How do we, and when do we (political)
#41
In my position as a Trade Union rep at the old Rover Cars factory, I met 3 MP`s at the time that BMW was trying to shut it down. Two were Labour, one a Lib Dem. All of them were an absolute shower. One, speaking to people who were faced with losing their jobs, tried making jokes about which curry they had on a Saturday, another, a minister at the Dept Of Trade & Industry in Blairs government,when asked why BMW could do to us, what would be illegal in Germany, responded with, `If you like Germany that much, go and live there`. The Lib Dem turned up at the gate,said he couldn`t stop, but if the T.V cameras came, be sure to mention him.
Incidentally, Carl Chinn, off Radio WM, mentioned in his phone in show that , given the scale of job losses, Tony Blair should come up and see for himself. Apparently, Blair heard about it, and got the Police to bug his phone, have him followed etc. Chinn was told this by a senior figure at the BBC in Birmingham, and warned to be careful what he said.
Reply
#42
According to Wikipedia:

"In 2000 Chinn was a leading figure in the temporarily successful, but eventually doomed, campaign to save the Longbridge car factory from closure. In 2001 he was awarded the MBE for services to local history and charity."

If this story is true, it seems strange that the very same Blair government gave Chinn an MBE one year later!!

Wikipedia also says Chinn's a villa supporter, so maybe he's prone to inflate his own importance!!
Reply
#43
(06-07-2022, 10:17 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: This is genuinely an enjoyable thread to read. Some good posts that haven't turned into petty insults. I don't agree with some, but at least they're respectful, and it's interesting to read other points of view.

What is clear, though, is if you're Tory (or at least lean towards them) you're blind to anything they've done wrong. The same applies if you're a Labour supporter, with the added caveat that you refuse to acknowledge the few things Tories have gotten right (As Tories would do if Labour were in power).

Brexit is/was/has been a cluster fuck. My point about politicians being selfish and in it for them selves applies wonderfully in relation to this. The country, rightly or wrongfully, voted for Brexit. Yet Parliament spent months/years arguing the toss over petty matters, bickering amongst themselves, trying to point score and further their own careers, rather than see through Brexit as smoothly as possible, while getting the best deals and exit for the country.

The same can be said for COVID. How often did we see and hear politicians fight amongst themselves, clamouring for change in leadership etc, when they should've put party allegiances to one side, and work together to protect the nation in the best possible way, and provide a long term exit out of lockdown plan. That never happened, and like Brexit, the coming in, and out, back in, out, various levels of restrictions was a complete cluster fuck.

Yes, Tories were in power then, but Labour and other parties MP's should've ensured rivalries and petty arguments were put to oneside. It was a farce.

For me, the vaccine rollout, the Furlough schemes and the swiftness we went into the first lockdown were matters the government have got right and should be priased for.

Isn't employment at a record high right now? That's incredible given what the country has been through. But you counter that by pointing at cost of living, the state of the NHS, the fuel pricing, and rising crime. The point I'm making, is those who are staunch Labour, I understand and agree with your criticism, that's fair, but shouldn't forget to acknowledge at least some positives.

Would Labour/Starmer have handled the last 4, or so, years any better? I'm not so sure. Would they have handled it worse? Again, I'm not sure. You can't say. Ultimately, I don't think it'd have been much different, as the majority of MP's aren't concerned about the general public, the above comments on the Brexit and COVID debates pretty much prove that.

The fact Boris lied about parties, Starmer then campaigned for him to resign (rightfully, but hypocritically!), then was accused himself of breaching lockdown rules, denied it, then was pictured having a party, is as laughable as it gets. These pair are both lying idiots, who should be no where near power, yet they're currently the two options the Nation has of running our country. What a state of affairs. 

As with anything, I guess you need balance. It's not black and white. Labour would do some things well, and some things not so well, if in power. Ditto with Conservatives, as I've already pointed out. 

How have other countries coped with the pandemic? Some better. Some much worse (America!). 

In all honesty I don't care who is in power, as ignorant as that is of me, I don't believe my life would be all much different whichever self absorbed member of Parliament has the thankless task of running the country. The NHS will still be overrun, crime will still happen, we'll go in and out of recession, and cost of living will rise, all while MP after MP is involved in some scandal or other (Let's be realistic,  the majority of MP's across all parties have no doubt breached some COVID restriction, or other), regardless of what party is in power. 

And you wonder why I'm disillusioned with it all!

Starmer wasn’t pictured having a party.
Reply
#44
(06-07-2022, 06:51 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 06:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The second part of your post is correct Dekka. A bit of self reflection on the part of those who fought tooth and nail to prevent any form of Brexit wouldn’t go amiss either. They’re just as much to blame for this as anyone who voted Tory in 2019.

Errr, no Proth.

Who did you vote for in the 2019 leadership election?

A wise man  - and BB you know exactly who I'm referring to - once said “I will forgive no one who does not accept the sovereign voice of the British people one it has spoken whether it’s by one percent or 20 percent. It’s our duty to serve the public and make sure our country does the best it can with the decision people have given us."

You all keep denying responsibility for creating the monster in No.10, but Johnson would be nowhere near power had Parliament (nb not "the government") worked together to deliver on the promise they ALL made to the electorate in June 2016. 

As it is, I like tens of thousands of other Tory members voted for Johnson as Tory Leader in total exasperation as Parliamentarians of all sides sought to break that promise and to frustrate the sovereign voice of the British people.

He is in large part the creation of you and people like you, whether you choose to acknowledge that truth or not.
Reply
#45
(06-07-2022, 12:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 06:51 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 06:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The second part of your post is correct Dekka. A bit of self reflection on the part of those who fought tooth and nail to prevent any form of Brexit wouldn’t go amiss either. They’re just as much to blame for this as anyone who voted Tory in 2019.

Errr, no Proth.

Who did you vote for in the 2019 leadership election?

A wise man  - and BB you know exactly who I'm referring to - once said “I will forgive no one who does not accept the sovereign voice of the British people one it has spoken whether it’s by one percent or 20 percent. It’s our duty to serve the public and make sure our country does the best it can with the decision people have given us."

You all keep denying responsibility for creating the monster in No.10, but Johnson would be nowhere near power had Parliament (nb not "the government") worked together to deliver on the promise they ALL made to the electorate in June 2016. 

As it is, I like tens of thousands of other Tory members voted for Johnson as Tory Leader in total exasperation as Parliamentarians of all sides sought to break that promise and to frustrate the sovereign voice of the British people.

He is in large part the creation of you and people like you, whether you choose to acknowledge that truth or not.

So it's the people's fault now?
Reply
#46
(06-07-2022, 12:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 06:51 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 06:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The second part of your post is correct Dekka. A bit of self reflection on the part of those who fought tooth and nail to prevent any form of Brexit wouldn’t go amiss either. They’re just as much to blame for this as anyone who voted Tory in 2019.

Errr, no Proth.

Who did you vote for in the 2019 leadership election?

A wise man  - and BB you know exactly who I'm referring to - once said “I will forgive no one who does not accept the sovereign voice of the British people one it has spoken whether it’s by one percent or 20 percent. It’s our duty to serve the public and make sure our country does the best it can with the decision people have given us."

You all keep denying responsibility for creating the monster in No.10, but Johnson would be nowhere near power had Parliament (nb not "the government") worked together to deliver on the promise they ALL made to the electorate in June 2016. 

As it is, I like tens of thousands of other Tory members voted for Johnson as Tory Leader in total exasperation as Parliamentarians of all sides sought to break that promise and to frustrate the sovereign voice of the British people.

He is in large part the creation of you and people like you, whether you choose to acknowledge that truth or not.

Wow. So, it's not the people who voted for him that were to blame For Boris Johnson - it was those who didn't...

We the 'sovereign' public, give the MP's the right to govern through elections. Yet, for some reason, they abdicated their responsibility and organised a referendum. Surely, you've got to wonder why? The conservatives made an electoral promise to offer a referendum. They didn't need to to do this, if they were so behind Brexit, they could have included 'Brexit' in their manifesto - but they didn't. The substantiated answer was that it was done for party reasons. Cameron believed we would vote to stay in Europe and by doing so it would stop the internal strife in his party. (Ironically from the same people that are now calling for unity!)

So essentially, this has bugger all to do with the sovereign will of the people. it was an internal conservative party matter. It was just a cynical attempt by Cameron and the conservative leadership to shore up their party power base. It went spectacularly wrong and now the country are paying.

Cue Farage, lies, NHS buses, Boris Johnson and in fairness, an arrogant and insulting 'remain' campaign.

That's the real beginning of all this. Both sides have plenty to learn from this disaster. Although I doubt we will...
Reply
#47
FAO Kratos . First, Starmer was not at a party, 2nd, the plod decided it wasn't worth investigating originally. They were forced into the investigation by tories trying to muddy the waters. (Which has succeeded). Third, Starmer has said he will resign should he penalised for it. It doesn't compare on any level.
Further (whoever mentioned Brexit). The referendum was a means thought up by Cameron to retain power. By agreeing to the referendum he stopped UKIP taking tory votes. Labour did not read that room and it cost them. When selecting candidates for the worst ever PM, Cameron is a very strong contender.
Reply
#48
Fuck me, read the post FFS. PARLIAMENTARIANS egged on by the likes of BB and his loony pal Steve Bray.
Reply
#49
(06-07-2022, 10:47 AM)Ossian Wrote:
(06-06-2022, 09:24 PM)MrFizz Wrote: The system needs changing. A general election should be in 2 parts. Part one vote for your local MP. Part two (within say 6 weeks) should be vote for Prime Minister, candidates put forward by the majority party in the commons.

I'd make both houses fully elected, and by PR, using a 4-year rotating cycle (a bit like the Euros and the World Cup).

Year 1: Commons, or whatever we want to call it
Year 2: Nowt
Year 3: Second chamber
Year 4: Nowt again
Year 5: Commons

No opportunity for the incumbent party to manipulate the timing of the election(s); rolling fixed terms. And I'd take a flame-thrower to the accommodation - particularly the seating arrangements in the commons chamber - and empower the speaker to dissuade the 'honourable' members from making farmyard noises. 
Agree, though devoicing the legitimate farmyard animals who have been elected parliament seems a tad harsh.
Reply
#50
(06-07-2022, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fuck me, read the post FFS. PARLIAMENTARIANS egged on by the likes of BB and his loony pal Steve Bray.

Erm how far do you want to go back on this? The Conservatives only put the referendum to the people to appease their right wing faction of the party. They did this because their seats were being put under threat by UKIP. You campaigned presumably for Cameron and co, you campaigned for Brexit and presumably you didn’t support May’s deal which was blocked numerous times by the likes of Mogg and and Baker who were integral parts of the vote leave ERG group that you campaigned for led in all but name by Johnson. 

To push the blame onto those who said it wasn’t a good idea and many if not all the promises made were impossible to achieve doesn’t stand up to argument.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: