How do explain school is important to young people anymore?
I don't disagree with you at all, but I'm unsure as to the practicality of engaging parents of the children with those problems in the immediate term.
Reply
(01-15-2024, 01:50 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I went to school with a lad who didn't wear socks, he's in prison now.
You can be arrested and thrown in jail for not wearing socks now?
Reply
(01-16-2024, 04:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yes, it should absolutely be the sole domain of parents/guardians and in an ideal world it would be but unfortunately we're not in an ideal world and that's emerged as a problem big enough that the incoming government have announced it as a needed policy.

Which will make the problem worse.
Reply
(01-16-2024, 09:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-16-2024, 04:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yes, it should absolutely be the sole domain of parents/guardians and in an ideal world it would be but unfortunately we're not in an ideal world and that's emerged as a problem big enough that the incoming government have announced it as a needed policy.

Which will make the problem worse.

If kids aged 4 and 5 can't brush their teeth or use the toilet how exactly can things get worse?
Reply
(01-16-2024, 01:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-16-2024, 01:00 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-16-2024, 12:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It is trivial, it serves no purpose, it doesn't contribute anything to providing a good learning environment and I find it absolutely hilarious that just attributed - of all things - colourful socks to a slippery slope fallacy.

Just to be an awkward prick then... when do rules and discipline become not trivial?

When the rules evidence-based. With regards to school classrooms that would be where there is evidence to improving learning environments. In terms of available literature that would mean proportional measures to ensure legitimacy and moral authority (which I would argue you lose by arguing over trivial things like the colour of socks especially with respect to the consistency of application), while dealing with the root causes of behavioural issues and positive engagement with students. There's also the acknowledgement that the application of those rules need to change as age progresses, I understand where Ponty and Proth is coming from for primary school-aged children not only with respect to the kids and parents engagement with discipline but at secondary level it just smacks to me of being reductive and irrelevant to developing a good learning environment, especially in conjunction with the fact that you're dealing with teenagers and not young children.

You talk of learning environments, literature and research off the top of your head and still do not “get” the grey socks position. There is no easy answer to maintaining discipline in schools and it is a constant struggle for staff. Hard work, requiring them to work as team and play their part. It requires leadership. The issue is about children being compliant. Of course most of them will be until the situation deteriorates to the extent that many begin to rebel and the staff give up and the lid comes off. Behaviour is learned, both good and bad and it can be unlearned. You request that the parents send their children to school in the correct uniform. Most will comply, some will not and some can’t. The consequences of not complying will be according to the behaviour management/pastoral system, but you don’t give up because you think it’s trivial. The staff who can’t be arsed to enforce the “grey socks” rule are the ones who can’t be arsed to prepare lessons, mark books and record what the children have done etc. This is how good secondary schools work and always have done. It is simple on paper but it is about process. The harder the staff work, the less hard it will be. Schools should be fun and when it isn’t you’ve got a problem.
Reply
Your entire premise is built entirely on vibes and it's grounded in logical fallacies. It is you who does not "get" the point about sock colour because you don't want to get the point about sock colour.
Reply
Speaking as the partner to a secondary school teacher at a school with significant behaviour issues who hears about it all the time when she gets home - sorry Ponty but you're way off the mark with this. There was recent talk of bringing legal action against the head for negligence because all he did was go on about uniform which the teachers - to a (wo)man - see as irrelevant (and I can assure you my OH works her arse off prepping, marking and creating resources for lessons thank you very much!). "Discipline" sorts itself out when the kids are engaged properly and have the proper support ie more teachers and more classroom assistants.

ps. condescension is an incredibly ineffective method of bringing someone round to your POV
Reply
Great summary Chamonix and the actually truth.

Shame Ponty is a bit of a tit cos it’s been a good debate otherwise

As ever, best to hear the views of the people at the coalface rather than the keyboard
Someone could have been killed
Reply
(01-17-2024, 01:38 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Speaking as the partner to a secondary school teacher at a school with significant behaviour issues who hears about it all the time when she gets home - sorry Ponty but you're way off the mark with this. There was recent talk of bringing legal action against the head for negligence because all he did was go on about uniform which the teachers - to a (wo)man - see as irrelevant (and I can assure you my OH works her arse off prepping, marking and creating resources for lessons thank you very much!). "Discipline" sorts itself out when the kids are engaged properly and have the proper support ie more teachers and more classroom assistants.

ps. condescension is an incredibly ineffective method of bringing someone round to your POV

I agree with the idea that discipline sorts itself out if pupils are engaged with lessons.

Of course with any organisation, there has to be certain expectations of behaviour in schools. Schools cannot function if there is a lack of respect for all participants. There has to be some consequence for Pupils who go beyond these expected levels of behaviour. 

All my daughters were involved in clubs or organisations outside of school. They were all members of a local swimming club for example. Clearly there are issues of safety with a swimming club that mean certain types of behaviours that are not allowed e.g running along the side of the pool. But the club does not feel it necessary to proclaim they have a disciplinary code, with severe sanctions for those in breach. It clearly and calmly tell the members of the club what is expected, reminds them what is expected if they occasionally fall below those expected standard of behaviour, without the need to impose a sanction. 

Schools should adopt the same strategies.
Reply
Since the Gove era all that is happened is people in their 50s and 60s resorting to the processes that were in place in 1960s to answer a problem that has no relation to that era.

I went to a job interview a year or so ago and they asked me to give an example of when I’ve had to deal with a serious behavioural incident in the class. I haven’t, so I couldnt. And the reason has nothing to do with socks.
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)