Fuck Bruce off now
(04-05-2022, 06:47 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-05-2022, 06:38 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(04-05-2022, 06:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:
WorcsWBA Wrote:Taking us from 5th to 12th is "kept us performing mid-table" is it? Good job Brucie! Please remind me what his remit was when he arrived at the club? I must have missed the bit where it was stated that this season was a write-off so we need to focus on next season.

Also, how is pointing out the fact that Bruce has done worse in his first 10 games than the (according to some) hapless and clueless Ismael did in his last 10 games a "weird and wonderful statistical story"?

Fans were booing the side when we were unbeaten during the first 10 games and top of the table, so we can be in no doubt that if Ismael had been in charge of a local derby defeat in which we had no shots on target and generally didn't have a clue, there would have been raucous booing and loud renditions of "you're getting sacked in the morning". Bruce, on the other hand, continues to get a free pass for some reason.
Thanks for illustrating what I said about weird statistics.

We didn't finish the season 5th with Val did we? We were going backwards at a massive rate of knots. 5th having completely lost the plot was just the point he was taken out having played like a team destined for relegation the way we were going on. After we'd lost to Stoke for the rest of him time here we were playing like a team averaging finishing 18th or 19th.

I've supported Albion 47 years and it was clear he was toast to all but a tiny tiny minority of fans, of which you are one. It's a weird fixation some have.

It was a surprise he got the Millwall game in most fans eyes- it was the most obvious sacking you could wish for.

He might have turned things around, but Christ alive there was nothing to say that- everything we'd seen for the previous 3 months indicated no - failing form, losing the players and losing the fans. The board made the decision and no one was surprised. The general consensus was he had been found out by other managers. Anyhow, this is Groundhog Day.

We are in a state at the minute, and Bruce started off very poorly, with Val's partly assembled squad, but we lost our first game in 5 and let's hope there is a semblance of a plan and if like many say the players are the fault I'd rather a bloke with experience sort it out. Let's see the next 7 games out and take it from there. Those in the club at a senior level will size it up whether he's up for it.
I don't know the answer but it surprises me Ishmael gets stick for the players having a tantrum after Johnston stormed off after being rightly put on the bench (for one game only) after his indiscipline. Yes, Preston was terrible but it was the players that didn't show. They did the same again against Blues. That, for me was the lowest point of the season. Blues are so bad the fans that I know only left the pub for the game because of the Baz tribute. I am not around the training ground to see what our lot practise but I have absolutely no idea what our plan is. I don't know if Bruce is any good or not, I do know the players aren't.

It was another stick to beat Val with. Under any other manager (except Allardyce and maybe Pardew), the players would have been blamed 100% for downing tools. A fan favourite manager like Mowbray or Bilic would have been praised for sticking to his guns.

No, what a ridiculous post.

They become a fan's favourite by doing well. Ishmael was doing bad. Many turned on Bilic when things started going wrong. Allardyce didn't have fans in the ground, started abysmally, and he only improved stuff after he had a transfer window to get players in.

Most people wanted Ishmael to succeed but after Stoke we had 3 months of things getting progressively worse.

Very few wanted a stick to beat Val with, but get all dewy-eyed with your selective nostalgia.

There were - and still are - plenty of people looking for sticks to beat Val with but that isn't even my issue here. My issue is that certain managers are criticised for making decisions that other managers are praised for. Whether you choose to believe that this happens is up to you but I've seen it plenty of times from our fans and from other clubs too.
Reply
(04-05-2022, 07:34 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(04-05-2022, 06:47 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-05-2022, 06:38 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(04-05-2022, 06:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Spandaubaggie Wrote:Thanks for illustrating what I said about weird statistics.

We didn't finish the season 5th with Val did we? We were going backwards at a massive rate of knots. 5th having completely lost the plot was just the point he was taken out having played like a team destined for relegation the way we were going on. After we'd lost to Stoke for the rest of him time here we were playing like a team averaging finishing 18th or 19th.

I've supported Albion 47 years and it was clear he was toast to all but a tiny tiny minority of fans, of which you are one. It's a weird fixation some have.

It was a surprise he got the Millwall game in most fans eyes- it was the most obvious sacking you could wish for.

He might have turned things around, but Christ alive there was nothing to say that- everything we'd seen for the previous 3 months indicated no - failing form, losing the players and losing the fans. The board made the decision and no one was surprised. The general consensus was he had been found out by other managers. Anyhow, this is Groundhog Day.

We are in a state at the minute, and Bruce started off very poorly, with Val's partly assembled squad, but we lost our first game in 5 and let's hope there is a semblance of a plan and if like many say the players are the fault I'd rather a bloke with experience sort it out. Let's see the next 7 games out and take it from there. Those in the club at a senior level will size it up whether he's up for it.
I don't know the answer but it surprises me Ishmael gets stick for the players having a tantrum after Johnston stormed off after being rightly put on the bench (for one game only) after his indiscipline. Yes, Preston was terrible but it was the players that didn't show. They did the same again against Blues. That, for me was the lowest point of the season. Blues are so bad the fans that I know only left the pub for the game because of the Baz tribute. I am not around the training ground to see what our lot practise but I have absolutely no idea what our plan is. I don't know if Bruce is any good or not, I do know the players aren't.

It was another stick to beat Val with. Under any other manager (except Allardyce and maybe Pardew), the players would have been blamed 100% for downing tools. A fan favourite manager like Mowbray or Bilic would have been praised for sticking to his guns.

No, what a ridiculous post.

They become a fan's favourite by doing well. Ishmael was doing bad. Many turned on Bilic when things started going wrong. Allardyce didn't have fans in the ground, started abysmally, and he only improved stuff after he had a transfer window to get players in.

Most people wanted Ishmael to succeed but after Stoke we had 3 months of things getting progressively worse.

Very few wanted a stick to beat Val with, but get all dewy-eyed with your selective nostalgia.

There were - and still are - plenty of people looking for sticks to beat Val with but that isn't even my issue here. My issue is that certain managers are criticised for making decisions that other managers are praised for. Whether you choose to believe that this happens is up to you but I've seen it plenty of times from our fans and from other clubs too.

All clubs have fans with different opinions. I heard people berating players when we were doing well under Hodgson and Clarke.

Simply though a broad brush comment on how our fan base were about certain managers is not absolute gospel as some try to make out.

Regardless of that though, to try to get rid of Bruce when he's been here for a few games having taken over a team in complete meltdown is utter lunacy.

Bruce may be a spent force etc, but for Christ's sake give him some time to prove otherwise. Bruce's poor start is less relevant than Ishmael's excellent start. At least Ishmael has had an input into the actual players at the club.

Personally, call it strange, but I trust a manager with 20 years experience and a CV full of promotions more than a bloke who got Barnsley to the play-offs once, and had us performing as a bottom 6 club for all but his first 10 games.
Reply
I’m with you Spandau I’m sick and tired of all the changes we must give Bruce a chance.
Reply
He inherited a team 5th and spoke about automatic promotion, we’re likely to finish outside the top 12

I’ve no issue with Bruce and he’s clearly trying but if you deliver such results in any job you are most likely to lose it

Very dangerous game for Gourmet to keep his mate on IMO

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
Big Sam had this lots number from ten minutes into his first game and bombed a good number of them out without blinking because they were either feckless, not good enough or both.

The biggest crime is that those he bombed out just started this season like nothing happened and got their shirts straight back, then there’s the fact we somehow managed to compound it by adding another little crew of averageness into the squad.

Like a turd that won’t flush. Highly paid and long term contracted turds. In some cases turds we decided to put on the mantelpiece with a view to flushing them away in another year or so.
Reply
(04-06-2022, 05:13 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Big Sam had this lots number from ten minutes into his first game and bombed a good number of them out without blinking because they were either feckless, not good enough or both.

The biggest crime is that those he bombed out just started this season like nothing happened and got their shirts straight back, then there’s the fact we somehow managed to compound it by adding another little crew of averageness into the squad.

Like a turd that won’t flush. Highly paid and long term contracted turds. In some cases turds we decided to put on the mantelpiece with a view to flushing them away in another year or so.

Well that sums things up.
Reply
(04-06-2022, 06:24 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2022, 05:13 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Big Sam had this lots number from ten minutes into his first game and bombed a good number of them out without blinking because they were either feckless, not good enough or both.

The biggest crime is that those he bombed out just started this season like nothing happened and got their shirts straight back, then there’s the fact we somehow managed to compound it by adding another little crew of averageness into the squad.

Like a turd that won’t flush. Highly paid and long term contracted turds. In some cases turds we decided to put on the mantelpiece with a view to flushing them away in another year or so.

Well that sums things up.

Indeed it does, I've missed him.      Big Grin
Reply
(04-06-2022, 01:01 AM)Cuzer Wrote: He inherited a team 5th and spoke about automatic promotion, we’re likely to finish outside the top 12

I’ve no issue with Bruce and he’s clearly trying but if you deliver such results in any job you are most likely to lose it

Very dangerous game for Gourmet to keep his mate on IMO

Cuzer

yeah true that. I said Bruce wasn't the right appointment, certainly not for 18 months. He's got a decent cv but generally with teams with strong squads. And his failure at vile was maybe a sign of where he is now. His style has been overtaken by better footballing sides. He just doesn't play a style that fans will stomach long term. Short term results may keep some happy but it's turgid stuff to watch. And after Ismael it was obvious you needed a ball playing style of manager. Imo you are passing the ball more but all in the wrong areas and are actually creating less chances.
Reply
(04-05-2022, 06:38 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: It was another stick to beat Val with. Under any other manager (except Allardyce and maybe Pardew), the players would have been blamed 100% for downing tools. A fan favourite manager like Mowbray or Bilic would have been praised for sticking to his guns.

I'm old enough to remember when the narrative was "all we need is a new manager to get the best out of this very good championship squad".

Then we got worse it's "ah yeah well the old manager sucked the confidence out of the players"

Now it's transformed into "OK maybe the players aren't good enough but the old manager had two transfer windows to fix it" Big Grin

Straw clutching AOTS
Reply
(04-06-2022, 01:01 AM)Cuzer Wrote: He inherited a team 5th and spoke about automatic promotion, we’re likely to finish outside the top 12

I’ve no issue with Bruce and he’s clearly trying but if you deliver such results in any job you are most likely to lose it

Very dangerous game for Gourmet to keep his mate on IMO

Cuzer

This, we were 5th blah, blah, blah narrative by some is really pissing me off as it's in no context whatsoever to what was actually going on. It's spoken like someone who doesn't support the club and heard we'd sacked the manager and said: "Why have they done that?."

We were 5th in a huge slide, having previously been cemented firmly in the top 3 for most of the season. We'd played with the form of a team likely to finish 17-18th for 3 months(19 games), after the 10 game unbeaten start.

There were teams with games in hand too and the bunch to mid table were on our shoulders. So we weren't strolling into the play-offs at least in the cosy fairytale in your Hans Christian Anderson world.

Sorry Cuzer, but your comment is like Gourlay is engaged in some kind of nepotism in a spring factory on Rabone Lane- it's way off and shows you trying to rubbish Gourlay already! 

I'm sure Bruce isn't 'his mate'. They may get on professionally, but Bruce is a bloke with a 20 year CV of managing in the top 2 divisions and 4 different clubs promoted.

I'm no fan of Bruce's but the lunacy of trying to blame him for a poor squad and not being able to get us in the play-offs is moronic black and white opinions for the hard of thinking.

He may succeed, he may fail, but he hasn't been given a chance at all at this juncture.

I was underwhelmed by his appointment, but he should see how the season pans out and then take it from there.

The level of instability you are calling for is the stuff which sees big clubs in League 1, and akin to the blueprint of the mad Italian who was running Leeds for a while.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 5 Guest(s)