Posts: 10,435
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
01-11-2024, 07:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2024, 07:36 AM by Remi_Moses.)
(01-11-2024, 07:16 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (01-11-2024, 05:51 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-11-2024, 03:02 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-10-2024, 11:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (01-10-2024, 09:53 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Fellows hasn't done anything of note in his time here to justify spunking a good wage on him. I actually believe the club are right not to throw silly contracts at youth prospects, all in the hope that they turn out to be good enough to attract a move to a Premier League club, and therefore to bargain for a healthy transfer fee.
I'd rather we use those funds (if they're available) on signing an established Championship player that will enhance our chances of promotion.
Of course, I'd love nothing more than to see Fellows, and numerous other academy prospects, earn their way into the first team and for the club to secure their long term services. But I do not want that to be at the detriment of the club.
Don't get me wrong, I've liked what I've seen of Fellows so far. He's shown promising glimpses. But they're just that - glimpses. Let's not go OTT here, and pretend we're letting the next Messi leave for free.
Here's the rub, by not offering the contracts and tying players down we find ourselves in these situations where potentially valuable players can leave under tribunal so we could potentially lose that big payday for a decent player. We got robbed with Ferguson, on the other hand I think we gave Harper a reasonably good contract and it didn't work out.
There's a bit of skill and a bit of luck in spotting the right ones to nurture and offer the bigger contracts to and the ones to keep more short term. There shouldn't just be a blanket policy on length/value of contract.
We had a really good set-up, but were a bit short-sighted, tight and didn't show a big enough vision to keep key personnel happy. This allowed that lot down the road to pick it up and change the colours to purple and blue and guess what, now they have a really good set-up! There was some elements we possibly couldn't compete with financially, but I suspect more realistic is that we chose not to.
Another legacy of the Lai years.
A well argued piece. I agree about the "skill and a bit of luck" but we have hardly helped ourselves with some woeful
decisions.
When we last got promoted we were strong favourites for relegation, which unfortunately happened. A worst case financial scenario at the time of promotion would show
Year 1 Premier money
Years 2 & 3 parachute payments from Premier league
Year 4 on, no parachute payments, forecast turnover under£30 million per annum.
So what did we do, we gave Grant a six year contract, knowing for 3 of those years we might have no Premier payments. Reach and Kelly 1 year of no premier payments. The argument they were cheap is rubbish as they have no
resale value, they should have been given contracts up to the period we ran out of parachute payments with the club having an option, we did that with Anichebe and wisely did not take it up.
I suspect skullduggery to put it mildly in the Kelly case he should probably have been given a contract until Xmas 2022 to prove his fitness. What payments were made to agents in this deal?
A legacy of this is that we are now having to sell our good young players for small fees. O'Shea has gone and I suspect Fellows will go as well. I have visions of Fellows playing for us next season, but as a loan player from Leicester!
This
I believe Fellows won't be the only player to have to leave.
The continued reduction in our wage bill is still needed although we have reduced it by 20% this season More urgent is the needs to get cash in to keep us afloat.
Ideally £15m may last us until the end of the season.
IMO we appear to think a fat yank is going to turn up and pay Lai off, clear all the debts and slap £20m in the bank and say carry on lads.
I honestly don't believe we will be sold just yet. Even after the DD has been completed we have to get past the offer and counter offer brinkmanship.
We maybe someway to the end game but these things take time that we no longer have.
The DD is done after the terms have been offered and accepted, not before! Obviously if the DD discovers material issues there might be an attempt to reduce the price, but nobody spends money on doing a DD exercise until they know that they’ve got a deal.
(01-11-2024, 03:02 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-10-2024, 11:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (01-10-2024, 09:53 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Fellows hasn't done anything of note in his time here to justify spunking a good wage on him. I actually believe the club are right not to throw silly contracts at youth prospects, all in the hope that they turn out to be good enough to attract a move to a Premier League club, and therefore to bargain for a healthy transfer fee.
I'd rather we use those funds (if they're available) on signing an established Championship player that will enhance our chances of promotion.
Of course, I'd love nothing more than to see Fellows, and numerous other academy prospects, earn their way into the first team and for the club to secure their long term services. But I do not want that to be at the detriment of the club.
Don't get me wrong, I've liked what I've seen of Fellows so far. He's shown promising glimpses. But they're just that - glimpses. Let's not go OTT here, and pretend we're letting the next Messi leave for free.
Here's the rub, by not offering the contracts and tying players down we find ourselves in these situations where potentially valuable players can leave under tribunal so we could potentially lose that big payday for a decent player. We got robbed with Ferguson, on the other hand I think we gave Harper a reasonably good contract and it didn't work out.
There's a bit of skill and a bit of luck in spotting the right ones to nurture and offer the bigger contracts to and the ones to keep more short term. There shouldn't just be a blanket policy on length/value of contract.
We had a really good set-up, but were a bit short-sighted, tight and didn't show a big enough vision to keep key personnel happy. This allowed that lot down the road to pick it up and change the colours to purple and blue and guess what, now they have a really good set-up! There was some elements we possibly couldn't compete with financially, but I suspect more realistic is that we chose not to.
Another legacy of the Lai years.
A well argued piece. I agree about the "skill and a bit of luck" but we have hardly helped ourselves with some woeful
decisions.
When we last got promoted we were strong favourites for relegation, which unfortunately happened. A worst case financial scenario at the time of promotion would show
Year 1 Premier money
Years 2 & 3 parachute payments from Premier league
Year 4 on, no parachute payments, forecast turnover under£30 million per annum.
So what did we do, we gave Grant a six year contract, knowing for 3 of those years we might have no Premier payments. Reach and Kelly 1 year of no premier payments. The argument they were cheap is rubbish as they have no
resale value, they should have been given contracts up to the period we ran out of parachute payments with the club having an option, we did that with Anichebe and wisely did not take it up.
I suspect skullduggery to put it mildly in the Kelly case he should probably have been given a contract until Xmas 2022 to prove his fitness. What payments were made to agents in this deal?
A legacy of this is that we are now having to sell our good young players for small fees. O'Shea has gone and I suspect Fellows will go as well. I have visions of Fellows playing for us next season, but as a loan player from Leicester!
Players of the ages of Reach and Kelly simply don’t come on very short-term contracts. They get the longest contract that they can secure. Whether either of them should have been signed is a different matter. Both are utility players covering several positions so I can see why we signed them (putting the length of contract to one side). Kelly at the time I thought was a decent signing based on what he offered, and of course he went out on loan to Wigan, did well, and then picked up a bad injury. We’ll probably never know what job he could have done for us had he not got injured.
There can never be justification for the Grant signing, both in terms of fee or length of contract. A massive millstone around the club’s neck for years. At around £7m on a 4-year contract it would have been about right - just about. Utterly reckless by all those responsible.
It's not quite as black and white as we would believe.
If Grant had been scoring 20 goals a season as we were expecting it wouldn't have been a bad buy.
We simply purchased a player we couldn't afford.
The goals dried up and we were then in the shite.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(01-11-2024, 07:35 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-11-2024, 07:16 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (01-11-2024, 05:51 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-11-2024, 03:02 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-10-2024, 11:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Here's the rub, by not offering the contracts and tying players down we find ourselves in these situations where potentially valuable players can leave under tribunal so we could potentially lose that big payday for a decent player. We got robbed with Ferguson, on the other hand I think we gave Harper a reasonably good contract and it didn't work out.
There's a bit of skill and a bit of luck in spotting the right ones to nurture and offer the bigger contracts to and the ones to keep more short term. There shouldn't just be a blanket policy on length/value of contract.
We had a really good set-up, but were a bit short-sighted, tight and didn't show a big enough vision to keep key personnel happy. This allowed that lot down the road to pick it up and change the colours to purple and blue and guess what, now they have a really good set-up! There was some elements we possibly couldn't compete with financially, but I suspect more realistic is that we chose not to.
Another legacy of the Lai years.
A well argued piece. I agree about the "skill and a bit of luck" but we have hardly helped ourselves with some woeful
decisions.
When we last got promoted we were strong favourites for relegation, which unfortunately happened. A worst case financial scenario at the time of promotion would show
Year 1 Premier money
Years 2 & 3 parachute payments from Premier league
Year 4 on, no parachute payments, forecast turnover under£30 million per annum.
So what did we do, we gave Grant a six year contract, knowing for 3 of those years we might have no Premier payments. Reach and Kelly 1 year of no premier payments. The argument they were cheap is rubbish as they have no
resale value, they should have been given contracts up to the period we ran out of parachute payments with the club having an option, we did that with Anichebe and wisely did not take it up.
I suspect skullduggery to put it mildly in the Kelly case he should probably have been given a contract until Xmas 2022 to prove his fitness. What payments were made to agents in this deal?
A legacy of this is that we are now having to sell our good young players for small fees. O'Shea has gone and I suspect Fellows will go as well. I have visions of Fellows playing for us next season, but as a loan player from Leicester!
This
I believe Fellows won't be the only player to have to leave.
The continued reduction in our wage bill is still needed although we have reduced it by 20% this season More urgent is the needs to get cash in to keep us afloat.
Ideally £15m may last us until the end of the season.
IMO we appear to think a fat yank is going to turn up and pay Lai off, clear all the debts and slap £20m in the bank and say carry on lads.
I honestly don't believe we will be sold just yet. Even after the DD has been completed we have to get past the offer and counter offer brinkmanship.
We maybe someway to the end game but these things take time that we no longer have.
The DD is done after the terms have been offered and accepted, not before! Obviously if the DD discovers material issues there might be an attempt to reduce the price, but nobody spends money on doing a DD exercise until they know that they’ve got a deal.
(01-11-2024, 03:02 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-10-2024, 11:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (01-10-2024, 09:53 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Fellows hasn't done anything of note in his time here to justify spunking a good wage on him. I actually believe the club are right not to throw silly contracts at youth prospects, all in the hope that they turn out to be good enough to attract a move to a Premier League club, and therefore to bargain for a healthy transfer fee.
I'd rather we use those funds (if they're available) on signing an established Championship player that will enhance our chances of promotion.
Of course, I'd love nothing more than to see Fellows, and numerous other academy prospects, earn their way into the first team and for the club to secure their long term services. But I do not want that to be at the detriment of the club.
Don't get me wrong, I've liked what I've seen of Fellows so far. He's shown promising glimpses. But they're just that - glimpses. Let's not go OTT here, and pretend we're letting the next Messi leave for free.
Here's the rub, by not offering the contracts and tying players down we find ourselves in these situations where potentially valuable players can leave under tribunal so we could potentially lose that big payday for a decent player. We got robbed with Ferguson, on the other hand I think we gave Harper a reasonably good contract and it didn't work out.
There's a bit of skill and a bit of luck in spotting the right ones to nurture and offer the bigger contracts to and the ones to keep more short term. There shouldn't just be a blanket policy on length/value of contract.
We had a really good set-up, but were a bit short-sighted, tight and didn't show a big enough vision to keep key personnel happy. This allowed that lot down the road to pick it up and change the colours to purple and blue and guess what, now they have a really good set-up! There was some elements we possibly couldn't compete with financially, but I suspect more realistic is that we chose not to.
Another legacy of the Lai years.
A well argued piece. I agree about the "skill and a bit of luck" but we have hardly helped ourselves with some woeful
decisions.
When we last got promoted we were strong favourites for relegation, which unfortunately happened. A worst case financial scenario at the time of promotion would show
Year 1 Premier money
Years 2 & 3 parachute payments from Premier league
Year 4 on, no parachute payments, forecast turnover under£30 million per annum.
So what did we do, we gave Grant a six year contract, knowing for 3 of those years we might have no Premier payments. Reach and Kelly 1 year of no premier payments. The argument they were cheap is rubbish as they have no
resale value, they should have been given contracts up to the period we ran out of parachute payments with the club having an option, we did that with Anichebe and wisely did not take it up.
I suspect skullduggery to put it mildly in the Kelly case he should probably have been given a contract until Xmas 2022 to prove his fitness. What payments were made to agents in this deal?
A legacy of this is that we are now having to sell our good young players for small fees. O'Shea has gone and I suspect Fellows will go as well. I have visions of Fellows playing for us next season, but as a loan player from Leicester!
