Is Lockdown Counter Productive?
#51
(04-30-2020, 06:49 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.

Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism. 

A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery. 

The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example? 

What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Let's put this another way,, who on here would be prepared to sacrifice their life in order to save the economy for the benefit of others!!!!!

Well that's more nuanced than you probably thought when you first wrote it.

I've a son in his 20s. Would I lay down my life for his future yes. If there's no economy, no jobs, no travel, no joy, no family for the foreseeable then maybe there's a different answer to your question

(05-01-2020, 07:36 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 04:30 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 03:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 11:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 09:10 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Stop revolving your life around opportunity costs for people's livelihoods FFS, there's no point running a business if all of the customers have died.

But that's the point isn't it? In the greater scheme of things very few people are going to die. Whereas hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of livelihoods are going to be ruined.

I'm fortunate that I've put enough away for a rainy day, which has finally arrived. The vast majority of people in this country live from paycheck  to paycheck and don't have that luxury - just as they didn't in 2008.

Well there's 2 way of looking at this.

In the long term we are all going to die, In the short term if unchecked covid 19 has the potential to take 200 -400 k uk citizens, that's not an insubstantial amount.

Another made up death number. I'll make one up as well. If we don't start getting back to something like normal soon then the indirect deaths of covid over the next 10 years, due to a multitude of factors such s quiet health, mental health, poverty, blah blah will be circa 200,000

Not actually a made up number, but given the parameters I set 200k made up numbers and not really made up at all.

Based on the virus being allowed to spread unchecked, and 60% of the population getting it. That approximately would be 40 million, and a death rate of between 0.5 to 1 per 100 people who get the virus. These are not unreasonable assumptions given how contagious the virus is, and a death rate of 1 per 100 is again not unreasonable given the numbers of people who would get the virus, it would almost certainly mean that some people who could have been saved would be lost due to lack of medical resources (not a criticism, no health service could deal with those numbers)

Sorry but you've just made up 3 more numbers: 60%, 40 million and 0.5-1.

Let's say it was 90% and 65 million and 1% and therefore 650000. Or say 99%, 68 million and 0.25% so 170K, or say 25%, 15 million, 2% - 300k.

All made up. They don't know the SARS numbers not sure how they will know Covid.

What we do know is that in 2018 there were 616K deaths in the UK. 77% of them over 70 yrs of age. Many of those with underlying illnesses.

Nobody wants people to die early but to say Covid is going to add 200k additional deaths to the UK is nonsense in my book.
Reply
#52
(05-01-2020, 11:30 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 06:49 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.

Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism. 

A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery. 

The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example? 

What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Let's put this another way,, who on here would be prepared to sacrifice their life in order to save the economy for the benefit of others!!!!!

Well that's more nuanced than you probably thought when you first wrote it.

I've a son in his 20s. Would I lay down my life for his future yes. If there's no economy, no jobs, no travel, no joy, no family for the foreseeable then maybe there's a different answer to your question

(05-01-2020, 07:36 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 04:30 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 03:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 11:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: But that's the point isn't it? In the greater scheme of things very few people are going to die. Whereas hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of livelihoods are going to be ruined.

I'm fortunate that I've put enough away for a rainy day, which has finally arrived. The vast majority of people in this country live from paycheck  to paycheck and don't have that luxury - just as they didn't in 2008.

Well there's 2 way of looking at this.

In the long term we are all going to die, In the short term if unchecked covid 19 has the potential to take 200 -400 k uk citizens, that's not an insubstantial amount.

Another made up death number. I'll make one up as well. If we don't start getting back to something like normal soon then the indirect deaths of covid over the next 10 years, due to a multitude of factors such s quiet health, mental health, poverty, blah blah will be circa 200,000

Not actually a made up number, but given the parameters I set 200k made up numbers and not really made up at all.

Based on the virus being allowed to spread unchecked, and 60% of the population getting it. That approximately would be 40 million, and a death rate of between 0.5 to 1 per 100 people who get the virus. These are not unreasonable assumptions given how contagious the virus is, and a death rate of 1 per 100 is again not unreasonable given the numbers of people who would get the virus, it would almost certainly mean that some people who could have been saved would be lost due to lack of medical resources (not a criticism, no health service could deal with those numbers)

Sorry but you've just made up 3 more numbers: 60%, 40 million and 0.5-1.

Let's say it was 90% and 65 million and 1% and therefore 650000. Or say 99%, 68 million and 0.25% so 170K, or say 25%, 15 million, 2% - 300k.

All made up. They don't know the SARS numbers not sure how they will know Covid.

What we do know is that in 2018 there were 616K deaths in the UK. 77% of them over 70 yrs of age. Many of those with underlying illnesses.

Nobody wants people to die early but to say Covid is going to add 200k additional deaths to the UK is nonsense in my book.

The numbers I put forward are quite conservative estimates - the PM mentioned the figure 500k in yesterdays press briefings.
You might quibble about actual numbers, I gave a range of figures, but they are not unreasonable, but realistic and slightly cautious . 
The idea that the number of deaths would be below 100k, if we had not had a lockdown is fanciful. Who knows how many of those who have dies and may have died, would die anyway this year is a guess.
Reply
#53
Just to put some real figures behind this; ONS published deaths up to the 19th April 2019 was 175,460 and up to the 17th April 2020 was 207,311, and increase of 31,851 (both dates were week 16). There is obviously a bit of a lag on these figures however it is noticeable that until week 13 the increase year on year for that period was 2%, as at week 16 that % is now 18% and we also know that there have been big increases in weeks 14 and 15.

Taking that on board and looking to the future (guessing!) I would say that we will hit the +100k figure easily by the end of the year and then we are dependant on it not becoming a seasonal problem that sends the figures up again in Autumn / Winter. The point that BB seems to be missing is that these are the figures with a lockdown, if we had let it run rife then the figures would have been a lot higher and that 200k figure appears realistic.
Reply
#54
(05-01-2020, 12:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Just to put some real figures behind this; ONS published deaths up to the 19th April 2019 was 175,460 and up to the 17th April 2020 was 207,311, and increase of 31,851 (both dates were week 16). There is obviously a bit of a lag on these figures however it is noticeable that until week 13 the increase year on year for that period was 2%, as at week 16 that % is now 18% and we also know that there have been big increases in weeks 14 and 15.

Taking that on board and looking to the future (guessing!) I would say that we will hit the +100k figure easily by the end of the year and then we are dependant on it not becoming a seasonal problem that sends the figures up again in Autumn / Winter. The point that BB seems to be missing is that these are the figures with a lockdown, if we had let it run rife then the figures would have been a lot higher and that 200k figure appears realistic.

BB is forgetting that there are many thousands of people who aren’t old and may die, of those many will be supporting families emotionally and financially and how is that going to improve the situation by living the lockdown whilst still only just after the peak (I have my doubts)? It will be madness to lift the lockdown without U.K. wide testing for a sustained period.
Reply
#55
Without wanting to be a doom monger here, the three weeks ups to week 13 had an increase year on year of 28k deaths, we know that 14 and 15 have followed suit and we only need to have weeks 16 to 19 be similar and that will mean we will add 60k to the total. Pray to God that by the end of May that figure doesn't appear.
Reply
#56
Is saving lives a bad thing? No I don't think so.
Reply
#57
A gradual release while measuring the R0 rate and keeping it below 1 is the way forward I feel.
Reply
#58
(04-30-2020, 09:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's no settled science on the matter, what we do know is that the opportunity cost for peoples' livelihoods is horrendous.

What if we're doing entirely the wrong thing?
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/coul...OoMt7Bql5s

Here's another argument in that sort of viewpoint. Thing is, we won't know until we look back, I don't think, as to the efficacy of all the different strategies.https://www.dailywire.com/news/israeli-s...ency-chair

I do wonder whether, by the time the virus threat has gone away, whether there will be massive differences in death rates. I am minded to think not.
Reply
#59
(05-01-2020, 07:36 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 09:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's no settled science on the matter, what we do know is that the opportunity cost for peoples' livelihoods is horrendous.

What if we're doing entirely the wrong thing?
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/coul...OoMt7Bql5s

Here's another argument in that sort of viewpoint. Thing is, we won't know until we look back, I don't think, as to the efficacy of all the different strategies.https://www.dailywire.com/news/israeli-s...ency-chair

I do wonder whether, by the time the virus threat has gone away, whether there will be massive differences in death rates. I am minded to think not.

You genuinely believe that the 30 odd thousand extra deaths in the 1st 4 months of the year will just net out?
Reply
#60
(05-01-2020, 09:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-01-2020, 07:36 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 09:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's no settled science on the matter, what we do know is that the opportunity cost for peoples' livelihoods is horrendous.

What if we're doing entirely the wrong thing?
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/coul...OoMt7Bql5s

Here's another argument in that sort of viewpoint. Thing is, we won't know until we look back, I don't think, as to the efficacy of all the different strategies.https://www.dailywire.com/news/israeli-s...ency-chair

I do wonder whether, by the time the virus threat has gone away, whether there will be massive differences in death rates. I am minded to think not.

You genuinely believe that the 30 odd thousand extra deaths in the 1st 4 months of the year will just net out?

We're going to have to wait until next year to get an answer to that but it's certainly got some logic to it. Given that somewhere like 95%(?) of the people who have died from CV-19 have had serious underlying medical conditions it is a possibility that quite a few would have died anyway quite soon. If the number of deaths start to go below their mean levels in the autumn/winter then surely it's as a result of the rates adjusting, the extent of that could be anywhere from a small bump evening out over several years to a short term blip.

That's why the Spanish flu was so devastating compared with other recent pandemics, it was particularly deadly to the young and healthy relative to the older population.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)