04-30-2020, 12:41 PM
|
Is Lockdown Counter Productive?
|
|
04-30-2020, 01:06 PM
What opportunity cost are you talking about, and is that lost or just delayed. You talk about lives ruined and reference 2008, how many lives were ruined then? And of those 'ruined' how many bounced back? At times when we have to take action you talk about ideological points.
I'll repeat a very simple argument - the last unchecked virus to hit Europe wiped out 50 million globally, I'm not certain we want to let a virus run like that ever again. Were those 50 million (living in less dense and therefore less transferrable conditions at the time btw and yes I do know about the spread in the trenches) worth the final outcome? Action had to be took, letting it run its course was never an option. I, like you, am ok financially so am probably not the best person to ask but no number of businesses that have to close and the jobs that go with it are worth an inflated number of deaths (unless you are arguing that the deaths wouldn't have occurred). Over the last few years we have had your view that we are one of the most resilient nations on the planet and will recover from any short term hots, are you saying we won't recover, and business won't restart and jobs won't be available?
04-30-2020, 01:51 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-30-2020, 01:54 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(04-30-2020, 12:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-30-2020, 12:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The ideology is so all encompassing that seeing anything outside of it’s constraints isn’t possible. Liberty for who? Those that can absorb the cost of shielding themselves from the situation. without government help? Are all those billionaires pushing for easing lockdown going to be putting themselves at risk? Those that are in the lowest category of risk? Those that may live in less built up areas where contact with others is less? Or those forced to work in places where they can’t self isolate? Or those that have underlying health conditions? Or those not adequately protected on the front line against the disease? The trouble with liberty is some people’s choices are more limited than others and in most cases the rich are afforded the most ‘liberty’ whilst the weakest have very limited choices. Let’s not dress this up as a libertarian argument it’s far from that as those seeking to force the governments hand to ease lockdown are curtailing others people’s ‘liberty’ to protect themselves.
04-30-2020, 01:58 PM
I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
04-30-2020, 02:03 PM
You want a debate but fail to respond to any of the questions in my post and choose to throw your toys out with a 'look at the lefties' post. You don't want a debate, you just want to sound clever with an idealistic point.
If you want to debate tell me how many lives were ruined in 2008 and of those how many stayed ruined. That was short term and this has all of the hallmarks of being the same. It will take some time to recover but we as a nation can take the hit and rebound can't we?
04-30-2020, 02:08 PM
(04-30-2020, 02:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: If you want to debate tell me how many lives were ruined in 2008 and of those how many stayed ruined. That was short term and this has all of the hallmarks of being the same. It will take some time to recover but we as a nation can take the hit and rebound can't we? Yes, we can. But the question I'm asking is what hit is necessary to take? That's the opportunity cost. Personally I believe this'll be far deeper than 2008 as the financial crisis didn't involve a complete shutdown of non-essential businesses, did it? (04-30-2020, 02:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(04-30-2020, 02:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: If you want to debate tell me how many lives were ruined in 2008 and of those how many stayed ruined. That was short term and this has all of the hallmarks of being the same. It will take some time to recover but we as a nation can take the hit and rebound can't we? It will bring the entire lot down within 3 years. The scaffolding was already deeply flawed. (04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down. I would. The green men on the traffic lights were way better than in the West.
04-30-2020, 02:16 PM
It doesn't matter about what the rulings are in this, people simply wouldn't be going into bars, restaurants and clubs at the moment (well not enough to sustain the business) anyway. As for other businesses, construction is still allowed, manufacturing will be back soon and quite a number of different shops have started opening again. I would imagine the next step will to allow shopping malls to open with guidelines in place as to what to do to protect, but again there will be limited customers and probably not enough to sustain business.
A lot of businesses have continued with working from home, so what businesses are you referring to? There is movement in the direction of getting back to work so it hasn't been a total shutdown, and the 6 week hit (so far) has been mitigated with furlough and other government schemes. It could be argued that the number of people hit financially (and terminally at that) will be far less than the number that would have died if we'd continued along the line of free trade to all.
04-30-2020, 02:33 PM
Open up shopping centres etc and you will see another wave come I honestly dont know how you can get round d the social distancing......pubs and leisure and food are going to take the biggest hit . Some places will be like a ghost town with no pubs and clubs as social distancing isnt going away until we get a vaccine so this is the new normal and fuck knows when we will be able to go to matches again .
04-30-2020, 02:38 PM
I agree Liq, even with any form of being allowed by the government it won't change peoples mindsets, they simply won't bother going there. I did see something about Wetherspoons planning to open in June, it will be interesting to see how many visit.
|
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)

