Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(01-10-2024, 07:19 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-10-2024, 05:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s archaic industrial era new right thinking for a world that has left it behind. Managing discipline is a people skill, not a pair of socks.
My recollection of the school contemporaries who did better than me at 'O' and 'A' level is that they were just generally more diligent, probably more mature, made smarter choices and were, often, simply more gifted.
I've never had reason to suspect it had anything to do with wardrobe discipline or tidy hair.
If only I had opted to wear black or grey socks at school/sixth form instead of patterned colourful ones, then I would have been able to get an A in A-Level chemistry and would have been able to do Natural Sciences at Cambridge instead of Mechanical Engineering at Birmingham.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
01-10-2024, 07:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2024, 07:36 PM by Fido.)
(01-10-2024, 07:19 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-10-2024, 05:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s archaic industrial era new right thinking for a world that has left it behind. Managing discipline is a people skill, not a pair of socks.
My recollection of the school contemporaries who did better than me at 'O' and 'A' level is that they were just generally more diligent, probably more mature, made smarter choices and were, often, simply more gifted.
I've never had reason to suspect it had anything to do with wardrobe discipline or tidy hair.
Wouldn’t the ideal position be that we have both? Discipline and respect for teachers that is driven by both rules and interesting lessons instead of constant testing? Some element of benchmarking needs to be done to make sure schools and teachers are on track but it seems my lad has tests most weeks on some subject or another.
The school dress element is important because if you don’t have a rule then kids push boundaries ever further and the ball is in their court. Zero tolerance is not a bad thing as long as punishment is appropriate; kids need to know where they stand, end of. Uniforms are a good thing and a leveller to save those less well off being teased at a place where the whole point of the exercise is learning and social interaction in a friendly environment. If different coloured socks, hair, make-up is allowed then where is the line to be drawn exactly?
This wasn’t so much a pop at you, Oss, just more of a general comment on the thread, of course.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
01-10-2024, 07:46 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2024, 07:48 PM by CaptainFantastico.)
I’ve worked in state education that includes very tight rules on uniform to no restrictions at all. The better discipline and behaviour was in the latter. It’s one of those relics that everyone focuses on but no one can really justify in this day and age.
I have absolutely no sense of why controlling how a person defines themselves in that way is either right or helpful. It isn’t
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I’ve always seen uniforms as a good thing. If everyone is wearing the same gear then it isn’t as obvious in the difference between the group wearing the latest trend and those wearing the primark basics. There will still be the differences but they won’t be as marked.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
01-10-2024, 08:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-10-2024, 08:06 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(01-10-2024, 07:35 PM)Fido Wrote: (01-10-2024, 07:19 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-10-2024, 05:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s archaic industrial era new right thinking for a world that has left it behind. Managing discipline is a people skill, not a pair of socks.
My recollection of the school contemporaries who did better than me at 'O' and 'A' level is that they were just generally more diligent, probably more mature, made smarter choices and were, often, simply more gifted.
I've never had reason to suspect it had anything to do with wardrobe discipline or tidy hair.
Wouldn’t the ideal position be that we have both? Discipline and respect for teachers that is driven by both rules and interesting lessons instead of constant testing? Some element of benchmarking needs to be done to make sure schools and teachers are on track but it seems my lad has tests most weeks on some subject or another.
The school dress element is important because if you don’t have a rule then kids push boundaries ever further and the ball is in their court. Zero tolerance is not a bad thing as long as punishment is appropriate; kids need to know where they stand, end of. Uniforms are a good thing and a leveller to save those less well off being teased at a place where the whole point of the exercise is learning and social interaction in a friendly environment. If different coloured socks, hair, make-up is allowed then where is the line to be drawn exactly?
This wasn’t so much a pop at you, Oss, just more of a general comment on the thread, of course.
There are much better things to focus on for school discipline than minor uniform things that you won't see like socks.
Smaller class sizes enabling better management of pupils, engagement of students so they don't get bored and disruptive, extracurricular opportunities (I did some extra maths qualification alongside my GCSE's that was basically AS level maths) so kids don't get bored, having the resources to isolate disruptive individuals and find out why they are being disruptive rather than cop-out exclusions, positive reinforcement of behaviours from primary upwards, cross-curricular activities (maybe try and build maths skills by applying it to more practical subjects or activities that some kids prefer to do?) etc. But all that requires money, money for staff, money for facilities, money for support and money to develop and implement new curriculums. And stop tying teachers up in paperwork and writing lesson plans.
I'd also say there is a level of difference between sensible school uniform and pointless and overbearing power trip regulations. Blazer, jumper, tie, white shirt, black shoes and trousers - fine. Socks - why? Branded school PE shorts/skirts - why? The very sensible line here is outward appearance and not focusing on the minutiae.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Follow rules. Do as you’re told. Don’t question.
Turn 16/18 - off you go now, innovate, adapt, explore
Bizarre
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(01-10-2024, 07:35 PM)Fido Wrote: (01-10-2024, 07:19 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-10-2024, 05:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s archaic industrial era new right thinking for a world that has left it behind. Managing discipline is a people skill, not a pair of socks.
My recollection of the school contemporaries who did better than me at 'O' and 'A' level is that they were just generally more diligent, probably more mature, made smarter choices and were, often, simply more gifted.
I've never had reason to suspect it had anything to do with wardrobe discipline or tidy hair.
Wouldn’t the ideal position be that we have both? Discipline and respect for teachers that is driven by both rules and interesting lessons instead of constant testing? Some element of benchmarking needs to be done to make sure schools and teachers are on track but it seems my lad has tests most weeks on some subject or another.
The school dress element is important because if you don’t have a rule then kids push boundaries ever further and the ball is in their court. Zero tolerance is not a bad thing as long as punishment is appropriate; kids need to know where they stand, end of. Uniforms are a good thing and a leveller to save those less well off being teased at a place where the whole point of the exercise is learning and social interaction in a friendly environment. If different coloured socks, hair, make-up is allowed then where is the line to be drawn exactly?
This wasn’t so much a pop at you, Oss, just more of a general comment on the thread, of course.
This.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
01-11-2024, 10:52 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2024, 10:53 AM by Protheroe.)
To be fair, one of the cleverest and quickest on the uptake people I've ever met was a young chap who'd had a very traditional Jewish education (no formal qualifications or anything like that). Though I imagine all the education he ever needed was spending two years between 16-18 on a Kibbutz on the Gaza frontline and then a year or two in the IDF. I worked with him to set up a Group Property Department for £1 billion PLC which he ended up leading.
However the conceit in some of the arguments here is that you can tailor education to an individual. You can't. At least not in the state sector as it'd be completely unaffordable.
I hesitate to say it, but perhaps what we have is #leastworst.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(01-11-2024, 09:11 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-10-2024, 07:35 PM)Fido Wrote: (01-10-2024, 07:19 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-10-2024, 05:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: It’s archaic industrial era new right thinking for a world that has left it behind. Managing discipline is a people skill, not a pair of socks.
My recollection of the school contemporaries who did better than me at 'O' and 'A' level is that they were just generally more diligent, probably more mature, made smarter choices and were, often, simply more gifted.
I've never had reason to suspect it had anything to do with wardrobe discipline or tidy hair.
Wouldn’t the ideal position be that we have both? Discipline and respect for teachers that is driven by both rules and interesting lessons instead of constant testing? Some element of benchmarking needs to be done to make sure schools and teachers are on track but it seems my lad has tests most weeks on some subject or another.
The school dress element is important because if you don’t have a rule then kids push boundaries ever further and the ball is in their court. Zero tolerance is not a bad thing as long as punishment is appropriate; kids need to know where they stand, end of. Uniforms are a good thing and a leveller to save those less well off being teased at a place where the whole point of the exercise is learning and social interaction in a friendly environment. If different coloured socks, hair, make-up is allowed then where is the line to be drawn exactly?
This wasn’t so much a pop at you, Oss, just more of a general comment on the thread, of course.
This.
Do you have so little respect and understanding of secondary school children that you think the adoption of a school uniform means that they won't know who among their class colleagues come from wealthy or poor homes. Probably the most ridiculous argument of all time.
It's not a hill I would opt to die on, but I don't understand why the state through the medium of schools need to dictate what my children wear for a significant period of their childhood.
Other western countries conspicuously don't insist on school uniform, and their mountains have not crumbled into the sea nor their rivers run dry.
|