Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(09-03-2021, 02:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 10:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: (09-03-2021, 10:50 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: I would differ on that, Reach and Hugill have had far more chances to prove that they are journeymen
It will be interesting to see how the careers of Edwards, Field, Harper and Leko develop
Only one of them is currently playing above League One.
Barely and not excelling either.
Edwards is excelling at Ipswich, they absolutely love him.
Harper was liked at Birmingham last season, but not heard much if him at Ipswich yet.
Field is injured, again, but QPR fans liked him a lot, as did the coaching staff there.
Leko is what a few thought he was anyway, a quick runner with little tactical awareness, not helped by large periods of no actual football here.
Doesn't really help either sides argument those four.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Ipswich are yet to win in the League. Early days though.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-03-2021, 08:45 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:30 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think people have been trying to distinguish between giving the youth a chance of game time versus relying on them as our only back up plan.
As ever we seem to exaggerate and use the extremes from both sides of the argument.
I find it difficult to see how anyone can be genuinely happy with the squad depth. There are holes and a genuine reliance on kids rather than blooding them slowly over the season with cameo appearances etc.
Spot on.
Cameos aren't enough. They need full games, not constantly but enough. Buying back up players blocks that
The kids should be played on merit, not necessity. Tulloch is ahead of Zohore because he’s earned it, not because we have zero other options in that area. Also loads of players develop by having cameo roles at first and then going on to have full appearances once it’s clear they are at a level required to have an impact. It’s much better than having to throw in an 18 year old, then they have a shocker and their confidence goes out the window.
How do you know Val isn't relying on them on merit? He didn't want more players, that's a thing too. He wants the cover to be provided by academy products.
What benefit is there, spending our limited budget on more Championship journeymen who either block the kids progress, or never actually play?
It was interesting the other night. Bartley went off at half time and Caleb Taylor was our only centre half on the bench. Val chose to play Townsend at centre half rather than play Taylor. We were playing against a side in league one last season so you would maybe think it might be a sink or swim moment.
Maybe he doesn't feel he is ready for first team football but that would surely show that we are filling the bench with players he doesn't trust yet or feel are ready.
I'm massively PRO us using the kids if they are good enough BTW.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(09-03-2021, 05:06 PM)Peachy Wrote: (09-03-2021, 08:45 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:30 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Spot on.
Cameos aren't enough. They need full games, not constantly but enough. Buying back up players blocks that
The kids should be played on merit, not necessity. Tulloch is ahead of Zohore because he’s earned it, not because we have zero other options in that area. Also loads of players develop by having cameo roles at first and then going on to have full appearances once it’s clear they are at a level required to have an impact. It’s much better than having to throw in an 18 year old, then they have a shocker and their confidence goes out the window.
How do you know Val isn't relying on them on merit? He didn't want more players, that's a thing too. He wants the cover to be provided by academy products.
What benefit is there, spending our limited budget on more Championship journeymen who either block the kids progress, or never actually play?
It was interesting the other night. Bartley went off at half time and Caleb Taylor was our only centre half on the bench. Val chose to play Townsend at centre half rather than play Taylor. We were playing against a side in league one last season so you would maybe think it might be a sink or swim moment.
Maybe he doesn't feel he is ready for first team football but that would surely show that we are filling the bench with players he doesn't trust yet or feel are ready.
I'm massively PRO us using the kids if they are good enough BTW.
Because Townsend is the most ideal replacement in the middle of a game with Reach, a player of his choosing, being able to come on.
Maybe he was deciding between them, who knows, it's not an indictment on Taylor, we kept a clean sheet and won the game, so it was justified anyway.
If Reach wasn't available to cover for Townsend, then I imagine Taylor would have come on, but he seems to like Reach coming on every game, and that was a good way to do that.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-03-2021, 05:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 05:06 PM)Peachy Wrote: (09-03-2021, 08:45 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Cameos aren't enough. They need full games, not constantly but enough. Buying back up players blocks that
The kids should be played on merit, not necessity. Tulloch is ahead of Zohore because he’s earned it, not because we have zero other options in that area. Also loads of players develop by having cameo roles at first and then going on to have full appearances once it’s clear they are at a level required to have an impact. It’s much better than having to throw in an 18 year old, then they have a shocker and their confidence goes out the window.
How do you know Val isn't relying on them on merit? He didn't want more players, that's a thing too. He wants the cover to be provided by academy products.
What benefit is there, spending our limited budget on more Championship journeymen who either block the kids progress, or never actually play?
It was interesting the other night. Bartley went off at half time and Caleb Taylor was our only centre half on the bench. Val chose to play Townsend at centre half rather than play Taylor. We were playing against a side in league one last season so you would maybe think it might be a sink or swim moment.
Maybe he doesn't feel he is ready for first team football but that would surely show that we are filling the bench with players he doesn't trust yet or feel are ready.
I'm massively PRO us using the kids if they are good enough BTW.
Because Townsend is the most ideal replacement in the middle of a game with Reach, a player of his choosing, being able to come on.
Maybe he was deciding between them, who knows, it's not an indictment on Taylor, we kept a clean sheet and won the game, so it was justified anyway.
If Reach wasn't available to cover for Townsend, then I imagine Taylor would have come on, but he seems to like Reach coming on every game, and that was a good way to do that.
I'm not suggesting it was the wrong thing Birdy. In hindsight it was a great decision. I'm merely pointing out we had a centre half on the bench and we didn't use him. Now was that age or Val preferring to play a small left wing back at centre half? I'm not sure Townsend has ever played there before?
The point I was making is if Kipre or Clarke was on the bench would he have still used Townsend and bought on Reach at LB?
The answer to that, I believe, is no.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
09-03-2021, 06:14 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-03-2021, 06:31 PM by CA Baggie.)
(09-02-2021, 02:33 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (09-02-2021, 02:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think people have been trying to distinguish between giving the youth a chance of game time versus relying on them as our only back up plan.
As ever we seem to exaggerate and use the extremes from both sides of the argument.
I find it difficult to see how anyone can be genuinely happy with the squad depth. There are holes and a genuine reliance on kids rather than blooding them slowly over the season with cameo appearances etc.
I don't think this is a case of extremes in this instance.
If you have a squad bloated with "experienced pros" you do block a path for your promising youth players. If they were first reserve for any position I would be unhappy. But as I don't even know what seasoned pros like Kipre, Reach, Snodgrass, Molumby & Hugil can do, which between them can cover pretty much every position on the pitch, I am not going to worry myself too much over our kids who may, between them, make a dozen appearances this year if we are short.
CA, just out of interest, and I know its been done to death. Where do you se these "holes"?
We have what 21 players who are "seasoned pros" if you include 3 Goalkeepers, O'Shea, Kipre, Molumby and Zahore. So 18 outfield players of which 5 are centre halves and cover 3 positions.
We have 1 RWB.
We have 3 CMs covering 2 positions
We have a Left Forward currently playing Centre Forward (and very well at the mo).
We have 2 recognised forwards in Zahore and Hugill.
We have 1 right footed player to play right of the 3 forwards, Diangana looks a pale shadow of himself out there.
We have bits of cover by moving players around and we have Snodgrass. After that it's kids.
A test of the squad depth is how many positions and players need to change to cover 1 injury. At Peterbrough we had to make 2 changes to cover Robinson (Phillips moved to the centre and Diangana right). This would be the case for other positions.
I don't expect to have equal ability for back up players but we should have enough to slot in as and when required or battling with the kids on merit for a bench place or starting place as required. We've left ourselves in the position that we may have to rely on the kids whether they're good enough or not.
Let's hope it's enough to get us home in the next 2 years as I don't fancy Championship football with these owners and no parachute payments. Yr 2 will be much harder too.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(09-03-2021, 05:46 PM)Peachy Wrote: (09-03-2021, 05:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 05:06 PM)Peachy Wrote: (09-03-2021, 08:45 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-03-2021, 07:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: The kids should be played on merit, not necessity. Tulloch is ahead of Zohore because he’s earned it, not because we have zero other options in that area. Also loads of players develop by having cameo roles at first and then going on to have full appearances once it’s clear they are at a level required to have an impact. It’s much better than having to throw in an 18 year old, then they have a shocker and their confidence goes out the window.
How do you know Val isn't relying on them on merit? He didn't want more players, that's a thing too. He wants the cover to be provided by academy products.
What benefit is there, spending our limited budget on more Championship journeymen who either block the kids progress, or never actually play?
It was interesting the other night. Bartley went off at half time and Caleb Taylor was our only centre half on the bench. Val chose to play Townsend at centre half rather than play Taylor. We were playing against a side in league one last season so you would maybe think it might be a sink or swim moment.
Maybe he doesn't feel he is ready for first team football but that would surely show that we are filling the bench with players he doesn't trust yet or feel are ready.
I'm massively PRO us using the kids if they are good enough BTW.
Because Townsend is the most ideal replacement in the middle of a game with Reach, a player of his choosing, being able to come on.
Maybe he was deciding between them, who knows, it's not an indictment on Taylor, we kept a clean sheet and won the game, so it was justified anyway.
If Reach wasn't available to cover for Townsend, then I imagine Taylor would have come on, but he seems to like Reach coming on every game, and that was a good way to do that.
I'm not suggesting it was the wrong thing Birdy. In hindsight it was a great decision. I'm merely pointing out we had a centre half on the bench and we didn't use him. Now was that age or Val preferring to play a small left wing back at centre half? I'm not sure Townsend has ever played there before?
The point I was making is if Kipre or Clarke was on the bench would he have still used Townsend and bought on Reach at LB?
The answer to that, I believe, is no.
Probably not, and I'd agree with that too. I'm not advocating throwing them in as quickly as possible, but them providing 4rd option cover is absolutely fine.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I'm really not sure I'm understanding Peachy's argument here. We were two centre-backs down already. We lost a third during the match. There were two options for covering and VI went for the more experienced option, which also gave a chance for one of the squad players he's brought in. This can't be viewed as any kind of comment on the quality of Caleb Taylor or the manager's confidence in him. He was on the bench due to injuries and would have played if necessary.
As for CAB agonizing over how many changes we need to make to cover injuries, don't you remember the days when we had one substitute? Villa played a whole season with just 14 players, a left back coming in off the bench and everyone shuffling around. We've seen Darren Bradley in goal, Mick Martin at centre back. Footballers are versatile and (hopefully) intelligent. Three subs from seven gives you more choice and more legs, but if the guys on the park can adapt, what's your problem?
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-03-2021, 11:01 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm really not sure I'm understanding Peachy's argument here. We were two centre-backs down already. We lost a third during the match. There were two options for covering and VI went for the more experienced option, which also gave a chance for one of the squad players he's brought in. This can't be viewed as any kind of comment on the quality of Caleb Taylor or the manager's confidence in him. He was on the bench due to injuries and would have played if necessary.
As for CAB agonizing over how many changes we need to make to cover injuries, don't you remember the days when we had one substitute? Villa played a whole season with just 14 players, a left back coming in off the bench and everyone shuffling around. We've seen Darren Bradley in goal, Mick Martin at centre back. Footballers are versatile and (hopefully) intelligent. Three subs from seven gives you more choice and more legs, but if the guys on the park can adapt, what's your problem?
The argument Chesh was if we are going to trust these kids, and Val has proven he does in his managerial career already, what better chance are you going to get to see if he's good enough?
It was a proper game of football against a decent side and he was the only centre half on the bench. What you are saying is he chose the experienced option even though he was out of position.
If we want Caleb Taylor to improve and become part of the first team that was the time to see if he has the minerals imo. If not then when?
There will always be the "it was an important game and we needed the point/s argument". I'd sooner he was given his chance early in the season than when it gets to the business end when the pressure will intensify.
Anyway I am not criticising Val, he's been absolutely terrific so far, I was just making the point that actually blooding these kids in league games Is more than likely not going to happen.
A Furlong injury or suspension will be the acid test I guess. Will he play Ingram, Hickman or shift across an experienced centre half?
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-04-2021, 08:11 AM)Peachy Wrote: (09-03-2021, 11:01 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I'm really not sure I'm understanding Peachy's argument here. We were two centre-backs down already. We lost a third during the match. There were two options for covering and VI went for the more experienced option, which also gave a chance for one of the squad players he's brought in. This can't be viewed as any kind of comment on the quality of Caleb Taylor or the manager's confidence in him. He was on the bench due to injuries and would have played if necessary.
As for CAB agonizing over how many changes we need to make to cover injuries, don't you remember the days when we had one substitute? Villa played a whole season with just 14 players, a left back coming in off the bench and everyone shuffling around. We've seen Darren Bradley in goal, Mick Martin at centre back. Footballers are versatile and (hopefully) intelligent. Three subs from seven gives you more choice and more legs, but if the guys on the park can adapt, what's your problem?
The argument Chesh was if we are going to trust these kids, and Val has proven he does in his managerial career already, what better chance are you going to get to see if he's good enough?
It was a proper game of football against a decent side and he was the only centre half on the bench. What you are saying is he chose the experienced option even though he was out of position.
If we want Caleb Taylor to improve and become part of the first team that was the time to see if he has the minerals imo. If not then when?
There will always be the "it was an important game and we needed the point/s argument". I'd sooner he was given his chance early in the season than when it gets to the business end when the pressure will intensify.
Anyway I am not criticising Val, he's been absolutely terrific so far, I was just making the point that actually blooding these kids in league games Is more than likely not going to happen.
A Furlong injury or suspension will be the acid test I guess. Will he play Ingram, Hickman or shift across an experienced centre half?
We were only drawing at the time, I can’t say if this is the reason but whilst the match had a high chance of going either way, I imagine like most managers he looked to the more experienced players and had the option to put Townsend in the back three with Reach on the bench. If we were two or three up perhaps he would have played Taylor. This is just another daft argument to prove a point about expensive Chumpionship players not being brought in to sit on our bench.
|