Very pissed off ratings
#11
(10-26-2019, 05:15 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I went today and I thought we were excellent second half, playing some exquisite football. Charlton first equaliser owed a lot to good fortune, I'll wait to see replay of penalty decision but it looked harsh from the Brummie. Terrific atmosphere and really entertaining game, just pity ny jinx struck again.

There 1st goal from were i was sitting i couldnt tell if it was on target but either way it was fortunate to hit someone and fell perfectly for there player . As for pen decision well it just summed the refs afternoons work up as that he hadnt got a clue  . Ive seen better parks refs .
Reply
#12
Don’t agree with the assessment.

Thought we were very good second half and stepped up a gear. Missed some chances to double the lead and even when down to 10 looked the most threatening.

Ref cost us the game.
Reply
#13
Not that far off with the ratings SW. strange game today - we were dreadful first 45 but excellent after the break (with 10 and 11).  A lot of complacent performances first half - if they had played for 80 instead of 45, we would have won 4-2. Conclusion correct tho - 2 points and 2 performances not good enough. 


Sj. 7. Huge save first half. Did well 2nd to take a few crosses
Furlong. 5.5. Out of position and careless at times. Missed 2 huge chances 
Ferguson 6. Too advanced for equaliser and silly tackle. Don’t give the ref a decision.  It cost us
Bartley. 7.5. Pick of the back 4. Only one to win first ball. Good block 1 half
Semi. 5.5. Thought he was poor today. Got hustled and suicide pass 1 half. Pen harsh but needs to sharpen up. 

Sawyers. 6. Did well 2 half but way too casual. Doesn’t do anything like enough out of possession. Needs to do better
Jake 6. Stupid booking gave us a problem. Plenty of effort over the 90
Pereira 8. Absolute king of the killer pass. Not enough effort first half but huge shift 2nd
MP. 6.5. Excellent goal but way too sluggish. Needs to up his workrate. Absolute sitter on 46
Dig. 7. V poor first half but excellent after break. Should of buried his chance

CA. 5. Atrocious first half. Really looks busted. Better linkplay 2 half as the runners played closer too him

Hal. 7.5. Great goal and played the point striker role well. Mom had he buried that chance 
Townsend. 6.5. Steady sub. Looked to get forward and plenty of energy.
Reply
#14
(10-26-2019, 05:58 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Don’t agree with the assessment.

Thought we were very good second half and stepped up a gear. Missed some chances to double the lead and even when down to 10 looked the most threatening.

Ref cost us the game.

I think I was too angry at FT.

For 20 mins in the second half we were excellent, but 2 points from 2 games against promoted sides at home isn’t good enough.
Reply
#15
I'd give Johnstone a 9. Made the defence look more solid and made some good saves.

Penalty was utter BS. Never in a million years a penalty.

I would give Austin a game or two off if Zohore is fit, but otherwise not. And definitely not start HRK - he's doing great as a sub.
Personally I think Austin will start scoring late November/December. He'll get a few.
Reply
#16
(10-26-2019, 05:59 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: Not that far off with the ratings SW. strange game today - we were dreadful first 45 but excellent after the break (with 10 and 11).  A lot of complacent performances first half - if they had played for 80 instead of 45, we would have won 4-2. Conclusion correct tho - 2 points and 2 performances not good enough. 


Sj. 7. Huge save first half. Did well 2nd to take a few crosses
Furlong. 5.5. Out of position and careless at times. Missed 2 huge chances 
Ferguson 6. Too advanced for equaliser and silly tackle. Don’t give the ref a decision.  It cost us
Bartley. 7.5. Pick of the back 4. Only one to win first ball. Good block 1 half
Semi. 5.5. Thought he was poor today. Got hustled and suicide pass 1 half. Pen harsh but needs to sharpen up. 

Sawyers. 6. Did well 2 half but way too casual. Doesn’t do anything like enough out of possession. Needs to do better
Jake 6. Stupid booking gave us a problem. Plenty of effort over the 90
Pereira 8. Absolute king of the killer pass. Not enough effort first half but huge shift 2nd
MP. 6.5. Excellent goal but way too sluggish. Needs to up his workrate. Absolute sitter on 46
Dig. 7. V poor first half but excellent after break. Should of buried his chance

CA. 5. Atrocious first half. Really looks busted. Better linkplay 2 half as the runners played closer too him

Hal. 7.5. Great goal and played the point striker role well. Mom had he buried that chance 
Townsend. 6.5. Steady sub. Looked to get forward and plenty of energy.

I think the system isn’t helping Furlong. 
Bilic wants him so far up the field he’s getting caught out too easily. 
Today was his worst game, but I think I was overly harsh, and maybe he’s losing part of his game for the benefit of the system.

Periera is just head and shoulders above this division. I love how much he tracks back as well. He is a steal.
Reply
#17
(10-26-2019, 05:15 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I went today and I thought we were excellent second half, playing some exquisite football. Charlton first equaliser owed a lot to good fortune, I'll wait to see replay of penalty decision but it looked harsh from the Brummie. Terrific atmosphere and really entertaining game, just pity ny jinx struck again.

said after the Cardiff game - we need a goal scorer - game should have been out of sight before they equalised - fair play to Charlton who played some good stuff although even their manager has admitted they were a tad fortunate.

Thought Bartley was immense today - best game I've seen him have for the Albion.
Reply
#18
(10-26-2019, 04:30 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Don't agree we were poor 2nd half, I thought we were excellent in an attacking sense just missing the finish

Agree. The worry is we are invariably flat in the 1st half.
Reply
#19
(10-26-2019, 07:28 PM)igorbalis Wrote:
(10-26-2019, 05:15 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I went today and I thought we were excellent second half, playing some exquisite football. Charlton first equaliser owed a lot to good fortune, I'll wait to see replay of penalty decision but it looked harsh from the Brummie. Terrific atmosphere and really entertaining game, just pity ny jinx struck again.

said after the Cardiff game - we need a goal scorer - game should have been out of sight before they equalised - fair play to Charlton who played some good stuff although even their manager has admitted they were a tad fortunate.

Thought Bartley was immense today - best game I've seen him have for the Albion.

Agreed. Thought he was magnificent today. Overall he isn't consistently good enough and I'd still bring Hegazi in for him next game but I have to give credit where it's due he was our best player today.
Reply
#20
(10-26-2019, 07:38 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(10-26-2019, 04:30 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Don't agree we were poor 2nd half, I thought we were excellent in an attacking sense just missing the finish

Agree. The worry is we are invariably flat in the 1st half.

Yet went in 1-0 up at the break.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: