Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(06-12-2024, 08:36 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The missed appointments thing - who would issue, administer and enforce the fines? Police? Admin? Would they be enforced by courts? If so, how would they produce more money than they cost to chase? In a nutshell that’s why I agree with your pension suggestion but not the NHS. I think the former is at least fairly straight forward to implement and work out the framework for. Also has existing structures that can underpin it.
With health, once you create a system where some people will fall through the net, what you may save in one area, you’ll eventually find costs you more somewhere else.
It would need a thorough review I agree. A cost analysis of how much missed appointments actually cost. Then you can look at what sort of war chest you would have to put together an enforcement team. Most likely managed by the local authority in the same way school fines are administered.
I work in social housing, and it a similar issue we have when it comes down to repairs that are the result of tenants negligence. We "recharge" them for the repairs but really struggle to recover the charges. But that's because politically there is no appetite for enforcement as we are soft as shit.
Rent arrears are taken directly from people benefits if they claim them so that could be an option. Missed appointments are fined 20 quid and it sits in an account and it's recovered directly from benefits at a manageable weekly/monthly amount. Those who are self funders are harder to deal with, but the threat of losing their home is not ally enough leverage. I suppose what would the final leverage be in terms of healthcare.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Take a fine from someone’s benefits - for example - let’s say that fine is £60. Chances it hasn’t cost more than that to process recovering it are zero. Then the person who loses the cash through the fine either buys less food or avoids going back to the doctors in future because of this outcome. Then they become more likely to either get ill or miss a diagnosis. Then it costs a fortune down the track to put right. I can see why you think like you do mon, with that sports analysis brain, but you need to apply some much broader thinking to this one and it simply wouldn’t work.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
06-12-2024, 09:49 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2024, 09:50 AM by Lurker#3.)
(06-12-2024, 09:14 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Take a fine from someone’s benefits - for example - let’s say that fine is £60. Chances it hasn’t cost more than that to process recovering it are zero. Then the person who loses the cash through the fine either buys less food or avoids going back to the doctors in future because of this outcome. Then they become more likely to either get ill or miss a diagnosis. Then it costs a fortune down the track to put right. I can see why you think like you do mon, with that sports analysis brain, but you need to apply some much broader thinking to this one and it simply wouldn’t work.
That's why the cost analysis should include estimations of any compounding factors. Also for every case you have like above I wonder how many more early diagnosis's you would have if all those wasted appointments were given to people who needed them.
We have a "throw away" mentality generally as a society and that wastefulness also effects the NHS. Having more political/financial deterrents would deincentivise this behaviour.
Then there's the argument around personal responsibility. 'The state' is so large at the moment and after measures such as furlough, whilst honourable and good willed, it has caused many to lose sight of fact that their lives/wellbeing is mainly in their own hands and is ultimately their responsibility. And it needs some reformative policies, which sadly may mean that some, in the short term, fail. But at the moment many who want to take responsibility are being let down by a service unable to cater for them, so we're in a lose lose.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Health is just too precious and consequential to start quantifying in this way. I agree with you and Proth that both the pension sector and health need reform and are unsustainable to the state. I just think dealing with pensions first is much more achievable and open to positive implementation than health is at this point in time. It’s also much easier to stratify without profound unseen consequences. By the way pal - you’re starting to sound like you’re on that middle aged path to the right wing (winky thing)
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
06-12-2024, 10:05 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2024, 10:07 AM by Lurker#3.)
(06-12-2024, 09:55 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Health is just too precious and consequential to start quantifying in this way. I agree with you and Proth that both the pension sector and health need reform and are unsustainable to the state. I just think dealing with pensions first is much more achievable and open to positive implementation than health is at this point in time. It’s also much easier to stratify without profound unseen consequences. By the way pal - you’re starting to sound like you’re on that middle aged path to the right wing (winky thing)
Funnily enough I have always been just right of centre
But only because I genuinely enjoy helping people and in all my socially involved jobs over the last decade the one thing that has stopped me helping more people is the amount of time I have had to spend buffering the organisation/myself from the "what ifs" with those who are sadly beyond help.
As a result I have always come to the conclusion that you sometimes have to cut off the toe to save the foot. Its never sat well with me, but I have never seen or heard anything that has offered me a way to stop thinking that way.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Hope you post on here a bit more pal, add plenty of value
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(06-12-2024, 07:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The biggest challenge at this election is for the parties to show us how they are going to reform our welfare system and NHS to future proof it against an ageing population with hoarded wealth.
I would like to see state pension fall into a UC style model. Where it tops up income when you get to retirement age. So if you have a private pension/non earned income, annually of 40k, you frankly don't need that benefit.
Also, the NHS needs serious reform in the face of a growing, ageing and generally more unhealthy population. I never want to see the principle of "free at the point of use" taken away for those that need it, but I think some careful tax breaks for the middle classes if they have private medical insurance should be considered in line with salary sacrifice schemes that not everyone has access to.
As much as this sounds like sense there are a few holes - what are you calling non-earned income and how would you measure it? Are you talking about drawing down from savings and if that is the case then people will just stop saving and either give it to their kids or spend it. And I think you'd be surprised about how few people have pensions that give them £40k.
And as for the salary sacrifice schemes, private medical insurance route, you are mainly looking at employed people in that bracket and by definition probably under 65 which is exactly the demographic that tend not to use it that much. The ones that use it are the elderly who may not have access to PMI. Otherwise are you saying that people who have cancer treatment should be making sure they have adequate insurance - i have an example of a colleague that is terrified of losing her job because of the medical insurance that looks after her husband who is terminal, she has to travel away from her husband who needs very personal care a lot of the time because she feels pressured, that's not how the system should work.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Means testing the state pension will merely result in a collapse in private pension savings.
The NHS needs root and branch reform, one aspect of which is to incentivise people not use it - instead of taxing PMI as a benefit if it's provided through an employer.
There should definitely be sanctions for failing to turn up to an appointment too.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
What sanctions? And what circumstances would be a valid reason to have missed one? Who will administer this and at what cost?
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
06-12-2024, 01:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2024, 01:04 PM by Protheroe.)
In a world with countless methods of communication, there is no valid reason not to let someone know if you can't make an appointment - even if it's just moments before.
The simplest way of administering it is to charge for access the next time an individual wishes to make an appointment. GPs should be charging £50 per missed appointment, hospitals much more. You communicate it clearly enough and compliance will follow. It's for the common good of everyone.
Interestingly. under the terms of my PMI I would be charged should I fail to turn up or cancel - and that fee could be £hundreds.
|