Energy Twattery
#41
The price cap is expected to go up by over 3 times what it has been over the last decade, the fiscal headroom we have is a drop in the ocean. Also your suggestion does nothing to address issues with the downstream markets which are on fire at the moment, and it ignores the need to taper off on top of the fact that if energy prices don't settle down by 2024 (futures are being priced into them not being settled until primarily Germany gets it's shit together). It's not like it's just energy bill relief we need to focus on either, we need to transition away from gas heating (and fund that), we need to invest in insulation, we need to reinforce grid capacity to cope with demand surges and we need more interconnectors to Norway, the Netherlands and France all in the short to medium term.

BP's shares are down because people have been divesting from petrochemical companies for obvious reasons, and rightly so. Why do you think Shell have been talking incessantly about their electric car chargers powered by renewables? If BP want their share price to go up then they know they need to invest in renewables, why do you think the heads of the upstream side of the petrochemical industry have said a windfall tax won't affect their investment strategy? Because they don't want to be forced to tie their neck to the anchor that is a declining industry that is being phased out by the markets.
Reply
#42
Rumours of the death of the petrochemical industry are greatly exaggerated. We need oil and gas for many more applications than fuel - from the carpet you walk on to the drugs needed to keep you alive to the fertiliser to grow our gene edited grain. You cannot switch the lights out on all that until you’ve undertaken a laborious transition.

To go green you need plenty of black. You don’t seem to appreciate that.
Reply
#43
I'm in the energy industry, Proth. I know what hydrocarbons are used for and how they're processed. Don't patronise me.

You can literally track the divestment from fossil fuels over the last 10 years and see how global regulatory frameworks are designed to, rightly, promote that. I'm not making that up, that's the reality and markets are unsettled by the uncertainty of divestment from major revenue streams because you need replace those revenue streams. I'm also well aware that we need fossil fuels for things like scaled virgin polymers, composites, steel production and the transition to net zero over the next 28 years (hopefully, in spite of the stupid and dangerous rhetoric coming out of right wing populists), I don't need you to tell me that. Fact is though that's a very small slice of the pie for Big Oil and the markets that have driven their revenue over the last 150-200 years are shrinking, investors know this and the share prices are going up so Big Oil are investing into the growing markets that are displacing their gravy trains and until they're sufficiently large players in the growing markets to the same extent they are in the declining markets their share prices are going to keep going down.

What I don't like is people harking on about absolute bullshit like fracking and trying to distract and take investment away from clean energy storage, nuclear and renewables because it's all one shared pot and wasting time and money on bullshit like fracking isn't going to solve any of the immediate term issues and will just take away time and money from the actual solutions. I also don't like people who think that the shitshow caused by the failures of short termist energy policy in this country, excluding the blip between 2013 and 2015, as well as in other countries can be sorted by a quick fudge and that people are defending the blatant war profiteering, even if it's inadvertent and there's antitrust regulations blocking transfers into downstream markets, of upstream gas markets at this moment in time.
Reply
#44
Then I sense we agree on most of that.

Where I suspect we diverge is the speed of the transition away from gas. Gas isn't going anywhere for domestic heating for a long time. Any government here will find it impossible to sell the existing tepid, crappy and expensive alternative technology to hard pressed punters.
Reply
#45
Talking of energy twitter, I wonder if the energy suppliers will increase standing charges again in October.
Reply
#46
(08-11-2022, 08:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Then I sense we agree on most of that.

Where I suspect we diverge is the speed of the transition away from gas. Gas isn't going anywhere for domestic heating for a long time. Any government here will find it impossible to sell the existing tepid, crappy and expensive alternative technology to hard pressed punters.

The solution to carbon free heating is already out there and mature, district heating. It's been extremely successful for Finland. Only thing blocking it from being deployed in the UK is chronic short termist and unimaginative government incapable of making the big decisions. London, the West Midlands and the North West are crying out for district heating.

Also, investing in insulating buildings and bringing in tighter building regs to that effect will reduce gas demand even if we do rely on gas meaning that regardless heating demand should drop.
Reply
#47
Again, I don't disagree with the sentiments. I don't know enough about district heating to understand just how disruptive it would be.

Even with super insulation the problem with so much of the UK's stock is its age and method of construction. It doesn't help that the EPC ratings are skewed towards cost of energy rather than energy efficiency which is going to have a huge impact on what can be done in the rental market before 2025; let me give you an example - I've had a retrofit assessment of one of our houses which is currently a "D". If we clad two elevations and install a new boiler it becomes a C. If we clad two elevations and install a heat pump it becomes borderline D/E.

You can see the problem racing towards us. No one in government does.
Reply
#48
(08-10-2022, 06:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Ok. So let’s say 15 million households need help. 13 million x £400 is a good start. The rest can be found within the fiscal headroom that’s generally accepted we have. Alongside this we need an energy strategy that ensures investment occurs during market and profit peaks.

What also needs to be borne in mind is that BP shares are worth less than they were ten years ago. You’ll not encourage investment if returns are negated by government whim.

And the optics of transferring that £400 would be great in the red wall.

Also important to note that BP’s profit margins on fuel and the increasing price aren’t linked in any way. Fuel is generally sold on a platts plus basis, particularly to big customers like logistics firms, so their margins (percentage-wise) will actually shrink massively when the prices spike.
Reply
#49
(08-11-2022, 02:13 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(08-10-2022, 06:57 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Ok. So let’s say 15 million households need help. 13 million x £400 is a good start. The rest can be found within the fiscal headroom that’s generally accepted we have. Alongside this we need an energy strategy that ensures investment occurs during market and profit peaks.

What also needs to be borne in mind is that BP shares are worth less than they were ten years ago. You’ll not encourage investment if returns are negated by government whim.

And the optics of transferring that £400 would be great in the red wall.

Also important to note that BP’s profit margins on fuel and the increasing price aren’t linked in any way. Fuel is generally sold on a platts plus basis, particularly to big customers like logistics firms, so their margins (percentage-wise) will actually shrink massively when the prices spike.

That's the downstream side of things, on the upstream side of things they're selling gas at a huge markup with little increase in input cost.
Reply
#50
It’d be well funny if Borin Baggie turns out to be Proth’s “Energy Guy”.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: