03-01-2022, 11:15 PM
Some have told me to let go on this topic and I've honestly been trying to, but I keep seeing sweeping generalisations like "he was the worst manager in 20/30 years", "teams sussed us out after the first 10 games", "we couldn't create anything" and so on. All those subjective assertions can reasonably be challenged. Although this has been a lot of effort for me, I'm sure no-one is going to change their mind on the basis of this post, but doing it will get it off my chest, so
Let's look at Val's final 10 games with us, by which time a lot of people regularly claim the wheels had come off. They had to a degree in terms of results, but the underlying stats tell a different story. I wish you could do HTML tables on this forum, but it seems you can't, so the data I've compiled can't be presented very well sadly. Anyway, first we have the data headings and then the values for Val's final 10 games (sources - WhoScored and Infogol):
Game Shots For Shots Against xG For xG Against Actual Points Expected Points
Albion 0 Forest 0 16 9 1.18 0.57 1 1
Coventry 1 Albion 2 10 12 1.53 0.88 3 3
Albion 1 Reading 0 25 4 3.11 0.55 3 3
Barnsley 0 Albion 0 16 3 1.75 0.09 1 3
Derby 1 Albion 0 19 3 1.16 0.2 0 3
Albion 1 Cardiff 1 13 6 0.99 0.21 1 3
QPR 1 Albion 0 12 9 0.95 1.26 0 1
Albion 3 Peterboro' 0 27 1 3.91 0.08 3 3
Albion 0 Preston 2 8 10 0.33 1.79 0 0
Millwall 2 Albion 0 7 9 0.39 1.9 0 0
Avg Avg Avg Avg Total Total
15.3 6.6 1.53 0.75 12 20
The data is hopefully self-evident, but just to note that we averaged twice as many goal attempts against and the average xG for was twice the average xG against. Remember that the equivalent stats from earlier in the season would look even better than these. Apart from our failure to score from enough of our attempts, there wasn't really anything wrong until those final 2 games. I believe the fans' negativity plus the Johnstone toys out of the pram episode had got to the players by then.
It's clearly apparent that the wheels only actually fell off in the last 2 games, but the fans had already turned toxic before that - people will no doubt recall the mass booing and negative chanting during the Peterborough game before we scored, despite the flow of the game actually being a procession towards the Peterbrough goal throughout.
Now, let's move on to Steve Bruce's first 5 games:
Game Shots For Shots Against xG For xG Against Actual Points Expected Points
Sheff U 2 Albion 0 12 13 0.73 1.44 0 0
Albion 0 Blackburn 0 13 10 1.46 0.69 1 3
Luton 2 Albion 0 16 6 1.69 0.71 0 3
Middlesbrough 2 Albion 1 8 8 0.58 1.39 0 0
Albion 0 Swansea 2 12 15 0.77 1.2 0 1
Avg Avg Avg Avg Total Total
12.2 10.4 1.05 1.09 1 7
What's clear here is that Bruce's stats are worse in every single respect compared to those for Val's last 10 games.
In brief conclusion, I feel that the fans turning on Val so soon, when they knew the club was trying to implement a long-term project for once, was largely unjustified and unfair. Much more patience was needed and warranted than was shown. The players also eventually downing tools (which they've yet to pick up again) was an utter disgrace.
As the new manager Bruce also deserves some patience, but the worse stats and just 1 point in 5 games, combined with a refusal to change obvious personnel failings in the side plus making a previously solid defence look shaky and become leaky, mean that he really needs to try something different immediately if he is to deserve some respect going forward.
I'll be steering well clear of responding to the Val-bashing comments from now on. Thank you to anyone who made some effort to consider the stats!
Let's look at Val's final 10 games with us, by which time a lot of people regularly claim the wheels had come off. They had to a degree in terms of results, but the underlying stats tell a different story. I wish you could do HTML tables on this forum, but it seems you can't, so the data I've compiled can't be presented very well sadly. Anyway, first we have the data headings and then the values for Val's final 10 games (sources - WhoScored and Infogol):
Game Shots For Shots Against xG For xG Against Actual Points Expected Points
Albion 0 Forest 0 16 9 1.18 0.57 1 1
Coventry 1 Albion 2 10 12 1.53 0.88 3 3
Albion 1 Reading 0 25 4 3.11 0.55 3 3
Barnsley 0 Albion 0 16 3 1.75 0.09 1 3
Derby 1 Albion 0 19 3 1.16 0.2 0 3
Albion 1 Cardiff 1 13 6 0.99 0.21 1 3
QPR 1 Albion 0 12 9 0.95 1.26 0 1
Albion 3 Peterboro' 0 27 1 3.91 0.08 3 3
Albion 0 Preston 2 8 10 0.33 1.79 0 0
Millwall 2 Albion 0 7 9 0.39 1.9 0 0
Avg Avg Avg Avg Total Total
15.3 6.6 1.53 0.75 12 20
The data is hopefully self-evident, but just to note that we averaged twice as many goal attempts against and the average xG for was twice the average xG against. Remember that the equivalent stats from earlier in the season would look even better than these. Apart from our failure to score from enough of our attempts, there wasn't really anything wrong until those final 2 games. I believe the fans' negativity plus the Johnstone toys out of the pram episode had got to the players by then.
It's clearly apparent that the wheels only actually fell off in the last 2 games, but the fans had already turned toxic before that - people will no doubt recall the mass booing and negative chanting during the Peterborough game before we scored, despite the flow of the game actually being a procession towards the Peterbrough goal throughout.
Now, let's move on to Steve Bruce's first 5 games:
Game Shots For Shots Against xG For xG Against Actual Points Expected Points
Sheff U 2 Albion 0 12 13 0.73 1.44 0 0
Albion 0 Blackburn 0 13 10 1.46 0.69 1 3
Luton 2 Albion 0 16 6 1.69 0.71 0 3
Middlesbrough 2 Albion 1 8 8 0.58 1.39 0 0
Albion 0 Swansea 2 12 15 0.77 1.2 0 1
Avg Avg Avg Avg Total Total
12.2 10.4 1.05 1.09 1 7
What's clear here is that Bruce's stats are worse in every single respect compared to those for Val's last 10 games.
In brief conclusion, I feel that the fans turning on Val so soon, when they knew the club was trying to implement a long-term project for once, was largely unjustified and unfair. Much more patience was needed and warranted than was shown. The players also eventually downing tools (which they've yet to pick up again) was an utter disgrace.
As the new manager Bruce also deserves some patience, but the worse stats and just 1 point in 5 games, combined with a refusal to change obvious personnel failings in the side plus making a previously solid defence look shaky and become leaky, mean that he really needs to try something different immediately if he is to deserve some respect going forward.
I'll be steering well clear of responding to the Val-bashing comments from now on. Thank you to anyone who made some effort to consider the stats!