Players of the ages of Reach and Kelly simply don’t come on very short-term contracts. They get the longest contract that they can secure. Whether either of them should have been signed is a different matter. Both are utility players covering several positions so I can see why we signed them (putting the length of contract to one side). Kelly at the time I thought was a decent signing based on what he offered, and of course he went out on loan to Wigan, did well, and then picked up a bad injury. We’ll probably never know what job he could have done for us had he not got injured.
There can never be justification for the Grant signing, both in terms of fee or length of contract. A massive millstone around the club’s neck for years. At around £7m on a 4-year contract it would have been about right - just about. Utterly reckless by all those responsible.
It's not quite as black and white as we would believe.
If Grant had been scoring 20 goals a season as we were expecting it wouldn't have been a bad buy.
We simply purchased a player we couldn't afford.
The goals dried up and we were then in the shite.
Touching cloth?
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Kelly was a free agent when we signed him, if he has other offers then he would have taken them up when his contract at Crystal Palace expired. If you had looked at how many games he had played in the previous two seasons (one) and his age (over 30) I doubt you would have considered him a good signing.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(01-11-2024, 07:35 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-11-2024, 07:16 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (01-11-2024, 05:51 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-11-2024, 03:02 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-10-2024, 11:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Here's the rub, by not offering the contracts and tying players down we find ourselves in these situations where potentially valuable players can leave under tribunal so we could potentially lose that big payday for a decent player. We got robbed with Ferguson, on the other hand I think we gave Harper a reasonably good contract and it didn't work out.
There's a bit of skill and a bit of luck in spotting the right ones to nurture and offer the bigger contracts to and the ones to keep more short term. There shouldn't just be a blanket policy on length/value of contract.
We had a really good set-up, but were a bit short-sighted, tight and didn't show a big enough vision to keep key personnel happy. This allowed that lot down the road to pick it up and change the colours to purple and blue and guess what, now they have a really good set-up! There was some elements we possibly couldn't compete with financially, but I suspect more realistic is that we chose not to.
Another legacy of the Lai years.
A well argued piece. I agree about the "skill and a bit of luck" but we have hardly helped ourselves with some woeful
decisions.
When we last got promoted we were strong favourites for relegation, which unfortunately happened. A worst case financial scenario at the time of promotion would show
Year 1 Premier money
Years 2 & 3 parachute payments from Premier league
Year 4 on, no parachute payments, forecast turnover under£30 million per annum.
So what did we do, we gave Grant a six year contract, knowing for 3 of those years we might have no Premier payments. Reach and Kelly 1 year of no premier payments. The argument they were cheap is rubbish as they have no
resale value, they should have been given contracts up to the period we ran out of parachute payments with the club having an option, we did that with Anichebe and wisely did not take it up.
I suspect skullduggery to put it mildly in the Kelly case he should probably have been given a contract until Xmas 2022 to prove his fitness. What payments were made to agents in this deal?
A legacy of this is that we are now having to sell our good young players for small fees. O'Shea has gone and I suspect Fellows will go as well. I have visions of Fellows playing for us next season, but as a loan player from Leicester!
This
I believe Fellows won't be the only player to have to leave.
The continued reduction in our wage bill is still needed although we have reduced it by 20% this season More urgent is the needs to get cash in to keep us afloat.
Ideally £15m may last us until the end of the season.
IMO we appear to think a fat yank is going to turn up and pay Lai off, clear all the debts and slap £20m in the bank and say carry on lads.
I honestly don't believe we will be sold just yet. Even after the DD has been completed we have to get past the offer and counter offer brinkmanship.
We maybe someway to the end game but these things take time that we no longer have.
The DD is done after the terms have been offered and accepted, not before! Obviously if the DD discovers material issues there might be an attempt to reduce the price, but nobody spends money on doing a DD exercise until they know that they’ve got a deal.
(01-11-2024, 03:02 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-10-2024, 11:49 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (01-10-2024, 09:53 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Fellows hasn't done anything of note in his time here to justify spunking a good wage on him. I actually believe the club are right not to throw silly contracts at youth prospects, all in the hope that they turn out to be good enough to attract a move to a Premier League club, and therefore to bargain for a healthy transfer fee.
I'd rather we use those funds (if they're available) on signing an established Championship player that will enhance our chances of promotion.
Of course, I'd love nothing more than to see Fellows, and numerous other academy prospects, earn their way into the first team and for the club to secure their long term services. But I do not want that to be at the detriment of the club.
Don't get me wrong, I've liked what I've seen of Fellows so far. He's shown promising glimpses. But they're just that - glimpses. Let's not go OTT here, and pretend we're letting the next Messi leave for free.
Here's the rub, by not offering the contracts and tying players down we find ourselves in these situations where potentially valuable players can leave under tribunal so we could potentially lose that big payday for a decent player. We got robbed with Ferguson, on the other hand I think we gave Harper a reasonably good contract and it didn't work out.
There's a bit of skill and a bit of luck in spotting the right ones to nurture and offer the bigger contracts to and the ones to keep more short term. There shouldn't just be a blanket policy on length/value of contract.
We had a really good set-up, but were a bit short-sighted, tight and didn't show a big enough vision to keep key personnel happy. This allowed that lot down the road to pick it up and change the colours to purple and blue and guess what, now they have a really good set-up! There was some elements we possibly couldn't compete with financially, but I suspect more realistic is that we chose not to.
Another legacy of the Lai years.
A well argued piece. I agree about the "skill and a bit of luck" but we have hardly helped ourselves with some woeful
decisions.
When we last got promoted we were strong favourites for relegation, which unfortunately happened. A worst case financial scenario at the time of promotion would show
Year 1 Premier money
Years 2 & 3 parachute payments from Premier league
Year 4 on, no parachute payments, forecast turnover under£30 million per annum.
So what did we do, we gave Grant a six year contract, knowing for 3 of those years we might have no Premier payments. Reach and Kelly 1 year of no premier payments. The argument they were cheap is rubbish as they have no
resale value, they should have been given contracts up to the period we ran out of parachute payments with the club having an option, we did that with Anichebe and wisely did not take it up.
I suspect skullduggery to put it mildly in the Kelly case he should probably have been given a contract until Xmas 2022 to prove his fitness. What payments were made to agents in this deal?
A legacy of this is that we are now having to sell our good young players for small fees. O'Shea has gone and I suspect Fellows will go as well. I have visions of Fellows playing for us next season, but as a loan player from Leicester!
Players of the ages of Reach and Kelly simply don’t come on very short-term contracts. They get the longest contract that they can secure. Whether either of them should have been signed is a different matter. Both are utility players covering several positions so I can see why we signed them (putting the length of contract to one side). Kelly at the time I thought was a decent signing based on what he offered, and of course he went out on loan to Wigan, did well, and then picked up a bad injury. We’ll probably never know what job he could have done for us had he not got injured.
There can never be justification for the Grant signing, both in terms of fee or length of contract. A massive millstone around the club’s neck for years. At around £7m on a 4-year contract it would have been about right - just about. Utterly reckless by all those responsible.
It's not quite as black and white as we would believe.
If Grant had been scoring 20 goals a season as we were expecting it wouldn't have been a bad buy.
We simply purchased a player we couldn't afford.
The goals dried up and we were then in the shite.
Another poem that doesn't rhyme
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
In silent verses,
Words dance in rhythmless flow,
Meaning still blooms bright.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I think Fellows will sign with us.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(01-11-2024, 12:10 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think Fellows will sign with us.
I mean he is a jolly good Fellows after all...
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(01-11-2024, 12:10 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think Fellows will sign with us.
Only to protect our future fee, in a Jude Bellingham kind of way (not saying he is the next Jude Bellingham).
Posts: 10,435
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(01-11-2024, 12:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (01-11-2024, 12:10 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think Fellows will sign with us.
Only to protect our future fee, in a Jude Bellingham kind of way (not saying he is the next Jude Bellingham).
Do we do wise things like that ?
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(01-11-2024, 12:46 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (01-11-2024, 12:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (01-11-2024, 12:10 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think Fellows will sign with us.
Only to protect our future fee, in a Jude Bellingham kind of way (not saying he is the next Jude Bellingham).
Do we do wise things like that ?
I think this comes down to how you treat the kids and their family through the process. Blues seem to have a way of creating "family", and a sense of belonging. Ours can't wait to FODTV.
|