Confirmed Shan in charge
#61
Nice positive slant on the official site saying Shan has averaged 2 points a game to make it sound like he’s making good steady progress.
Imagine if one of us had written it? Something along the lines of ..... “3 wins to start but could’ve just as easily lost, dog shit for 2 games before finally turning in a good performance albeit against a poor side”.
I really don’t know why my career in marketing never took off !
Reply
#62
(04-16-2019, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2019, 04:35 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: So the club have affectively admitted they were wrong to sack Moore by not appointing an adequate replacement?

We now have an inexperienced manager. Which we already had.

How has it been proven that the club were wrong to let DM go?

You can never prove one way or the other what would have happened if he had remained in the job.

But what I would say is that the list of managers who have been sacked 10 games to go from the end of the season with their side sitting in 4th position and still with a realistic chance of promotion is a very short one. Might be one with only one name on it.

The decision was bizarre, and there not being a definite replacement lined up turns the decision from bizarre to incompetent.
Reply
#63
There's no other multi-million pound business in the world that sacks their CEO and puts in charge some underling from 3 ranks down the chain. Completely bananas. The shareholders would revolt. No disrespect to Shan he's doing ok but regardless of how we get on it's clear that our future is going to be just one short term decision after another and in the end that will see us precisely nowhere.

All I'm hoping for now is not to lose to that bunch of arrogant claret clarnets down the road.
Reply
#64
(04-17-2019, 07:41 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-16-2019, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2019, 04:35 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: So the club have affectively admitted they were wrong to sack Moore by not appointing an adequate replacement?

We now have an inexperienced manager. Which we already had.

How has it been proven that the club were wrong to let DM go?

You can never prove one way or the other what would have happened if he had remained in the job.

But what I would say is that the list of managers who have been sacked 10 games to go from the end of the season with their side sitting in 4th position and still with a realistic chance of promotion is a very short one. Might be one with only one name on it.

The decision was bizarre, and there not being a definite replacement lined up turns the decision from bizarre to incompetent.

Correct. Plus it removed from the scene an incumbent who is Albion to the core and has an unrivalled knowledge of the set up from the youths upwards. My take has always been that Jones was the problem and BD needed a different no. 2 or an experienced DOF to guide him through his first season.
Reply
#65
(04-17-2019, 07:46 AM)billybassett Wrote: There's no other multi-million pound business in the world that sacks their CEO and puts in charge some underling from 3 ranks down the chain. Completely bananas. The shareholders would revolt. No disrespect to Shan he's doing ok but regardless of how we get on it's clear that our future is going to be just one short term decision after another and in the end that will see us precisely nowhere.

All I'm hoping for now is not to lose to that bunch of arrogant claret clarnets down the road.

Irony of your post is that we would probably be better off sacking Jenkins and putting an underling in charge but actually that's not what they've done they've sacked an underling and put another underling in charge.
Reply
#66
The club hierarchy should hang their heads in shame after this debacle. It really comes down to whether or not we get promotion. If we succeed in reaching the Prem with Shan, it will have been a masterstroke. However, failure to do so and the current board will never live it down. My take, regardless of where we are come the start of the new season is that the new owners reign has been a cluster thus far. I never thought I would say this, but I would taker JP back in a heartbeat. He knew how to run a football club.
Reply
#67
(04-17-2019, 07:41 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-16-2019, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2019, 04:35 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: So the club have affectively admitted they were wrong to sack Moore by not appointing an adequate replacement?

We now have an inexperienced manager. Which we already had.

How has it been proven that the club were wrong to let DM go?

You can never prove one way or the other what would have happened if he had remained in the job.

But what I would say is that the list of managers who have been sacked 10 games to go from the end of the season with their side sitting in 4th position and still with a realistic chance of promotion is a very short one. Might be one with only one name on it.

The decision was bizarre, and there not being a definite replacement lined up turns the decision from bizarre to incompetent.

Absolutely. No matter how it's framed or the outcome of the season there's no getting away from this.

If Shan somehow manages to take us up the board don't deserve the credit, he does.
Reply
#68
(04-16-2019, 05:19 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-16-2019, 05:16 PM)Atomic Wrote: I think this is the right decision. Regardless of whether or not we should've sacked Darren Moore, that decision has come and gone. The fact is it would be silly to appoint a new manager with four (league) games to go not knowing what division we will be in next season, therefore not knowing what our requirements will be.

Jimmy Shan has shown he isn't completely useless. Yes we had a couple of bad defeats on the road but he reacted to that by making positive and correct changes last Saturday.

Re-evaluate in the summer but for now get behind Jimmy and the lads for the rest of the season

+1

He doesn't talk in cliches either
Reply
#69
(04-17-2019, 10:00 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 09:24 AM)westbromjack Wrote: The club hierarchy should hang their heads in shame after this debacle. It really comes down to whether or not we get promotion. If we succeed in reaching the Prem with Shan, it will have been a masterstroke. However, failure to do so and the current board will never live it down. My take, regardless of where we are come the start of the new season is that the new owners reign has been a cluster thus far. I never thought I would say this, but I would taker JP back in a heartbeat. He knew how to run a football club.

We had several relegations under Peace and many a transfer window debacle. He got us Jenkins and sold to Lai. His last two managerial appointments were Irvine and Pulis. And then there's the treatment of the small shareholders and Astle family etc. It's a No from me.

There were undoubtedly ups and downs during JPs time but the the fact is, it's still the most successful period of time our club has had since the late 1970s nearly 40 yrs ago. At the time when we were finishing midtable in the Prem I did say some fans should try and enjoy those times more, because there is no guarantee they are coming back.
Reply
#70
Listening to BBC WM last night and Garry Thompson was very critical of the decision to appoint Shan. I thought Thompson was more Villa than Albion anyway? I’m sure he’s there analyst for the games in which Villa play.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: