Official approach
#21
Ok Statto I know you cannot betray a confidence, but to give us any hope of a new man coming in, without giving names are we serious talks with anyone and if so could it be close.
Reply
#22
(04-15-2019, 05:50 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 08:27 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 06:57 PM)Statto Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 05:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: As I said earlier Neil himself said he had not spoken to anyone about the job.

He lied

But, but, but, but, people don't tell lies. 

Arf   Big Grin

I'm not sure he died lie. Did he himself actually speak to anyone at the club? Probably not. What's more likely to have happened is someone spoke to his agent, told them we are interested and what terms we were offering etc. We would also have spoken to Preston to find out IF we did make an approach how much would it cost etc and would they let him go.

So no formal approach. There must have been some credible contact for Preston to suddenly offer the bloke a 3 year deal on much better terms.

But like I said did Neil directly speak to anyone? No.

No-one at Board level is going to tell anyone anything.   It was all pure speculation probably started by his agent or someone close to him. 

Scenario - there's a vacancy at West Brom, Neil wants a pay rise and a new contract - speculation intensifies as Saturday's game approached.  Preston panic and offer new deal - he's got what he wanted purely through speculation.  

Happens all the time.  Bloke I worked with did the same thing, never produced ANY evidence of another offer but senior management bought it.
Reply
#23
It’s the ITK not ITK thread. We had to have one.
Reply
#24
(04-15-2019, 09:40 AM)wba13 Wrote: Ok Statto I know you cannot betray a confidence, but to give us any hope of a new man coming in, without giving names are we serious talks with anyone and if so could it be close.

That I don’t know, but whether there was a ‘formal’ approach for AN or not, there was a meeting. 

There are a number of reasons why the situation could have changed between the meeting and yesterday. No concrete info on that, I’m afraid. 

My guess, and it’s purely a guess, is that amongst other factors both of their styles of play on Saturday - long balls to Stockley, then fuggin about st the back - are likely to have frightened the life out of our lot. First half was very naive as it played straight to our strongest suit, while the second half style was reminiscent of one of the big reasons why they wanted rid of Jones. 

Shan made positive changes that worked and no doubt MJ would have been questioning what he was spending the £650k on. 

MJ is a cockwomble and dithers, but the club are in a very awkward situation. This is not a common scenario. A short term arrangement with someone like Big Sam would have been ideal, then reassess in the summer when we know where we are. I’m not a fan of him for a long term solution, but it’s a shame those discussions didn’t bear fruit.
Reply
#25
(04-15-2019, 10:34 AM)Statto Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 09:40 AM)wba13 Wrote: Ok Statto I know you cannot betray a confidence, but to give us any hope of a new man coming in, without giving names are we serious talks with anyone and if so could it be close.

That I don’t know, but whether there was a ‘formal’ approach for AN or not, there was a meeting. 

There are a number of reasons why the situation could have changed between the meeting and yesterday. No concrete info on that, I’m afraid. 

My guess, and it’s purely a guess, is that amongst other factors both of their styles of play on Saturday - long balls to Stockley, then fuggin about st the back - are likely to have frightened the life out of our lot. First half was very naive as it played straight to our strongest suit, while the second half style was reminiscent of one of the big reasons why they wanted rid of Jones. 

Shan made positive changes that worked and no doubt MJ would have been questioning what he was spending the £650k on. 

MJ is a cockwomble and dithers, but the club are in a very awkward situation. This is not a common scenario. A short term arrangement with someone like Big Sam would have been ideal, then reassess in the summer when we know where we are. I’m not a fan of him for a long term solution, but it’s a shame those discussions didn’t bear fruit.

Yes they are in an awkward position. A position they have put themselves in by making the sacking.

I said in a post last week that Jenkins is proving to be a muddled thinker. Making decisions and then having no real plan.

The 'game by game' plan means we have a fan base who after every result, be it good or bad, question what the board are doing.

I think they now need to come out and say 'its Shan until the end of the season and draw a line under it. That way the players and staff can be focused.

It really is too late to bring in a Number 1 now.

An experienced No 2 would make more sense. I wonder if we couldn't get someone like Downing in from the FA on a short term consultancy deal. He'd be ideal in being a sounding board, knows the club and would have no desires on staying longer.
Reply
#26
(04-15-2019, 10:53 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:34 AM)Statto Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 09:40 AM)wba13 Wrote: Ok Statto I know you cannot betray a confidence, but to give us any hope of a new man coming in, without giving names are we serious talks with anyone and if so could it be close.

That I don’t know, but whether there was a ‘formal’ approach for AN or not, there was a meeting. 

There are a number of reasons why the situation could have changed between the meeting and yesterday. No concrete info on that, I’m afraid. 

My guess, and it’s purely a guess, is that amongst other factors both of their styles of play on Saturday - long balls to Stockley, then fuggin about st the back - are likely to have frightened the life out of our lot. First half was very naive as it played straight to our strongest suit, while the second half style was reminiscent of one of the big reasons why they wanted rid of Jones. 

Shan made positive changes that worked and no doubt MJ would have been questioning what he was spending the £650k on. 

MJ is a cockwomble and dithers, but the club are in a very awkward situation. This is not a common scenario. A short term arrangement with someone like Big Sam would have been ideal, then reassess in the summer when we know where we are. I’m not a fan of him for a long term solution, but it’s a shame those discussions didn’t bear fruit.

Yes they are in an awkward position. A position they have put themselves in by making the sacking.

I said in a post last week that Jenkins is proving to be a muddled thinker. Making decisions and then having no real plan.

The 'game by game' plan means we have a fan base who after every result, be it good or bad, question what the board are doing.

I think they now need to come out and say 'its Shan until the end of the season and draw a line under it. That way the players and staff can be focused.

It really is too late to bring in a Number 1 now.

An experienced No 2 would make more sense. I wonder if we couldn't get someone like Downing in from the FA on a short term consultancy deal. He'd be ideal in being a sounding board, knows the club and would have no desires on staying longer.

The sacking was just as complicated. We all love and admire DM as a man of impeccable loyalty and integrity, but in this case it did for him after he backed himself into a corner. 

There is also a lot of opinion stated and accepted as fact in all things Albion at the minute. One of these is that Jenkins sacked DM, which isn’t as cut and dried as some may think. 

Jenkins is a cunt to the fans. However, he’s exactly what we need financially. It’s shit but true. The problem is the level of control he’s been given over football decisions. In the past he’d have set the budgetary constraints and others would them have taken the football decisions within those parameters.
Reply
#27
If we had all the facts and figures as some on here would like - this bored would become a defunct, dull boring place.
Long live the opinions, gossip, rumors, mistakes, genuine errors and lies.
Reply
#28
(04-15-2019, 11:48 AM)Statto Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:53 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:34 AM)Statto Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 09:40 AM)wba13 Wrote: Ok Statto I know you cannot betray a confidence, but to give us any hope of a new man coming in, without giving names are we serious talks with anyone and if so could it be close.

That I don’t know, but whether there was a ‘formal’ approach for AN or not, there was a meeting. 

There are a number of reasons why the situation could have changed between the meeting and yesterday. No concrete info on that, I’m afraid. 

My guess, and it’s purely a guess, is that amongst other factors both of their styles of play on Saturday - long balls to Stockley, then fuggin about st the back - are likely to have frightened the life out of our lot. First half was very naive as it played straight to our strongest suit, while the second half style was reminiscent of one of the big reasons why they wanted rid of Jones. 

Shan made positive changes that worked and no doubt MJ would have been questioning what he was spending the £650k on. 

MJ is a cockwomble and dithers, but the club are in a very awkward situation. This is not a common scenario. A short term arrangement with someone like Big Sam would have been ideal, then reassess in the summer when we know where we are. I’m not a fan of him for a long term solution, but it’s a shame those discussions didn’t bear fruit.

Yes they are in an awkward position. A position they have put themselves in by making the sacking.

I said in a post last week that Jenkins is proving to be a muddled thinker. Making decisions and then having no real plan.

The 'game by game' plan means we have a fan base who after every result, be it good or bad, question what the board are doing.

I think they now need to come out and say 'its Shan until the end of the season and draw a line under it. That way the players and staff can be focused.

It really is too late to bring in a Number 1 now.

An experienced No 2 would make more sense. I wonder if we couldn't get someone like Downing in from the FA on a short term consultancy deal. He'd be ideal in being a sounding board, knows the club and would have no desires on staying longer.

The sacking was just as complicated. We all love and admire DM as a man of impeccable loyalty and integrity, but in this case it did for him after he backed himself into a corner. 

There is also a lot of opinion stated and accepted as fact in all things Albion at the minute. One of these is that Jenkins sacked DM, which isn’t as cut and dried as some may think. 

Is it not that Dowling and Jenkins wanted Jones out and Moore said "If he goes, I go?". If so, it's fair to say that's what most on here think happened, if not the wider fanbase/world.

With regards to decision making, there's been far too much time spent on lost causes. We can't afford Jokanovic, move on. Wagner can't work now and sees himself as a PL manager, move on. Yet we seemed to spend weeks dithering over these two.

Likewise whether to get in the likes of Moyes/Allardyce as interim.

It's the indecisiveness which is worrying fans as opposed to the actual decisions being made. As an example, despite the outcry when Allardyce emerged in the betting, post Millwall, many were calling for his appointment.
Reply
#29
Promotion is so important - I would have gotten half a dozen experts in for a couple of weeks.
We need all the help we can get.
Reply
#30
(04-15-2019, 12:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 11:48 AM)Statto Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:53 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 10:34 AM)Statto Wrote:
(04-15-2019, 09:40 AM)wba13 Wrote: Ok Statto I know you cannot betray a confidence, but to give us any hope of a new man coming in, without giving names are we serious talks with anyone and if so could it be close.

That I don’t know, but whether there was a ‘formal’ approach for AN or not, there was a meeting. 

There are a number of reasons why the situation could have changed between the meeting and yesterday. No concrete info on that, I’m afraid. 

My guess, and it’s purely a guess, is that amongst other factors both of their styles of play on Saturday - long balls to Stockley, then fuggin about st the back - are likely to have frightened the life out of our lot. First half was very naive as it played straight to our strongest suit, while the second half style was reminiscent of one of the big reasons why they wanted rid of Jones. 

Shan made positive changes that worked and no doubt MJ would have been questioning what he was spending the £650k on. 

MJ is a cockwomble and dithers, but the club are in a very awkward situation. This is not a common scenario. A short term arrangement with someone like Big Sam would have been ideal, then reassess in the summer when we know where we are. I’m not a fan of him for a long term solution, but it’s a shame those discussions didn’t bear fruit.

Yes they are in an awkward position. A position they have put themselves in by making the sacking.

I said in a post last week that Jenkins is proving to be a muddled thinker. Making decisions and then having no real plan.

The 'game by game' plan means we have a fan base who after every result, be it good or bad, question what the board are doing.

I think they now need to come out and say 'its Shan until the end of the season and draw a line under it. That way the players and staff can be focused.

It really is too late to bring in a Number 1 now.

An experienced No 2 would make more sense. I wonder if we couldn't get someone like Downing in from the FA on a short term consultancy deal. He'd be ideal in being a sounding board, knows the club and would have no desires on staying longer.

The sacking was just as complicated. We all love and admire DM as a man of impeccable loyalty and integrity, but in this case it did for him after he backed himself into a corner. 

There is also a lot of opinion stated and accepted as fact in all things Albion at the minute. One of these is that Jenkins sacked DM, which isn’t as cut and dried as some may think. 

Is it not that Dowling and Jenkins wanted Jones out and Moore said "If he goes, I go?". If so, it's fair to say that's what most on here think happened, if not the wider fanbase/world.

With regards to decision making, there's been far too much time spent on lost causes. We can't afford Jokanovic, move on. Wagner can't work now and sees himself as a PL manager, move on. Yet we seemed to spend weeks dithering over these two.

Likewise whether to get in the likes of Moyes/Allardyce as interim.

It's the indecisiveness which is worrying fans as opposed to the actual decisions being made. As an example, despite the outcry when Allardyce emerged in the betting, post Millwall, many were calling for his appointment.

I fail to see how we can't afford Jokanovic??
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)