AF beers...
#41
(11-18-2026, 08:53 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-18-2026, 08:26 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Lucky saint I find wish washy and a bit metalic. But in general AF has come on leaps and bounds, luckily for me at the moment.

The key for me is not to compare them with 'full fat' beers. They are a different product entirely. But many are so much better than drinking soft drinks. And by and large much better for you as they are just made from 4/5 ingredients and you get the benefit of the brewing/fermentation.

This. The nearest I'll get to a Lucky Saint again is from a fair way away, sporting a pair of binoculars.

You'll look fu**ing weird in Tesco's like that.
Reply
#42
(11-18-2026, 08:10 AM)11amstart Wrote:
(11-17-2026, 07:34 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Another for Erdinger here. I sometimes have 2 of them mixed with 2 normal beers if I’m driving over a length of time.
Guinness Zero decent too.
It’s really a case of if you’re the sort that sups pints you need the volume.
I had Lucky Saint at a wedding in the summer and after 2 couldn’t face another.

In the summer, a barman convinced me to have a taster of Lucky Saint, saying AF beers had come a long way recently. The colour and head looked ok, but it didn’t taste good. However, despite there being (for me) a clear difference with its alcoholic brother, a cold Guinness Zero is palatable.

Yup - Lucky Saint is atrocious. It neither recreates the taste or a beer, nor does it actually taste nice as a stand alone drink. I've no idea how it has become such a fixture on the AF scene, it's utterly revolting, and I don't know anyone who has tried it and thought I'll order that again next time I'm out.

Guinness Zero absolutely the best of the lot...
Reply
#43
Unlucky Saint. Fuggin atrocious.
Reply
#44
Nolia by Beak is hands down the best AF beer I've tried. So good
Reply
#45
Agree on Lucky Saint being awful and Guinness 0 being pretty good.

The best ones I've tried are Williams Bros Joker AF which you rarely see south of the border. It's the only IPA that I've found to be decent. Most AF lagers are 'fine' but most IPAs are awful.

The other one which is somewhat left field is Leffe. I'm not a massive Leffe fan but I don't hate it. The Leffe AF is to me, indistinguishable and currently the best AF beer I've tried. Couldn't have a lot of them mind.
Reply
#46
(11-18-2026, 12:35 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Agree on Lucky Saint being awful and Guinness 0 being pretty good.

The best ones I've tried are Williams Bros Joker AF which you rarely see south of the border. It's the only IPA that I've found to be decent. Most AF lagers are 'fine' but most IPAs are awful.

The other one which is somewhat left field is Leffe. I'm not a massive Leffe fan but I don't hate it. The Leffe AF is to me, indistinguishable and currently the best AF beer I've tried. Couldn't have a lot of them mind.

Interesting you say this about Leffe. For me Leffe has a very distinctive taste presumably due to it's strength? If that taste is replicated I'd definitely be trying it the next time I'm coerced into driving. That doesnt happen too often, fortunately,  but when it does I'llhave Guiness Zero. There is a taste difference , but as someone said upthread, it satisfies the urge for volume. I was at the Hare and Hounds a few months ago and I swear half the audience were on Guiness Zero.
Reply
#47
If there is no alcoholic effect from my alcoholic drink I wouldn’t bother drinking any of them for the taste alone. Lager or beer without the reward that alcohol can bring is a pretty bitter tasting drink. What would be/is the point of gin or vodka two horrible tasting drinks to start with, if they are alcohol free!

I appreciate tastebuds differ.. Wink
Reply
#48
Guinness zero on tap is easily the best, but haven't seen a pub this side of the Irish sea selling it. In cans it's also OK, but a long way off the real thing. Haven't found a AF lager / beer that I like to drink. Adrian Childs had a good tip if you want a few beers without any worries about getting drunk, half a soda water and half a lager in a pint glass, about 1.25 units in a pint a decent drink, refreshing without the sweetness of a regular shandy.
Reply
#49
(11-18-2026, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If there is no alcoholic effect from my alcoholic drink I wouldn’t bother drinking any of them for the taste alone. Lager or beer without the reward that alcohol can bring is a pretty bitter tasting drink. What would be/is the point of gin or vodka two horrible tasting drinks to start with, if they are alcohol free!

I appreciate tastebuds differ.. Wink

I totally agree. Which is why when I stopped drinking many years ago (I couldn’t even if I wanted to anyway, due to the sheer amount of painkillers I still have to take) I never went down this route. Consumption of AF beer was once best described to me (maybe even by one of you ponners on here) as like ‘having a wank, but being unable to cum’. 

The cynic in me also believes it’s a sinister way of keeping reformed alcoholics, alcoholic. A bit like the Philip Morris’s out there desperate to tap into the burgeoning vape market, in the hope of luring people back. 

A nice alternative, but there are far tastier soft drinks available. For instance, mango juice is now my ‘go to’ when ten years ago it would almost automatically have been a Cobra or Kingfisher washing down my curry.

(11-18-2026, 02:41 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Guinness zero on tap is easily the best, but haven't seen a pub this side of the Irish sea selling it.  In cans it's also OK, but a long way off the real thing.  Haven't found a AF lager / beer that I like to drink.  Adrian Childs had a good tip if you want a few beers without any worries about getting drunk, half a soda water and half a lager in a pint glass, about 1.25 units in a pint a decent drink, refreshing without the sweetness of a regular shandy.

I’ve never really liked Guinness. However the above being said, of all the AF consumers I know out there this is the one most highly regarded among them.
Reply
#50
(11-18-2026, 04:14 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-18-2026, 01:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If there is no alcoholic effect from my alcoholic drink I wouldn’t bother drinking any of them for the taste alone. Lager or beer without the reward that alcohol can bring is a pretty bitter tasting drink. What would be/is the point of gin or vodka two horrible tasting drinks to start with, if they are alcohol free!

I appreciate tastebuds differ.. Wink

I totally agree. Which is why when I stopped drinking many years ago (I couldn’t even if I wanted to anyway, due to the sheer amount of painkillers I still have to take) I never went down this route. Consumption of AF beer was once best described to me (maybe even by one of you ponners on here) as like ‘having a wank, but being unable to cum’. 

The cynic in me also believes it’s a sinister way of keeping reformed alcoholics, alcoholic. A bit like the Philip Morris’s out there desperate to tap into the burgeoning vape market, in the hope of luring people back. 

A nice alternative, but there are far tastier soft drinks available. For instance, mango juice is now my ‘go to’ when ten years ago it would almost automatically have been a Cobra or Kingfisher washing down my curry.

(11-18-2026, 02:41 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Guinness zero on tap is easily the best, but haven't seen a pub this side of the Irish sea selling it.  In cans it's also OK, but a long way off the real thing.  Haven't found a AF lager / beer that I like to drink.  Adrian Childs had a good tip if you want a few beers without any worries about getting drunk, half a soda water and half a lager in a pint glass, about 1.25 units in a pint a decent drink, refreshing without the sweetness of a regular shandy.

I’ve never really liked Guinness. However the above being said, of all the AF consumers I know out there this is the one most highly regarded among them.

Sipping a mango juice whilst people throw down pints is a tough ask, if you're used to beer. I did a month without drinking in the late 90s and found my mouth just tasted of sugar on a Saturday and Sunday morning,
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: