O'Shea
#91
The closeness of the game was one reason why Taylor might not have come on.

The other might be that Tsylor had played on wed night and showed some signs of fatigue. Reach haf also played that night, but being more experienced would be more use to playing games at first team level so close together.
Reply
#92
(09-04-2021, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-04-2021, 08:11 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(09-03-2021, 11:01 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm really not sure I'm understanding Peachy's argument here. We were two centre-backs down already. We lost a third during the match. There were two options for covering and VI went for the more experienced option, which also gave a chance for one of the squad players he's brought in. This can't be viewed as any kind of comment on the quality of Caleb Taylor or the manager's confidence in him. He was on the bench due to injuries and would have played if necessary.

As for CAB agonizing over how many changes we need to make to cover injuries, don't you remember the days when we had one substitute? Villa played a whole season with just 14 players, a left back coming in off the bench and everyone shuffling around. We've seen Darren Bradley in goal, Mick Martin at centre back. Footballers are versatile and (hopefully) intelligent. Three subs from seven gives you more choice and more legs, but if the guys on the park can adapt, what's your problem?

The argument Chesh was if we are going to trust these kids, and Val has proven he does in his managerial career already, what better chance are you going to get to see if he's good enough?

It was a proper game of football against a decent side and he was the only centre half on the bench. What you are saying is he chose the experienced option even though he was out of position.
If we want Caleb Taylor to improve and become part of the first team that was the time to see if he has the minerals imo. If not then when?

There will always be the "it was an important game and we needed the point/s argument". I'd sooner he was given his chance early in the season than when it gets to the business end when the pressure will intensify.

Anyway I am not criticising Val, he's been absolutely terrific so far, I was just making the point that actually blooding these kids in league games Is more than likely not going to happen.

A Furlong injury or suspension will be the acid test I guess. Will he play Ingram, Hickman or shift across an experienced centre half?

We were only drawing at the time, I can’t say if this is the reason but whilst the match had a high chance of going either way, I imagine like most managers he looked to the more experienced players and had the option to put Townsend in the back three with Reach on the bench. If we were two or three up perhaps he would have played Taylor. This is just another daft argument to prove a point about expensive Chumpionship players not being brought in to sit on our bench.

As per usual you are miles off softy. 

I'm a massive fan of the youth team. I drive from Dorset to go and watch them and did a 400 mile round trip to watch them in the Birmingham senior Cup final a few years back. I'm totally the opposite of what you've just accused me of. 

I wanted to see Taylor come on instead of Reach and a reshuffle so I'm not really sure what your basing your comment on? 

The point I'm trying to make is however good a manager, and whatever their best intentions, more often than not they will always go for experience.
Reply
#93
Football Insider predicting out for 4 months. Hope not.
Reply
#94
(09-04-2021, 09:29 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(09-04-2021, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-04-2021, 08:11 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(09-03-2021, 11:01 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm really not sure I'm understanding Peachy's argument here. We were two centre-backs down already. We lost a third during the match. There were two options for covering and VI went for the more experienced option, which also gave a chance for one of the squad players he's brought in. This can't be viewed as any kind of comment on the quality of Caleb Taylor or the manager's confidence in him. He was on the bench due to injuries and would have played if necessary.

As for CAB agonizing over how many changes we need to make to cover injuries, don't you remember the days when we had one substitute? Villa played a whole season with just 14 players, a left back coming in off the bench and everyone shuffling around. We've seen Darren Bradley in goal, Mick Martin at centre back. Footballers are versatile and (hopefully) intelligent. Three subs from seven gives you more choice and more legs, but if the guys on the park can adapt, what's your problem?

The argument Chesh was if we are going to trust these kids, and Val has proven he does in his managerial career already, what better chance are you going to get to see if he's good enough?

It was a proper game of football against a decent side and he was the only centre half on the bench. What you are saying is he chose the experienced option even though he was out of position.
If we want Caleb Taylor to improve and become part of the first team that was the time to see if he has the minerals imo. If not then when?

There will always be the "it was an important game and we needed the point/s argument". I'd sooner he was given his chance early in the season than when it gets to the business end when the pressure will intensify.

Anyway I am not criticising Val, he's been absolutely terrific so far, I was just making the point that actually blooding these kids in league games Is more than likely not going to happen.

A Furlong injury or suspension will be the acid test I guess. Will he play Ingram, Hickman or shift across an experienced centre half?

We were only drawing at the time, I can’t say if this is the reason but whilst the match had a high chance of going either way, I imagine like most managers he looked to the more experienced players and had the option to put Townsend in the back three with Reach on the bench. If we were two or three up perhaps he would have played Taylor. This is just another daft argument to prove a point about expensive Chumpionship players not being brought in to sit on our bench.

As per usual you are miles off softy. 

I'm a massive fan of the youth team. I drive from Dorset to go and watch them and did a 400 mile round trip to watch them in the Birmingham senior Cup final a few years back. I'm totally the opposite of what you've just accused me of. 

I wanted to see Taylor come on instead of Reach and a reshuffle so I'm not really sure what your basing your comment on? 

The point I'm trying to make is however good a manager, and whatever their best intentions, more often than not they will always go for experience.

Which is what I said in a match where the result could go either way, we reshuffled to utilise experienced players. It still doesn’t follow that the best thing for the club was / is to assemble relatively expensive Championship quality second / third eleven as cover. We have a mix of younger players and others that can play in different positions. I’d rather a leaner squad as it cuts down on moaning and a more cohesive unit. If we had signed players for millions they would have to be better than what we had and quite frankly the first eleven is better than we can currently afford to replace.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: