Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-05-2023, 02:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's not a question of left, right or centre Dekka. It's a question of basic competence and enlightened self interest.
The nation is right to give the Tories a kicking. It should have been harder. They've comprehensively fucked up the response to the GFC to the extent that we have the worst cost of living crisis in a generation, a wholly self inflicted housing crisis, a generation of kids indebted to the eyeballs with useless degrees, an NHS that isn't very good at keeping people alive, a pensions timebomb, high and rising debt interest and the highest peacetime taxes in our history.
It's quite a legacy to bequeath to the next government. And quite a straitjacket.
But with a first past the post system you won’t get anything but ideological decision making rather than pragmatic ones as dissenting voices can only snipe from the sidelines. I don’t see any appetite for poorer public service (further austerity), obsession with migration outside of Tory / UKIP supporters etc. I do see people who want decent schools, health, roads, the environment, public transport, keeping libraries and community places open. The fact people are turning to parties who are left of centre can be seen as a barometer of where the majority of people are politically speaking currently.
Posts: 932
Threads: 58
Joined: Mar 2020
Reputation:
9
05-05-2023, 03:08 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-05-2023, 03:10 PM by TTM2.)
(05-05-2023, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:38 AM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-05-2023, 08:49 AM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 08:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Didn’t Princes End vote in a BNP candidate? I wonder where their votes went?
Not big on detail, are you Derek. Labour have hoovered up UKIP votes aplenty, that’s what politics is.
The BaggieNick of the politics board, chipping in with irrelevant shite.
My point was Princes End has been an outlier when it comes to which way an area votes previously. If you want to sling insults around you go for it, but only a day or so ago you were saying how mean someone was for doing just that, so despite the country being in a total mess you decided to vote for the architects of that decline. You’re not very good on the big picture.
Which is absolutely nothing to do with the debate that’s ongoing and being contributed to by people from all sides of the political spectrum. You’ve just chipped in with a sneering comment designed to denigrate the population of an area so it fits your narrative.
You add nothing of significance to the debate, you never do - your replies rarely have anything to do with what’s being discussed.
If you think me pointing this out to you is comparable with a political opponent using the recent death of a candidates 19 year old son as a means to have a pop at them there’s really no hope for you.
Two points you mentioned Princes End, I pointed out that the area has a history of voting for parties with strong anti-immigration policies. It’s not such a surprise that the area has voted Conservative given that they are currently running on policies that focus on immigration as one of their five main policies. That isn’t denigrating anyone. The other point was you got personal with me not the other way around and you didn’t like it, when others did so. I’m not condoning or even knew what the twat who brought the families son into a political debate said. He’s clearly an idiot who is best out of politics.
At the moment it’s still up in the air with so many areas yet to decide where we are politically and local elections can be skewed by local problems and issues. There are of course trends you can extrapolate across national politics which people will be picking the bones out of for months. The question for your party is which way they go next? Further right or cool the immigration rhetoric and stubborn refusal to talk properly with public servants and key workers etc and move back to the centre socially. I think the Tory’s are in danger of snookering themselves. To clarify, alienating leafy traditional areas with house building on green belt land and allowing water companies to dump sewage into rivers and rivers seas with impunity. Whilst trying to appease former red wall voters with talk about levelling up with little action / current evidence that it’s helping or in some cases happening. For true blue Tory’s promises to ramp up the rhetoric around immigration and cutting taxes and therefore services further. The trends in voting suggest that these policies don’t reflect where voters are going currently locally and perhaps nationally.
You alluded to the BNP and made a connection to the conservatives, let’s not try and rewrite your posts here.
I’ve not been a member of any political party for getting on for 3 years and won’t be anytime soon, however, I applaud anyone who does and gets off their backsides to campaign for what they believe in. Sooner that than shooting off on the internet.
(05-05-2023, 11:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-05-2023, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 10:41 AM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:56 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:38 AM)TTM2 Wrote: If you think me pointing this out to you is comparable with a political opponent using the recent death of a candidates 19 year old son as a means to have a pop at them there’s really no hope for you.
You've mentioned that a couple of times Rowls, what happened? It sounds awful.
Labour activist:
“Makes a change you out and about rather than standing on the memorial with a picture of your dead son”
That’s a shocker mate, is the activist still part of the party. PM me if you want me to raise something internally.
Pete Lowe's daughter insisted to me that the woman in question was not a member, but her social profiles and feed made it pretty bloody obvious she was an activist. You could have reported Halesowen's Richest Pensioner for blocking roads and swearing in front of kids, but I think someone already did that...
They said she wasn’t a member to the lady in question too, miraculously she had by them changed her profile pic from a labour election poster to a bunch of flowers. Coincidence or what!
She’s also the chairperson of the Dudley Tenants Association.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
You can't blame the electoral system for the mess we're in. Proportional systems in Italy have hardly delivered stable government, in Germany there's crumbling infrastructure and generational foolishness dumping nuclear power and embracing a fascist's gas, France is a basket case, Spain has huge social problems caused by youth unemployment - dropping FPTP is not the panacea you believe it is unless you're suggesting benign dictatorship?
Nor does it matter what people have the appetite for if there's no money, a rising debt interest bill, no plan for growth or productivity beyond the ill-defined "Green Industrial Revolution" - which always ends up sounding like an interventionist's charter to me. There's still time before the next election, but I don't see how Labour's crack team of ex-social workers, union reps, actors and local government officers is particularly well equipped to come with a plan (any more than the Tories are).
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
I partially agree with you about PR - but surely you agree with me that the system does need huge modernisation and it’s inherently prevented by no one who is within it having the motivation to wish to transform it. Until there is sufficient extrernal pressure, it’ll continue to decay
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 932
Threads: 58
Joined: Mar 2020
Reputation:
9
(05-05-2023, 03:34 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I partially agree with you about PR - but surely you agree with me that the system does need huge modernisation and it’s inherently prevented by no one who is within it having the motivation to wish to transform it. Until there is sufficient extrernal pressure, it’ll continue to decay
Sounds like you’re talking about the NHS …..
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
(05-05-2023, 03:39 PM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 03:34 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I partially agree with you about PR - but surely you agree with me that the system does need huge modernisation and it’s inherently prevented by no one who is within it having the motivation to wish to transform it. Until there is sufficient extrernal pressure, it’ll continue to decay
Sounds like you’re talking about the NHS …..
The difference there is the external forces preventing change are different and the arguments for and against the direction of that change are more diverse. The average waiting time when Labour left govt was 2 months and is now nearly 2 years. It’s no political accident
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-05-2023, 03:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-05-2023, 03:49 PM by Protheroe.)
(05-05-2023, 03:34 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I partially agree with you about PR - but surely you agree with me that the system does need huge modernisation and it’s inherently prevented by no one who is within it having the motivation to wish to transform it. Until there is sufficient extrernal pressure, it’ll continue to decay
Christ, yes. None of the parties have done themselves any favours by taking partisan positions on housing, health, social care and pensions.
Even today the Lib Dems are winning councils across the south promising a moratorium on development and Andrea Leadsom's on the telly promising the same from the Tories. It's inexcusable in the same way that EVERYONE knows the NHS & Social Care is a busted flush but all they do is bid up the amount of money they want to extract from us (or borrow) to shovel into wholly failed systems.
If the Labour Party (or anyone else for that matter) really wanted to impress me they'd promise Royal Commissions on Health, Social Care, Housing & Pensions - and consider depoliticising all those issues via funding mechanisms and / or arms length delivery bodies with clear long term delivery targets and clear costs for the public.
People aren't stupid, this lot have taken them for mugs particularly for the last 3 years and although Starmer likes to appear as if he's the grown-up in the room his manifesto is thin, very few of his policy prescriptions bear scrutiny and some like VAT on school fees are just throwbacks to the politics of envy under Corbyn and ridiculously self defeating. I really think an approach of levelling with the British public about the hole we're in, and asking for their help and patience in getting us out would do Starmer the world of good - and draw a clear dividing line between him and Sunak who appears oblivious to what's obvious to the rest of us.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-05-2023, 03:08 PM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:38 AM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-05-2023, 08:49 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Not big on detail, are you Derek. Labour have hoovered up UKIP votes aplenty, that’s what politics is.
The BaggieNick of the politics board, chipping in with irrelevant shite.
My point was Princes End has been an outlier when it comes to which way an area votes previously. If you want to sling insults around you go for it, but only a day or so ago you were saying how mean someone was for doing just that, so despite the country being in a total mess you decided to vote for the architects of that decline. You’re not very good on the big picture.
Which is absolutely nothing to do with the debate that’s ongoing and being contributed to by people from all sides of the political spectrum. You’ve just chipped in with a sneering comment designed to denigrate the population of an area so it fits your narrative.
You add nothing of significance to the debate, you never do - your replies rarely have anything to do with what’s being discussed.
If you think me pointing this out to you is comparable with a political opponent using the recent death of a candidates 19 year old son as a means to have a pop at them there’s really no hope for you.
Two points you mentioned Princes End, I pointed out that the area has a history of voting for parties with strong anti-immigration policies. It’s not such a surprise that the area has voted Conservative given that they are currently running on policies that focus on immigration as one of their five main policies. That isn’t denigrating anyone. The other point was you got personal with me not the other way around and you didn’t like it, when others did so. I’m not condoning or even knew what the twat who brought the families son into a political debate said. He’s clearly an idiot who is best out of politics.
At the moment it’s still up in the air with so many areas yet to decide where we are politically and local elections can be skewed by local problems and issues. There are of course trends you can extrapolate across national politics which people will be picking the bones out of for months. The question for your party is which way they go next? Further right or cool the immigration rhetoric and stubborn refusal to talk properly with public servants and key workers etc and move back to the centre socially. I think the Tory’s are in danger of snookering themselves. To clarify, alienating leafy traditional areas with house building on green belt land and allowing water companies to dump sewage into rivers and rivers seas with impunity. Whilst trying to appease former red wall voters with talk about levelling up with little action / current evidence that it’s helping or in some cases happening. For true blue Tory’s promises to ramp up the rhetoric around immigration and cutting taxes and therefore services further. The trends in voting suggest that these policies don’t reflect where voters are going currently locally and perhaps nationally.
You alluded to the BNP and made a connection to the conservatives, let’s not try and rewrite your posts here.
I’ve not been a member of any political party for getting on for 3 years and won’t be anytime soon, however, I applaud anyone who does and gets off their backsides to campaign for what they believe in. Sooner that than shooting off on the internet.
(05-05-2023, 11:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-05-2023, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 10:41 AM)TTM2 Wrote: (05-05-2023, 09:56 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You've mentioned that a couple of times Rowls, what happened? It sounds awful.
Labour activist:
“Makes a change you out and about rather than standing on the memorial with a picture of your dead son”
That’s a shocker mate, is the activist still part of the party. PM me if you want me to raise something internally.
Pete Lowe's daughter insisted to me that the woman in question was not a member, but her social profiles and feed made it pretty bloody obvious she was an activist. You could have reported Halesowen's Richest Pensioner for blocking roads and swearing in front of kids, but I think someone already did that...
They said she wasn’t a member to the lady in question too, miraculously she had by them changed her profile pic from a labour election poster to a bunch of flowers. Coincidence or what!
She’s also the chairperson of the Dudley Tenants Association.
I asked a question as the language/rhetoric around small boats and invasions regarding migrants by Braverman and others in the Conservative Party is very similar in tone and language used by BNP previously. The BNP clearly had strong support in that area at one time and those votes have to go somewhere which is why I asked the question.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
(05-05-2023, 03:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-05-2023, 03:34 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I partially agree with you about PR - but surely you agree with me that the system does need huge modernisation and it’s inherently prevented by no one who is within it having the motivation to wish to transform it. Until there is sufficient extrernal pressure, it’ll continue to decay
Christ, yes. None of the parties have done themselves any favours by taking partisan positions on housing, health, social care and pensions.
Even today the Lib Dems are winning councils across the south promising a moratorium on development and Andrea Leadsom's on the telly promising the same from the Tories. It's inexcusable in the same way that EVERYONE knows the NHS & Social Care is a busted flush but all they do is bid up the amount of money they want to extract from us (or borrow) to shovel into wholly failed systems.
If the Labour Party (or anyone else for that matter) really wanted to impress me they'd promise Royal Commissions on Health, Social Care, Housing & Pensions - and consider depoliticising all those issues via funding mechanisms and / or arms length delivery bodies with clear long term delivery targets and clear costs for the public.
People aren't stupid, this lot have taken them for mugs particularly for the last 3 years and although Starmer likes to appear as if he's the grown-up in the room his manifesto is thin, very few of his policy prescriptions bear scrutiny and some like VAT on school fees are just throwbacks to the politics of envy under Corbyn and ridiculously self defeating. I really think an approach of levelling with the British public about the hole we're in, and asking for their help and patience in getting us out would do Starmer the world of good - and draw a clear dividing line between him and Sunak who appears oblivious to what's obvious to the rest of us.
On de-politicisation I couldn’t agree with you more. I’d go further and have the pass-the-parcel key posts in education and other areas filled by an appointment process much like any other such job. People with the actual key skills to do them.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-05-2023, 04:07 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: People with the actual key skills to do them.
Yes. Absolutely yes.
|