society has "just accepted" dead women as "one of those things".
#11
(03-12-2021, 01:36 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-11-2021, 10:59 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote: Completely ridiculous to say society just accepts dead women as one of those things. Society accepts that unfortunately murders will happen. Always have and always will.
To try and make out that nobody cares that women get murdered is utter bollocks.
When you consider that the population is split equally between men and women and last year roughly 3/4 of the victims of murder were men, in theory you could make an argument for men being under protected.
Perhaps we should start a campaign to persuade anyone thinking of committing murder to focus more on women just so we can ensure the quotas are more representative. And before anyone accuses me of promoting violence against women - no, that wasn’t a serious suggestion, but it’s about as ridiculous as Jess Phillips claim that we all just accept dead women as one of those things.

(03-12-2021, 12:47 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Of course this isn't the case, which is why Sarah's death has received such coverage. It is a typical brainless claim.

It will never be 'just accepted' and nor should it ever come close to that.
Just out of interest, how long would it take to read out the names of all the males who have committed suicide since last IWD?

Except it's acknowledged that suicide in men is a massive problem.

There are many high profile campaigns talking about it (like this https://www.projecteightyfour.com/)

All four UK nations have a suicide prevention strategy.

England has a Minister for Suicide Prevention.

There are all the Time to Talk about Mental Health campaigns, which are largely aimed at men.

As for men murdering other men, again there is a big government strategy for preventing violent crime, mainly aimed at knife crime. They even increased the minimum tariff for murder with a bladed article from 15 years to 25 to act as a deterrent/increased punishment. Most police patrols are in city centres at night, largely to stop alcohol-fuelled men (and occasionally women) fighting with each other.

So the deaths of men are clearly not accepted. If you went on the likes of Mumsnet or Netmums or similar to talk about male suicide during an awareness campaign you would find women on there talking about the brothers, fathers and saddest of all, sons that they lost due to suicide. Some of the biggest campaigners against knife crime are bereaved mothers. 


In the UK, three women a week are killed by men. Usually a partner or their ex-partner. And the response to it is exactly as described above:
"Murder is a fact of life"
"What about the men"
"Other countries are worse".

It's as if women are some ungrateful sub-species as opposed to the people you love as mothers, wives, sisters, daughters and friends.  We don't accept other forms of violent death, as I've described above we actively campaign and legislate against them.

If there was one thing I would recommend anyone reading this do, it's read the Gift of Fear by Gavin de Becker. He's not some weird soppy bloke, he's security expert and there is some brilliant advice about recognising abusive people that you can bring your daughters up to know and explains a lot about some of the issues women face.

Superb post.  

Admittedly, JP's statement can be taken out of context as deliberately provocative, but she was using the moment to bring attention to a cause she is closely involved in. This is actually something that she does every year in parliament but it has caught extra attention because of the current case in the the news.

it should be pointed out that the national press coverage of this current case is not reflective of our normal reaction to the violent death of women in this country, very few accounts of femicide make headline news. But she was a young, pretty and very photogenic professional white women living in London and the press picked up on the fact that there might be salicuos details involved in the disappearance.

On the same day there was another story given no more than a couple of paragraphs in my newspaper about the sentencing of a man who had killed his ex partner in a horribly frenzied and pre-meditated attack....I'm pretty sure the original incident did not make a lead story across the news channels and neither would any of the other murders commited around the same day as this one.

In case you are not aware, femicide is a specific type of murder, the killing of a woman, or girl, in particular by a man and on account of her gender, and this is what JP was particularly confronting  as per the extract below. There need be no comparison to other countries, this is happening here, today and again tomorrow.  So some context and I hope food for thought.  

In what has become a grim annual event to mark International Women's Day, The  MP read out more than 110 names in a bid to help ensure "the scale of male violence against women can be known".

Ms Phillips said: "In this place we count what we care about. We count vaccines done, we count the number of people on benefits, we rule or oppose based on a count. And we obsessively track that data. We love to count data about our own popularity.

"However we don't currently count dead women. No current study is done into the patterns every year and the data of victims who are killed, die by suicide or die suddenly. Dead women is a thing that we've all just accepted as part of our daily lives. Dead women is just one of those things. Killed women are not vanishingly rare. Killed women are common."
Reply
#12
Nice to see some balance on this thread to break the chain of middle-aged men spouting bollocks.
Reply
#13
Couldn't agree more Sol. I started reading this fred and started to think it was almost a carbon copy of "Black lives matter!? Don't ALL live matter?".
Reply
#14
(03-12-2021, 07:01 AM)YamYam Wrote: Couldn't agree more Sol. I started reading this fred and started to think it was almost a carbon copy of "Black lives matter!? Don't ALL live matter?".

I think this thread touches very closely with the issue of identity politics. I’m transgender, I’m black, I’m gay, I’m a woman.
This fascination with segmenting us all into smaller groups is so counterproductive.
All Jess Phillips has done is spread fear and make those women who hate men have more fuel for the fire.
Reply
#15
(03-12-2021, 06:15 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote: Nice to see some balance on this thread to break the chain of middle-aged men spouting bollocks.

I was thinking exactly that.

(03-12-2021, 07:31 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2021, 07:01 AM)YamYam Wrote: Couldn't agree more Sol. I started reading this fred and started to think it was almost a carbon copy of "Black lives matter!? Don't ALL live matter?".

I think this thread touches very closely with the issue of identity politics. I’m transgender, I’m black, I’m gay, I’m a woman.
This fascination with segmenting us all into smaller groups is so counterproductive.
All Jess Phillips has done is spread fear and make those women who hate men have more fuel for the fire.

I would suggest the cunt that took the life of an innocent woman walking home has done that, not an MP who campaigns against violence against women. How dare she.
Reply
#16
97% of women aged 18-24 have been sexually assaulted. It might not be all men but judging on those numbers it's a fair fucking few.

EDIT: Not assaulted, harassed. Apologies.
Reply
#17
What our society has accepted is terrorism the other side of the world. Eg if 30 people are killed in a terrorist attack in Afghanistan it hardly gets any media coverage. Bring it closer to home and if 1 person is stabbed in <insert neighbouring European country> by the same terrorist group, then it is big news.
Reply
#18
(03-12-2021, 03:21 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(03-12-2021, 01:36 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-11-2021, 10:59 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote: Completely ridiculous to say society just accepts dead women as one of those things. Society accepts that unfortunately murders will happen. Always have and always will.
To try and make out that nobody cares that women get murdered is utter bollocks.
When you consider that the population is split equally between men and women and last year roughly 3/4 of the victims of murder were men, in theory you could make an argument for men being under protected.
Perhaps we should start a campaign to persuade anyone thinking of committing murder to focus more on women just so we can ensure the quotas are more representative. And before anyone accuses me of promoting violence against women - no, that wasn’t a serious suggestion, but it’s about as ridiculous as Jess Phillips claim that we all just accept dead women as one of those things.

(03-12-2021, 12:47 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Of course this isn't the case, which is why Sarah's death has received such coverage. It is a typical brainless claim.

It will never be 'just accepted' and nor should it ever come close to that.
Just out of interest, how long would it take to read out the names of all the males who have committed suicide since last IWD?

Except it's acknowledged that suicide in men is a massive problem.

There are many high profile campaigns talking about it (like this https://www.projecteightyfour.com/)

All four UK nations have a suicide prevention strategy.

England has a Minister for Suicide Prevention.

There are all the Time to Talk about Mental Health campaigns, which are largely aimed at men.

As for men murdering other men, again there is a big government strategy for preventing violent crime, mainly aimed at knife crime. They even increased the minimum tariff for murder with a bladed article from 15 years to 25 to act as a deterrent/increased punishment. Most police patrols are in city centres at night, largely to stop alcohol-fuelled men (and occasionally women) fighting with each other.

So the deaths of men are clearly not accepted. If you went on the likes of Mumsnet or Netmums or similar to talk about male suicide during an awareness campaign you would find women on there talking about the brothers, fathers and saddest of all, sons that they lost due to suicide. Some of the biggest campaigners against knife crime are bereaved mothers. 


In the UK, three women a week are killed by men. Usually a partner or their ex-partner. And the response to it is exactly as described above:
"Murder is a fact of life"
"What about the men"
"Other countries are worse".

It's as if women are some ungrateful sub-species as opposed to the people you love as mothers, wives, sisters, daughters and friends.  We don't accept other forms of violent death, as I've described above we actively campaign and legislate against them.

If there was one thing I would recommend anyone reading this do, it's read the Gift of Fear by Gavin de Becker. He's not some weird soppy bloke, he's security expert and there is some brilliant advice about recognising abusive people that you can bring your daughters up to know and explains a lot about some of the issues women face.

Superb post.  

Admittedly, JP's statement can be taken out of context as deliberately provocative, but she was using the moment to bring attention to a cause she is closely involved in. This is actually something that she does every year in parliament but it has caught extra attention because of the current case in the the news.

it should be pointed out that the national press coverage of this current case is not reflective of our normal reaction to the violent death of women in this country, very few accounts of femicide make headline news. But she was a young, pretty and very photogenic professional white women living in London and the press picked up on the fact that there might be salicuos details involved in the disappearance.


On the same day there was another story given no more than a couple of paragraphs in my newspaper about the sentencing of a man who had killed his ex partner in a horribly frenzied and pre-meditated attack....I'm pretty sure the original incident did not make a lead story across the news channels and neither would any of the other murders commited around the same day as this one.

In case you are not aware, femicide is a specific type of murder, the killing of a woman, or girl, in particular by a man and on account of her gender, and this is what JP was particularly confronting  as per the extract below.  There need be no comparison to other countries, this is happening here, today and again tomorrow.  So some context and I hope food for thought.  

In what has become a grim annual event to mark International Women's Day, The  MP read out more than 110 names in a bid to help ensure "the scale of male violence against women can be known".

Ms Phillips said: "In this place we count what we care about. We count vaccines done, we count the number of people on benefits, we rule or oppose based on a count. And we obsessively track that data. We love to count data about our own popularity.

"However we don't currently count dead women. No current study is done into the patterns every year and the data of victims who are killed, die by suicide or die suddenly. Dead women is a thing that we've all just accepted as part of our daily lives. Dead women is just one of those things. Killed women are not vanishingly rare. Killed women are common."

I think it’s more the case that it’s rare that this type of murder happens.  Most murders are committed by a family member or friend.  So the husband or ex murdering the spouse etc doesn’t make the news.  When it’s a missing person that generally gets the news folk going.

White, young, London etc would have sent the titillation factor through the roof too.

When more of what JP actually said it brings it into context.  The laws around abusive ex/partners are difficult and I think there’s still a whiff of “not getting involved in a domestic” by both the law makers and the people upholding the law on our behalf (the police).
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#19
(03-12-2021, 07:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: 97% of women aged 18-24 have been sexually assaulted. It might not be all men but judging on those numbers it's a fair fucking few.

If that was true we'd have to go back to our caves.
Reply
#20
Me and the wife was discussing this this morning as a woman she said its her responsibility to make sure she is safe getting home and pick a decent route...... One thing she said that the street lighting is non exsistant as they are saving money with them being off....... She said she will never put her life in the hands of the police or anyone on the street who she expects to respect a woman because its simply not going to happen.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: