Acceptance of the Albion situation
#61
(03-07-2023, 09:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Blackburn 17/18 League 1
Sunderland 21/22 league 1
Luton 18/19 League 1
Millwall 16/17 League 1
Coventry 19/20 League 1

So as many that have parachutes were in League 1 in the last 5 or 6 years...

Shows how crazy this division really is.

Luton are a great example here, whilst we (Derek) was celebrating our self-sufficiency in the PL, the EFL tried to put Luton out of business, relegated them to non-league with a 30 point deduction and now look. They're above us. If we don't get promoted this season, it is not the end of the world.
Reply
#62
(03-07-2023, 09:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Blackburn 17/18 League 1
Sunderland 21/22 league 1
Luton 18/19 League 1
Millwall 16/17 League 1
Coventry 19/20 League 1

So as many that have parachutes were in League 1 in the last 5 or 6 years...

Shows how crazy this division really is.

Coventry and Luton both were also in League 2 under 10 years ago

However as I asked earlier, how many of this 5 were bought for over £150m not that long ago?

You'd probably get all five for that money.
Reply
#63
(03-07-2023, 09:53 AM)strawman Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:51 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:47 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Burnley last in Prem 21/22
Blades last in prem 20/21
Boro last in Prem 16/17
Blackburn last in Prem 11/12
Luton never been in prem
Norwich last in prem 21/22
Millwall never been in prem
Coventry last in prem 00/01
Watford last in prem 21/22
Sunderland last in prem 16/17
WBA last in prem 20/21

So of the top 11 only 2 have never been in the Prem
4 of them haven't been in the Prem within the last 5 years
Leaving 5 of 11 that have been in the Prem within the last 3 years... (so have some form of parachutes?)

That's what I said, at least half the teams above us aren't on parachute money so it's not the be all and end all. Some of those teams have been playing League One football in recent years too.

The Championship is an absolute minefield of financial catastrophes were sides have overstretched themselves chasing the dream. You can get pretty far by being ran quietly and competently.

And the chances of that  Sad

I'd say pretty good. Do you not think all fans of clubs outside the glory hunter bollocks clubs think that they are cursed?

We are certainly one of the more attractive clubs currently out of the top flight, for the reasons I posted a few minutes ago.

The Albion and the angst of supporting a proper club rather than some bollocks corporate machine in the North West or London is just part of the fabric of modern football. You have to accept the good times and take the bad times on the chin.
Reply
#64
(03-07-2023, 10:00 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:53 AM)strawman Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:51 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:47 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Burnley last in Prem 21/22
Blades last in prem 20/21
Boro last in Prem 16/17
Blackburn last in Prem 11/12
Luton never been in prem
Norwich last in prem 21/22
Millwall never been in prem
Coventry last in prem 00/01
Watford last in prem 21/22
Sunderland last in prem 16/17
WBA last in prem 20/21

So of the top 11 only 2 have never been in the Prem
4 of them haven't been in the Prem within the last 5 years
Leaving 5 of 11 that have been in the Prem within the last 3 years... (so have some form of parachutes?)

That's what I said, at least half the teams above us aren't on parachute money so it's not the be all and end all. Some of those teams have been playing League One football in recent years too.

The Championship is an absolute minefield of financial catastrophes were sides have overstretched themselves chasing the dream. You can get pretty far by being ran quietly and competently.

And the chances of that  Sad

I'd say pretty good. Do you not think all fans of clubs outside the glory hunter bollocks clubs think that they are cursed?

We are certainly one of the more attractive clubs currently out of the top flight, for the reasons I posted a few minutes ago.

The Albion and the angst of supporting a proper club rather than some bollocks corporate machine in the North West or London is just part of the fabric of modern football. You have to accept the good times and take the bad times on the chin.

I don't believe in curses, maybe it's pretty good for the future, but allowing an interest free loan which still hasn't been repaid doesn't cry out for current competency.
Reply
#65
(03-07-2023, 09:59 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Blackburn 17/18 League 1
Sunderland 21/22 league 1
Luton 18/19 League 1
Millwall 16/17 League 1
Coventry 19/20 League 1

So as many that have parachutes were in League 1 in the last 5 or 6 years...

Shows how crazy this division really is.

Coventry and Luton both were also in League 2 under 10 years ago

However as I asked earlier, how many of this 5 were bought for over £150m not that long ago?

You'd probably get all five for that money.

And that is still our biggest problem. I've no doubt that Lai would have got out by now had he not spunked so much on us to start with. *** I say he, I mean his mystery consortium.
Reply
#66
(03-07-2023, 10:04 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:59 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Blackburn 17/18 League 1
Sunderland 21/22 league 1
Luton 18/19 League 1
Millwall 16/17 League 1
Coventry 19/20 League 1

So as many that have parachutes were in League 1 in the last 5 or 6 years...

Shows how crazy this division really is.

Coventry and Luton both were also in League 2 under 10 years ago

However as I asked earlier, how many of this 5 were bought for over £150m not that long ago?

You'd probably get all five for that money.

And that is still our biggest problem. I've no doubt that Lai would have got out by now had he not spunked so much on us to start with. *** I say he, I mean his mystery consortium.

Yup.  It's the reason I don't do the phone light and Lai out stuff within the game. Dont need to tell him, he would fking love to be out of West Brom.  Must be an embarrassment for him, if he exists.    But he wont/cant sell at a loss, not whilst he can dip into the till occasionally.  So we are stuck with each other for the moment.
Reply
#67
(03-07-2023, 09:46 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Derek complaining about being down here, when he was champion of doing all the things that got us down here. Giving one manager all the power (Pulis) only signing experienced pros with no resale value, leading to an aged, valueless squad, never giving youth a chance to develop to help bring in cash or provide suitable first team players. Having no long term planning over recruitment or style, because that's too much of a project....

That's what got us here, it's that thinking that leads to where we are now. He advocated for it all and now moaning the inevitable effects have occured.

Of course the fault goes way back to not replacing Ashworth properly and turning into a scatter gun approach club constantly fire fighting and just surviving one season to next.

Birdie you’re caricaturing and ignoring what I said and what was happening at the time. 

The system was failing when Pulis was brought in. That’s why he was brought in, if it was working he would have been nowhere near our club.

Proof? 

The employment of Mel without more than one coach due to the inflexibility of our set-up. 
The employment of Garlick who allowed half the squad to leave and then replaced with dross like Blanco, Gamboa, Davidson etc
The employment of Terry Burton as DoF who had an impossible brief to find a new head coach that again fitted into a completely inflexible structure, the result? Alan Irvine who saw us struggle until he was sacked. 

This system was completely reliant on have the very best people in it like any other way of working. After numerous attempts to fix it / find those people on the cheap they gave up on the model because it was continually failing and Peace wanted to sell the club. You can blame bad recruitment for that but ultimately and this was ALWAYS my point ANY structure be it Head Coach or Trad Managerial will fail if you don’t have the right people in place, particularly in an ever increasingly competitive / owners prepared to spend a fortune on investment Premier League. 

I never said or advocated (show me one post where I said we should) buy older proven players. I argued that we shouldn’t suddenly start trying to play expansive attacking football whilst we have a squad built to grind out results. By all means bring young players through and get gems from the lower leagues but integrate them into how we are set-up to play. Which young players were frozen out at the time that have gone on to play regularly in the Prem? I can only think of one and that was Chris Wood. 

We should have sacked Pulis earlier but we shouldn’t have employed Pardew whose results were abysmal and was imo opinion nearly as culpable as Pulis for our relegation. That had nothing to do with structures, arguably the squad was good enough to stay up, it was down to recruitment not systems. 

The financial investments / clout of those teams in the Prem currently bar perhaps Brentford are way above anything we have had at the club at any time. Financial reality is every bit to blame as decisions on the pitch, recruitment or systems. When teams like Brighton are spending £100s millions to stay up, the idea we were going to survive by buying gems from lower leagues and playing youngsters (who aren’t then poached by again richer clubs) from home and abroad seems a tad far fetched. 

The club is a mess, it has been for years with or without a Head Coach system. It only ever worked properly when we had the very best people in those positions in Ashworth and Roy Hodgson. When they went it was a matter of a year or so before everything started to fall apart but that was against a backdrop of many richer clubs getting even richer and spending their way to success. No system or project is going to buck that for decades.
Reply
#68
(03-07-2023, 11:25 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 10:04 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:59 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 09:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Blackburn 17/18 League 1
Sunderland 21/22 league 1
Luton 18/19 League 1
Millwall 16/17 League 1
Coventry 19/20 League 1

So as many that have parachutes were in League 1 in the last 5 or 6 years...

Shows how crazy this division really is.

Coventry and Luton both were also in League 2 under 10 years ago

However as I asked earlier, how many of this 5 were bought for over £150m not that long ago?

You'd probably get all five for that money.

And that is still our biggest problem. I've no doubt that Lai would have got out by now had he not spunked so much on us to start with. *** I say he, I mean his mystery consortium.

Yup.  It's the reason I don't do the phone light and Lai out stuff within the game. Dont need to tell him, he would fking love to be out of West Brom.  Must be an embarrassment for him, if he exists.    But he wont/cant sell at a loss, not whilst he can dip into the till occasionally.  So we are stuck with each other for the moment.

The more he dips into the till, the lower the chances of us getting anywhere near the prem and him being able to sell for a decent amount.
Reply
#69
One of the key things for our future is definitely the quality of the off-field football management. I agree Ashworth has never been effectively replaced, although he was superb in the role and a visionary, so not sure how many people like that are around. 
The owner and us both have a lot of interest in getting the best system and off-field personnel as possible. The Ken/Ron double act doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence. If you except Ken is the mouth piece of the Lai consortium then it’s down to Ron…….
Reply
#70
(03-07-2023, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: the idea we were going to survive by buying gems from lower leagues and playing youngsters (who aren’t then poached by again richer clubs) from home and abroad seems a tad far fetched. 

Would have been excellent post if it wasn't for the fact that there are currently four teams sitting above us in the league right now who are doing exactly what you say we can't.

EDIT: make that five team, so only half of all the teams above us then.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: