Shouldn’t the clowns SAY something?
#41
(04-15-2019, 12:00 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:30 AM)wba13 Wrote: The negativity on here is crap we don’t know what is going on behind the scenes, ok we need a new man in but we’re not a bottom 6 side we’re in the play offs with a decent shot at promotion. Why you cannot get behind the club makes me wonder what some of your agenda is. There are a lot of out of work and those in work managers who would love a shot at this job, but me I am glad to see them taking there time and hopefully getting the right man in place we have to trust the board to get this one right. I know most of you don’t trust our board but remember for every Guardiola there is a Pulis so hopefully they have the right people in mind.

I personally think that the fact we're going for promotion means there should be more urgency to appoint a new Manager. If we were mid-table with nothing to play for, I could understand the stance more (still think 37 days is way too long though).

As for getting behind the club, I've been a ST holder for the last 20 years, and always support the team, that's not going to change. I'm not however going to support the board for how they've managed this situation. If you think they're doing a good job, and have handled this process well, that's your prerogative. I hold the opposite view.

Again, the original question...

Who should we appoint, and why would they deliver any more than Shan currently is?

We are in promotion winning form, despite missing key players, and are arguably now playing a system that is more productive than what we’ve done to get to the playoffs...
Reply
#42
(04-15-2019, 12:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 12:00 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:30 AM)wba13 Wrote: The negativity on here is crap we don’t know what is going on behind the scenes, ok we need a new man in but we’re not a bottom 6 side we’re in the play offs with a decent shot at promotion. Why you cannot get behind the club makes me wonder what some of your agenda is. There are a lot of out of work and those in work managers who would love a shot at this job, but me I am glad to see them taking there time and hopefully getting the right man in place we have to trust the board to get this one right. I know most of you don’t trust our board but remember for every Guardiola there is a Pulis so hopefully they have the right people in mind.

I personally think that the fact we're going for promotion means there should be more urgency to appoint a new Manager. If we were mid-table with nothing to play for, I could understand the stance more (still think 37 days is way too long though).

As for getting behind the club, I've been a ST holder for the last 20 years, and always support the team, that's not going to change. I'm not however going to support the board for how they've managed this situation. If you think they're doing a good job, and have handled this process well, that's your prerogative. I hold the opposite view.

Again, the original question...

Who should we appoint, and why would they deliver any more than Shan currently is?

We are in promotion winning form, despite missing key players, and are arguably now playing a system that is more productive than what we’ve done to get to the playoffs...

I would agree there is no point appointing a permanent manager now. There is too much difference between the role required depending on which division we are in.

But, up until this point the message from the board is that Shan has the role on a game by game basis. Hence the flurry towards Neil, post-Bristol match.

Fans are entitled to object to this ahead of the play-offs, because as you've pointed out, who are we going to get in now, anyway? It smacks of indecisiveness ahead of a critical period for the club. 

If the club announced that Shan has the role until the end of the season, with X as coaching support, most would be happy with that. 

No question of him getting it permanently as whatever happens next season, it will be a task beyond his level of experience.
Reply
#43
I haven't seen any valid reasons not to clarify whether we're sticking with Shan at this point or not
Reply
#44
What were the reasons BD was sacked? Has that question even been properly asked?

Why on earth was he even appointed if the top two was the aim? Was that ever realistic or fair?

And, if so, has whatever problem he has caused/was causing since been alleviated?.

What priority did the board place upon the sacking of BD versus promotion, given where we were placed at the time, and the likely outcome afterwards? Surely a plan or forecast was in place?

Or was it simply as knee-jerk a sacking as it was an appointment?

My strong suspicion is the latter. It is a laughable situation, and the attention of the national press into this is only a result of the misgivings of the locals to properly interrogate the situation. Which is, however you slice it, a clusterfuck.
Reply
#45
(04-15-2019, 12:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 12:00 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:30 AM)wba13 Wrote: The negativity on here is crap we don’t know what is going on behind the scenes, ok we need a new man in but we’re not a bottom 6 side we’re in the play offs with a decent shot at promotion. Why you cannot get behind the club makes me wonder what some of your agenda is. There are a lot of out of work and those in work managers who would love a shot at this job, but me I am glad to see them taking there time and hopefully getting the right man in place we have to trust the board to get this one right. I know most of you don’t trust our board but remember for every Guardiola there is a Pulis so hopefully they have the right people in mind.

I personally think that the fact we're going for promotion means there should be more urgency to appoint a new Manager. If we were mid-table with nothing to play for, I could understand the stance more (still think 37 days is way too long though).

As for getting behind the club, I've been a ST holder for the last 20 years, and always support the team, that's not going to change. I'm not however going to support the board for how they've managed this situation. If you think they're doing a good job, and have handled this process well, that's your prerogative. I hold the opposite view.

Again, the original question...

Who should we appoint, and why would they deliver any more than Shan currently is?

We are in promotion winning form, despite missing key players, and are arguably now playing a system that is more productive than what we’ve done to get to the playoffs...
In answer....

I think the victory against Preston has papered over the cracks again. Had the result been different there would be a greater clamber to appoint a new Manager. I'm not paid a shed load of money to run a football club, but I would have thought we'd have lined up numerous options, and would have been holding interviews the same week that we sacked Big Dave. Perhaps we did, and not one of them met our requirements.

I've stated all along Jokanovic would have been my choice - Not sure if he was interviewed or if he's turned us down, but as an out of work Manager, you'd hope he was within our reach. I have no idea if he'd have delivered more than Shan, if he had been appointed the week after Moore's dismissal, but either way I believe we need a permanent Manager in place

I think the formation played in the last game & a half suits the players that Shan has at his disposal, so fair play to him for deploying it. The only reason it didn't work for Big Dave was the way he wanted to continually play out from the back. Shan has done a much better job than I expected, but it's a big risk going into the play-offs with a rookie Manager. He'll get my full support while he's in the role, but I still don't think he should still be in the gig this long after Big Dave's sacking.
Reply
#46
(04-15-2019, 12:55 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 12:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 12:00 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:30 AM)wba13 Wrote: The negativity on here is crap we don’t know what is going on behind the scenes, ok we need a new man in but we’re not a bottom 6 side we’re in the play offs with a decent shot at promotion. Why you cannot get behind the club makes me wonder what some of your agenda is. There are a lot of out of work and those in work managers who would love a shot at this job, but me I am glad to see them taking there time and hopefully getting the right man in place we have to trust the board to get this one right. I know most of you don’t trust our board but remember for every Guardiola there is a Pulis so hopefully they have the right people in mind.

I personally think that the fact we're going for promotion means there should be more urgency to appoint a new Manager. If we were mid-table with nothing to play for, I could understand the stance more (still think 37 days is way too long though).

As for getting behind the club, I've been a ST holder for the last 20 years, and always support the team, that's not going to change. I'm not however going to support the board for how they've managed this situation. If you think they're doing a good job, and have handled this process well, that's your prerogative. I hold the opposite view.

Again, the original question...

Who should we appoint, and why would they deliver any more than Shan currently is?

We are in promotion winning form, despite missing key players, and are arguably now playing a system that is more productive than what we’ve done to get to the playoffs...
In answer....

I think the victory against Preston has papered over the cracks again. Had the result been different there would be a greater clamber to appoint a new Manager. I'm not paid a shed load of money to run a football club, but I would have thought we'd have lined up numerous options, and would have been holding interviews the same week that we sacked Big Dave. Perhaps we did, and not one of them met our requirements.

I've stated all along Jokanovic would have been my choice - Not sure if he was interviewed or if he's turned us down, but as an out of work Manager, you'd hope he was within our reach. I have no idea if he'd have delivered more than Shan, if he had been appointed the week after Moore's dismissal, but either way I believe we need a permanent Manager in place

I think the formation played in the last game & a half suits the players that Shan has at his disposal, so fair play to him for deploying it. The only reason it didn't work for Big Dave was the way he wanted to continually play out from the back. Shan has done a much better job than I expected, but it's a big risk going into the play-offs with a rookie Manager. He'll get my full support while he's in the role, but I still don't think he should still be in the gig this long after Big Dave's sacking.

I think the Moore sacking had been bubbling for a while, we'd been poor for a few weeks, and there had been lots of rumblings of discontent around Jones and the system we were playing from the senior pros. For me, the writing was on the wall from the moment Moore stood by Jones and the insipid display against Ipswich forced our hand to let him go sooner than we'd planned - however the decision was taken to move quickly after seeing how clinging on to Pardew and Pulis had ultimately relegated us. 

I imagine we spoke to Jokanovic, Wagner and a couple of others shortly after sacking BD, but their demands and the upturn in form meant it made more sense to stick with what we had.

I agree that this weekend's result has papered over the cracks a little bit and I can understand the clamour for a decision one way or another on Shan, but given PNE were unsettled and looked partly on the beach, we probably don't want to read too much into that game given it was a bit of a dead rubber. Friday pits us against a more competitive side, who still have an outside chance of the top 6 and are in decent form, so I expect we'll make a decision after that match.
Reply
#47
(04-14-2019, 02:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: What is there to be said that hasn't already been said?

We said we were looking to make a quick appointment, however shortly after both Wagner and Jokanovic distanced themselves from the job.

It was then announced Shan would be in control on a game by game basis whilst we considered our options.

As it stands, there is no outstanding candidate available, and Shan is showing he's more than capable. We've since stated we're looking at bringing some support in for Shan, but it's his decision.

Sometimes silence is the best option.... imagine if we'd come out saying Neil was our number one choice and then the last 24 hours happened?

Just becasue nothing has been made public doesn't mean the players/Shan haven't had relatively consistent dialogue.

They all see each other every day at the training ground so I'm sure Shan get's a daily update.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)