Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(03-03-2019, 12:53 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:50 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 11:41 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Surprised this hasn't been widely reported in the press. Maybe there's nothing to see here? There isn't, or more to the point no-one posting on here really knows what is going on despite the pretence that they do.
Does Dr Tony post on here then?
arf
Posts: 406
Threads: 7
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(03-03-2019, 12:55 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:53 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:50 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 11:41 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Surprised this hasn't been widely reported in the press. Maybe there's nothing to see here? There isn't, or more to the point no-one posting on here really knows what is going on despite the pretence that they do.
Does Dr Tony post on here then?
arf
arf +1
No one has a clue though....
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
So they're still in business then?
My interest ends here, for now.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(03-03-2019, 12:59 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:55 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:53 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:50 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 11:41 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Surprised this hasn't been widely reported in the press. Maybe there's nothing to see here? There isn't, or more to the point no-one posting on here really knows what is going on despite the pretence that they do.
Does Dr Tony post on here then?
arf
arf +1
No one has a clue though....
it's difficult to analyse a set of abbreviated accounts, but I can assure you that 35 years of experience has taught me how to analyse accounts to a fair standard. These are historic accounts, of course, and we don't know how much of a loss they are trading at now. The wage bill disclosed by Recon will give people like Swiss Ramble the ability to project forward where they really are. His summaries are very rarely wrong. Stripping the P&L back into a cashflow is the key to unlocking what is going on. This is what P&S rules do, with the "addbacks".
What is difficult to understand is what the EFL are going to do about it - if anything at all.
Posts: 406
Threads: 7
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(03-03-2019, 09:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:59 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:55 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:53 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:50 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: There isn't, or more to the point no-one posting on here really knows what is going on despite the pretence that they do.
Does Dr Tony post on here then?
arf
arf +1
No one has a clue though....
it's difficult to analyse a set of abbreviated accounts, but I can assure you that 35 years of experience has taught me how to analyse accounts to a fair standard. These are historic accounts, of course, and we don't know how much of a loss they are trading at now. The wage bill disclosed by Recon will give people like Swiss Ramble the ability to project forward where they really are. His summaries are very rarely wrong. Stripping the P&L back into a cashflow is the key to unlocking what is going on. This is what P&S rules do, with the "addbacks".
What is difficult to understand is what the EFL are going to do about it - if anything at all.
This and this alone is my point. Do not doubt for one minute there are lots of posters on here, yourself included, who are a million more times adept at understanding accounts, in any format, than I am.
The EFL and their decision making process are completely unknown.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-03-2019, 09:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:59 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:55 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:53 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:50 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: There isn't, or more to the point no-one posting on here really knows what is going on despite the pretence that they do.
Does Dr Tony post on here then?
arf
arf +1
No one has a clue though....
it's difficult to analyse a set of abbreviated accounts, but I can assure you that 35 years of experience has taught me how to analyse accounts to a fair standard. These are historic accounts, of course, and we don't know how much of a loss they are trading at now. The wage bill disclosed by Recon will give people like Swiss Ramble the ability to project forward where they really are. His summaries are very rarely wrong. Stripping the P&L back into a cashflow is the key to unlocking what is going on. This is what P&S rules do, with the "addbacks".
What is difficult to understand is what the EFL are going to do about it - if anything at all.
If Villa get away without huge sanctions it will be a travesty, as it would establish the principle that a change of ownership wiped the overspending slate clean.
My hunch is that when the Recon accounts are published, the adjusted losses for 2017/8 will be in region of £70m-£80m. Villa also have to provide the EFL during March with their forecast figures for 2018/9. With no parachute payment income I suspect their projected losses for 2018/9 could well be around £10m higher, so £80m-£90m. They are of course allowed a total of £39m FFP losses from 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9 combined.
What worries me is that they were apparently 2 hours from liquidation (not administration but actual liquidation) last summer. The EFL will not have wanted one of its oldest members to die, and it is quite feasible that nobody would have bought them with massive FFP sanctions hanging over them. This may well be why Purslow has been so confident. He may well have negotiated a deal whereby any sanctions for prior overspending would be ignored, with a new reset button. But whether that reset button started from last summer or from summer 2019 would be crucial. Even 2018/9 was the first year to count, then a loss this season of £80m-£90m would mean that they would have to make profits of £41m-£51m in 2019/20 and 2020/21, which is simply not possible, so they may have that kicked the can down the street and gambled on quickly going up.
I think they are still in massive FFP trouble even though their future existence is secured, but the timing of FFP sanctions is the key.
It provides the EFL with a huge headache of how to deal with Birmingham, especially after QPR got fined effectively £42m. I’m not sure how they could penalise Birmingham without penalising Villa. Any deal struck with Purslow may really have put the cat amongst the pigeons.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(03-03-2019, 10:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-03-2019, 09:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:59 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:55 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:53 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Does Dr Tony post on here then?
arf
arf +1
No one has a clue though....
it's difficult to analyse a set of abbreviated accounts, but I can assure you that 35 years of experience has taught me how to analyse accounts to a fair standard. These are historic accounts, of course, and we don't know how much of a loss they are trading at now. The wage bill disclosed by Recon will give people like Swiss Ramble the ability to project forward where they really are. His summaries are very rarely wrong. Stripping the P&L back into a cashflow is the key to unlocking what is going on. This is what P&S rules do, with the "addbacks".
What is difficult to understand is what the EFL are going to do about it - if anything at all.
If Villa get away without huge sanctions it will be a travesty, as it would establish the principle that a change of ownership wiped the overspending slate clean.
My hunch is that when the Recon accounts are published, the adjusted losses for 2017/8 will be in region of £70m-£80m. Villa also have to provide the EFL during March with their forecast figures for 2018/9. With no parachute payment income I suspect their projected losses for 2018/9 could well be around £10m higher, so £80m-£90m. They are of course allowed a total of £39m FFP losses from 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9 combined.
What worries me is that they were apparently 2 hours from liquidation (not administration but actual liquidation) last summer. The EFL will not have wanted one of its oldest members to die, and it is quite feasible that nobody would have bought them with massive FFP sanctions hanging over them. This may well be why Purslow has been so confident. He may well have negotiated a deal whereby any sanctions for prior overspending would be ignored, with a new reset button. But whether that reset button started from last summer or from summer 2019 would be crucial. Even 2018/9 was the first year to count, then a loss this season of £80m-£90m would mean that they would have to make profits of £41m-£51m in 2019/20 and 2020/21, which is simply not possible, so they may have that kicked the can down the street and gambled on quickly going up.
I think they are still in massive FFP trouble even though their future existence is secured, but the timing of FFP sanctions is the key.
It provides the EFL with a huge headache of how to deal with Birmingham, especially after QPR got fined effectively £42m. I’m not sure how they could penalise Birmingham without penalising Villa. Any deal struck with Purslow may really have put the cat amongst the pigeons.
I agree, Pragmatist, i think they just squeaked under the FFP figures this time last year, but with the impact of reduced income this year, and the last 2 years spending, it is almost impossible to see how they haven't failed this time, or indeed how they won't fail with this March's forward assessment.
I suspect as you suggest, that some sort of deal has been done. The EFL does not announce FFP sanctions, so it would be down to Villa to announce. Given the reaction to Wolves last year though, i can see how the members would accept Villa escaping with no censure for effectively sticking two fingers up to the rules - even if the reality is that they would not have wanted Villa Liquidated (although we would have enjoyed it).
Anything they may have done will set dangerous precedents, and lead to more clubs taking reckless gambles, which is exactly what FFP is designed to prevent. The next few weeks could be interesting.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-04-2019, 07:35 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 10:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-03-2019, 09:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:59 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:55 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: arf
arf +1
No one has a clue though....
it's difficult to analyse a set of abbreviated accounts, but I can assure you that 35 years of experience has taught me how to analyse accounts to a fair standard. These are historic accounts, of course, and we don't know how much of a loss they are trading at now. The wage bill disclosed by Recon will give people like Swiss Ramble the ability to project forward where they really are. His summaries are very rarely wrong. Stripping the P&L back into a cashflow is the key to unlocking what is going on. This is what P&S rules do, with the "addbacks".
What is difficult to understand is what the EFL are going to do about it - if anything at all.
If Villa get away without huge sanctions it will be a travesty, as it would establish the principle that a change of ownership wiped the overspending slate clean.
My hunch is that when the Recon accounts are published, the adjusted losses for 2017/8 will be in region of £70m-£80m. Villa also have to provide the EFL during March with their forecast figures for 2018/9. With no parachute payment income I suspect their projected losses for 2018/9 could well be around £10m higher, so £80m-£90m. They are of course allowed a total of £39m FFP losses from 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9 combined.
What worries me is that they were apparently 2 hours from liquidation (not administration but actual liquidation) last summer. The EFL will not have wanted one of its oldest members to die, and it is quite feasible that nobody would have bought them with massive FFP sanctions hanging over them. This may well be why Purslow has been so confident. He may well have negotiated a deal whereby any sanctions for prior overspending would be ignored, with a new reset button. But whether that reset button started from last summer or from summer 2019 would be crucial. Even 2018/9 was the first year to count, then a loss this season of £80m-£90m would mean that they would have to make profits of £41m-£51m in 2019/20 and 2020/21, which is simply not possible, so they may have that kicked the can down the street and gambled on quickly going up.
I think they are still in massive FFP trouble even though their future existence is secured, but the timing of FFP sanctions is the key.
It provides the EFL with a huge headache of how to deal with Birmingham, especially after QPR got fined effectively £42m. I’m not sure how they could penalise Birmingham without penalising Villa. Any deal struck with Purslow may really have put the cat amongst the pigeons.
I agree, Pragmatist, i think they just squeaked under the FFP figures this time last year, but with the impact of reduced income this year, and the last 2 years spending, it is almost impossible to see how they haven't failed this time, or indeed how they won't fail with this March's forward assessment.
I suspect as you suggest, that some sort of deal has been done. The EFL does not announce FFP sanctions, so it would be down to Villa to announce. Given the reaction to Wolves last year though, i can see how the members would accept Villa escaping with no censure for effectively sticking two fingers up to the rules - even if the reality is that they would not have wanted Villa Liquidated (although we would have enjoyed it).
Anything they may have done will set dangerous precedents, and lead to more clubs taking reckless gambles, which is exactly what FFP is designed to prevent. The next few weeks could be interesting.
If they don’t issue sanctions then FFP has to be scrapped. If either applies and gets enforced or it had to go. QPR will want their £42m back, plus damages.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(03-04-2019, 08:19 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-04-2019, 07:35 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 10:14 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (03-03-2019, 09:34 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (03-03-2019, 12:59 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: arf +1
No one has a clue though....
it's difficult to analyse a set of abbreviated accounts, but I can assure you that 35 years of experience has taught me how to analyse accounts to a fair standard. These are historic accounts, of course, and we don't know how much of a loss they are trading at now. The wage bill disclosed by Recon will give people like Swiss Ramble the ability to project forward where they really are. His summaries are very rarely wrong. Stripping the P&L back into a cashflow is the key to unlocking what is going on. This is what P&S rules do, with the "addbacks".
What is difficult to understand is what the EFL are going to do about it - if anything at all.
If Villa get away without huge sanctions it will be a travesty, as it would establish the principle that a change of ownership wiped the overspending slate clean.
My hunch is that when the Recon accounts are published, the adjusted losses for 2017/8 will be in region of £70m-£80m. Villa also have to provide the EFL during March with their forecast figures for 2018/9. With no parachute payment income I suspect their projected losses for 2018/9 could well be around £10m higher, so £80m-£90m. They are of course allowed a total of £39m FFP losses from 2016/7, 2017/8 and 2018/9 combined.
What worries me is that they were apparently 2 hours from liquidation (not administration but actual liquidation) last summer. The EFL will not have wanted one of its oldest members to die, and it is quite feasible that nobody would have bought them with massive FFP sanctions hanging over them. This may well be why Purslow has been so confident. He may well have negotiated a deal whereby any sanctions for prior overspending would be ignored, with a new reset button. But whether that reset button started from last summer or from summer 2019 would be crucial. Even 2018/9 was the first year to count, then a loss this season of £80m-£90m would mean that they would have to make profits of £41m-£51m in 2019/20 and 2020/21, which is simply not possible, so they may have that kicked the can down the street and gambled on quickly going up.
I think they are still in massive FFP trouble even though their future existence is secured, but the timing of FFP sanctions is the key.
It provides the EFL with a huge headache of how to deal with Birmingham, especially after QPR got fined effectively £42m. I’m not sure how they could penalise Birmingham without penalising Villa. Any deal struck with Purslow may really have put the cat amongst the pigeons.
I agree, Pragmatist, i think they just squeaked under the FFP figures this time last year, but with the impact of reduced income this year, and the last 2 years spending, it is almost impossible to see how they haven't failed this time, or indeed how they won't fail with this March's forward assessment.
I suspect as you suggest, that some sort of deal has been done. The EFL does not announce FFP sanctions, so it would be down to Villa to announce. Given the reaction to Wolves last year though, i can see how the members would accept Villa escaping with no censure for effectively sticking two fingers up to the rules - even if the reality is that they would not have wanted Villa Liquidated (although we would have enjoyed it).
Anything they may have done will set dangerous precedents, and lead to more clubs taking reckless gambles, which is exactly what FFP is designed to prevent. The next few weeks could be interesting.
If they don’t issue sanctions then FFP has to be scrapped. If either applies and gets enforced or it had to go. QPR will want their £42m back, plus damages.
The majority of EFL members voted to bring it in, though, and there are more clubs that want it enforced than not. if they don't enforce it though, there will have to be a radical re-think. Perhaps Prem 2 is the solution??
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
The QPR issue is a big one.
How on earth can the EFL let Villa off/or give them special dispensation without QPR banging on their door and demanding their money returned in full. Not to mention the impact their transfer embargo may have had.
It's for this reason alone that I can't see Vill escaping entirely.
|