Grant
#61
(07-21-2022, 11:50 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:37 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:33 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:17 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:05 AM)Dumbo Wrote: We don’t have a use for a goal scorer? We’d have been relegated without his contribution last season.

As a wide  player, we have better options.

Would we have played with 10 men, if he wasn't selected? If he could score penalties we would have been closer to the play-offs.

Reminds me a lot of David Mills. Not his fault he was signed for so much, but contributes very little.
If the "better" options are Phillips, Grady, Reach and Robinson, then none of them have ever scored anywhere near 18 goals in a season.

You can question Grant's all round ability and contribution in open play, many will agree, but his goalscoring and assist record last year cannot be questioned.

We now have better that were signed in the summer.

Bruce thinks he can turn Grant into a central striker, but that's not his game. 

He scored 15 goals from open play, which isn't enough for your top goalscorer. That said, nobody else came close to that.

I wouldn't put him in my starting 11. Others would. Fair enough.
Two different things though, criticising his performance last season and whether or not to play him this.

The former is beyond reproach as he was so much better than his peers, wherever he played.

If, however, the new signings are indeed an improvement, then he will need to earn his place same as everyone else. As good as they were though, neither Wallace nor Swift matched his goalscoring achievements last season, so it is far from a foregone conclusion. He's also ahead of Dike for goals scored pre-season.

I've said previously, in my opinion I don't think his play would have been good enough to command a starting position in any of the promoted teams. He scored his 15 open play goals from many chances created, and missed a fair few as well. He isn't one of the best Chump strikers, in fact last years crop were the worst we have had in living memory.

He finished joint 8th in the open play goals scoring table last year, which is a fair assessment of him. Last season he started 41 games. 

I think this analysis is a fair assessment of him and us last season https://eflanalysis.com/analysis/karlan-...s-analysis
Reply
#62
(07-21-2022, 11:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:43 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: He's a bit of a dilemma - scored 18 goals, missed quite a few, but doesn't have much of an all round game.

To play him means we'd have to set ourselves up in a 433 formation, with Swift at the front of a midfield 3 triangle and probably Dike and Wallace as central and wide right forwards.  Is that Swift's best position?

It means no Grady, but based solely on last year that's probably fair, however we all know the Grady we first signed on loan has a much better all round game than Grant. Grant might get 20 goals but Grady, if the link is like anything he had with Pereira  may bring out the best in the other 3 moreso.

They're Bruce's problems and it's good to have options.  We still need a Dike replica to alternate with  AND, IMO, a different type of forward, someone to play off the big man.  Grant has shown he can't do it.  We couldn't really go 442 as we don't have a 2nd forward to play that role.

I think he can play in a front 2. I just don't think he can be the man to link and hold the ball up. His movement off the ball in the channels is great, he gets shot off quickly, even if its on the half volley when bouncing awkwardly, a couple of his pre season goals have been from through balls and smart finishes. 

He's fine.

And yet he hadn't a clue how to play off Carroll last season (nor had Robinson either).  Neither had any anticipation of a flick on etc and it was something Bomber Brown consistently banged on about.  Neither, according to him, had the abilities required to play off someone in the "Big man/little man" style combo.

I know it sounds ridiculous but f Grant didn't score he'd contribute zero to the game, unlike say Robinson (attitude aside) he does have ability to take players on, to see passes etc.  If Grant had a deadly finish then his lack of other skills would be less important.  Many a forward made a career out of "just" scoring goals.  Not many around in the modern game and Grant isn't deadly enough to qualify.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#63
(07-21-2022, 12:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:43 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: He's a bit of a dilemma - scored 18 goals, missed quite a few, but doesn't have much of an all round game.

To play him means we'd have to set ourselves up in a 433 formation, with Swift at the front of a midfield 3 triangle and probably Dike and Wallace as central and wide right forwards.  Is that Swift's best position?

It means no Grady, but based solely on last year that's probably fair, however we all know the Grady we first signed on loan has a much better all round game than Grant. Grant might get 20 goals but Grady, if the link is like anything he had with Pereira  may bring out the best in the other 3 moreso.

They're Bruce's problems and it's good to have options.  We still need a Dike replica to alternate with  AND, IMO, a different type of forward, someone to play off the big man.  Grant has shown he can't do it.  We couldn't really go 442 as we don't have a 2nd forward to play that role.

I think he can play in a front 2. I just don't think he can be the man to link and hold the ball up. His movement off the ball in the channels is great, he gets shot off quickly, even if its on the half volley when bouncing awkwardly, a couple of his pre season goals have been from through balls and smart finishes. 

He's fine.

And yet he hadn't a clue how to play off Carroll last season (nor had Robinson either).  Neither had any anticipation of a flick on etc and it was something Bomber Brown consistently banged on about.  Neither, according to him, had the abilities required to play off someone in the "Big man/little man" style combo.

I know it sounds ridiculous but f Grant didn't score he'd contribute zero to the game, unlike say Robinson (attitude aside) he does have ability to take players on, to see passes etc.  If Grant had a deadly finish then his lack of other skills would be less important.  Many a forward made a career out of "just" scoring goals.  Not many around in the modern game and Grant isn't deadly enough to qualify.
We've had many a forward who made a career out of "NOT" scoring goals. I know which I'd prefer.
Reply
#64
(07-21-2022, 09:17 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 08:43 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(07-20-2022, 07:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-20-2022, 06:23 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(07-20-2022, 10:08 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: But we seem to want creative wide forwards, delivering to goal scoring centre forwards. He is neither (not his fault). Square peg in a round hole.

If Grant's a square peg in a round hole I don't know what some of the others are. 

It could be argued we played to his strengths last season and he scored 18, had 6 assists and missed two pens.  How many wide forwards get anywhere near that,  only Wiemann surprisingly last season, with 22.

Not forgetting we were utterly shite last season and he still scored 18!
The others are shite. What we have with Grant is a player that doesn't suit our style of play.

Our style of play being?

His stats indicate otherwise.

I don't need stats, I have a pair of eyes. His overall game isn't good enough.

How come he is so highly rated and respected by his team-mates?  He must be doing something right.  

Compare his season with Diangana who we paid almost as much for.  Or anyone last season for that matter.  Should have got player of the season.

(07-20-2022, 08:20 PM)MrFizz Wrote: I just wish people would leave the guy alone. He's far from technically gifted and is a bit of a hybrid player in that he's not a no9, but neither is he intelligent enough to be a creator. However the guy has won me over. He never gives less than 100%, he has an eye for goal and can finish. He got 18 goals last season in an under-performing mid-table team that didn't create much. It's not his fault we massively overpaid for him, or played him in positions he doesn't like in systems that don't suit. I don't know what system we will employ this season, but i reckon if he plays the majority of games, with Swift and Wallace creating chances, KG will get 20+ goals for us.

This. 

Jeez he didn't exactly have brilliant service last season.  

Look at two of the goals he has scored in pre-season - two brilliant assists from Diang and Swift but he was on to them in a flash.  He's deceptively quick.  

If he stays fit will be another 15-20 season, maybe 20 plus.  If Dike does the same and Swift and Wallace wade in we're in business.
Reply
#65
It's clear he obviously divides opinion.
Reply
#66
(07-21-2022, 12:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:43 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: He's a bit of a dilemma - scored 18 goals, missed quite a few, but doesn't have much of an all round game.

To play him means we'd have to set ourselves up in a 433 formation, with Swift at the front of a midfield 3 triangle and probably Dike and Wallace as central and wide right forwards.  Is that Swift's best position?

It means no Grady, but based solely on last year that's probably fair, however we all know the Grady we first signed on loan has a much better all round game than Grant. Grant might get 20 goals but Grady, if the link is like anything he had with Pereira  may bring out the best in the other 3 moreso.

They're Bruce's problems and it's good to have options.  We still need a Dike replica to alternate with  AND, IMO, a different type of forward, someone to play off the big man.  Grant has shown he can't do it.  We couldn't really go 442 as we don't have a 2nd forward to play that role.

I think he can play in a front 2. I just don't think he can be the man to link and hold the ball up. His movement off the ball in the channels is great, he gets shot off quickly, even if its on the half volley when bouncing awkwardly, a couple of his pre season goals have been from through balls and smart finishes. 

He's fine.

And yet he hadn't a clue how to play off Carroll last season (nor had Robinson either).  Neither had any anticipation of a flick on etc and it was something Bomber Brown consistently banged on about.  Neither, according to him, had the abilities required to play off someone in the "Big man/little man" style combo.

I know it sounds ridiculous but f Grant didn't score he'd contribute zero to the game, unlike say Robinson (attitude aside) he does have ability to take players on, to see passes etc.  If Grant had a deadly finish then his lack of other skills would be less important.  Many a forward made a career out of "just" scoring goals.  Not many around in the modern game and Grant isn't deadly enough to qualify.

Last year was a shit show from December onwards. We had no style of play, and a squad limited by poor transfer business last summer, punctuated by awful injury problems (O'Shea, Dike etc). I try not to go off last year too much.

I do, contrary to some others, see a player who grafts, makes the correct runs regularly, and puts the ball in the net when I don't expect it to go in. I rarely saw him as the issue last year, but due to the insane price tag people want him to be a world beater. Like Livermore, he is a perfectly capable squad member who should start some games and sit out others, when we have more options.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#67
(07-21-2022, 01:06 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 12:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 11:43 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: He's a bit of a dilemma - scored 18 goals, missed quite a few, but doesn't have much of an all round game.

To play him means we'd have to set ourselves up in a 433 formation, with Swift at the front of a midfield 3 triangle and probably Dike and Wallace as central and wide right forwards.  Is that Swift's best position?

It means no Grady, but based solely on last year that's probably fair, however we all know the Grady we first signed on loan has a much better all round game than Grant. Grant might get 20 goals but Grady, if the link is like anything he had with Pereira  may bring out the best in the other 3 moreso.

They're Bruce's problems and it's good to have options.  We still need a Dike replica to alternate with  AND, IMO, a different type of forward, someone to play off the big man.  Grant has shown he can't do it.  We couldn't really go 442 as we don't have a 2nd forward to play that role.

I think he can play in a front 2. I just don't think he can be the man to link and hold the ball up. His movement off the ball in the channels is great, he gets shot off quickly, even if its on the half volley when bouncing awkwardly, a couple of his pre season goals have been from through balls and smart finishes. 

He's fine.

And yet he hadn't a clue how to play off Carroll last season (nor had Robinson either).  Neither had any anticipation of a flick on etc and it was something Bomber Brown consistently banged on about.  Neither, according to him, had the abilities required to play off someone in the "Big man/little man" style combo.

I know it sounds ridiculous but f Grant didn't score he'd contribute zero to the game, unlike say Robinson (attitude aside) he does have ability to take players on, to see passes etc.  If Grant had a deadly finish then his lack of other skills would be less important.  Many a forward made a career out of "just" scoring goals.  Not many around in the modern game and Grant isn't deadly enough to qualify.

Last year was a shit show from December onwards. We had no style of play, and a squad limited by poor transfer business last summer, punctuated by awful injury problems (O'Shea, Dike etc). I try not to go off last year too much.

I do, contrary to some others, see a player who grafts, makes the correct runs regularly, and puts the ball in the net when I don't expect it to go in. I rarely saw him as the issue last year, but due to the insane price tag people want him to be a world beater. Like Livermore, he is a perfectly capable squad member who should start some games and sit out others, when we have more options.

That is part of the problem. Everyone (including me) has said it's not his fault he was sold for so much, but it would be interesting to see how much anyone else offered for him. 

His goals alone give him value, but I don't see a striker that anyone would necessarily want.  What I mean by this is that anyone with a parachute payment would want better, and the rest of the division would struggle to meet a realistic fee of (say) £7.5M, and the wages.

And don't forget we bought him on HP, so we probably owe Hudds more than he is realistically worth!
Reply
#68
Part of the reason his price was inflated is due to us buying him on the never never. We arent going to be picking up the bargains like he did when we had decent scouts.
Reply
#69
(07-21-2022, 01:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's clear he obviously divides opinion.

No he doesn't. Tongue
Reply
#70
(07-21-2022, 01:45 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 01:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It's clear he obviously divides opinion.

No he doesn't. Tongue

Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: