Dudley Council
#41
(05-05-2023, 03:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You can't blame the electoral system for the mess we're in. Proportional systems in Italy have hardly delivered stable government, in Germany there's crumbling infrastructure and generational foolishness dumping nuclear power and embracing a fascist's gas, France is a basket case, Spain has huge social problems caused by youth unemployment - dropping FPTP is not the panacea you believe it is unless you're suggesting benign dictatorship?

Nor does it matter what people have the appetite for if there's no money, a rising debt interest bill, no plan for growth or productivity beyond the ill-defined "Green Industrial Revolution" - which always ends up sounding like an interventionist's charter to me. There's still time before the next election, but I don't see how Labour's crack team of ex-social workers, union reps, actors and local government officers is particularly well equipped to come with a plan (any more than the Tories are).

I can blame the electoral system and I will, because it's a significant issue as to what's exasperating a lack of solutions to the housing problem.

FPTP results in needing to pander to swing voters in swing seats, the swing voters are middle class property owners and the swing seats are suburban and rural.

Young voters are overlooked by FPTP, they're the ones who want houses to be built but their votes are stacked in specific seats or too spread out to matter in swing seats.

I do not see how we can go Dutch or Danish on house-building with FPTP.
Reply
#42
It would help enormously if your lot stopped campaigning so irresponsibly on the issue. The main reason for Jenrick's planning reforms being binned was the Chesham & Amersham by-election result.
Reply
#43
(05-05-2023, 04:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It would help enormously if your lot stopped campaigning so irresponsibly on the issue. The main reason for Jenrick's planning reforms being binned was the Chesham & Amersham by-election result.

The main reason was because it was a shit, poorly thought out and rushed policy that didn't have the backing of the Tory membership or parliamentary party. The Lib Dems campaign in C&A was just a convenient excuse. The fact that the Tory campaign down there wanted to make most of the constituency a national park so no houses could be built there ever again if testament to how weak the policy was. The campaigns in North Shropshire and Tiverton & Honiton didn't push the Tories into a 180 on A&E access, sewage or more capacity for councils to buy land for social housing, did they? And they were both bigger bombshells.


As for "my party", I backed Liberal Reform's push for a federal party housing strategy which was successful and the party will be reporting back in Autumn, I support Street Votes and Community Land Auctions, I voted in favour of the upped 380k housing target and I was campaigning for adapting the South Warwickshire Plan to include upgraded infrastructure instead of cutting the number of houses like the Greens have been pushing for. What do you want me to do? I'm trying, the fact is as much as I'd love everywhere to follow Eastleigh and Eastbourne it's not going to happen unless the Lib Dems win seats which everyone has to play the stupid game and pander to people.
Reply
#44
(05-05-2023, 06:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:  everyone has to play the stupid game and pander to people.

Only if you think people are stupid.

Ben Houchen in today's greatest statement of the bleeding obvious:

"There has been an issue that the Labour Party have been quite successful in making this a referendum on the government, it was very much about the cost of living, NHS… we could have done better at being able to tackle those questions," he said.
Reply
#45
The truth is that everyone can be guilty of nimbyism when it suits them.

I was reading thus week about one if the Koch brothers, famous for their libertarian, free market, anti govt spending and anti regulations views, who successfully campaigned against an off shore wind turbine project.

His objection. It would spoil the view from his Cape Cod holiday home.
Reply
#46
(05-05-2023, 06:23 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The truth is that everyone can be guilty of nimbyism when it suits them.

I was reading thus week about one if the Koch brothers, famous for their libertarian, free market, anti govt spending and anti regulations views, who successfully campaigned against an off shore wind turbine project.

His objection. It would spoil the view from his Cape Cod holiday home.

Exactly, liberty for me not everyone else! This is the Libertarian way!
Reply
#47
Re the OP. In my experience, the tory success in the red wall areas was due to huge own goals by both Labour and Lib Dem on top of years of accusations of "doesn't matter who gets in, they don't care about us".  Since then many of the recent occupants of those seats appear to have worked quite hard on behalf of their areas. The people of Dudley, Tipton and West Brom are not fools, they know the tories are giving them hell, but they do appear to feel they had long been taken for granted by Labour. I repeat, this is just my experience in the area. Further, I wouldn't read too much into a local council election with sometimes only 11-20% turnout.
Reply
#48
(05-05-2023, 06:23 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The truth is that everyone can be guilty of nimbyism when it suits them.

Entirely missing the point that political parties should put the national need far above narrow local sectional interests. How do you think the new towns got built? Motorways? Railways?
Reply
#49
(05-05-2023, 06:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-05-2023, 06:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:  everyone has to play the stupid game and pander to people.

Only if you think people are stupid.

No, I think the voting system is stupid making far too many people's votes entirely worthless.
Reply
#50
I'm utterly delighted to find Lichfield District Council is no longer under Conservative control. Possibly the locals have opened their eyes and this will translate into Fabricant being booted out next year.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)