This is ok then
#71
(04-21-2021, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:14 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: It's really not corruption.

As for the intricacies of Cabinet Government, I really don't think anyone would object to measures which - on face value - increase ventilator supplies in the UK. A PM saying "I will do x," is really no big news, either.

A random person sidestepping procedure to get preferential treatment from the PM for their woefully out of depth company (as attested by the fact that we did not use a single Dyson "Ventilator" as they were so useless, and little more than a PR campaign from Dyson) is not corruption? Seriously? It's the exact same thing Cameron did, it's blatant and textbook corruption.

But Dyson derived no benefit from it. The employees would have/did.

Had the PM not sought to attract the employees, no doubt Starmer would have been doing one of his "What the Prime Minister should have done..." speeches at the Box.

Dyson claims the company did £20m quid on it, if so, that's an expensive PR campaign!! However, I didn't know that no Dyson ventilators ended-up in use. That doesn't change my view on this, though.

(04-21-2021, 03:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:14 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: It's really not corruption.

As for the intricacies of Cabinet Government, I really don't think anyone would object to measures which - on face value - increase ventilator supplies in the UK. A PM saying "I will do x," is really no big news, either.

A random person sidestepping procedure to get preferential treatment from the PM for their woefully out of depth company (as attested by the fact that we did not use a single Dyson "Ventilator" as they were so useless, and little more than a PR campaign from Dyson) is not corruption? Seriously? It's the exact same thing Cameron did, it's blatant and textbook corruption.

Not to mention the original campaign to funnel public funds to manufacturing companies such as Dyson or JCB, who just coincidentally were big supporters of Brexit, shows how seriously the crooks in power took this pandemic from the start by seeing it as a way of 'giving back' as a thankyou to their mates. But oh no, it's not corruption, it was the cabinet doing their best - if only they'd done their best by working with actual manufacturers of medical supplies in the first place, who'd have thought.

Where and when did this funneling of public money occur?
Reply
#72
https://www.ft.com/content/ee4f2220-9b22...e8034f8e8c

Some highlights:
  • The National Audit Office said the Cabinet Office and the Department of Health and Social Care had failed to explain why some companies with government connections or poor due diligence records were chosen to provide crucial services during the pandemic, such as supplying personal protective equipment or consulting and policy advice.
  • Emergency procurement rules allowed government departments to procure services and equipment quickly but have raised concerns about potential bias and the quality of services delivered. 
  • Such companies were 10 times more likely to have obtained contracts than suppliers who pitched through ordinary channels, the NAO found. A person close to the report said there were “no rules” for using the high-priority referrals system, which meant there was “a risk of it being open to abuse or inconsistency
  • ...added the “high-priority lane” was “bad enough . . . but the failure to track how half the companies had ended up on it made it impossible to ensure proper safeguards were in place
I have to ask, where have you been for the past 12 months to not be aware of the government funnelling public money to their mates?
Reply
#73
(04-21-2021, 03:52 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:14 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: It's really not corruption.

As for the intricacies of Cabinet Government, I really don't think anyone would object to measures which - on face value - increase ventilator supplies in the UK. A PM saying "I will do x," is really no big news, either.

A random person sidestepping procedure to get preferential treatment from the PM for their woefully out of depth company (as attested by the fact that we did not use a single Dyson "Ventilator" as they were so useless, and little more than a PR campaign from Dyson) is not corruption? Seriously? It's the exact same thing Cameron did, it's blatant and textbook corruption.

But Dyson derived no benefit from it. The employees would have/did.

Had the PM not sought to attract the employees, no doubt Starmer would have been doing one of his "What the Prime Minister should have done..." speeches at the Box.

Dyson claims the company did £20m quid on it, if so, that's an expensive PR campaign!! However, I didn't know that no Dyson ventilators ended-up in use. That doesn't change my view on this, though.

Dyson would have had to cover tax increases for their "senior individuals" to ensure there is no difference in net income. Them being tax exempt means Dyson wouldn't have had to pay more money out of pocket, that's a pretty clear and obvious benefit. Dyson spends less, employees get paid the same, taxpayers get shafted. If I'm asked to work in another tax jurisdiction on a short term basis you can bet my arse that I am not going to do it unless my net income is the same along with expensing other perks.

I don't give a shit about what Starmer would or would not have said. I am not a Labour voter, I have never in my life voted Labour and I am not planning on voting Labour at any local or national election in the near or far future unless something fundamental changes. Dyson being able to secure a direct line to the PM for the benefit of his company's bottom line by altering tax policy without external oversight or transparency is blatant corruption, not to mention a waste of time during the early stages of the pandemic. And what the PM should have done is work with the private sector to expand the manufacturing license for Draeger's ventilators, something with a good prior medical track record and with prior MHRA approval, to be produced on a short term basis in the UK as was eventually done through Babcock completely independent of the government who were too busy being the lapdogs of overrated tax exiles who couldn't design a functional pencil. You complain about Cameron's corruption with his links to Greensill, you complain about Labour being beholden to lobbying from unions without oversight yet you don't apply the same line to Johnson doing the same thing with Dyson?

Dyson's sham design didn't even get MHRA approval, it wasn't designed to meet basic functions of a ventilator, it was a PR stunt never designed to be used as a serious product. And £20m is fuck all for a PR campaign. I bet £10m of that covered the cost of production and editing of their fancy promo video of the piece of junk.
Reply
#74
The point was that if you have access to the Prime Minister you can be afforded preferential treatment. There were companies who were experts in the sector who actually had a proven record of making ventilators who were ignored / hit a brick wall with procurement. This is the crux of the matter, it seems if you have access to ministers or have links or support the party you have an advantage over others and rules or the spirit of them are optional.
Reply
#75
Far be it from me to offer any mitigation where Johnson is concerned; in my opinion the bloke is a chancer and a charlatan. However, on this occasion, he might not have waded into quite so much political quicksand had he handled the exchange with Dyson with a bit more professionalism. Unpunctuated text messages with phrases like "I will fix it tomo!" and "Rishi says it is fixed" would look, at the very least, iffy when viewed in any light. If he could have been arsed to use a more professional medium of communication (and employ a more professional use of language) he could easily have informed Dyson that the government would not want the employees to be penalised for their participation in what was, at the time, thought to be a potentially critical project. Few people would have seen anything sinister in that, whether it was ultimately achievable or not.

But he didn't because he couldn't help himself: he lacks the judgement to see that his 'I'm your mate, Jim, and I can fix it' and 'Come directly to me, I'm the head honcho around here' schtick has long since worn thin with all but a few camp followers and sycophants. He managed to make this episode look worse than it was, which shouldn't be taken as me saying that I've changed my view that he and his government are dodgy as fuck. I haven't.

However, to quote The Supremes and many others since... there ain't nothing I can do about it.
Reply
#76
(04-21-2021, 04:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/ee4f2220-9b22...e8034f8e8c

Some highlights:
  • The National Audit Office said the Cabinet Office and the Department of Health and Social Care had failed to explain why some companies with government connections or poor due diligence records were chosen to provide crucial services during the pandemic, such as supplying personal protective equipment or consulting and policy advice.
  • Emergency procurement rules allowed government departments to procure services and equipment quickly but have raised concerns about potential bias and the quality of services delivered. 
  • Such companies were 10 times more likely to have obtained contracts than suppliers who pitched through ordinary channels, the NAO found. A person close to the report said there were “no rules” for using the high-priority referrals system, which meant there was “a risk of it being open to abuse or inconsistency
  • ...added the “high-priority lane” was “bad enough . . . but the failure to track how half the companies had ended up on it made it impossible to ensure proper safeguards were in place
I have to ask, where have you been for the past 12 months to not be aware of the government funnelling public money to their mates?

I wondered what you meant by 'campaign'.

If there has been underhand dealings going on I will be as angry as anyone but I am not convinced that these examples were corrupt. They may have been examples of people volunteering to provide stuff at a time of dire need. But there will be ain inquiry and we'll see, won't we?
Reply
#77
(04-21-2021, 04:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 03:52 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 02:14 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: It's really not corruption.

As for the intricacies of Cabinet Government, I really don't think anyone would object to measures which - on face value - increase ventilator supplies in the UK. A PM saying "I will do x," is really no big news, either.

A random person sidestepping procedure to get preferential treatment from the PM for their woefully out of depth company (as attested by the fact that we did not use a single Dyson "Ventilator" as they were so useless, and little more than a PR campaign from Dyson) is not corruption? Seriously? It's the exact same thing Cameron did, it's blatant and textbook corruption.

But Dyson derived no benefit from it. The employees would have/did.

Had the PM not sought to attract the employees, no doubt Starmer would have been doing one of his "What the Prime Minister should have done..." speeches at the Box.

Dyson claims the company did £20m quid on it, if so, that's an expensive PR campaign!! However, I didn't know that no Dyson ventilators ended-up in use. That doesn't change my view on this, though.

Dyson would have had to cover tax increases for their "senior individuals" to ensure there is no difference in net income. Them being tax exempt means Dyson wouldn't have had to pay more money out of pocket, that's a pretty clear and obvious benefit. Dyson spends less, employees get paid the same, taxpayers get shafted. If I'm asked to work in another tax jurisdiction on a short term basis you can bet my arse that I am not going to do it unless my net income is the same along with expensing other perks.

