WBAUnofficial
What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? (/showthread.php?tid=34039)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Derek Hardballs - 06-12-2024

Both seem completely unrealistic and uncosted.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Protheroe - 06-12-2024

If you apply our average growth rate since 2010 rather than the OBRs exceptionally ambitious projection to Labour’s plans you end up with a £60bn black hole.

But I also agree that what Sunak is proposing, and how he proposes to fund it is just bollocks.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Lurker#3 - 06-12-2024

The biggest challenge at this election is for the parties to show us how they are going to reform our welfare system and NHS to future proof it against an ageing population with hoarded wealth.

I would like to see state pension fall into a UC style model. Where it tops up income when you get to retirement age. So if you have a private pension/non earned income, annually of 40k, you frankly don't need that benefit.

Also, the NHS needs serious reform in the face of a growing, ageing and generally more unhealthy population. I never want to see the principle of "free at the point of use" taken away for those that need it, but I think some careful tax breaks for the middle classes if they have private medical insurance should be considered in line with salary sacrifice schemes that not everyone has access to.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Protheroe - 06-12-2024

Another heretic.

Like me.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - CaptainFantastico - 06-12-2024

Lurker - agree with you about pensions but not the NHS. However, imagine what would happen to the electoral chances of any party that proposed either.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Fido - 06-12-2024

(06-12-2024, 08:21 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Lurker - agree with you about pensions but not the NHS. However, imagine what would happen to the electoral chances of any party that proposed either.

Would be refreshing for most of us, I would hope, to see either party address any of the fuggin massive elephants in the room.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Lurker#3 - 06-12-2024

(06-12-2024, 08:21 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Lurker - agree with you about pensions but not the NHS. However, imagine what would happen to the electoral chances of any party that proposed either.

There in lies the problem. The main parties are dancing to the tune of 45+ voters as they are generally the group with the highest turn out. 

In terms of the NHS, I don't want it to change. I just want more and more people to be encouraged to take private medical insurance. 

Me for example. Me and the missus have a combined income of 80k/year. As a result of a bereavement we are likely to be mortgage free in the next year, in our mid thirties, way ahead of 48 which it was due to be originally due to our modest home. So if I was offered a model similar to a salary sacrifice saving me 30% in private medical care. I would likely take it. I imagine there would be millions in the same bracket, and that reduction in demand on the NHS, along with some changes in social care and primary care could just start to put it back on track. 

However, we still need to look at some other contentious issues such as missed appointments. Which need to be enforced against so how. But again, who's going to drop that hammer?


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - CaptainFantastico - 06-12-2024

The missed appointments thing - who would issue, administer and enforce the fines? Police? Admin? Would they be enforced by courts? If so, how would they produce more money than they cost to chase? In a nutshell that’s why I agree with your pension suggestion but not the NHS. I think the former is at least fairly straight forward to implement and work out the framework for. Also has existing structures that can underpin it.

With health, once you create a system where some people will fall through the net, what you may save in one area, you’ll eventually find costs you more somewhere else.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Borin' Baggie - 06-12-2024

(06-12-2024, 08:36 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The missed appointments thing - who would issue, administer and enforce the fines? Police? Admin? Would they be enforced by courts? If so, how would they produce more money than they cost to chase? In a nutshell that’s why I agree with your pension suggestion but not the NHS. I think the former is at least fairly straight forward to implement and work out the framework for. Also has existing structures that can underpin it.

With health, once you create a system where some people will fall through the net, what you may save in one area, you’ll eventually find costs you more somewhere else.

Could go with a deposit system, if you make it you get the money back. 

Would probably need some sort of income exemption though


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - CaptainFantastico - 06-12-2024

You only have to look at the furore over the child benefit delays last week to see how many people are hand to mouth. Deposit system and means testing same as above - will end up costing more in ramifications than it does in savings