Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
07-20-2021, 12:29 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2021, 12:30 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(07-20-2021, 12:18 PM)Ossian Wrote: (07-20-2021, 11:34 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I think the average member of the public had had an enormous amount of fear drilled into them. The most for decades. Nothing on my lifetime has ever had this volume of news. Some people are very frightened despite their very low risk.
Yes the more that have the vaccine the better. But this has kept changing. First the over 50s and vulnerable. Then adults. Next children. The vaccine was supposed to get us back to normal. People on here told me months ago my predictions of winter lockdowns were doom mongering. Now despite massive uptake, restrictions are coming back soon (probably). The government told us in January vaccinate for freedom. Uptake is high but it’s still not enough. Yet keep trusting the government…
With the uptake as high as it is, if restrictions are coming back, then the government and Sage were totally wrong. They have said many times do this and we’ll beat the virus. First lockdown. Then lose November to save Xmas. Then lose Xmas to save Easter. And so on. Vaccination is the way out of this they said. Yet despite the huge uptake, it’s still not enough. We have to go blackmailing now.
Myself and baggie Nick said months ago this would happen and we were told no, the success of the vaccine action programme means the nhs will be able to cope. Well what happened to that?
I expect the government to try to mandate this jab, and an annual covid/flu booster. That’s my guess. And I’m absolutely confident that they’ll not have any investments in large pharmaceutical companies. Honest guv. And I’m sure the digital passes to get in places will honestly be for peoples safety. For the greater good, to look after them. After they’ve scared the shit out of them. Nothing to do with control, honest.
I like history and used to wonder how authoritarian governments, both far right and far left, got people onside. I can see it now, through fear and division. Piece of piss. The non vaxed are a threat to you! The Jews are a threat to you, said Adolf. An extreme example I know, but there’s some truth in it IMO. This is getting way out of hand. Fuck this government.
I don't: caution - yes; apprehension - in some cases, possibly and understandably; an "enormous amount of fear drilled in"? really? You must move in different circles to those I encounter.
But reading down your post it looks like you have: mandatory vaccinations? the Nazis? I really should have stopped at the "me and Baggie Nick" bit, but I decided to work my way through the entire post. A mistake I won't be repeating.
I did point out the adolf thing was an extreme comparison. I didn’t mean it equates to the same thing.
As for me and baggie Nick, we both said there’s be further restrictions in autumn, and we were told to stop being doom mongers. We are likely to be right.
This is a step towards mandatory vaccinations. The government have in the past said there’d be no domestic passports. It’s changed. It’ll keep changing.
(07-20-2021, 12:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-20-2021, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No! There are many including children under 12 who are specifically but not exclusively vulnerable to Covid. The chance that they would die from a cold or flu for example are significantly smaller than if they caught Covid. Your tough-titty argument can easily be reversed for those perfectly fit and healthy people who can but refuse to have the vaccine, or the passport. You are simply putting the rights of the fittest ahead of the weakest in society. If you're comfortable with this and think rights always trump responsibilities then fair enough but I'm never going to agree or respect that decision. If I'm mistaken then I will apologise in advance.
The argument about 'Fear' is real for many families who could lose a child to Covid and to not even try and see it from their perspective is quire a slap in the face. Passports wouldn't even be on the agenda if people simply had the vaccine in sufficient numbers. We want our rights but we abdicate all responsibility to the rest of society!
At least you admit your "Zero Covid" stance Dekka.
It is however the most singularly illiberal, selfish, authoritarian and wealth destroying take it's possible to have.
Totally agree proth.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
07-20-2021, 12:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2021, 12:42 PM by baggy1.)
(07-20-2021, 12:28 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: It wouldn't surprise me based on this report
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguar...-hospitals
32,307 as a % of 480,512 patients admitted to hospital is 6.7%
In fact I'll update that in your favour, the report was based on numbers as at the 1st March so the cumulative figure should be 444,576 and they received data from 81 of 126 acute hospital trusts. So 32,307 divided by 81 times 126 as a % of 444,576 equal 11.3% (and that is not really taking into account the size of the missing 45 hospitals but it should be ball park). Which ever way it isn't 40%
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(07-20-2021, 12:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (07-20-2021, 12:25 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: If you think fear hasn’t effected the populations thinking as a whole, well fair enough. I think it’s consumed many peoples lives.
I’d also point out with this latest news that proof of negative test, nor previous infection, is not acceptable. If that’s not raising alarm bells, I don’t know what is. A vaccinated person can still carry the virus, therefore a negative test should suffice. There’s no reason for that to not be enough. In terms of someone previously infected, that is literally the best option for safety. Why should they have to prove vaccination? They are more safe than anyone to be around. But no, it’s got to be the vaccine. That stinks. And what stinks more, is that I bet the government won’t explain the science behind that. Because there is none! It’s literally anti science to exclude someone previously infected in favour of someone who is jabbed, despite not knowing how long the jab works for, and the fact we know the jab is not 100% effective.
When I said beat the virus, I meant live with it like flu. Something Sage have said a number of times. This is not living with it like flu.
Of course it wasn’t rocket science to predict lockdowns this autumn. It was obvious as fuck. I couldn’t believe so many people said otherwise on here.
But my pain point is it won’t stop here. This is digital ID through the back door. It is blackmailing young people to have a vaccine. It won’t stop at nightclubs (unless enough MPs stop this in its tracks). It won’t stop at this years vaccine. “Get your annual shots to live normally” is the way we’re heading. Sod that. Medical autonomy is so important and I think many people who are currently in favour of the passports will seriously backtrack in future when they realise this is the thin end of the wedge. I do not want to hand over my medical choices to the government. No way.
Ok so what is your solution because currently we have rising hospital numbers - how are you going to stop that before it impacts on other services?
Sort the nhs out for a start. Years of under funding have murdered it. The cost of covid lockdowns and restrictions is now into the trillions is it? Just a guess. We could have built 50 hospitals and staffed them for that!! I’m not sure if that’s true but crikey how much has this cost?
I’d point out that the solutions the government and Sage have given have repeatedly not been enough. I’d like a journalist to ask them their true exit strategy for this. Because they never really tell us. Fast forward 12 months and we’ll face the same again next winter. And so on.
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
Yes I know but that that was up until March. Since then the numbers in hospital have been generally lower but if the Delta variant is more transmissible then it wouldn't be a massive shock to find out a substantial number were acquired in hospital. Not necessarily 40% but I recall seeing something about 25%.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
07-20-2021, 12:46 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2021, 12:47 PM by baggy1.)
(07-20-2021, 12:41 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Yes I know but that that was up until March. Since then the numbers in hospital have been generally lower but if the Delta variant is more transmissible then it wouldn't be a massive shock to find out a substantial number were acquired in hospital. Not necessarily 40% but I recall seeing something about 25%.
I've updated it bb, it's 12%
(07-20-2021, 12:35 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-20-2021, 12:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (07-20-2021, 12:25 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: If you think fear hasn’t effected the populations thinking as a whole, well fair enough. I think it’s consumed many peoples lives.
I’d also point out with this latest news that proof of negative test, nor previous infection, is not acceptable. If that’s not raising alarm bells, I don’t know what is. A vaccinated person can still carry the virus, therefore a negative test should suffice. There’s no reason for that to not be enough. In terms of someone previously infected, that is literally the best option for safety. Why should they have to prove vaccination? They are more safe than anyone to be around. But no, it’s got to be the vaccine. That stinks. And what stinks more, is that I bet the government won’t explain the science behind that. Because there is none! It’s literally anti science to exclude someone previously infected in favour of someone who is jabbed, despite not knowing how long the jab works for, and the fact we know the jab is not 100% effective.
When I said beat the virus, I meant live with it like flu. Something Sage have said a number of times. This is not living with it like flu.
Of course it wasn’t rocket science to predict lockdowns this autumn. It was obvious as fuck. I couldn’t believe so many people said otherwise on here.
But my pain point is it won’t stop here. This is digital ID through the back door. It is blackmailing young people to have a vaccine. It won’t stop at nightclubs (unless enough MPs stop this in its tracks). It won’t stop at this years vaccine. “Get your annual shots to live normally” is the way we’re heading. Sod that. Medical autonomy is so important and I think many people who are currently in favour of the passports will seriously backtrack in future when they realise this is the thin end of the wedge. I do not want to hand over my medical choices to the government. No way.
Ok so what is your solution because currently we have rising hospital numbers - how are you going to stop that before it impacts on other services?
Sort the nhs out for a start. Years of under funding have murdered it. The cost of covid lockdowns and restrictions is now into the trillions is it? Just a guess. We could have built 50 hospitals and staffed them for that!! I’m not sure if that’s true but crikey how much has this cost?
I’d point out that the solutions the government and Sage have given have repeatedly not been enough. I’d like a journalist to ask them their true exit strategy for this. Because they never really tell us. Fast forward 12 months and we’ll face the same again next winter. And so on.
The is a future solution that is something we would all like to see but it doesn't solve this problem now, how would you solve the problem today?
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
07-20-2021, 12:50 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2021, 12:53 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(07-20-2021, 12:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (07-20-2021, 12:29 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-20-2021, 12:18 PM)Ossian Wrote: (07-20-2021, 11:34 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I think the average member of the public had had an enormous amount of fear drilled into them. The most for decades. Nothing on my lifetime has ever had this volume of news. Some people are very frightened despite their very low risk.
Yes the more that have the vaccine the better. But this has kept changing. First the over 50s and vulnerable. Then adults. Next children. The vaccine was supposed to get us back to normal. People on here told me months ago my predictions of winter lockdowns were doom mongering. Now despite massive uptake, restrictions are coming back soon (probably). The government told us in January vaccinate for freedom. Uptake is high but it’s still not enough. Yet keep trusting the government…
With the uptake as high as it is, if restrictions are coming back, then the government and Sage were totally wrong. They have said many times do this and we’ll beat the virus. First lockdown. Then lose November to save Xmas. Then lose Xmas to save Easter. And so on. Vaccination is the way out of this they said. Yet despite the huge uptake, it’s still not enough. We have to go blackmailing now.
Myself and baggie Nick said months ago this would happen and we were told no, the success of the vaccine action programme means the nhs will be able to cope. Well what happened to that?
I expect the government to try to mandate this jab, and an annual covid/flu booster. That’s my guess. And I’m absolutely confident that they’ll not have any investments in large pharmaceutical companies. Honest guv. And I’m sure the digital passes to get in places will honestly be for peoples safety. For the greater good, to look after them. After they’ve scared the shit out of them. Nothing to do with control, honest.
I like history and used to wonder how authoritarian governments, both far right and far left, got people onside. I can see it now, through fear and division. Piece of piss. The non vaxed are a threat to you! The Jews are a threat to you, said Adolf. An extreme example I know, but there’s some truth in it IMO. This is getting way out of hand. Fuck this government.
I don't: caution - yes; apprehension - in some cases, possibly and understandably; an "enormous amount of fear drilled in"? really? You must move in different circles to those I encounter.
But reading down your post it looks like you have: mandatory vaccinations? the Nazis? I really should have stopped at the "me and Baggie Nick" bit, but I decided to work my way through the entire post. A mistake I won't be repeating.
I did point out the adolf thing was an extreme comparison. I didn’t mean it equates to the same thing.
As for me and baggie Nick, we both said there’s be further restrictions in autumn, and we were told to stop being doom mongers. We are likely to be right.
This is a step towards mandatory vaccinations. The government have in the past said there’d be no domestic passports. It’s changed. It’ll keep changing.
(07-20-2021, 12:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-20-2021, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No! There are many including children under 12 who are specifically but not exclusively vulnerable to Covid. The chance that they would die from a cold or flu for example are significantly smaller than if they caught Covid. Your tough-titty argument can easily be reversed for those perfectly fit and healthy people who can but refuse to have the vaccine, or the passport. You are simply putting the rights of the fittest ahead of the weakest in society. If you're comfortable with this and think rights always trump responsibilities then fair enough but I'm never going to agree or respect that decision. If I'm mistaken then I will apologise in advance.
The argument about 'Fear' is real for many families who could lose a child to Covid and to not even try and see it from their perspective is quire a slap in the face. Passports wouldn't even be on the agenda if people simply had the vaccine in sufficient numbers. We want our rights but we abdicate all responsibility to the rest of society!
At least you admit your "Zero Covid" stance Dekka.
It is however the most singularly illiberal, selfish, authoritarian and wealth destroying take it's possible to have.
Totally agree proth.
And again, what solution for the rising hospital numbers do you propose? Either of you can answer if you like.
As I’ve stated, sort the nhs. There’s something wrong with the nhs if it can’t cope with covid when a massive percentage have been vaccinated.
And I’d like Sage to explain the solution, as they’re the experts. Experts who have continually said do this to get through the pandemic, then we do it and it’s still not enough. It’s gone from a few weeks to flatten the curve, to vaccinate the vulnerable, to vaccinate adults, to vaccinate all, to blackmail to vaccinate, while dividing the population through turning people on anyone who doesn’t want the vaccine, despite the overall uptake being way higher than expected at first. Next is digital proof to live a normal life and go places (it won’t stop at nightclubs), despite this not making scientific sense for those who have recovered from covid. Each to their own, but I think it’s time for some honesty from Sage and a proper exit strategy, as them and the government just keep kicking the can down the road, saying things like well live with it like flu, then it never actually happens. This time next year we’ll be in exactly the same position IMO.
Digital vaccine passports were literally a conspiracy theory a year ago. How I laughed at those on social media who said this would happen.
Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
Vaccine rollout aside, I have nothing good to say about this wretched government. But I simply can't buy that they have the intellectual firepower to plot and implement anything like as Machiavellian as some people seem to think; it's a front bench of cock-up artists rather than conspirators. Johnson is a blundering tit, not a strategist.
Mandatory vaccinations - even with our pathetic excuse for a parliament - I just can't see it.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
So basically they are learning as they go along, it's almost like this is a new disease that they are still learning about. They are experts in knowing what solutions to try, they aren't clairvoyants or Nostradamus. The ones tried so far haven't worked yet, they've reduced deaths which is a great step forward but there is some way to go yet.
So your solution is 'fix the NHS' - that is a very generic answer to a very real problem here and now. What solution would you put in place to help us get through until one of the experts hits upon a solution.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
07-20-2021, 01:02 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2021, 01:06 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(07-20-2021, 12:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically they are learning as they go along, it's almost like this is a new disease that they are still learning about. They are experts in knowing what solutions to try, they aren't clairvoyants or Nostradamus. The ones tried so far haven't worked yet, they've reduced deaths which is a great step forward but there is some way to go yet.
So your solution is 'fix the NHS' - that is a very generic answer to a very real problem here and now. What solution would you put in place to help us get through until one of the experts hits upon a solution.
And Sage get predictions wrong regularly then, so I’d start with changing those advising the government.
I’m not an expert, but I’d say to you if numbers keep causing this, and restrictions continue indefinitely, on and off, is that the solution? Is excluding people from going to places a solution, with the anger that will cause? The underground parties and raves will be plentiful I guess!
You see this is the point. The science says we must do this. And how can I argue? I can’t. But that is extremely dodgy in itself because they can literally say to us we must face restrictions as the science requires it. Even if that’s forever. Even if people are indefinitely restricted from seeing family. I can’t argue. That’s the point. Then what happens when some inevitably rebel? Criminal convictions for breaking lockdown rules or refusing the latest booster? Not allowed jobs? I’m giving extreme examples I know, I’m doing this to make a point, but where are we heading with this? Towards authoritarianism IMO.
(07-20-2021, 12:53 PM)Ossian Wrote: Vaccine rollout aside, I have nothing good to say about this wretched government. But I simply can't buy that they have the intellectual firepower to plot and implement anything like as Machiavellian as some people seem to think; it's a front bench of cock-up artists rather than conspirators. Johnson is a blundering tit, not a strategist.
Mandatory vaccinations - even with our pathetic excuse for a parliament - I just can't see it.
I hope you’re right and I’m wrong, I genuinely do. As I said the extreme comparisons I use are to make a point. Im not saying boris is like Hitler. But I just see where this is heading, and if the government can control/mandate/blackmail people into this vaccine, I don’t believe it will stop there.
Posts: 994
Threads: 36
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
It's not just the Government though is it? France has recently announced similar restrictions except they have added in restaurants and shopping centres.
|