Problems ignored
#51
(07-03-2023, 08:43 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The number of cars on the road was tiny in the 60s compared to now. So they weren’t in the sane position as we are now. It’s incomparable.

The fact is I dont think you’ll change peoples behaviours and get many more on bikes here. I could be wrong, but I doubt it. People do 5 minute journeys in their cars as they can’t be bothered to walk. What does that tell you?

Doesn't really matter with regards to the number of cars, I'm more on about infrastructure in dense urban areas and in both the UK and the Netherlands the infrastructure in those areas is centuries old and in both cases it was turned towards prioritising cars in the 1960s, the Netherlands just started reversing it. Unless you manage to flatten Birmingham and rebuild it from scratch to enable full modal separation like in Milton Keynes you are going to have to prioritise.

As for your question, that says to me that it's too easy to drive and not easy enough to walk.

(07-03-2023, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:55 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No I’m not I said give priority to pedestrians, I said stop bad and dangerous driving, I said stop illegal parking. You are talking absolute bollocks if you banned mobility vehicles tomorrow in this country you are condemning thousands of people to less liberty and less equality.

Right, and where did I talk about banning mobility vehicles? Please, do point it out. Where did I talk about banning anything?

I'm pretty sure there are specialist mobility cars for disabled people that are legal to use in cycle lanes, seeing as I've seen them. As I said, visit the Netherlands.

What are you on about? Many people who are either disabled have a carer and need a proper car not a glorified electric scooter. Many can’t get about by themselves. Some have special needs which means they need help with transport from a carer. You would be rightly offended if I was showing such ignorance about other minorities but you seem to be glibly brushing aside some of the most vulnerable people in societies right to access places others take for granted easily for the sake of a pious and myopic anti-car utopia. 

How about you try and listen or talk to people who actually have to navigate the U.K. with someone who is in a wheelchair rather than just tell people to visit Amsterdam.

Derek, kindly read what I've read. Firstly, that isn't a glorified scooter, it's a specialised car that operates like a car but also provides independence. Secondly, cars aren't banned and you can still use larger adapted cars, aas evidenced by this website. Thirdly, cars aren't banned in Amsterdam, you can still drive if you want to and need to and you still see people drive in Amsterdam, just fewer people than in other comparable cities. Fourthly, disabled people aren't a monolith and improving pedestrian access and prioritising pedestrians helps wheelchair accessibility as well as people with other disabilities like being visually impaired.

All of these supposed "problems" that you are highlighting that effect less able people have been thought of and solutions exist already, using the real world example of the Netherlands. Instead of relaying issues that have already been addressed, apply them to a Dutch city and see how they stack up instead of arguing like nobody has ever thought or considered them before. Why do you think I told you to visit the Netherlands? If you want to see solutions to your problems go look at them.

How about you live in the here and now in the UK rather than constantly refer to a city unlike any city here. With all due respect you have demonstrated that you know absolutely nothing about the challenges of those who live or look after people who have to use wheelchairs. You may not realise it but it’s quite offensive.

I do live in the here and now in the UK, and pedestrian access for people with various disabilities is poor and oftentimes unsafe. Am I allowed to mention infrastructure that makes it safer for a wheelchair user or blind person to use the pavement or cross the road, even if the infrastructure that does that might make things inconvenient for a car as they need to take a detour?

I don't know why you're zeroing in on this one thing that affects disabled people and ignoring the thousands of other things. You can't say "disabled people can do this here" and ignore me saying "they can also do that there but they also can do other things and that's better than it is here". Do you know what one of the most accessible cities in Europe is? Breda, in the Netherlands. So clearly people already considered what you're raising as an issue and figured out solutions, otherwise it wouldn't have won that award would it?

And you're right, I don't understand how me pointing out that those things you're identifying as problems have solutions in other countries and that you should visit one of those is offensive to less abled people.
Reply
#52
(07-03-2023, 08:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:43 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The number of cars on the road was tiny in the 60s compared to now. So they weren’t in the sane position as we are now. It’s incomparable.

The fact is I dont think you’ll change peoples behaviours and get many more on bikes here. I could be wrong, but I doubt it. People do 5 minute journeys in their cars as they can’t be bothered to walk. What does that tell you?

Doesn't really matter with regards to the number of cars, I'm more on about infrastructure in dense urban areas and in both the UK and the Netherlands the infrastructure in those areas is centuries old and in both cases it was turned towards prioritising cars in the 1960s, the Netherlands just started reversing it. Unless you manage to flatten Birmingham and rebuild it from scratch to enable full modal separation like in Milton Keynes you are going to have to prioritise.

As for your question, that says to me that it's too easy to drive and not easy enough to walk.

(07-03-2023, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Right, and where did I talk about banning mobility vehicles? Please, do point it out. Where did I talk about banning anything?

I'm pretty sure there are specialist mobility cars for disabled people that are legal to use in cycle lanes, seeing as I've seen them. As I said, visit the Netherlands.

What are you on about? Many people who are either disabled have a carer and need a proper car not a glorified electric scooter. Many can’t get about by themselves. Some have special needs which means they need help with transport from a carer. You would be rightly offended if I was showing such ignorance about other minorities but you seem to be glibly brushing aside some of the most vulnerable people in societies right to access places others take for granted easily for the sake of a pious and myopic anti-car utopia. 

How about you try and listen or talk to people who actually have to navigate the U.K. with someone who is in a wheelchair rather than just tell people to visit Amsterdam.

Derek, kindly read what I've read. Firstly, that isn't a glorified scooter, it's a specialised car that operates like a car but also provides independence. Secondly, cars aren't banned and you can still use larger adapted cars, aas evidenced by this website. Thirdly, cars aren't banned in Amsterdam, you can still drive if you want to and need to and you still see people drive in Amsterdam, just fewer people than in other comparable cities. Fourthly, disabled people aren't a monolith and improving pedestrian access and prioritising pedestrians helps wheelchair accessibility as well as people with other disabilities like being visually impaired.

All of these supposed "problems" that you are highlighting that effect less able people have been thought of and solutions exist already, using the real world example of the Netherlands. Instead of relaying issues that have already been addressed, apply them to a Dutch city and see how they stack up instead of arguing like nobody has ever thought or considered them before. Why do you think I told you to visit the Netherlands? If you want to see solutions to your problems go look at them.

How about you live in the here and now in the UK rather than constantly refer to a city unlike any city here. With all due respect you have demonstrated that you know absolutely nothing about the challenges of those who live or look after people who have to use wheelchairs. You may not realise it but it’s quite offensive.

I do live in the here and now in the UK, and pedestrian access for people with various disabilities is poor and oftentimes unsafe. Am I allowed to mention infrastructure that makes it safer for a wheelchair user or blind person to use the pavement or cross the road, even if the infrastructure that does that might make things inconvenient for a car as they need to take a detour?

I don't know why you're zeroing in on this one thing that affects disabled people and ignoring the thousands of other things. You can't say "disabled people can do this here" and ignore me saying "they can also do that there but they also can do other things and that's better than it is here". Do you know what one of the most accessible cities in Europe is? Breda, in the Netherlands. So clearly people already considered what you're raising as an issue and figured out solutions, otherwise it wouldn't have won that award would it?

And you're right, I don't understand how me pointing out that those things you're identifying as problems have solutions in other countries and that you should visit one of those is offensive to less abled people.

Not easy enough to walk? That’s absurd. You could argue about cycle lanes but there’s literally pavements everywhere to walk. It’s a piece of cake (for able bodied people) to walk round the city. Tons can’t be arsed. They’d rather drive paying huge prices for cars and fuel.

Then there’s people disabled, and those not fit enough to walk and cycle, the elderly etc. Then there’s also the safety aspect of walking round a large city. I honestly think you’re in cloud cuckoo land with this.

In the 60s a small percentage of people had cars, so it wouldn’t be that hard to get people to use bikes and walk. Now every other person has a car and despite huge costs, traffic etc, they’d still rather drive than use public transport of bikes or walk. Cars are now way more ingrained in our culture than in the 60s. You may persuade a few to get on their bikes, but the idea it can get even close to the Netherlands is utterly bonkers and totally detached from reality IMO.
Reply
#53
(07-03-2023, 09:24 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:43 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The number of cars on the road was tiny in the 60s compared to now. So they weren’t in the sane position as we are now. It’s incomparable.

The fact is I dont think you’ll change peoples behaviours and get many more on bikes here. I could be wrong, but I doubt it. People do 5 minute journeys in their cars as they can’t be bothered to walk. What does that tell you?

Doesn't really matter with regards to the number of cars, I'm more on about infrastructure in dense urban areas and in both the UK and the Netherlands the infrastructure in those areas is centuries old and in both cases it was turned towards prioritising cars in the 1960s, the Netherlands just started reversing it. Unless you manage to flatten Birmingham and rebuild it from scratch to enable full modal separation like in Milton Keynes you are going to have to prioritise.

