How do we, and when do we (political)
#51
(06-07-2022, 12:09 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: So essentially, this has bugger all to do with the sovereign will of the people. 

And that attitude, is exactly why you ended up with Johnson. Own it.

Parliament cannot ask the people a binary question, receive an answer and then say - no, you're wrong, without reaping the consequences. If anyone finds this a controversial concept then clearly you'd be happier living in a totalitarian state. Or the Irish Republic. Or Denmark.

(06-07-2022, 12:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fuck me, read the post FFS. PARLIAMENTARIANS egged on by the likes of BB and his loony pal Steve Bray.

Erm how far do you want to go back on this? The Conservatives only put the referendum to the people to appease their right wing faction of the party. They did this because their seats were being put under threat by UKIP. You campaigned presumably for Cameron and co, you campaigned for Brexit and presumably you didn’t support May’s deal which was blocked numerous times by the likes of Mogg and and Baker who were integral parts of the vote leave ERG group that you campaigned for led in all but name by Johnson. 

To push the blame onto those who said it wasn’t a good idea and many if not all the promises made were impossible to achieve doesn’t stand up to argument.

Johnson was never even a member of the ERG, let alone it's Leader in name or otherwise. 

An overwhelmingly Remain Parliament passed the Brexit Referendum Act into law. Arch Remainer Philip Hammond even moved the enabling bill FFS. 

554 MPs voted for the 2nd Reading of the Referendum bill. Only the Scottish Nationalists voted against it.

Is there any other aspect of history you wish me to correct you on?
Reply
#52
If only, around summer 2017 there was an alternative to the Tories who wasn't threatening to throw Brexit in the bin.
Reply
#53
(06-07-2022, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fuck me, read the post FFS. PARLIAMENTARIANS egged on by the likes of BB and his loony pal Steve Bray.

Aye, because the fact that I was pissed off about Stephen Lloyd having the whip removed, voted against every internal Lib Dem measure that didn't support single market membership, voted for Ed Davey in the 2019 leadership election as he was open to pursuing single market membership when I asked him at the Stratford hustings, cancelled my membership over Jo Swinson's unilateral cancellation and opted to vote for the Monster Raving Loony Party in 2019 primarily because of the Brexit position.

I think you're mixing up my opposition to leaving without a deal and leaving the single market, which certainly fit in with what the late and great Paddy Ashdown was on about with what was best for the country. I would also like to note that as he was alive at the time of the referendum he agreed with me.

You voted for Johnson as leader and you campaigned for his party despite knowing he was unfit to be Prime Minister, don't blame me or anyone else for trusting a serial liar and unaccountable populist. You made your bed, willingly, now lie in it.
Reply
#54
(06-07-2022, 12:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 12:09 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: So essentially, this has bugger all to do with the sovereign will of the people. 

And that attitude, is exactly why you ended up with Johnson. Own it.

Parliament cannot ask the people a binary question, receive an answer and then say - no, you're wrong, without reaping the consequences. If anyone finds this a controversial concept then clearly you'd be happier living in a totalitarian state. Or the Irish Republic. Or Denmark.

Or France, or Germany, or Singapore or Switzerland....all very fine examples of totalitarian states, I'm sure...

Even for the most myopic, leaving was never a binary issue. As I said, the whole concept was flawed. They already thought they knew the outcome, so they wouldn't have to execute it. What I resent is a government manoeuvring a crisis under the pretext of democracy when in reality they had abdicated their democratic responsibility for the sake of internal party squabbling.

If they had really done it for democracy's sake, they would have let us vote on the reality, rather than different strains of bullshit. It would have been more obvious to negotiate it and then when the agreement was done and put it to the people. (Whenever that might be). They chose not to do that and we all know why - the conservative party had a coup, the lies became clear and 'the sovereignty of the people' was no longer needed.

But - even if you thought that Brexit has been great, surely it would have made sense to vote on something real? Instead, everything went hyperbolic and caused even more division..

Of course, the ultimate irony of all this is that if I only wanted labour to win and didn't care about the country, I would be doing everything possible to keep BJ in power. He is the best chance of Labour winning not just the next election, but the one after that and the one after that. Which of course is the real reason why the conservatives want to get rid of him. Not because he is a proven liar. They already knew that before they voted him in.
Reply
#55
To be honest FB, with the policy programme BJ has run - we might as well all have voted for Chaos with Ed Miliband in 2015 anyway.
Reply
#56
Politics has just become a cock waving contest for both the politicians and the so called experts on social media.
It's now just about reinforcement of your prejudices, be they against those on benefits or those you perceive as wealthy etc.
Basically it's become so tribalistic there is no sensible debate to be had with the followers of any camp and political discussion is now more about showing off how clever you think you are.
The real way forward for humanity is not to be found in Tue voting for one tribe or another that you believe will serve your interest best (after all self interest, even those who want a "fairer society" do so because they believe it will somehow benefit them even if it leaves them personally financially worse off).
What we really need is a spiritual revolution where we truly see the reality of things, understand that everything in the universe is interconnected and that all politics is just an extension of ego.
Reply
#57
(06-07-2022, 12:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 12:09 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: So essentially, this has bugger all to do with the sovereign will of the people. 

And that attitude, is exactly why you ended up with Johnson. Own it.

Parliament cannot ask the people a binary question, receive an answer and then say - no, you're wrong, without reaping the consequences. If anyone finds this a controversial concept then clearly you'd be happier living in a totalitarian state. Or the Irish Republic. Or Denmark.

(06-07-2022, 12:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fuck me, read the post FFS. PARLIAMENTARIANS egged on by the likes of BB and his loony pal Steve Bray.

Erm how far do you want to go back on this? The Conservatives only put the referendum to the people to appease their right wing faction of the party. They did this because their seats were being put under threat by UKIP. You campaigned presumably for Cameron and co, you campaigned for Brexit and presumably you didn’t support May’s deal which was blocked numerous times by the likes of Mogg and and Baker who were integral parts of the vote leave ERG group that you campaigned for led in all but name by Johnson. 

To push the blame onto those who said it wasn’t a good idea and many if not all the promises made were impossible to achieve doesn’t stand up to argument.

Johnson was never even a member of the ERG, let alone it's Leader in name or otherwise. 

An overwhelmingly Remain Parliament passed the Brexit Referendum Act into law. Arch Remainer Philip Hammond even moved the enabling bill FFS. 

554 MPs voted for the 2nd Reading of the Referendum bill. Only the Scottish Nationalists voted against it.

Is there any other aspect of history you wish me to correct you on?

Ok in bullet points instead…
  • You campaigned for Cameron. 
  • Cameron appeased his right wing back benchers due to the threat of UKIP. 
  • You campaigned for subsequent Brexit. 
  • You didn’t support May’s deal and were more aligned to the ERG position. They blocked her deal and various amends to it. 
  • You campaigned for Johnson knowing full well what he was like. He was backed by those in the ERG as a man they could trust to ‘get Brexit done’. 

You can’t now say it’s everyone else’s fault that Johnson is who you knew he was, and that Brexit isn’t working out as you think it should have.
Reply
#58
Great innit. A fair and reasoned discussion about the state of politics in our country descends into mud-slinging and petty sniping as soon as anyone with political leanings gets involved.

As Ms Morisette once sang: Isn't it ironic.......
Reply
#59
(06-07-2022, 12:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: To be honest FB, with the policy programme BJ has run - we might as well all have voted for Chaos with Ed Miliband in 2015 anyway.

People were warned at the time and again in 2017 and again in 2019. Oh well.
Reply
#60
(06-07-2022, 01:02 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Great innit. A fair and reasoned discussion about the state of politics in our country descends into mud-slinging and petty sniping as soon as anyone with political leanings gets involved.

As Ms Morisette once sang: Isn't it ironic.......

She didn’t understand irony anyway.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: