Very pissed off ratings
#1
Not good enough today. Putting aside the incompetent twat in the middle, we just weren’t good enough, and 2 points from these, and 5 from the last 3 isn’t good enough. 

We were far too slow, to get started and far too pedestrian in our build up. 

We have a very strong plan a, but plan b seems a bit sketchy. We were crowded out on the middle, Charlton again pressed up high and left up top to give us problems.

Our central midfield is also becoming too easily dominated. Livermore and Sawyers just don’t dominate the space in the middle, and take too long to get the ball into dangerous spaces. Their 11 was finding far too much space between our lines, and the fact Darren Pratley bossed our midfield shows something needs tweaking.

Austin is also a busted flush. Sorry but he’s getting worse by the game and whilst his hold up play is ok, it’s not good enough to compensate for his lack of goals. That HRK now has more goals than him is alarming. 

We’re top of the league, and for the most part deserve to be here, but our last 3 games have shown that there’s a lot of work to do still.

Johnstone - 8 - excellent double save, and some smart stops throughout.

Furlong - 5 - worst game for us. Lost his man too easily and struggles when against a wingback. Should have buried his chance.
Bartley - 9 MOTM - thought he was excellent today. An absolute warrior.
Ajayi - 7 - Less composed than usual, seemed to get bullied when Aneke came on.
Ferguson - 7 - came back strongly after last week’s horror show, very unlucky to be sent off. Cracking tackle but can’t give refs decisions to make. 

Sawyers - 5 - worst game for us. Too complacent, too slow, and complicated it too much. When we play scrappers we need to look at how him and Livermore are played.
Livermore - 7 - did well after an early booking... thought he did the dirty work 

Diangana - 7 - should have scored, was well managed by Charlton.
Periera - 7 - cracking ball for the goal, and got a lot of rough treatment. Has to tone down the shithousing as he’s getting a reputation 
Phillips - 7 - should have killed the game but left his shooting boots at home. We have so much more balance with him in the team, no reason why he won’t get double figures.

Austin - 4 - sorry Charlie but it just isn’t happening. Didn’t even look like going close. The sooner Ken is back the better.

HRK - 7 - stunner. Was convinced it was the winner again. Did more than Austin in 15 mins.
Townsend - 7 - the right decision to balance us again. No complaints with him coming in.

Bilic - 8 - managed the game well, tinkered and clearly gave them a HT rollicking. 

That ref and his team should never ref at this level again. Consistently missed offsides, balls going out, lost control of the players, sent the wrong player off... was never a ref for Ferguson, and was never a penalty. An absolute disgrace and I hope Slav tears into him.
Reply
#2
(10-26-2019, 04:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Not good enough today. Putting aside the incompetent twat in the middle, we just weren’t good enough, and 2 points from these, and 5 from the last 3 isn’t good enough. 

We were far too slow, to get started and far too pedestrian in our build up. 

We have a very strong plan a, but plan b seems a bit sketchy. We were crowded out on the middle, Charlton again pressed up high and left up top to give us problems.

Our central midfield is also becoming too easily dominated. Livermore and Sawyers just don’t dominate the space in the middle, and take too long to get the ball into dangerous spaces. Their 11 was finding far too much space between our lines, and the fact Darren Pratley bossed our midfield shows something needs tweaking.

Austin is also a busted flush. Sorry but he’s getting worse by the game and whilst his hold up play is ok, it’s not good enough to compensate for his lack of goals. That HRK now has more goals than him is alarming. 

We’re top of the league, and for the most part deserve to be here, but our last 3 games have shown that there’s a lot of work to do still.

Johnstone - 8 - excellent double save, and some smart stops throughout.

Furlong - 5 - worst game for us. Lost his man too easily and struggles when against a wingback. Should have buried his chance.
Bartley - 9 MOTM - thought he was excellent today. An absolute warrior.
Ajayi - 7 - Less composed than usual, seemed to get bullied when Aneke came on.
Ferguson - 7 - came back strongly after last week’s horror show, very unlucky to be sent off. Cracking tackle but can’t give refs decisions to make. 

Sawyers - 5 - worst game for us. Too complacent, too slow, and complicated it too much. When we play scrappers we need to look at how him and Livermore are played.
Livermore - 7 - did well after an early booking... thought he did the dirty work 

Diangana - 7 - should have scored, was well managed by Charlton.
Periera - 7 - cracking ball for the goal, and got a lot of rough treatment. Has to tone down the shithousing as he’s getting a reputation 
Phillips - 7 - should have killed the game but left his shooting boots at home. We have so much more balance with him in the team, no reason why he won’t get double figures.

Austin - 4 - sorry Charlie but it just isn’t happening. Didn’t even look like going close. The sooner Ken is back the better.

HRK - 7 - stunner. Was convinced it was the winner again. Did more than Austin in 15 mins.
Townsend - 7 - the right decision to balance us again. No complaints with him coming in.

Bilic - 8 - managed the game well, tinkered and clearly gave them a HT rollicking. 

That ref and his team should never ref at this level again. Consistently missed offsides, balls going out, lost control of the players, sent the wrong player off... was never a ref for Ferguson, and was never a penalty. An absolute disgrace and I hope Slav tears into him.

Wouldn’t be so quick to slate the midfield two myself given that they were trying to pick up 4 opposition players at times. Their midfield diamond was a real problem for us and we didn’t do anything to try and deal with it.

Agree that was generally a poor showing overall.
Reply
#3
Regardless of your opinion of Austin, I've really not seen anything to suggest that Zohore is going to do any better. Hopefully I'm wrong. Certainly Austin needs a break
Reply
#4
Don't agree we were poor 2nd half, I thought we were excellent in an attacking sense just missing the finish
Reply
#5
Agree for the most part, though maybe a 6 for Ajayi he wasn't really at it today and could've gifted them another. Austin hasn't got it.

Sawyers is a graceful player that likes to play in a slow/medium tempo environment. He's very good but would be great if he found that extra bit of intensity.

Diangana wasn't bad but wasn't at his best either and should've buried his chance.

That's 3 games now where we haven't looked great and I'm choosing to take it as a positive that we're still picking up points during a "bad run" (such as it is) which all teams will have.

It was the same at the start of the season and then we suddenly looked like world beaters for a few games which I'm confident will come again. We've got Gibbs and Hegaxi to come back who are arguably 1st choice all day so no need to be too downhearted.

Anyway it was that cheating bastard of a ref that cost us
Reply
#6
(10-26-2019, 04:31 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Agree for the most part, though maybe a 6 for Ajayi he wasn't really at it today and could've gifted them another. Austin hasn't got it.

Sawyers is a graceful player that likes to play in a slow/medium tempo environment. He's very good but would be great if he found that extra bit of intensity.

Diangana wasn't bad but wasn't at his best either and should've buried his chance.

That's 3 games now where we haven't looked great and I'm choosing to take it as a positive that we're still picking up points during a "bad run" (such as it is) which all teams will have.

It was the same at the start of the season and then we suddenly looked like world beaters for a few games which I'm confident will come again. We've got Gibbs and Hegaxi to come back who are arguably 1st choice all day so no need to be too downhearted.

Anyway it was that cheating bastard of a ref that cost usrgusion dec

Wasn't there but saw it on a decent stream, and I think with VAR it would have been  1 1, as I thought HRK handled it before his goal and the penalty decision was a disgrace . Ferguson decision looked correct (eventually)we also had more than enough chances to win it easily, Pereira looked very frustrated at times, after delivering some brilliant balls.
Reply
#7
I’d knock a point off HRK just for missing that sitter at the end. Did well apart from that.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#8
I went today and I thought we were excellent second half, playing some exquisite football. Charlton first equaliser owed a lot to good fortune, I'll wait to see replay of penalty decision but it looked harsh from the Brummie. Terrific atmosphere and really entertaining game, just pity ny jinx struck again.
Reply
#9
Felt we were better today than Tuesday and was far more relaxed about the outcome even with 10 men than I did against Barnsley (almost wanted the ref to blow for full time as soon as we equalised...). Second half was, at times, excellent and the fact is one of the most ridiculous penalty decisions ever has cost us 2 points today. The ref seemed desperate to give it and the free kick a couple of moments before seemed very soft too.
Stand out for me today were SJ, Bartley and Livermore but sadly Charlie Austin was as poor as ever. 2 points from the last 2 games is, however, disappointing but top of the league despite everything and this season has a far more optimistic feel about it.
Reply
#10
Generally agree with SW4s ratings.

Quick word for Johnstone - thought he did well today. Smart double save in the first half, unlucky with first goal, and the pen was a joke. Credit where it is due.

Ferguson's suspension isn't a disaster - he needs a breather.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)