Problems ignored
#21
(07-03-2023, 07:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Interesting stuff this as I live in the JQ.

The thing is, although there’s many bike lanes gone up the last few years, they’re not used much.

And I still think although we can talk about bikes being good, public transport etc, I think this misses a fundamental point… that millions of people like cars. Additionally, bikes are rubbish in the wet and cold winter. I’m sure infrastructure could get a few to shift towards public transport and bikes, but not many imo.

And if people are priced out of cars, we end up with only the rich being able to drive, and the working classes get pushed into other forms of transport surely? (Not through choice)

Exactly this.

And the only thing wrong with public transport in the main, is the public bit.
Reply
#22
(07-03-2023, 07:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Interesting stuff this as I live in the JQ.

The thing is, although there’s many bike lanes gone up the last few years, they’re not used much.

And I still think although we can talk about bikes being good, public transport etc, I think this misses a fundamental point… that millions of people like cars. Additionally, bikes are rubbish in the wet and cold winter. I’m sure infrastructure could get a few to shift towards public transport and bikes, but not many imo.

And if people are priced out of cars, we end up with only the rich being able to drive, and the working classes get pushed into other forms of transport surely? (Not through choice)

Exactly this.

And the only thing wrong with public transport in the main, is the public bit.

Not to mention those who need a car for carrying various things, those with disabilities, those who haven’t got specific disabilities but definitely couldn’t ride a bike, the elderly, etc.
Reply
#23
(07-03-2023, 07:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 06:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Unlike you I believe in empirical evidence and not feels and twisting reality around my world view. Bicycles are convenient and they're personal transportation. Fact is that due to the limited space within established economic centres it's near impossible to create grade separated throughways for bikes, cars, pedestrians, public transport and commercial traffic as you can't rip up cities very easily and start again (and if you can do that it often makes them worse). The UK isn't planned out like Milton Keynes and Stevenage were. You need to prioritise something and if you're a city you should always prioritise the most efficient means to do that which is always pedestrians, followed by bicycles, transit, commercial traffic and finally personal cars.

I agree public transport is a joke outside London but let's not forget that the biggest butchering of public transport capacity in this country took place because the then Minister for Transport with an interest in a family tarmac businesses gutted the railway lines, including key lines through the second biggest city in the UK. It also can't be ignored that one of the biggest factors in public transport being shit in the UK (after Treasury Brain) is prioritising cars with public money over pedestrians.

As for Kings Heath, lack of pedestrian priority and a busy thoroughfare makes it dangerous to pedestrians as pointed out by a child nearly getting killed by a hit and run recently.

Unlike you I believe in personal freedom, particularly for the vast majority of us who don't have access to adequate public transport and wouldn't get on a bike or a bus if our lives depended on it. It's clear from the tone of your posts that you're more than happy to force people (like the tax drones you hope they are) into cycling, trains and - God forbid, buses.

Cheap, convenient personal transportation is one of the foundations of a free society. And for the vast majority of us a bike is not convenient and a bus is like the seventh level of Hell.

Hahahaha. You believe in your own freedoms, you don't give a shit about utility or positive freedoms.

Bicycles are cheap and personal transportation. I don't give a shit if you don't like cycling, that's a fact. What's also a fact is there are very culturally similar Western European countries manage perfectly fine prioritising pedestrians and bicycles over cars. You might be surprised to know that cars aren't banned in the Netherlands or Denmark and people still drive, they just don't drive to the chippy or corner shop. I'm perfectly happy to shift in that direction as, having been to those countries, it's a damn sight better than it is over here.

Face the facts, Proth. You're not going to tear up every single city in the UK and start from scratch creating modal separation everywhere like in Milton Keynes or Stevenage. You need to prioritise one mode and it's more as cars are the least tax and space efficient transport option then municipalities are perfectly and rightly entitled to deprioritise them. And if you think that amounts to "forcing" people out of their cars then you're a deranged conspiracy nut.

(07-03-2023, 07:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Interesting stuff this as I live in the JQ.

The thing is, although there’s many bike lanes gone up the last few years, they’re not used much.

And I still think although we can talk about bikes being good, public transport etc, I think this misses a fundamental point… that millions of people like cars. Additionally, bikes are rubbish in the wet and cold winter. I’m sure infrastructure could get a few to shift towards public transport and bikes, but not many imo.

And if people are priced out of cars, we end up with only the rich being able to drive, and the working classes get pushed into other forms of transport surely? (Not through choice)

Cycling is flat out dangerous in Brum. Even the dedicated cycle lane the goes up from UoB to the city centre stops randomly in the Gay Village. You also have the issue of the A4400 cutting off the JQ/St Paul's from the city centre. In an ideal world the A4400 would be buried and built over, as happened in Boston, but that costs money. You also see the side effect of that being cyclists using towpaths on the canal, but mixing pedestrians and cyclists is dangerous.

As for being shit in cold and wet weather, Amsterdam and Copenhagen are the same climate as the UK and if they can manage it in a place like Oula in Finland then we can manage it. The only thing as a pedestrian walking in snow or the rain that bothers me is cars splashing me with standing water.
Reply
#24
(07-03-2023, 07:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 06:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Unlike you I believe in empirical evidence and not feels and twisting reality around my world view. Bicycles are convenient and they're personal transportation. Fact is that due to the limited space within established economic centres it's near impossible to create grade separated throughways for bikes, cars, pedestrians, public transport and commercial traffic as you can't rip up cities very easily and start again (and if you can do that it often makes them worse). The UK isn't planned out like Milton Keynes and Stevenage were. You need to prioritise something and if you're a city you should always prioritise the most efficient means to do that which is always pedestrians, followed by bicycles, transit, commercial traffic and finally personal cars.

I agree public transport is a joke outside London but let's not forget that the biggest butchering of public transport capacity in this country took place because the then Minister for Transport with an interest in a family tarmac businesses gutted the railway lines, including key lines through the second biggest city in the UK. It also can't be ignored that one of the biggest factors in public transport being shit in the UK (after Treasury Brain) is prioritising cars with public money over pedestrians.

As for Kings Heath, lack of pedestrian priority and a busy thoroughfare makes it dangerous to pedestrians as pointed out by a child nearly getting killed by a hit and run recently.

Unlike you I believe in personal freedom, particularly for the vast majority of us who don't have access to adequate public transport and wouldn't get on a bike or a bus if our lives depended on it. It's clear from the tone of your posts that you're more than happy to force people (like the tax drones you hope they are) into cycling, trains and - God forbid, buses.

Cheap, convenient personal transportation is one of the foundations of a free society. And for the vast majority of us a bike is not convenient and a bus is like the seventh level of Hell.

Hahahaha. You believe in your own freedoms, you don't give a shit about utility or positive freedoms.

Bicycles are cheap and personal transportation. I don't give a shit if you don't like cycling, that's a fact. What's also a fact is there are very culturally similar Western European countries manage perfectly fine prioritising pedestrians and bicycles over cars. You might be surprised to know that cars aren't banned in the Netherlands or Denmark and people still drive, they just don't drive to the chippy or corner shop. I'm perfectly happy to shift in that direction as, having been to those countries, it's a damn sight better than it is over here.

Face the facts, Proth. You're not going to tear up every single city in the UK and start from scratch creating modal separation everywhere like in Milton Keynes or Stevenage. You need to prioritise one mode and it's more as cars are the least tax and space efficient transport option then municipalities are perfectly and rightly entitled to deprioritise them. And if you think that amounts to "forcing" people out of their cars then you're a deranged conspiracy nut.

How are people going to be persuaded though? You couldn’t persuade me to bike anywhere, and by the looks of the cycle lanes in Brum not many are being persuaded right now.

I walk to work but my other journies in life are in a car. I need to get in and out the JQ for that. And the car park at my block of flats is full of cars, and quite bad ass ones at that (again suggesting they’re a hobby as well as a transport form).

(07-03-2023, 07:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 06:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Unlike you I believe in empirical evidence and not feels and twisting reality around my world view. Bicycles are convenient and they're personal transportation. Fact is that due to the limited space within established economic centres it's near impossible to create grade separated throughways for bikes, cars, pedestrians, public transport and commercial traffic as you can't rip up cities very easily and start again (and if you can do that it often makes them worse). The UK isn't planned out like Milton Keynes and Stevenage were. You need to prioritise something and if you're a city you should always prioritise the most efficient means to do that which is always pedestrians, followed by bicycles, transit, commercial traffic and finally personal cars.

I agree public transport is a joke outside London but let's not forget that the biggest butchering of public transport capacity in this country took place because the then Minister for Transport with an interest in a family tarmac businesses gutted the railway lines, including key lines through the second biggest city in the UK. It also can't be ignored that one of the biggest factors in public transport being shit in the UK (after Treasury Brain) is prioritising cars with public money over pedestrians.

As for Kings Heath, lack of pedestrian priority and a busy thoroughfare makes it dangerous to pedestrians as pointed out by a child nearly getting killed by a hit and run recently.

Unlike you I believe in personal freedom, particularly for the vast majority of us who don't have access to adequate public transport and wouldn't get on a bike or a bus if our lives depended on it. It's clear from the tone of your posts that you're more than happy to force people (like the tax drones you hope they are) into cycling, trains and - God forbid, buses.

Cheap, convenient personal transportation is one of the foundations of a free society. And for the vast majority of us a bike is not convenient and a bus is like the seventh level of Hell.

Hahahaha. You believe in your own freedoms, you don't give a shit about utility or positive freedoms.

Bicycles are cheap and personal transportation. I don't give a shit if you don't like cycling, that's a fact. What's also a fact is there are very culturally similar Western European countries manage perfectly fine prioritising pedestrians and bicycles over cars. You might be surprised to know that cars aren't banned in the Netherlands or Denmark and people still drive, they just don't drive to the chippy or corner shop. I'm perfectly happy to shift in that direction as, having been to those countries, it's a damn sight better than it is over here.

Face the facts, Proth. You're not going to tear up every single city in the UK and start from scratch creating modal separation everywhere like in Milton Keynes or Stevenage. You need to prioritise one mode and it's more as cars are the least tax and space efficient transport option then municipalities are perfectly and rightly entitled to deprioritise them. And if you think that amounts to "forcing" people out of their cars then you're a deranged conspiracy nut.

(07-03-2023, 07:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Interesting stuff this as I live in the JQ.

The thing is, although there’s many bike lanes gone up the last few years, they’re not used much.

And I still think although we can talk about bikes being good, public transport etc, I think this misses a fundamental point… that millions of people like cars. Additionally, bikes are rubbish in the wet and cold winter. I’m sure infrastructure could get a few to shift towards public transport and bikes, but not many imo.

And if people are priced out of cars, we end up with only the rich being able to drive, and the working classes get pushed into other forms of transport surely? (Not through choice)

Cycling is flat out dangerous in Brum. Even the dedicated cycle lane the goes up from UoB to the city centre stops randomly in the Gay Village. You also have the issue of the A4400 cutting off the JQ/St Paul's from the city centre. In an ideal world the A4400 would be buried and built over, as happened in Boston, but that costs money. You also see the side effect of that being cyclists using towpaths on the canal, but mixing pedestrians and cyclists is dangerous.

As for being shit in cold and wet weather, Amsterdam and Copenhagen are the same climate as the UK and if they can manage it in a place like Oula in Finland then we can manage it. The only thing as a pedestrian walking in snow or the rain that bothers me is cars splashing me with standing water.

I mix with a wide range of people and I don’t know a single person who would trade their car for a bike. Cars are a hobby as well as a transport form for many. Throw in those who need to carry stuff in boots, plus those who can’t physically ride a bike, and I think you’ll have very few people agreeing with you.
Reply
#25
(07-03-2023, 07:21 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: How are people going to be persuaded though? You couldn’t persuade me to bike anywhere, and by the looks of the cycle lanes in Brum not many are being persuaded right now.

I walk to work but my other journies in life are in a car. I need to get in and out the JQ for that. And the car park at my block of flats is full of cars, and quite bad ass ones at that (again suggesting they’re a hobby as well as a transport form).

Same way they persuaded people in Amsterdam, modal priority. Cars have access but they have to go a looping route through congested areas whereas pedestrians, cyclists and motorcycles get more direct routes. The end result is people still drive but far fewer do as it takes longer. Ultimately unless you're building somewhere from scratch you need to operate within the bounds of your existing infrastructure which ultimately results in prioritising one mode over another. If you're making a new town like Milton Keynes it's easier to add in that modal separation, and modal separation should be built in from the start in new developments, but you can't do that in busy urban areas.

Pedestrians -> Cyclists -> Public Transport -> Commercial Traffic -> Cars.

Fact is that most people just want to get where they're going as quickly as possible. If it's quicker to walk than it is to drive then people will walk. People don't like cycling in Birmingham because it's dangerous and it's inconvenient, if you want to get from the JQ to town you need to cross over that dodgy walkway or go some round about route instead.
Reply
#26
(07-03-2023, 05:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 05:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 05:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 04:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 03:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I got to complaining about 15 minute towns lol. If you're complaining about 15 minute towns and improving pedestrian access then that kind of points to you being unhinged and reading conspiracy theory nonsense on it, which wouldn't surprise me.

Improving pedestrian access is one thing. Making it beyond frustrating to get anywhere by car in a city centre is quite another.

There is a lot of conspiracy guff around, but there's a universal truth at the heart of it; the government is trying to wean us off cheap / convenient personal transportation - because it won't exist anyway with the demise of the ICE.

Local government want to make people walk, cycle and take public transport because cars are very space inefficient and as a result are an economic drag.
Nothing to do with the "demise" of the ICE. People in Norway drive aplenty and they buy fuck all new ICEs.

Also, bicycles are personal transportation. I suggest you take a trip to Denmark or the Netherlands and find out. They're wealthier and more productive countries than the UK! What a shame it would be if Birmingham was more like Copenhagen or Amsterdam, eh?

Need I mention the incident in Kings Heath recently as well? I also suggest you look up Kindermoort and discover why Amsterdam and other Dutch cities pivoted away from the car being king in the 60s and 70s.

All lovely and I agree that wankers usually in Audi’s BMWs, Mercedes and 4x4s in many cases drive appallingly and should be clamped down on in some cases literally. However some people have to have access to city/town centres in cars due to their mobility, wheelchair use etc. You cannot just abandon them to appalling public transport. If you disagree I would suggest you don’t have any understanding of the problems those people face and I would say it was discriminatory to stop them accessing town centres. Able bodied people fine, let them walk but a blanket ban on cars surely goes against the liberalism of those so in favour of the idea. Has there been any thought for the disabled in terms of access by those who just want to dump a couple of flower boxes in the road to block cars. If there has been and their is genuine places for the disabled to park then fine, because people do park and drive appallingly, they do block pavements for wheelchairs and buggies and they do block ramps to vehicles so yes get rid of those car users who could walk or take public transport but don’t just abandon those who can’t to some utopian dream of children drawing chalk pictures in the road and watering flowerpots on the Zebra crossing.

You do realise that prioritising pedestrians makes it easier for people with mobility issues and other disabilities to get around, right?

I suggest you try visiting any city in the Netherlands.

You do realise that those who have mobility problems particularly in wheelchairs or need assistance with wheelchairs as carers need a vehicle to get about don’t you? Without it you limit their lives, their liberties, their families liberty. It’s ableist nonsense by people who have absolutely no idea how difficult it is to live as normal life as possible, to just say walk or use the pathetic, inadequate and impractical public transport. No other minorities rights would be so so glibly brushed aside by those who declare themselves as liberal and progressive. There is nothing liberal, progressive or even thoughtful for the able bodied to dismiss the rights, liberties and needs of those who find it difficult or impossible to use other forms of transport other than a car or adapted vehicle. 

I have no problem with town centres been prioritised for pedestrians, stopping bad driving, stopping inconsiderate and illegal parking but I do have a problem with forcing even more barriers on the disabled for a ableist utopia that ignores the needs of arguably people less fortunate than themselves.
Reply
#27
(07-03-2023, 07:21 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I mix with a wide range of people and I don’t know a single person who would trade their car for a bike. Cars are a hobby as well as a transport form for many. Throw in those who need to carry stuff in boots, plus those who can’t physically ride a bike, and I think you’ll have very few people agreeing with you.

Cars a hobby for me too, I like cars which is why I trained as an engineer. I also like motorcycles.

If you go to cycling-oriented towns and cities there are already solutions that are widely implemented. Trolley/carriers and cargo bikes for people and goods are commonplace in the Netherlands. The Dutch still drive, a lot. They also cycle, the infrastructure there supports that (like removing on-street parking to open up pedestrian and bicycle paths while also implementing underground car parking).
Reply
#28
(07-03-2023, 07:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 07:21 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: How are people going to be persuaded though? You couldn’t persuade me to bike anywhere, and by the looks of the cycle lanes in Brum not many are being persuaded right now.

I walk to work but my other journies in life are in a car. I need to get in and out the JQ for that. And the car park at my block of flats is full of cars, and quite bad ass ones at that (again suggesting they’re a hobby as well as a transport form).

Same way they persuaded people in Amsterdam, modal priority. Cars have access but they have to go a looping route through congested areas whereas pedestrians, cyclists and motorcycles get more direct routes. The end result is people still drive but far fewer do as it takes longer. Ultimately unless you're building somewhere from scratch you need to operate within the bounds of your existing infrastructure which ultimately results in prioritising one mode over another. If you're making a new town like Milton Keynes it's easier to add in that modal separation, and modal separation should be built in from the start in new developments, but you can't do that in busy urban areas.

Pedestrians -> Cyclists -> Public Transport -> Commercial Traffic -> Cars.

Fact is that most people just want to get where they're going as quickly as possible. If it's quicker to walk than it is to drive then people will walk. People don't like cycling in Birmingham because it's dangerous and it's inconvenient, if you want to get from the JQ to town you need to cross over that dodgy walkway or go some round about route instead.

Well I walk into town and to work, but I do like walking and I’m fit and able. Everywhere else I need a car.

I don’t agree that people don’t like cycling because it’s dangerous and inconvenient. It’s so cheap compared to driving, yet millions would rather enjoy driving, even spending a fortune on cars that are way more expensive than they need to.

Yes for very short trips I agree you may be able to persuade some to walk, but they can walk now round the JQ and tons still take their cars. I don’t see what’s dodgy about the footbridge personally, I think most just can’t be arsed to walk or cycle, or aren’t fit/healthy enough.

Also, if you push cars onto a longer slower congested route, and there isn’t much of reduction, isn’t that worse environmentally?
Reply
#29
(07-03-2023, 07:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 05:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 05:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 05:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-03-2023, 04:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Improving pedestrian access is one thing. Making it beyond frustrating to get anywhere by car in a city centre is quite another.

There is a lot of conspiracy guff around, but there's a universal truth at the heart of it; the government is trying to wean us off cheap / convenient personal transportation - because it won't exist anyway with the demise of the ICE.

Local government want to make people walk, cycle and take public transport because cars are very space inefficient and as a result are an economic drag.
Nothing to do with the "demise" of the ICE. People in Norway drive aplenty and they buy fuck all new ICEs.

Also, bicycles are personal transportation. I suggest you take a trip to Denmark or the Netherlands and find out. They're wealthier and more productive countries than the UK! What a shame it would be if Birmingham was more like Copenhagen or Amsterdam, eh?

Need I mention the incident in Kings Heath recently as well? I also suggest you look up Kindermoort and discover why Amsterdam and other Dutch cities pivoted away from the car being king in the 60s and 70s.

All lovely and I agree that wankers usually in Audi’s BMWs, Mercedes and 4x4s in many cases drive appallingly and should be clamped down on in some cases literally. However some people have to have access to city/town centres in cars due to their mobility, wheelchair use etc. You cannot just abandon them to appalling public transport. If you disagree I would suggest you don’t have any understanding of the problems those people face and I would say it was discriminatory to stop them accessing town centres. Able bodied people fine, let them walk but a blanket ban on cars surely goes against the liberalism of those so in favour of the idea. Has there been any thought for the disabled in terms of access by those who just want to dump a couple of flower boxes in the road to block cars. If there has been and their is genuine places for the disabled to park then fine, because people do park and drive appallingly, they do block pavements for wheelchairs and buggies and they do block ramps to vehicles so yes get rid of those car users who could walk or take public transport but don’t just abandon those who can’t to some utopian dream of children drawing chalk pictures in the road and watering flowerpots on the Zebra crossing.

You do realise that prioritising pedestrians makes it easier for people with mobility issues and other disabilities to get around, right?

I suggest you try visiting any city in the Netherlands.

You do realise that those who have mobility problems particularly in wheelchairs or need assistance with wheelchairs as carers need a vehicle to get about don’t you? Without it you limit their lives, their liberties, their families liberty. It’s ableist nonsense by people who have absolutely no idea how difficult it is to live as normal life as possible, to just say walk or use the pathetic, inadequate and impractical public transport. No other minorities rights would be so so glibly brushed aside by those who declare themselves as liberal and progressive. There is nothing liberal, progressive or even thoughtful for the able bodied to dismiss the rights, liberties and needs of those who find it difficult or impossible to use other forms of transport other than a car or adapted vehicle. 

I have no problem with town centres been prioritised for pedestrians, stopping bad driving, stopping inconsiderate and illegal parking but I do have a problem with forcing even more barriers on the disabled for a ableist utopia that ignores the needs of arguably people less fortunate than themselves.

As I said, I suggest you visit a Dutch town or city. It bluntly allays your concerns, they even have raised crosswalks making it easier for people in wheelchairs to get around than in the UK.

I'd also like to point out that you're being dismissive of two rather large groups of disabled people where cars are the number one danger to mobility: the visually and hearing impaired.
Reply
#30
(07-03-2023, 07:04 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I’d imagine you knew what the transport options were when you moved to Hagley. Your obsession with personal choice with cars isn’t a personal choice for everyone who has to suffer the pollution. Grow up

Neither is restricting peoples lives to a near open prison territory who need a vehicle because they or their carer uses a wheelchair or has mobility problems. If there was a right leaning campaign group who declared they wanted to make it really difficult for the disabled to get to the shops, to leisure centres, to schools etc etc there would be an outcry by the very same people who are declaring areas should be completely free of cars regardless of the needs of those who use them. 

I completely agree with making places safer, I completely disagree with restricting some of the most vulnerable peoples lives to a trip to the local shop or a three, four hour round trip to just visit a town centre if they can even access public transport. Imo there are a lot of MCW ableism who have given zero thought to others because it’s an inconvenient truth they don’t want to address.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)