Phillips
#11
(11-04-2026, 09:40 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Phillips and Mepham make a very poor pairing. Campbell is the calming and organizing influence who improves both of them. Mepham is streets ahead of Phillips as a footballer and will surely be first choice.

MOL made a few good saves last night (which I doubt Griffiths or Wildsmith would have managed), but his composure went right down the toilet once he had the Chuckle Brothers in front of him. Let's hope George is fit soon.

Agree, plus Mepham appears more comfortable on the right.
Reply
#12
Shows how quickly things can shift these days - prior to the head wobbles in the derby he was being lauded for being a beast!

Campbell is one of the best centre halves in the league so it's not really helpful to compare anyone to him. That being said even he has a wobble in him.
Reply
#13
Phillips is not well suited to the way we are playing at the moment and it was obvious we'd concede once he had to come on. He was a complete calamity under Mason and really cost us in both derbies.

His passing isn't really the problem, I think he's got quite good vision and plays some good forward balls out of defence which is useful in transition and in a game where we're under the cosh and dealing with balls into the box he seems like a super star who could head anything away but that's also one of his weaknesses.

Last night his two key deficiencies combined to give Southampton a goal. He's followed a man who is already marked into the box rather than being aware of the player who ultimately gets the ball and then when the ball goes past him he tries to throw his head at it and takes himself out of the game when he could have just turned towards the the ball and attempted a block.

I think he's great to bring on as an extra defender when you're holding onto a lead, or dealing with a lot of high balls into the box, but I really hope we bring in another centre back in January.
Reply
#14
(11-04-2026, 01:46 PM)SeanFlynnsPressUps Wrote: Phillips is not well suited to the way we are playing at the moment and it was obvious we'd concede once he had to come on. He was a complete calamity under Mason and really cost us in both derbies.

His passing isn't really the problem, I think he's got quite good vision and plays some good forward balls out of defence which is useful in transition and in a game where we're under the cosh and dealing with balls into the box he seems like a super star who could head anything away but that's also one of his weaknesses.

Last night his two key deficiencies combined to give Southampton a goal. He's followed a man who is already marked into the box rather than being aware of the player who ultimately gets the ball and then when the ball goes past him he tries to throw his head at it and takes himself out of the game when he could have just turned towards the the ball and attempted a block.

I think he's great to bring on as an extra defender when you're holding onto a lead, or dealing with a lot of high balls into the box, but I really hope we bring in another centre back in January.

I think a Saints player was in the way which meant he missed his header. I was fuming initially but it looks like he may have been impeded.
Reply
#15
Perhaps they deserve a fresh start this campaign after being so poorly managed by the man who signed them, and his successor. But - at times - it was hard to believe last term that this was the pairing that saw Bournemouth promoted.

So who is to say they can’t rekindle that.

But until then, either will do, but preferably alongside GC. I hope he’s not out for too long (any news there?) as he’s one of the best readers of a game we have.
Reply
#16
Coincidence, or has Mepham’s upturn in form coincided with him playing on the right alongside Campbell? He had to shift to the left last night to accommodate Phillips, so rather than just being a straight like-for-like replacement the balance of the defence was upset as well.
Reply
#17
(11-04-2026, 04:02 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Coincidence, or has Mepham’s upturn in form coincided with him playing on the right alongside Campbell? He had to shift to the left last night to accommodate Phillips, so rather than just being a straight like-for-like replacement the balance of the defence was upset as well.

Aye, can't help.
Reply
#18
Hopefully that 45 mins will help Phillips blow cobwebs off re Saturday because he just makes me so nervous.
Reply
#19
Don’t think he’s being spacegoated, but that term is rarely used correctly.
He was at fault for the goal, completely missed a straightforward header, but he recovered ok and helped to keep them out when they upped a gear or two 2nd half so was part of a decent result.

I do worry about him and Mepham, though, it gives me Nam style flashbacks.
Hope Campbell’s injury is not too serious and he is back after the break. He stayed in the players area for the full 90 (didn’t leave early to get the 74) which I hope is a good sign.
Reply
#20
(11-04-2026, 02:12 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Perhaps they deserve a fresh start this campaign after being so poorly managed by the man who signed them, and his successor. But - at times - it was hard to believe last term that this was the pairing that saw Bournemouth promoted.

So who is to say they can’t rekindle that.

But until then, either will do, but preferably alongside GC. I hope he’s not out for too long (any news there?) as he’s one of the best readers of a game we have.

That is very misleading

Phillips played in 17 of the last 18 games in 21/22 for them, the one game he missed for them saw him replaced by Mepham.  In those 17 games Mepham started none of them and only came on 3 times as a sub, they won all three. Bournemouth had Smith and Kelly there and Hill in reserve. They also had Rogers on loan from Man City that season
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)