As for your question, that says to me that it's too easy to drive and not easy enough to walk.

(07-03-2023, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What are you on about? Many people who are either disabled have a carer and need a proper car not a glorified electric scooter. Many can’t get about by themselves. Some have special needs which means they need help with transport from a carer. You would be rightly offended if I was showing such ignorance about other minorities but you seem to be glibly brushing aside some of the most vulnerable people in societies right to access places others take for granted easily for the sake of a pious and myopic anti-car utopia. 

How about you try and listen or talk to people who actually have to navigate the U.K. with someone who is in a wheelchair rather than just tell people to visit Amsterdam.

Derek, kindly read what I've read. Firstly, that isn't a glorified scooter, it's a specialised car that operates like a car but also provides independence. Secondly, cars aren't banned and you can still use larger adapted cars, aas evidenced by this website. Thirdly, cars aren't banned in Amsterdam, you can still drive if you want to and need to and you still see people drive in Amsterdam, just fewer people than in other comparable cities. Fourthly, disabled people aren't a monolith and improving pedestrian access and prioritising pedestrians helps wheelchair accessibility as well as people with other disabilities like being visually impaired.

All of these supposed "problems" that you are highlighting that effect less able people have been thought of and solutions exist already, using the real world example of the Netherlands. Instead of relaying issues that have already been addressed, apply them to a Dutch city and see how they stack up instead of arguing like nobody has ever thought or considered them before. Why do you think I told you to visit the Netherlands? If you want to see solutions to your problems go look at them.

How about you live in the here and now in the UK rather than constantly refer to a city unlike any city here. With all due respect you have demonstrated that you know absolutely nothing about the challenges of those who live or look after people who have to use wheelchairs. You may not realise it but it’s quite offensive.

I do live in the here and now in the UK, and pedestrian access for people with various disabilities is poor and oftentimes unsafe. Am I allowed to mention infrastructure that makes it safer for a wheelchair user or blind person to use the pavement or cross the road, even if the infrastructure that does that might make things inconvenient for a car as they need to take a detour?

I don't know why you're zeroing in on this one thing that affects disabled people and ignoring the thousands of other things. You can't say "disabled people can do this here" and ignore me saying "they can also do that there but they also can do other things and that's better than it is here". Do you know what one of the most accessible cities in Europe is? Breda, in the Netherlands. So clearly people already considered what you're raising as an issue and figured out solutions, otherwise it wouldn't have won that award would it?

And you're right, I don't understand how me pointing out that those things you're identifying as problems have solutions in other countries and that you should visit one of those is offensive to less abled people.

Not easy enough to walk? That’s absurd. You could argue about cycle lanes but there’s literally pavements everywhere to walk. It’s a piece of cake (for able bodied people) to walk round the city. Tons can’t be arsed. They’d rather drive paying huge prices for cars and fuel.

Then there’s people disabled, and those not fit enough to walk and cycle, the elderly etc. Then there’s also the safety aspect of walking round a large city. I honestly think you’re in cloud cuckoo land with this.

In the 60s a small percentage of people had cars, so it wouldn’t be that hard to get people to use bikes and walk. Now every other person has a car and despite huge costs, traffic etc, they’d still rather drive than use public transport of bikes or walk. Cars are now way more ingrained in our culture than in the 60s. You may persuade a few to get on their bikes, but the idea it can get even close to the Netherlands is utterly bonkers and totally detached from reality IMO.

Right then, we'll find out in 30 years once Birmingham's transport plan is operational then won't we?
Reply
#54
(07-03-2023, 09:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 09:24 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:43 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The number of cars on the road was tiny in the 60s compared to now. So they weren’t in the sane position as we are now. It’s incomparable.

The fact is I dont think you’ll change peoples behaviours and get many more on bikes here. I could be wrong, but I doubt it. People do 5 minute journeys in their cars as they can’t be bothered to walk. What does that tell you?

Doesn't really matter with regards to the number of cars, I'm more on about infrastructure in dense urban areas and in both the UK and the Netherlands the infrastructure in those areas is centuries old and in both cases it was turned towards prioritising cars in the 1960s, the Netherlands just started reversing it. Unless you manage to flatten Birmingham and rebuild it from scratch to enable full modal separation like in Milton Keynes you are going to have to prioritise.

As for your question, that says to me that it's too easy to drive and not easy enough to walk.

(07-03-2023, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Derek, kindly read what I've read. Firstly, that isn't a glorified scooter, it's a specialised car that operates like a car but also provides independence. Secondly, cars aren't banned and you can still use larger adapted cars, aas evidenced by this website. Thirdly, cars aren't banned in Amsterdam, you can still drive if you want to and need to and you still see people drive in Amsterdam, just fewer people than in other comparable cities. Fourthly, disabled people aren't a monolith and improving pedestrian access and prioritising pedestrians helps wheelchair accessibility as well as people with other disabilities like being visually impaired.

All of these supposed "problems" that you are highlighting that effect less able people have been thought of and solutions exist already, using the real world example of the Netherlands. Instead of relaying issues that have already been addressed, apply them to a Dutch city and see how they stack up instead of arguing like nobody has ever thought or considered them before. Why do you think I told you to visit the Netherlands? If you want to see solutions to your problems go look at them.

How about you live in the here and now in the UK rather than constantly refer to a city unlike any city here. With all due respect you have demonstrated that you know absolutely nothing about the challenges of those who live or look after people who have to use wheelchairs. You may not realise it but it’s quite offensive.

I do live in the here and now in the UK, and pedestrian access for people with various disabilities is poor and oftentimes unsafe. Am I allowed to mention infrastructure that makes it safer for a wheelchair user or blind person to use the pavement or cross the road, even if the infrastructure that does that might make things inconvenient for a car as they need to take a detour?

I don't know why you're zeroing in on this one thing that affects disabled people and ignoring the thousands of other things. You can't say "disabled people can do this here" and ignore me saying "they can also do that there but they also can do other things and that's better than it is here". Do you know what one of the most accessible cities in Europe is? Breda, in the Netherlands. So clearly people already considered what you're raising as an issue and figured out solutions, otherwise it wouldn't have won that award would it?

And you're right, I don't understand how me pointing out that those things you're identifying as problems have solutions in other countries and that you should visit one of those is offensive to less abled people.

Not easy enough to walk? That’s absurd. You could argue about cycle lanes but there’s literally pavements everywhere to walk. It’s a piece of cake (for able bodied people) to walk round the city. Tons can’t be arsed. They’d rather drive paying huge prices for cars and fuel.

Then there’s people disabled, and those not fit enough to walk and cycle, the elderly etc. Then there’s also the safety aspect of walking round a large city. I honestly think you’re in cloud cuckoo land with this.

In the 60s a small percentage of people had cars, so it wouldn’t be that hard to get people to use bikes and walk. Now every other person has a car and despite huge costs, traffic etc, they’d still rather drive than use public transport of bikes or walk. Cars are now way more ingrained in our culture than in the 60s. You may persuade a few to get on their bikes, but the idea it can get even close to the Netherlands is utterly bonkers and totally detached from reality IMO.

Right then, we'll find out in 30 years once Birmingham's transport plan is operational then won't we?

Well we’ll find out sooner probably as I think in order to persuade people, they’ll have to price people out of cars or force them. The backlash to this will be seismic IMO.

In fact reading about Birmingham’s transport plan just now, it sounds bonkers to me. I have no idea how they think the elderly, obese, disabled etc can get around on a bike or walk. I guess the answer will be use public transport. But then the above have got to get to the public transport. Whereas right now they can drive in to the city from where they live. I think there’ll be a huge backlash.

So I’ll be shocked if it ever becomes operational in the form proposed.
Reply
#55
Birmingham's plans are great. Doubling the population of the inner ring road, creating more public green space, extending public transport, walkability and cycling provisions in line with Copenhagen (which, unlike Amsterdam is fully accessible to cars and is my favourite city on earth, except the beer prices), distributed heating schemes which are the best way to decarbonise heating in a ln urban area. More transport options, more private and social housing, cheaper and cleaner energy, redevelop seriously deprived parts of the inner city, expand the public realm. Don't see what's wrong with that really, it's basically going back to Joe Chamberlain's original vision for the city.

Also, they're not banning cars. They're just reducing the number of lanes. If you need to drive into the city centre you just use the car lanes that are available and the roads in the core part of the city centre that aren't changing.
Reply
#56
(07-03-2023, 11:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Birmingham's plans are great. Doubling the population of the inner ring road, creating more public green space, extending public transport, walkability and cycling provisions in line with Copenhagen (which, unlike Amsterdam is fully accessible to cars and is my favourite city on earth, except the beer prices), distributed heating schemes which are the best way to decarbonise heating in a ln urban area. More transport options, more private and social housing, cheaper and cleaner energy, redevelop seriously deprived parts of the inner city, expand the public realm. Don't see what's wrong with that really, it's basically going back to Joe Chamberlain's original vision for the city.

Also, they're not banning cars. They're just reducing the number of lanes. If you need to drive into the city centre you just use the car lanes that are available and the roads in the core part of the city centre that aren't changing.

If that’s the case, the vast majority will continue to use cars IMO. And the cycle lanes will be largely empty, especially in the winter. If the car lanes are limited, it will simply increase congestion on those that remain.

The green spaces we have in the city are mainly filled with homeless and drugs in my experience, not the sort of place you’d sit with your family. I’m all for regenerating run down areas, but not this way.

This reminds me of some regeneration ideas of the past which end up completely different to the utopia that’s envisaged.

But anyway, I’ll be staggered if it goes ahead in its proposed form.
Reply
#57
(07-03-2023, 08:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:02 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:50 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: As I said, I suggest you visit a Dutch town or city. It bluntly allays your concerns, they even have raised crosswalks making it easier for people in wheelchairs to get around than in the UK.

I'd also like to point out that you're being dismissive of two rather large groups of disabled people where cars are the number one danger to mobility: the visually and hearing impaired.

I’ve only had a quick Google on this, so I may be wrong, but it suggests it’s very expensive to own a car in the Netherlands. Is that (part of) the reason public transport and bikes are popular? If so, that goes back to me talking about the working classes being priced out of car ownership. Is that the real reason people use bikes and public transport more? I genuinely don’t know.

The Netherlands has a comparable car ownership rate to the UK.

Fair enough. But I have a feeling, and I could be wrong, that the U.K. culturally see cars as a hobby in addition to a mode of transport. The number of expensive brands on the road seems huge these days. People C spend more than they need to on cars suggesting they’re more than a mode of transport.

But anyway, I think you’ll see a real small amount of people prepared to bike or walk, as millions just love driving (and many with disabilities and the elderly can’t bike or walk). The only way to do it is to price people out of driving and that hammers the working classes. That’s a no from me.

So do the Dutch? I like cars, I will literally drive to Caffeine and Machine and I often take country lanes instead of the motorway. Fact is though that most of the time I drive it isn't for leisure, it's because the car is a tool and it's the most convenient way to get to point A from point B.

Also, if you need to price people out of car ownership to get people to cycle or walk then why does the Netherlands have a similar car ownership rate to the UK? I'm going to assume that the upper classes aren't riding around in a 15 year old Peugeot through Delft.

(07-03-2023, 08:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 08:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm pretty sure there are specialist mobility cars for disabled people that are legal to use in cycle lanes, seeing as I've seen them. As I said, visit the Netherlands.

Stick the disabled in a dangerous scooter in the wind and the rain why don't you?

Nasty authoritarian.

[Image: canta-micro-car.jpg]

"Scooter".

Just admit you don't know what you're on about?

Are you fucking serious? Jesus. For a liberal you have some very strange ideas.
Reply
#58
(07-03-2023, 07:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "positive freedoms"

Positively Stalinist concept that.

Metaphorically rolls eyes at proth.

Since the war transport policy has made it increasingly difficult for those who would prefer not to drive a car.

No one talks about the 'stalinism' that has forced people into using cars.
Reply
#59
(07-04-2023, 07:51 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "positive freedoms"

Positively Stalinist concept that.

Metaphorically rolls eyes at proth.

Since the war transport policy has made it increasingly difficult for those who would prefer not to drive a car.

No one talks about the 'stalinism' that has forced people into using cars.

Yes and the car has given thousands of people who would be consigned to a completely restricted life a means to work, live and experience things other people (able bodied) take for granted.
Reply
#60
(07-04-2023, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-04-2023, 07:51 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "positive freedoms"

Positively Stalinist concept that.

Metaphorically rolls eyes at proth.

Since the war transport policy has made it increasingly difficult for those who would prefer not to drive a car.

No one talks about the 'stalinism' that has forced people into using cars.

Yes and the car has given thousands of people who would be consigned to a completely restricted life a means to work, live and experience things other people (able bodied) take for granted.

No one is denying that Derek.

But transport policy over the last 50 or so years has been too skewed to car use.
Disadvantaging those who either cannot afford or prefer nor to use cars.
A recalibration of policy between the car and non car user is long overdue.

You should be able to understand there is a difference between reduce and eliminate.
I am in favour of policy that seeks to reduce car journeys (many of which are unnecessary and have negative impacts on society and the environment).
I would be absolutely opposed to eliminating car use. As you correctly state the car has provided opportunities to people who otherwise might not have been able to access them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)