I don't give a shit about what Starmer would or would not have said. I am not a Labour voter, I have never in my life voted Labour and I am not planning on voting Labour at any local or national election in the near or far future unless something fundamental changes. Dyson being able to secure a direct line to the PM for the benefit of his company's bottom line by altering tax policy without external oversight or transparency is blatant corruption, not to mention a waste of time during the early stages of the pandemic. And what the PM should have done is work with the private sector to expand the manufacturing license for Draeger's ventilators, something with a good prior medical track record and with prior MHRA approval, to be produced on a short term basis in the UK as was eventually done through Babcock completely independent of the government who were too busy being the lapdogs of overrated tax exiles who couldn't design a functional pencil. You complain about Cameron's corruption with his links to Greensill, you complain about Labour being beholden to lobbying from unions without oversight yet you don't apply the same line to Johnson doing the same thing with Dyson?

Dyson's sham design didn't even get MHRA approval, it wasn't designed to meet basic functions of a ventilator, it was a PR stunt never designed to be used as a serious product. And £20m is fuck all for a PR campaign. I bet £10m of that covered the cost of production and editing of their fancy promo video of the piece of junk.

As I understand it, the employees would be coming to the UK on the same salary as in Singapore and an increase to make up for the shortfall due to UK income tax rules was never envisaged. Dyson then asked for the rules to be amended to make this proposition more attractive.

Even if I am wrong on that and Dyson asked for the rules to be changed so he didn't have to bump-up the salaries of any employees coming to the UK from Singapore, Dyson was undertaking the payment of the salaries of those employees for pro bono reasons. I have no problem with him seeking to reduce what he is spending when he is spending for altruistic reasons.

How long would the licencing process take? How keen do you think IP owners would be to grant them, and what reaction do you think the current licencee(s) would would have to rights they have paid a premium for being diluted?

Waiving rules for a friend in response to a public need, is also a far cry from Cameron asking for favours for his employer.
Reply
#78
Exactly, so instead of the shortfall being made to by Dyson it's made up at the expense of UK taxpayers.

And, based on the design being a fancy looking piece of junk that any second year mechanical engineering student could do better than and the MHRA was never going to approve, due to it being nothing more than a PR stunt for Dyson, it clearly wasn't pro-bono. It was never intended to and never did serve any public good, and it's an actual disgrace that a company could say they were expending that

And given Draeger did license production to UK manufacturers with Babcock being forced to play the role of an intermediary that the government should have played, they were very keen to license their IP. We aren't bloody China.

It served no public need, it cost the taxpayers, it was solely to the benefit of Dyson, and what Johnson did is identical to what Cameron did in giving a friend preferential political treatment not afforded to anyone else. It's textbook cronyism, they're as bad as each other and it's astonishing that you refuse to condemn Johnson given how easily you condemned Cameron for the same shit.
Reply
#79
Here’s someone else who is qualified to talk about this subject... and backs up my earlier point and the one that Borin made. 

Expert in sector
Reply
#80
(04-21-2021, 10:33 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(04-21-2021, 04:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: https://www.ft.com/content/ee4f2220-9b22...e8034f8e8c

Some highlights:
  • The National Audit Office said the Cabinet Office and the Department of Health and Social Care had failed to explain why some companies with government connections or poor due diligence records were chosen to provide crucial services during the pandemic, such as supplying personal protective equipment or consulting and policy advice.
  • Emergency procurement rules allowed government departments to procure services and equipment quickly but have raised concerns about potential bias and the quality of services delivered. 
  • Such companies were 10 times more likely to have obtained contracts than suppliers who pitched through ordinary channels, the NAO found. A person close to the report said there were “no rules” for using the high-priority referrals system, which meant there was “a risk of it being open to abuse or inconsistency
  • ...added the “high-priority lane” was “bad enough . . . but the failure to track how half the companies had ended up on it made it impossible to ensure proper safeguards were in place
I have to ask, where have you been for the past 12 months to not be aware of the government funnelling public money to their mates?

I wondered what you meant by 'campaign'.

If there has been underhand dealings going on I will be as angry as anyone but I am not convinced that these examples were corrupt. They may have been examples of people volunteering to provide stuff at a time of dire need. But there will be ain inquiry and we'll see, won't we?

Of course not, getting your mates to set up companies and then tender, through a specially organised hotline not available to everyone, for contracts that they have never had any dealings in before is not corruption, it's bluesky thinking in a crisis situation. Coincidentally I have some magic beans available if you are interested.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: