don't disagree, he seems a really decent bloke although some of his comments overnight did hint at deliberate under funding of the NHS...

Also, how on earth is the Deputy PM from this election going to convince 75% of those who voted Reform yesterday to return to the Conservatives?