Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(08-05-2022, 06:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:36 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-04-2022, 04:12 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-04-2022, 11:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-04-2022, 11:18 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Is it impossible to respond to a specific point on here? Clearly it is.
Only if you're working on the assumption that people who voted #LeastWorst in 2019 did so based on the response to a conflict that wasn't to happen for another two and a half years.
Anyone paying attention could see that Russia was going to become an ever bigger problem and Corbyn's response to the Salisbury poisonings made it clear that he was not suitable to lead UK foreign policy.
But the man who gave Lebedev a peerage was.
The reason why Corbyn with all his faults was still a better bet than Johnson in 2019, was that Corbyn had less control over his parliamentary party than Johnson did over his.
Not forgetting that Labour's economic policy in 2019, although not perfect, was better than the Conservatives.
Worst thing Corbyn did in 2019 was giving in to the likes of Starmer in the party and backing a second vote on Brexit. To this day his worst move as leader.
It wasn’t a second vote per se, it was a confirmatory vote on the deal that would be on the table. Having seen what we have ended up with where no one got what they wanted it seems like a sensible policy.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(08-05-2022, 06:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:36 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-04-2022, 04:12 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-04-2022, 11:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Only if you're working on the assumption that people who voted #LeastWorst in 2019 did so based on the response to a conflict that wasn't to happen for another two and a half years.
Anyone paying attention could see that Russia was going to become an ever bigger problem and Corbyn's response to the Salisbury poisonings made it clear that he was not suitable to lead UK foreign policy.
But the man who gave Lebedev a peerage was.
The reason why Corbyn with all his faults was still a better bet than Johnson in 2019, was that Corbyn had less control over his parliamentary party than Johnson did over his.
Not forgetting that Labour's economic policy in 2019, although not perfect, was better than the Conservatives.
Worst thing Corbyn did in 2019 was giving in to the likes of Starmer in the party and backing a second vote on Brexit. To this day his worst move as leader.
It wasn’t a second vote per se, it was a confirmatory vote on the deal that would be on the table. Having seen what we have ended up with where no one got what they wanted it seems like a sensible policy.
I don't agree, B1.
If the EU knew there was going to be such a vote then they would have played hardball right up to the last minute to effectively beholden the UK to a deal that was completely in their favour, giving us a few crumbs. It would have made no sense whatsoever from a negotiation standpoint. As I've said before Brexit was our opportunity to stop being pulled further into federalism. Yes, the current government and previous have made a royal hash of it but there wasn't the opportunity to say "Yes, I'll vote leave if I can get to choose who actually administers the exit policy".
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
It was exactly the kind of "confirmatory vote" that reversed the initial decisions in Ireland (Lisbon) and Denmark (Maastricht).
We all know what "confirmatory votes" are about.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
08-05-2022, 08:09 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-05-2022, 08:10 AM by Ted Maul.)
(08-05-2022, 06:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:36 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-04-2022, 04:12 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-04-2022, 11:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Only if you're working on the assumption that people who voted #LeastWorst in 2019 did so based on the response to a conflict that wasn't to happen for another two and a half years.
Anyone paying attention could see that Russia was going to become an ever bigger problem and Corbyn's response to the Salisbury poisonings made it clear that he was not suitable to lead UK foreign policy.
But the man who gave Lebedev a peerage was.
The reason why Corbyn with all his faults was still a better bet than Johnson in 2019, was that Corbyn had less control over his parliamentary party than Johnson did over his.
Not forgetting that Labour's economic policy in 2019, although not perfect, was better than the Conservatives.
Worst thing Corbyn did in 2019 was giving in to the likes of Starmer in the party and backing a second vote on Brexit. To this day his worst move as leader.
It wasn’t a second vote per se, it was a confirmatory vote on the deal that would be on the table. Having seen what we have ended up with where no one got what they wanted it seems like a sensible policy.
It was a second vote in an election that was almost solely based around a desire to see a conclusion to Brexit.
"Get Brexit done" certainly got the turkeys voting for Christmas without any concern for anything else.
(08-05-2022, 07:39 AM)Protheroe Wrote: It was exactly the kind of "confirmatory vote" that reversed the initial decisions in Ireland (Lisbon) and Denmark (Maastricht).
We all know what "confirmatory votes" are about.
Spot on. Will always agree with you on the impact the arch-remainers had in ensuring we ended up with our current govt.
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(08-05-2022, 07:31 AM)Fido Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-05-2022, 06:36 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-04-2022, 04:12 PM)Squid Wrote: Anyone paying attention could see that Russia was going to become an ever bigger problem and Corbyn's response to the Salisbury poisonings made it clear that he was not suitable to lead UK foreign policy.
But the man who gave Lebedev a peerage was.
The reason why Corbyn with all his faults was still a better bet than Johnson in 2019, was that Corbyn had less control over his parliamentary party than Johnson did over his.
Not forgetting that Labour's economic policy in 2019, although not perfect, was better than the Conservatives.
Worst thing Corbyn did in 2019 was giving in to the likes of Starmer in the party and backing a second vote on Brexit. To this day his worst move as leader.
It wasn’t a second vote per se, it was a confirmatory vote on the deal that would be on the table. Having seen what we have ended up with where no one got what they wanted it seems like a sensible policy.
I don't agree, B1.
If the EU knew there was going to be such a vote then they would have played hardball right up to the last minute to effectively beholden the UK to a deal that was completely in their favour, giving us a few crumbs. It would have made no sense whatsoever from a negotiation standpoint. As I've said before Brexit was our opportunity to stop being pulled further into federalism. Yes, the current government and previous have made a royal hash of it but there wasn't the opportunity to say "Yes, I'll vote leave if I can get to choose who actually administers the exit policy".
There isn’t a good Brexit that’s the fallacy of this argument you and others are now trying to cling to. As much as I think this government are appalling it’s just another excuse to argue if it was done better it would be a success. At best it can be slightly worse than what we had but better? Please, just chasing unicorns again.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Ok, so having had the ability to get the deal where the EU weren’t holding our feet to the fire, which is a good point Fido, do we think that the deal we have would be voted for?
It was always a protest vote that people didn’t think would happen, probably very similar to voting for Corbyn in many cases. In this case it did happen and the problems outweigh the ‘benefits’ clearly.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(08-05-2022, 08:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Ok, so having had the ability to get the deal where the EU weren’t holding our feet to the fire, which is a good point Fido, do we think that the deal we have would be voted for?
It was always a protest vote that people didn’t think would happen, probably very similar to voting for Corbyn in many cases. In this case it did happen and the problems outweigh the ‘benefits’ clearly.
The scenario I would have envisaged is
1) the EU play brinkmanship and then say this is our last offer.
2) We then get a choice between that and staying in the union
3) Politicians will come out with the same guff of why the deal is good for the UK
4) People either vote for it, which inevitably means being tied to the EU in many areas that we may wish to avoid and possibly being drawn further into stuff we may not want.
5) OR they vote against and the cycle starts all over with people and businesses not knowing what the fugg is going to happen and more time and money is wasted
So regardless of whether you are for/against I think the idea for a vote on the deal would have been a bad one.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
On brexit you have to understand that Labour were in a very tricky situation.
The party was solidly remain, including it's voters, but a significant number of the seats it held had voted for brexit and the leader was known to be sympathetic to the brexit position.
With the benefit of hindsight, the plp should have been given a free vote on the May brexit agreement, with a recommendation for abstaining.
Abstention is never a good look, but in this case I think it would be acceptable, not defying the result of the referendum result, but not giving support to an agreement they disapproved of.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-05-2022, 10:22 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The party was solidly remain, including it's voters
That's simply not true. Metropolitan middle class Labour voters In Moseley and Kings Heath were overwhelmingly Remain, however solid working class Labour supporters in Dudley and Sandwell were not.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Most polling suggests that 70% of Labour voters, voted remain.
Hence the term solidly remain.
Clearly voters in cities were more likely to vote remain than voters in urban towns such as Dudley.
But even in places like Dudley there wasn't unanimous support for brexit, there were remain voters too, many of whom would also vote Labour.
And again we get thus stereotypical view that all city dwellers are metropolitan elites, who spend their days drinking expensive coffee and reading the Guardian. It denies the reality that cities have substantial working class populations.
|