My final word on Val's tenure
#31
Does Baggii still have his ilk?
Reply
#32
(03-02-2022, 11:42 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Does Baggii still have his ilk?

Don't mention that fuckwit anywhere near me! He was the twat who tried to get me the sack by emailing my boss! grrrrr! Big Grin
Reply
#33
(03-02-2022, 09:05 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(03-02-2022, 08:30 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/foo...op-battle/

Masi definitely must read this board, most of that article's pretty much what's been discussed on here for yonks.   Big Grin

Good article, but there's a bit of revisionism. "Multiple sources" reveal that several players had "their confidence shattered" during Allardyce's time. And we can "work out who those players were".

I'd say what was shattered was their previous confidence that they could do what they wanted, not what the manager told them to do. I think it's a big stretch to suggest that Sam was to blame for their continuing spinelessness.
Reply
#34
Good piece by Masi and hard to disagree with any of it.
Reply
#35
(03-01-2022, 11:15 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Some have told me to let go on this topic and I've honestly been trying to, but I keep seeing sweeping generalisations like "he was the worst manager in 20/30 years", "teams sussed us out after the first 10 games", "we couldn't create anything" and so on. All those subjective assertions can reasonably be challenged. Although this has been a lot of effort for me, I'm sure no-one is going to change their mind on the basis of this post, but doing it will get it off my chest, so Tongue 

Let's look at Val's final 10 games with us, by which time a lot of people regularly claim the wheels had come off. They had to a degree in terms of results, but the  underlying stats tell a different story. I wish you could do HTML tables on this forum, but it seems you can't, so the data I've compiled can't be presented very well sadly. Anyway, first we have the data headings and then the values for Val's final 10 games (sources - WhoScored and Infogol):

Game                       Shots For  Shots Against   xG For   xG Against   Actual Points   Expected Points
Albion 0 Forest 0            16                9              1.18         0.57               1                         1
Coventry 1 Albion 2       10              12              1.53         0.88               3                         3
Albion 1 Reading 0         25                4              3.11         0.55               3                         3
Barnsley 0 Albion 0         16                3              1.75         0.09               1                         3
Derby 1 Albion 0            19                3              1.16         0.2                 0                         3
Albion 1 Cardiff 1            13                6              0.99         0.21               1                         3
QPR 1 Albion 0               12                9              0.95         1.26               0                         1
Albion 3 Peterboro' 0      27                1              3.91         0.08               3                         3
Albion 0 Preston 2            8              10              0.33         1.79               0                         0
Millwall 2 Albion 0               7               9               0.39         1.9                 0                         0
                                     Avg           Avg               Avg          Avg            Total                    Total
                                     15.3           6.6              1.53         0.75              12                        20

The data is hopefully self-evident, but just to note that we averaged twice as many goal attempts against and the average xG for was twice the average xG against. Remember that the equivalent stats from earlier in the season would look even better than these. Apart from our failure to score from enough of our attempts, there wasn't really anything wrong until those final 2 games. I believe the fans' negativity plus the Johnstone toys out of the pram episode had got to the players by then.

It's clearly apparent that the wheels only actually fell off in the last 2 games, but the fans had already turned toxic before that - people will no doubt recall the mass booing and negative chanting during the Peterborough game before we scored, despite the flow of the game actually being a procession towards the Peterbrough goal throughout.

Now, let's move on to Steve Bruce's first 5 games:

Game                       Shots For  Shots Against   xG For   xG Against   Actual Points   Expected Points
Sheff U 2 Albion 0            12             13              0.73         1.44                0                         0
Albion 0 Blackburn 0        13             10              1.46         0.69                1                         3
Luton 2 Albion 0              16               6              1.69         0.71                0                         3
Middlesbrough 2 Albion 1   8               8              0.58         1.39                0                         0
Albion 0 Swansea 2          12             15              0.77         1.2                  0                         1
                                     Avg           Avg               Avg          Avg            Total                    Total
                                     12.2           10.4            1.05          1.09                1                        7

What's clear here is that Bruce's stats are worse in every single respect compared to those for Val's last 10 games.

In brief conclusion, I feel that the fans turning on Val so soon, when they knew the club was trying to implement a long-term project for once, was largely unjustified and unfair. Much more patience was needed and warranted than was shown. The players also eventually downing tools (which they've yet to pick up again) was an utter disgrace.

As the new manager Bruce also deserves some patience, but the worse stats and just 1 point in 5 games, combined with a refusal to change obvious personnel failings in the side plus making a previously solid defence look shaky and become leaky, mean that he really needs to try something different immediately if he is to deserve some respect going forward.

I'll be steering well clear of responding to the Val-bashing comments from now on. Thank you to anyone who made some effort to consider the stats! Smile
Couldn't be bothered to read the post to be honest but I'm intrigued why you detest Pulis yet appear to adore Ismael? I can understand why people don't like Pulis' style but, frankly, it worked for a good time and Ismael's was equally dull yet didn't after the first month. Very strange.
Reply
#36
(03-02-2022, 09:27 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We're all frustrated with the different things at the club it just seems Val is the bloke who was stuck in the middle of it all.

A lot was said in the summer about us needing to bounce back at the first attempt to enable Lai to sell us, or to even just keep us competitive financially. Lai would have known this, in which case he should have offered Allardyce whatever he wanted to stay. Instead we vetoed the Wilder appointment and went 'long-term' appointing Val off the back of some great work at Barnsley. Seemed fair enough at the time. I didn't mind the idea of a 'rebuild', for a number of years since our best PL side started to fall apart it felt as though we had been flying by the seat of our pants, held together by loan players who eventually we couldn't replace and once a decade talents like Pereira. It was all a bit house of cards. I think many of us welcomed the chance to reset and build something a bit more sustainable, afterall it's the only way to try and compete against the sides who have amassed such great wealth.

This is where my frustration around the Val situation comes from, he was six months into a four year job. Once we went down the route of a four year deal and a brief of turning the team over and looking to the future we should have been more accepting that it would not all be smooth sailing (admittedly towards the end it was BAD), we shit ourselves at the first sign of trouble. To see the club rip up any semblance of a plan after six months and Gourmet throw the job to his old pal is so depressing. All it has succeeded in doing is push us a year closer to the end of parachute payments whilst needing to do exactly the same job summer 2022 as we tried to do in summer 2021. We'd have been better off finishing 12th under a manager who's had a year to suss out the players, than finishing 12th under a bloke who's looking for a last pay day who's not won a match in around half a seasons worth of games.

The only positive from this is that I would hope the dismal results of the last few weeks mean that Bruce isn't here past the end of the season (I'd hope he isn't here that long) and we are forced into looking more long-term due to our financial situation in the summer and the finances of the relegated clubs - not that I think there is too much to be scared of in Norwich, Watford, Burnley or Brentford. I want to see Gourlay start walking the walk, some investment in a scouting network (Swansea picked up Flynn Downes for £1.5m in the summer and he was head and shoulders above anything we had in midfield Monday night), bring some youngsters through but the onus is on the fans to be patient. I'd love to see us pick up another young manager who has cut his teeth further down the pyramid. Liam Manning should MK Dons not get promoted would be an excellent candidate.

Instead I'm worried that we simply go through the motions under Bruce, Gourlay will run through his phone book of old pals and we end up wasting whatever parachute advantage we did have. The appointment of Val I saw as a decent opportunity to rid ourselves of some of the old guard, those who've needed moving on for years and develop a new style - the style bit is open for debate. I appreciate this is a bit of a wild rant, so to finish on Val. Was he right for us? No. Will he have success elsewhere? I would bet on it. Was the thought process behind his appointment the right one? Yes, he's exactly the type of manager I'd like to see us give some time and resource to in the summer. I just hope we do a bit more research into the way they like to play the game.

It's shit at the moment but the better times will come again, there's plenty of worse things going on in the world. Up the Albion.
Agree with everything you said Ted but even I wobbled towards the end of Val’s reign.Those at the top once giving a four year contract needed to stay strong and look at things at the end of the season.Don’t forget they are now being criticised for chopping and changing the manager too much,heaven forbid they now stick with the incompetent Bruce.
Reply
#37
Val played much higher up the pitch.

With the right players and training, it's very different from Pulis's apart from the use of direct passes to the attack.

We had neither the right players nor could training make them into the right players. It was a poor appointment in the circumstances we were in even if I actually like his tactical style.

Not sure Bruce is a good appointment either.
Reply
#38
(03-02-2022, 01:08 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Good piece by Masi and hard to disagree with any of it.
Agreed. I like the inclusion about Ian Pearce; this guy oversees recruitment yet it has been disastrous and he remains in the role.
Reply
#39
Yep, Ian Pearce is not looking like a good man in that role, and his silence hardly helps him.
Reply
#40
(03-02-2022, 01:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Val played much higher up the pitch.

With the right players and training, it's very different from Pulis's apart from the use of direct passes to the attack.

We had neither the right players nor could training make them into the right players. It was a poor appointment in the circumstances we were in even if I actually like his tactical style.

Not sure Bruce is a good appointment either.
It was the sort of appointment made by people with no knowledge of football....

The style is, admittedly, nothing like Pulis' but there are certain similarities in terms of it not being easy on the eye as it isn't expansive, there needs to be far less technical ability and, when sussed, it led to a total boredom fest. It also prioritises results over flair and style.

You, like I, prioritize results and not the aesthetics but I'm intrigued why someone so critical of Pulis would detest one and not the other.

(03-02-2022, 01:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Yep, Ian Pearce is not looking like a good man in that role, and his silence hardly helps him.
The fact is that Ismael and Bruce are not the key reasons for our decline. Decisions behind the scenes have led to our fate whether that be misguided contract extensions, dire new signings, sales or recruitment of coaching staff.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)