Jesus de Miguel
#31
According to Reuters, the Spanish police have opened an investigation for involuntary manslaughter.

Re the ice hockey death, Matt Petgrave (the player who caused the death) was an enforcer who had reputation for endangering opposing players.
Reply
#32
(11-03-2026, 05:08 PM)WWHO Wrote: According to Reuters, the Spanish police have opened an investigation for involuntary manslaughter.

Re the ice hockey death, Matt Petgrave (the player who caused the death) was an enforcer who had reputation for endangering opposing players.

From the BBC:

Under Spanish law, any death that is deemed non-natural automatically triggers a judicial inquiry.
Reply
#33
If the player hadn't suffered a cardiac arrest and subsequently died, I don't think anywhere near as many people would be highlighting the challenge. To me, it isn't overly outrageous. I'm certainly not defending it as a good footballing challenge, but we see these types of collisions fairly frequently, and thankfully, on most occasions, both players get up and walk away.

There was a clip circulating on social media the other day of a rugby player stamping on an opponent's leg. It was absolutely brutal. Thankfully, no injury resulted, but that incident seemingly demonstrated far more intent to injure and harm an opponent than this one - hence why it went viral. 

The first I'd heard of this particular incident was following the awful news of the player's passing. My point is that if the challenge had been horrendous, I would have expected to have seen it circulating much sooner, much like the rugby incident. While the outcome is obviously tragic, I don't think it should influence how we assess the challenge itself.

I've watched this incident numerous times now, and even knowing the outcome, I genuinely don't believe there was any malice in the challenge. It was reckless, absolutely, but I think that, in that split second, the goalkeeper has recognised that he's the last man. If he doesn't take the player out, it's almost certainly a goal anyway. So, he's attempted to win the header while simultaneously ensuring he takes the man with him, effectively sacrificing himself to prevent a goal.

We've all seen players 'take one for the team' in these situations. It's an unfortunate but familiar part of football.

I'm not suggesting it was a reasonable decision, because it was reckless, but I just don't see any thuggish behaviour in it. I genuinely believe it was a footballing challenge, driven by footballing logic.

When I think of truly abhorrent challenges, nothing comes close to Thatcher on Mendes. That was, as far as I'm concerned, attempted murder. This incident, as awful and reckless as it was, was nowhere near that.

I think people are incorrectly interpreting the speed and force of the collision as evidence of an intention to cause harm. Is it not simply a case of ensuring he gets something, man or ball, to stop the attack? This is professional football, played at a high standard and at considerable pace. Collisions can often look far worse than the actual intent behind them.

Maybe I'm being naive. Maybe I'm putting too much faith in footballing logic and hoping there's nothing malicious behind it. That's possible. But it's my honest interpretation of what I've seen.

It's tragic, it's awful, but I don't believe it's criminal. Ultimately, the only person who knows the true intention behind that challenge is the goalkeeper himself. None of us can say with any certainty what was going through his mind. I can't say there wasn't malice any more than someone else can definitively claim there was.
Reply
#34
(11-03-2026, 05:21 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 05:08 PM)WWHO Wrote: According to Reuters, the Spanish police have opened an investigation for involuntary manslaughter.

Re the ice hockey death, Matt Petgrave (the player who caused the death) was an enforcer who had reputation for endangering opposing players.

From the BBC:

Under Spanish law, any death that is deemed non-natural automatically triggers a judicial inquiry.

Ah, I didn't realise. Ta
Reply
#35
I feel pretty shitty typing up posts defending someone who has ultimately taken a life, BTW. But that's how I honestly feel. I don't think I need to apologise for my view, but I can understand how it'll cause friction.

It's just a fucked up situation, and there's lots of people who need a lot of help right now, which I hope they receive. GK included. Whatever your thoughts on the challenge, I think it's reasonable to conclude he's not intended to kill someone - that's gonna fuck him up.
Reply
#36
Leading with his knee as he did, it's impossible to see how he could have been making a legitimate challenge for the ball. A charge of manslaughter would not be out of order IMO. I think the goalie is in big trouble here.
Reply
#37
(11-03-2026, 06:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Leading with his knee as he did, it's impossible to see how he could have been making a legitimate challenge for the ball. A charge of manslaughter would not be out of order IMO. I think the goalie is in big trouble here.

You mean the way he'd have been taught to jump for high balls as a goalkeeper his entire life? Behave Chesh.
Reply
#38
I'm no jumping expert, bit I'm sure knees being high and sort of away from your body is one of the elements of a jump you need in order to complete the action?!

I'm here for reasonable arguments, and I can understand anyone being against my view, but using the natural action of jumping isn't the right way to go about it?
Reply
#39
(11-03-2026, 06:25 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm no jumping expert, bit I'm sure knees being high and sort of away from your body is one of the elements of a jump you need in order to complete the action?!

I'm here for reasonable arguments, and I can understand anyone being against my view, but using the natural action of jumping isn't the right way to go about it?

Keepers are taught to lead with a knee when coming and jumping for the ball, but what the hell is he doing on the halfway line
Reply
#40
(11-03-2026, 06:29 PM)strawman Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 06:25 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm no jumping expert, bit I'm sure knees being high and sort of away from your body is one of the elements of a jump you need in order to complete the action?!

I'm here for reasonable arguments, and I can understand anyone being against my view, but using the natural action of jumping isn't the right way to go about it?

Keepers are taught to lead with a knee when coming and jumping for the ball, but what the hell is he doing on the halfway line

Well, quite. What was the game situation? 

Even if it's unreasonable for him to be on the half way line, it's a very long stretch to say he's a murderer.

I play in goal at 7-a-side very occasionally, and it's so easy to forget where your goal is, and to wonder up the pitch as you follow the play. Maybe that's why? Does that mentality translate to XI a-side. Maybe that's just me!

Seriously, though, it's very easy to lose your place on the field of play.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)