Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
I do feel great sympathy for the mother here.
What many people might find challenging to understand is why, if you identify as a wench, why you'd wanna be a daddy too.
Is it greed? Like the "best of both worlds"?
Posts: 167
Threads: 7
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
4
It’s true that there’s now an unhealthy divide between right and left and it’s clear that the likes of Trump have been able to foster that and prosper as a result.
It’s also true that it’s human nature to judge and debate is often productive, but before we start exercising our right to free speech isn’t it worth considering if our opinions are adding any value at all?
How knowledgable are you really about the subject? Are you able to empathise with the parties involved? More specifically to this debate, do you know how it feels to be conflicted about your gender or sexuality and have you ever been prevented from doing something because of it? Does it have any impact on your life whatsoever?
In my view, if I can’t answer these questions on a particular topic then any opinion I might have doesn’t really count for a lot.
So before making quips about transgender people in the shower/toilets or ironically adding letters to the LGBTQ+ acronym - which by the way have been done to death - maybe just have a think about whether or not your opinion is required on the subject.
I should say that I’m not trying to target individual posts here, more of a response to the general theme.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-27-2020, 06:23 PM)OmarLittle Wrote: It’s true that there’s now an unhealthy divide between right and left and it’s clear that the likes of Trump have been able to foster that and prosper as a result.
It’s also true that it’s human nature to judge and debate is often productive, but before we start exercising our right to free speech isn’t it worth considering if our opinions are adding any value at all?
How knowledgable are you really about the subject? Are you able to empathise with the parties involved? More specifically to this debate, do you know how it feels to be conflicted about your gender or sexuality and have you ever been prevented from doing something because of it? Does it have any impact on your life whatsoever?
In my view, if I can’t answer these questions on a particular topic then any opinion I might have doesn’t really count for a lot.
So before making quips about transgender people in the shower/toilets or ironically adding letters to the LGBTQ+ acronym - which by the way have been done to death - maybe just have a think about whether or not your opinion is required on the subject.
I should say that I’m not trying to target individual posts here, more of a response to the general theme.
Spot on!
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
08-27-2020, 06:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-27-2020, 06:36 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(08-27-2020, 06:23 PM)OmarLittle Wrote: It’s true that there’s now an unhealthy divide between right and left and it’s clear that the likes of Trump have been able to foster that and prosper as a result.
It’s also true that it’s human nature to judge and debate is often productive, but before we start exercising our right to free speech isn’t it worth considering if our opinions are adding any value at all?
How knowledgable are you really about the subject? Are you able to empathise with the parties involved? More specifically to this debate, do you know how it feels to be conflicted about your gender or sexuality and have you ever been prevented from doing something because of it? Does it have any impact on your life whatsoever?
In my view, if I can’t answer these questions on a particular topic then any opinion I might have doesn’t really count for a lot.
So before making quips about transgender people in the shower/toilets or ironically adding letters to the LGBTQ+ acronym - which by the way have been done to death - maybe just have a think about whether or not your opinion is required on the subject.
I should say that I’m not trying to target individual posts here, more of a response to the general theme.
+1000
(08-27-2020, 06:21 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: I do feel great sympathy for the mother here.
What many people might find challenging to understand is why, if you identify as a wench, why you'd wanna be a daddy too.
Is it greed? Like the "best of both worlds"?
The same reason why anyone would want to freeze their sperm or their eggs. They plan on doing something that might stop them from procreating in the future but might still want to have a family later in life either with a partner or through surrogacy.
Really didn't think this needed spelling out.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
08-27-2020, 06:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-27-2020, 06:49 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
I guess social media doesn’t help as the nuances of communication are missed compared to face to face debate. It becomes statements and counter arguments.
Some want to look for division and bristle due to unPC comments. This highly strung righteousness creates the Trumps. The sensitive get their own angle depending on preconceptions.
My opinion is simply the article was about a ‘son who the PC say is a daughter. It’s nothing to do with the kids identity.
I also think that the mother is selfish trying to create life from the DNA without there being a partner. You are all welcome to your own opinions and I’m happy to be swayed. That’s what debate is about.
For instance I opposed parenting from same sex couples a decade ago, but have changed my mind. Society changes, people change. That’s how it should be.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
08-27-2020, 06:51 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-27-2020, 06:54 PM by backsidebaggie.)
The problem is, on the subject of the general theme rather than this specific case, anyone is entitled to an opinion as it MAY affect them. That’s the point Spandau made above. That’s why it can legitimately be people’s business if someone else identifies in a particular way (if it has an impact on others). Then so often when someone disagrees, they can just get labelled a transphobe. I know plenty of people will debate, but there is a shut down culture now amongst too many. For example, Sharon Davies (former swimmer) has been labelled it by some for simply believing Trans women shouldn’t compete in women’s sport as it’s simply not fair and impacts the other competitors unfairly. That’s a reasonable position. It doesn’t make her a transphobe, whether you agree with her or not.
I know the majority of people will debate, but there’s a shut down culture who are very loud these days, and sensitive subjects like this mean some folk can then be scared to offer opinions as they’re scared of being labelled a transphobe. That’s not healthy, and it only plays into the hands of people like Trump.
Jonathan Pie sums it up better than I ever could in some of his vids.
Edit: Pickle Rick has also explained that better than I ever could!
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
08-27-2020, 07:58 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-27-2020, 07:59 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(08-27-2020, 06:51 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The problem is, on the subject of the general theme rather than this specific case, anyone is entitled to an opinion as it MAY affect them. That’s the point Spandau made above. That’s why it can legitimately be people’s business if someone else identifies in a particular way (if it has an impact on others). Then so often when someone disagrees, they can just get labelled a transphobe. I know plenty of people will debate, but there is a shut down culture now amongst too many. For example, Sharon Davies (former swimmer) has been labelled it by some for simply believing Trans women shouldn’t compete in women’s sport as it’s simply not fair and impacts the other competitors unfairly. That’s a reasonable position. It doesn’t make her a transphobe, whether you agree with her or not.
I know the majority of people will debate, but there’s a shut down culture who are very loud these days, and sensitive subjects like this mean some folk can then be scared to offer opinions as they’re scared of being labelled a transphobe. That’s not healthy, and it only plays into the hands of people like Trump.
Jonathan Pie sums it up better than I ever could in some of his vids.
Edit: Pickle Rick has also explained that better than I ever could!
As you said ‘shut down’ culture explains it perfectly. I’m happy to be swayed if I think someone has offered me an insight. For instance I was/am pro Remain but still managed to maintain healthy debate with Brexit supporting friends.
Too many people, some on here like everywhere, are too quick to label good v evil, without listening to counter arguments.
It creates absurd situations with celebrities being vilified or lives ruined for minor indiscretions, even unintended- see Danny Baker.
It’s driven by an incredibly intolerant left wing that looks for division. It’s why we have real evil like Trump and is stoking up more of the same.
People better start having debates again instead of shouting matches or society is in for some real horror.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(08-27-2020, 06:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (08-27-2020, 06:23 PM)OmarLittle Wrote: It’s true that there’s now an unhealthy divide between right and left and it’s clear that the likes of Trump have been able to foster that and prosper as a result.
It’s also true that it’s human nature to judge and debate is often productive, but before we start exercising our right to free speech isn’t it worth considering if our opinions are adding any value at all?
How knowledgable are you really about the subject? Are you able to empathise with the parties involved? More specifically to this debate, do you know how it feels to be conflicted about your gender or sexuality and have you ever been prevented from doing something because of it? Does it have any impact on your life whatsoever?
In my view, if I can’t answer these questions on a particular topic then any opinion I might have doesn’t really count for a lot.
So before making quips about transgender people in the shower/toilets or ironically adding letters to the LGBTQ+ acronym - which by the way have been done to death - maybe just have a think about whether or not your opinion is required on the subject.
I should say that I’m not trying to target individual posts here, more of a response to the general theme.
+1000
(08-27-2020, 06:21 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: I do feel great sympathy for the mother here.
What many people might find challenging to understand is why, if you identify as a wench, why you'd wanna be a daddy too.
Is it greed? Like the "best of both worlds"?
The same reason why anyone would want to freeze their sperm or their eggs. They plan on doing something that might stop them from procreating in the future but might still want to have a family later in life either with a partner or through surrogacy.
Really didn't think this needed spelling out.
So the "best of both worlds" then.
I guess it works for some, fair enough.
Posts: 3,821
Threads: 250
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(08-27-2020, 06:51 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The problem is, on the subject of the general theme rather than this specific case, anyone is entitled to an opinion as it MAY affect them. That’s the point Spandau made above. That’s why it can legitimately be people’s business if someone else identifies in a particular way (if it has an impact on others). Then so often when someone disagrees, they can just get labelled a transphobe. I know plenty of people will debate, but there is a shut down culture now amongst too many. For example, Sharon Davies (former swimmer) has been labelled it by some for simply believing Trans women shouldn’t compete in women’s sport as it’s simply not fair and impacts the other competitors unfairly. That’s a reasonable position. It doesn’t make her a transphobe, whether you agree with her or not.
I know the majority of people will debate, but there’s a shut down culture who are very loud these days, and sensitive subjects like this mean some folk can then be scared to offer opinions as they’re scared of being labelled a transphobe. That’s not healthy, and it only plays into the hands of people like Trump.
Jonathan Pie sums it up better than I ever could in some of his vids.
Edit: Pickle Rick has also explained that better than I ever could!
Martina Navratilova too - and got booted out as spokeswoman for LGBT
All getting a bit silly if you ask me!
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(08-27-2020, 08:05 PM)baggpuss Wrote: (08-27-2020, 06:51 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The problem is, on the subject of the general theme rather than this specific case, anyone is entitled to an opinion as it MAY affect them. That’s the point Spandau made above. That’s why it can legitimately be people’s business if someone else identifies in a particular way (if it has an impact on others). Then so often when someone disagrees, they can just get labelled a transphobe. I know plenty of people will debate, but there is a shut down culture now amongst too many. For example, Sharon Davies (former swimmer) has been labelled it by some for simply believing Trans women shouldn’t compete in women’s sport as it’s simply not fair and impacts the other competitors unfairly. That’s a reasonable position. It doesn’t make her a transphobe, whether you agree with her or not.
I know the majority of people will debate, but there’s a shut down culture who are very loud these days, and sensitive subjects like this mean some folk can then be scared to offer opinions as they’re scared of being labelled a transphobe. That’s not healthy, and it only plays into the hands of people like Trump.
Jonathan Pie sums it up better than I ever could in some of his vids.
Edit: Pickle Rick has also explained that better than I ever could!
Martina Navratilova too - and got booted out as spokeswoman for LGBT
All getting a bit silly if you ask me!
Its an absolute cock up.
|