Generational politics… well done Millennials
#41
Shabby Russian Wrote:Going back to the OP.

There are for me two main reasons why the Conservative Party is struggling with younger voters and is nit winning them back as they head into their 30s and 40s.

1..the Conservatives place a lot of emphasis on home ownership. To the extent that there is an implication that if you don't own your own home you're a bit of a failure.
The reality is that it is becoming harder to get onto the property ladder. There is an increasing number of young voters who have come to the realisation that despite having good jobs, working hard etc they will never be in a position to own their own home. In short they will be worse off than their parents.
They are taking the view that the current economic policy of the govt is not working for them, and they would be right.

2..the right in this country are becoming increasingly unpleasant and nasty in the way they express their views.
And this is not about  keyboard warriors who write abusive and threatening stuff from a cloak of anonymity. The left have too many if these types as well.
I am talking about mainstream commentators and increasingly Conservative politicians, who appear to revel in expressing opinions that are mean spirited and downright unpleasant.
A recent example was Juila Hartley Brewer's tweet about Greta Thunberg, so unnecessarily nasty.
Can't they see how off putting this behaviour is.
I am all for political debate, and people disagreeing with each other, and if that can be done with a bit if humour all the better.

But then I am probably a snowflake  or woke , or some other term that has come into fashion in the last 10 years , to describe people like me.

Hasn't this always been so? With the exception of wierdos like Rees Mogg and Ian Duncan Disorderly young people tend to be left of centre. As they get older it then becomes a bit more I'm all right Jack. Conversely, as someone that has always voted Labour like supporting a football team, I never had an answer to what a mate once said to me; "When you are young and enjoying other people's money you can be socialist but when it's your own money, you go Conservative". (Not my view but it does seem to hold water)!
The point is, the tories have been in power for 13 years now, inevitably people want a change. I often wonder of some of those I spoke to in 2010 regret saying "It doesn't matter who is in...…"
Reply
#42
(01-04-2023, 01:02 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Shabby Russian Wrote:Going back to the OP.

There are for me two main reasons why the Conservative Party is struggling with younger voters and is nit winning them back as they head into their 30s and 40s.

1..the Conservatives place a lot of emphasis on home ownership. To the extent that there is an implication that if you don't own your own home you're a bit of a failure.
The reality is that it is becoming harder to get onto the property ladder. There is an increasing number of young voters who have come to the realisation that despite having good jobs, working hard etc they will never be in a position to own their own home. In short they will be worse off than their parents.
They are taking the view that the current economic policy of the govt is not working for them, and they would be right.

2..the right in this country are becoming increasingly unpleasant and nasty in the way they express their views.
And this is not about  keyboard warriors who write abusive and threatening stuff from a cloak of anonymity. The left have too many if these types as well.
I am talking about mainstream commentators and increasingly Conservative politicians, who appear to revel in expressing opinions that are mean spirited and downright unpleasant.
A recent example was Juila Hartley Brewer's tweet about Greta Thunberg, so unnecessarily nasty.
Can't they see how off putting this behaviour is.
I am all for political debate, and people disagreeing with each other, and if that can be done with a bit if humour all the better.

But then I am probably a snowflake  or woke , or some other term that has come into fashion in the last 10 years , to describe people like me.

Hasn't this always been so? With the exception of wierdos like Rees Mogg and Ian Duncan Disorderly young people tend to be left of centre. As they get older it then becomes a bit more I'm all right Jack. Conversely, as someone that has always voted Labour like supporting a football team, I never had an answer to what a mate once said to me; "When you are young and enjoying other people's money you can be socialist but when it's your own money, you go Conservative". (Not my view but it does seem to hold water)!
The point is, the tories have been in power for 13 years now, inevitably people want a change. I often wonder of some of those I spoke to in 2010 regret saying "It doesn't matter who is in...…"

Look at the graph in the first comment. The dip is more extreme for millennials than it was for Gen X in 1997. Also it doesn't look like the Silent Generation had a dip in 1964.
Reply
#43
(01-04-2023, 01:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Look at the graph in the first comment. The dip is more extreme for millennials than it was for Gen X in 1997. Also it doesn't look like the Silent Generation had a dip in 1964.

You and I both know this is pretty much entirely due to housing. If you can't get a stake in a capitalist system then de facto you're not a stakeholder.

By opposing pretty much any development anywhere the Tories are signing their own death warrant. It doesn't help when the two other main parties in England are also anti-development - particular when it suits their narrow electoral interests.
Reply
#44
It's not just access to capital though, is it? It's the entire message over the last 12 years.
Reply
#45
(01-04-2023, 04:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-04-2023, 01:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Look at the graph in the first comment. The dip is more extreme for millennials than it was for Gen X in 1997. Also it doesn't look like the Silent Generation had a dip in 1964.

You and I both know this is pretty much entirely due to housing. If you can't get a stake in a capitalist system then de facto you're not a stakeholder.

By opposing pretty much any development anywhere the Tories are signing their own death warrant. It doesn't help when the two other main parties in England are also anti-development - particular when it suits their narrow electoral interests.

Proof please. 

You really think that the younger generations are just not interested / dislike / won’t vote for the Tories because they can’t get on the housing ladder? I think you’re talking oss poop. Try austerity, wedge politics, an out of touch party and members, the contempt the party has for the truth and accountability, stagnating wages, Brexit, the abysmal cabinets, the hypocrisy, cronyism, blaming others for failure, violent crime rocketing, antisocial behaviour… as BB said it’s the whole package, it is about as appealing to younger people as a Wethers Original that has gone through the digestive system of a flatulent sloth with a tummy bug.
Reply
#46
The polling data you cite backs my contention Dekka. Those with a stake in capitalism are more likely to vote Conservative and always have been. Those without a stake are less likely to vote Conservative, particularly if it doesn’t appear they’ll be able to attain a stake.

A home of your own has a far greater influence on ontological security and voting intention than pretty much anything else.
Reply
#47
As a millennial who has managed to get themselves onto the property ladder I'd say you're both right. It's an interesting split.

I've got plenty of friends who struggle to afford to buy a house for them this is one of the key issues but is fast slipping down the list of priorities as it becomes more and more apparent that buying a house is something they'll only do in their dreams or if both their parents die immediately.

Friends who have managed to buy property, then tend to hone in on the myriad of other ways the Tories has destroyed the country and that seems to be the driver for us. In almost 13 years as many of us have become adults and into our thirties, the Tories have really not done a lot of good for us.

And good luck with Gen Z, who are about to seriously deliver a kicking to the Tories in the polls when they turn 18. They're even more mental than us.
Reply
#48
Ted Maul Wrote:As a millennial who has managed to get themselves onto the property ladder I'd say you're both right. It's an interesting split.

I've got plenty of friends who struggle to afford to buy a house for them this is one of the key issues but is fast slipping down the list of priorities as it becomes more and more apparent that buying a house is something they'll only do in their dreams or if both their parents die immediately.

Friends who have managed to buy property, then tend to hone in on the myriad of other ways the Tories has destroyed the country and that seems to be the driver for us. In almost 13 years as many of us have become adults and into our thirties, the Tories have really not done a lot of good for us.

And good luck with Gen Z, who are about to seriously deliver a kicking to the Tories in the polls when they turn 18. They're even more mental than us.
Sad to say that in my experience, there is very little appetite for politics among the young. In my experience, I say.
Reply
#49
(01-05-2023, 08:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: As a millennial who has managed to get themselves onto the property ladder I'd say you're both right. It's an interesting split.

I've got plenty of friends who struggle to afford to buy a house for them this is one of the key issues but is fast slipping down the list of priorities as it becomes more and more apparent that buying a house is something they'll only do in their dreams or if both their parents die immediately.

Friends who have managed to buy property, then tend to hone in on the myriad of other ways the Tories has destroyed the country and that seems to be the driver for us. In almost 13 years as many of us have become adults and into our thirties, the Tories have really not done a lot of good for us.

And good luck with Gen Z, who are about to seriously deliver a kicking to the Tories in the polls when they turn 18. They're even more mental than us.

What's most interesting is how housing dominates voting intention amongst young adults in the UK. In France and Germany where housing is less of an issue - particularly outside the largest cities there is huge support amongst Millennials for the National Front and AfD.
Reply
#50
(01-05-2023, 07:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-05-2023, 08:37 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: As a millennial who has managed to get themselves onto the property ladder I'd say you're both right. It's an interesting split.

I've got plenty of friends who struggle to afford to buy a house for them this is one of the key issues but is fast slipping down the list of priorities as it becomes more and more apparent that buying a house is something they'll only do in their dreams or if both their parents die immediately.

Friends who have managed to buy property, then tend to hone in on the myriad of other ways the Tories has destroyed the country and that seems to be the driver for us. In almost 13 years as many of us have become adults and into our thirties, the Tories have really not done a lot of good for us.

And good luck with Gen Z, who are about to seriously deliver a kicking to the Tories in the polls when they turn 18. They're even more mental than us.

What's most interesting is how housing dominates voting intention amongst young adults in the UK. In France and Germany where housing is less of an issue - particularly outside the largest cities there is huge support amongst Millennials for the National Front and AfD.

Younger people in Germany were significantly more likely to vote FDP or Die Gruenen, and were less likely to vote AfD. What are you on about?

As for France, young people were most likely to vote for frog Corbyn a.k.a. Jean-Luc Mélenchon who was the plurality for the under 34s.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: