Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-05-2022, 04:36 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Let’s look at the evidence. We have gone for experienced managers previously and we can all see what happened there. This will not work the club needs an entire reset but in all honesty we know this is not going to happen whilst these lot are in charge. I’m sorry to say Albion as a club are fucked for the forceable future
We have got promoted to the Prem and finished comfortably in the Prem under a number of experienced managers.
Posts: 1,637
Threads: 52
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
11
(04-05-2022, 04:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-05-2022, 04:36 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Let’s look at the evidence. We have gone for experienced managers previously and we can all see what happened there. This will not work the club needs an entire reset but in all honesty we know this is not going to happen whilst these lot are in charge. I’m sorry to say Albion as a club are fucked for the forceable future
We have got promoted to the Prem and finished comfortably in the Prem under a number of experienced managers.
Tell you what mate I ll come back next season when it’s all gone tits up with Bruce
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-05-2022, 05:19 PM)johntoewba Wrote: (04-05-2022, 04:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-05-2022, 04:36 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Let’s look at the evidence. We have gone for experienced managers previously and we can all see what happened there. This will not work the club needs an entire reset but in all honesty we know this is not going to happen whilst these lot are in charge. I’m sorry to say Albion as a club are fucked for the forceable future
We have got promoted to the Prem and finished comfortably in the Prem under a number of experienced managers.
Tell you what mate I ll come back next season when it’s all gone tits up with Bruce
Ok and I will still point out our success with experienced managers as that won’t change.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
04-05-2022, 06:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-05-2022, 06:13 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(04-05-2022, 05:19 PM)johntoewba Wrote: (04-05-2022, 04:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-05-2022, 04:36 PM)johntoewba Wrote: Let’s look at the evidence. We have gone for experienced managers previously and we can all see what happened there. This will not work the club needs an entire reset but in all honesty we know this is not going to happen whilst these lot are in charge. I’m sorry to say Albion as a club are fucked for the forceable future
We have got promoted to the Prem and finished comfortably in the Prem under a number of experienced managers.
Tell you what mate I ll come back next season when it’s all gone tits up with Bruce
Yes, because it's great the amount of little soothsayers who say: 'I told you so.'
They go remarkably quiet when they are proven wrong, but like the Radio WM phone in and social media there's heaps of them at bad times and looking forward to the day they are proven right for the sake of their fragile egos.
I see lots of them on the times I dare click on the Albion Facebook feed- they are generally very ugly!
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
The irony is that the argument from some of Vals supporters was that he needed time to build something here yet the same people want Bruce out after 10 games without any chance of bringing his own players in.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Spandaubaggie Wrote:WorcsWBA Wrote:Spandaubaggie Wrote:Huge difference -if you asked fans after the Preston game was it time for Val to go they would have said yes, it was overwhelming. We'd been sliding for months, getting worse. We were going backwards. He had overseen a summer and recruitment.
Bruce has kept us performing mid table thus far, with the duff players he inherited.
He's underwhelming so far, but he has a pedigree.
Fans screaming for Bruce's head are making all kinds of weird and wonderful statistical stories to back up their impatience, but anyone half reasonable knows he has to be given a chance to rebuild.
Taking us from 5th to 12th is "kept us performing mid-table" is it? Good job Brucie! Please remind me what his remit was when he arrived at the club? I must have missed the bit where it was stated that this season was a write-off so we need to focus on next season.
Also, how is pointing out the fact that Bruce has done worse in his first 10 games than the (according to some) hapless and clueless Ismael did in his last 10 games a "weird and wonderful statistical story"?
Fans were booing the side when we were unbeaten during the first 10 games and top of the table, so we can be in no doubt that if Ismael had been in charge of a local derby defeat in which we had no shots on target and generally didn't have a clue, there would have been raucous booing and loud renditions of "you're getting sacked in the morning". Bruce, on the other hand, continues to get a free pass for some reason. Thanks for illustrating what I said about weird statistics.
We didn't finish the season 5th with Val did we? We were going backwards at a massive rate of knots. 5th having completely lost the plot was just the point he was taken out having played like a team destined for relegation the way we were going on. After we'd lost to Stoke for the rest of him time here we were playing like a team averaging finishing 18th or 19th.
I've supported Albion 47 years and it was clear he was toast to all but a tiny tiny minority of fans, of which you are one. It's a weird fixation some have.
It was a surprise he got the Millwall game in most fans eyes- it was the most obvious sacking you could wish for.
He might have turned things around, but Christ alive there was nothing to say that- everything we'd seen for the previous 3 months indicated no - failing form, losing the players and losing the fans. The board made the decision and no one was surprised. The general consensus was he had been found out by other managers. Anyhow, this is Groundhog Day.
We are in a state at the minute, and Bruce started off very poorly, with Val's partly assembled squad, but we lost our first game in 5 and let's hope there is a semblance of a plan and if like many say the players are the fault I'd rather a bloke with experience sort it out. Let's see the next 7 games out and take it from there. Those in the club at a senior level will size it up whether he's up for it. I don't know the answer but it surprises me Ishmael gets stick for the players having a tantrum after Johnston stormed off after being rightly put on the bench (for one game only) after his indiscipline. Yes, Preston was terrible but it was the players that didn't show. They did the same again against Blues. That, for me was the lowest point of the season. Blues are so bad the fans that I know only left the pub for the game because of the Baz tribute. I am not around the training ground to see what our lot practise but I have absolutely no idea what our plan is. I don't know if Bruce is any good or not, I do know the players aren't.
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
(04-05-2022, 06:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandaubaggie Wrote:WorcsWBA Wrote:Spandaubaggie Wrote:Huge difference -if you asked fans after the Preston game was it time for Val to go they would have said yes, it was overwhelming. We'd been sliding for months, getting worse. We were going backwards. He had overseen a summer and recruitment.
Bruce has kept us performing mid table thus far, with the duff players he inherited.
He's underwhelming so far, but he has a pedigree.
Fans screaming for Bruce's head are making all kinds of weird and wonderful statistical stories to back up their impatience, but anyone half reasonable knows he has to be given a chance to rebuild.
Taking us from 5th to 12th is "kept us performing mid-table" is it? Good job Brucie! Please remind me what his remit was when he arrived at the club? I must have missed the bit where it was stated that this season was a write-off so we need to focus on next season.
Also, how is pointing out the fact that Bruce has done worse in his first 10 games than the (according to some) hapless and clueless Ismael did in his last 10 games a "weird and wonderful statistical story"?
Fans were booing the side when we were unbeaten during the first 10 games and top of the table, so we can be in no doubt that if Ismael had been in charge of a local derby defeat in which we had no shots on target and generally didn't have a clue, there would have been raucous booing and loud renditions of "you're getting sacked in the morning". Bruce, on the other hand, continues to get a free pass for some reason. Thanks for illustrating what I said about weird statistics.
We didn't finish the season 5th with Val did we? We were going backwards at a massive rate of knots. 5th having completely lost the plot was just the point he was taken out having played like a team destined for relegation the way we were going on. After we'd lost to Stoke for the rest of him time here we were playing like a team averaging finishing 18th or 19th.
I've supported Albion 47 years and it was clear he was toast to all but a tiny tiny minority of fans, of which you are one. It's a weird fixation some have.
It was a surprise he got the Millwall game in most fans eyes- it was the most obvious sacking you could wish for.
He might have turned things around, but Christ alive there was nothing to say that- everything we'd seen for the previous 3 months indicated no - failing form, losing the players and losing the fans. The board made the decision and no one was surprised. The general consensus was he had been found out by other managers. Anyhow, this is Groundhog Day.
We are in a state at the minute, and Bruce started off very poorly, with Val's partly assembled squad, but we lost our first game in 5 and let's hope there is a semblance of a plan and if like many say the players are the fault I'd rather a bloke with experience sort it out. Let's see the next 7 games out and take it from there. Those in the club at a senior level will size it up whether he's up for it. I don't know the answer but it surprises me Ishmael gets stick for the players having a tantrum after Johnston stormed off after being rightly put on the bench (for one game only) after his indiscipline. Yes, Preston was terrible but it was the players that didn't show. They did the same again against Blues. That, for me was the lowest point of the season. Blues are so bad the fans that I know only left the pub for the game because of the Baz tribute. I am not around the training ground to see what our lot practise but I have absolutely no idea what our plan is. I don't know if Bruce is any good or not, I do know the players aren't.
It was another stick to beat Val with. Under any other manager (except Allardyce and maybe Pardew), the players would have been blamed 100% for downing tools. A fan favourite manager like Mowbray or Bilic would have been praised for sticking to his guns.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-05-2022, 06:38 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (04-05-2022, 06:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandaubaggie Wrote:WorcsWBA Wrote:Spandaubaggie Wrote:Huge difference -if you asked fans after the Preston game was it time for Val to go they would have said yes, it was overwhelming. We'd been sliding for months, getting worse. We were going backwards. He had overseen a summer and recruitment.
Bruce has kept us performing mid table thus far, with the duff players he inherited.
He's underwhelming so far, but he has a pedigree.
Fans screaming for Bruce's head are making all kinds of weird and wonderful statistical stories to back up their impatience, but anyone half reasonable knows he has to be given a chance to rebuild.
Taking us from 5th to 12th is "kept us performing mid-table" is it? Good job Brucie! Please remind me what his remit was when he arrived at the club? I must have missed the bit where it was stated that this season was a write-off so we need to focus on next season.
Also, how is pointing out the fact that Bruce has done worse in his first 10 games than the (according to some) hapless and clueless Ismael did in his last 10 games a "weird and wonderful statistical story"?
Fans were booing the side when we were unbeaten during the first 10 games and top of the table, so we can be in no doubt that if Ismael had been in charge of a local derby defeat in which we had no shots on target and generally didn't have a clue, there would have been raucous booing and loud renditions of "you're getting sacked in the morning". Bruce, on the other hand, continues to get a free pass for some reason. Thanks for illustrating what I said about weird statistics.
We didn't finish the season 5th with Val did we? We were going backwards at a massive rate of knots. 5th having completely lost the plot was just the point he was taken out having played like a team destined for relegation the way we were going on. After we'd lost to Stoke for the rest of him time here we were playing like a team averaging finishing 18th or 19th.
I've supported Albion 47 years and it was clear he was toast to all but a tiny tiny minority of fans, of which you are one. It's a weird fixation some have.
It was a surprise he got the Millwall game in most fans eyes- it was the most obvious sacking you could wish for.
He might have turned things around, but Christ alive there was nothing to say that- everything we'd seen for the previous 3 months indicated no - failing form, losing the players and losing the fans. The board made the decision and no one was surprised. The general consensus was he had been found out by other managers. Anyhow, this is Groundhog Day.
We are in a state at the minute, and Bruce started off very poorly, with Val's partly assembled squad, but we lost our first game in 5 and let's hope there is a semblance of a plan and if like many say the players are the fault I'd rather a bloke with experience sort it out. Let's see the next 7 games out and take it from there. Those in the club at a senior level will size it up whether he's up for it. I don't know the answer but it surprises me Ishmael gets stick for the players having a tantrum after Johnston stormed off after being rightly put on the bench (for one game only) after his indiscipline. Yes, Preston was terrible but it was the players that didn't show. They did the same again against Blues. That, for me was the lowest point of the season. Blues are so bad the fans that I know only left the pub for the game because of the Baz tribute. I am not around the training ground to see what our lot practise but I have absolutely no idea what our plan is. I don't know if Bruce is any good or not, I do know the players aren't.
It was another stick to beat Val with. Under any other manager (except Allardyce and maybe Pardew), the players would have been blamed 100% for downing tools. A fan favourite manager like Mowbray or Bilic would have been praised for sticking to his guns.
No, what a ridiculous post.
They become a fan's favourite by doing well. Ishmael was doing bad. Many turned on Bilic when things started going wrong. Allardyce didn't have fans in the ground, started abysmally, and he only improved stuff after he had a transfer window to get players in.
Most people wanted Ishmael to succeed but after Stoke we had 3 months of things getting progressively worse.
Very few wanted a stick to beat Val with, but get all dewy-eyed with your selective nostalgia.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
The thing is, Spandau, without re-printing all the above. The board (whoever the fuck they are!), backed Val by getting in Dike, then Carroll. Where were they when the players started to rebel? They needed to come out and say that the manager won't be going anywhere and let him bomb some of the lily livered shirkers. Ishmael was not the choice they should have made if they weren't going to back him. His much derided 3 transfer window quote has now become clear-he needed to ship out some deadwood. The appointment of Bruce appeared to have put the ship in steady hands except all it really has done is give us deja vue from Allardyce having to loan a spine for the team. I'm happy to give Bruce a chance but those in charge need to keep a keen eye on whether he can handle the players that can't be bothered for more than one game in eight.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
Unless there is a drastic uptick in form, I cannot see Bruce being here next season. If he loses more than he draws (not even wins, draws) in the remaining matches, that surely is him done for.
I was neutral about Bruce and very willing to give him a chance. But the results and performances don't lie. I agree that the problem is on the pitch, but he surely should be getting more out of them.
|