You can change the lipstick but it’s still the Conservative party
#91
(09-08-2022, 09:45 AM)strawman Wrote: How do you nationlise global companies that are not based in this country and that produce most of the worlds oil and gas. Presumably we already have contracts with those companies for North Sea gas.

It would surely cost billions to nationalise the downstream providers and they would still have to pay the global price.

I'm neither gung-ho for, nor totally opposed to state ownership of certain areas of utilities and other infrastructure but, like yourself, I could imagine that unravelling and compensating the ownership of an entity like EDF - just as an example - would be prohibitively complex and expensive. I do find it staggering that such a high percentage (70+%) of the ownership of UK water companies is in foreign or offshore hands; perhaps that would be the place to look first for feasibility.

Railways are a different proposition, by virtue of franchises having time limitations and expiry dates; plus there's evidence from a number of post-privatisation examples to suggest that publicly-owned railways can outperform private franchises against all of the important benchmarks.
Reply
#92
There's a good argument for setting up a public / private fracking partnership. The sort of social enterprise the Left would love. Subsidise the price of fracked gas to consumers and all those old red wall energy intensive businesses - and set up a sovereign wealth fund to invest the profits. What's not to like?
Reply
#93
(09-08-2022, 10:18 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's a good argument for setting up a public / private fracking partnership. The sort of social enterprise the Left would love. Subsidise the price of fracked gas to consumers and all those old red wall energy intensive businesses - and set up a sovereign wealth fund to invest the profits. What's not to like?

Ah yes, continue using the commodity that is currently causing our energy crisis. Great idea.
Reply
#94
I see they've released the details of donors from the Tory leadership campaign. Truss received £100k from the wife of a former BP exec just I case you were wondering who's side she is on.
Reply
#95
(09-08-2022, 11:05 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2022, 10:18 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's a good argument for setting up a public / private fracking partnership. The sort of social enterprise the Left would love. Subsidise the price of fracked gas to consumers and all those old red wall energy intensive businesses - and set up a sovereign wealth fund to invest the profits. What's not to like?

Ah yes, continue using the commodity that is currently causing our energy crisis. Great idea.

#ShillForShale
Reply
#96
(09-08-2022, 11:22 AM)SophLad Wrote:
(09-08-2022, 11:05 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2022, 10:18 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's a good argument for setting up a public / private fracking partnership. The sort of social enterprise the Left would love. Subsidise the price of fracked gas to consumers and all those old red wall energy intensive businesses - and set up a sovereign wealth fund to invest the profits. What's not to like?

Ah yes, continue using the commodity that is currently causing our energy crisis. Great idea.

#ShillForShale

It's honestly pathetic how many people are trying to get something out of their dud investments through exploiting an international crisis and pretending it's a silver bullet when it won't make a lick of difference.

Some might say the market decided you deserve to lose money, deal with it.
Reply
#97
I fear the horse has bolted. I've dealt with many Utility companies over the years, and it's clear that their responsibilities (quite rightly) are to their shareholders.

Most of you probably know that my Politics are right of centre, but I fervently believe that our core requirements (heat, light, water etc) should never have been privatised.

Weren't we told that North Seas Oil and Gas would see us self-sufficient in energy for generations? We have Thatcher to blame for that one.
Reply
#98
Let's be very clear franking is very unlikely to happen in the UK.
Reply
#99
(09-08-2022, 12:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Let's be very clear franking is very unlikely to happen in the UK.

Good Post.  Unless there are a lot of brown envelopes.
Reply
So to sum up…

At last some sort of proper help for people
Cut taxes to encourage growth or exasperate inflation, we shall see.
Borrow huge amounts of money
Don’t ask energy companies to pay tax on excess profit that they have benefited from due to a war
Pass the debt onto the average person in the street for years to come but it’s not a tax
Proclaim you’re on the side of hard working people
Refuse to give pay rises in line with inflation to public sector workers whilst trying to fix the problems of not enough staff working in sector.

If rampant capitalism is so great how come we have had to bail the banking sector out, and now we are having to rely on vast sums of borrowing to keep energy bills just about affordable for a couple of years (just up to another election)? Surely such profitable and brilliant energy companies should be able to keep costs down for the consumer, after all they are rewarding themselves and their shareholders handsomely.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: