Defence
#1
has come in for some criticism, but only 3 teams have a better goals conceded record, and they are all tied on 1 goal conceded less than us.

Do we make mistakes in defence, yes we do, everyone does, but generally I think we defend well as a team. Wolves and second half at Boro are perhaps the only occasions where I would say our defending fell significantly below the standard required.

If there was a weakness in the team it was in scoring goals, the last 4 games have seen an uptick in that department, but we remain the lowest scorers in the top 8, which probably shows how previous to the Wrexham game how much scoring was an issue.

My only issue with the defence is with one man down already, we are an injury and suspension from a real problem. But I think that's an issue the majority of clubs in the championship have.
Reply
#2
Youd imagine we will target an experienced centre half or utility defender in the window.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#3
(11-01-2026, 09:16 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: has come in for some criticism, but only 3 teams have a better goals conceded record, and they are all tied on 1 goal conceded less than us.

Do we make mistakes in defence, yes we do, everyone does, but generally I think we defend well as a team. Wolves and second half at Boro are perhaps the only occasions where I would say our defending fell significantly below the standard required.

If there was a weakness in the team it was in scoring goals, the last 4 games have seen an uptick in that department, but we remain the lowest scorers in the top 8, which probably shows how previous to the Wrexham game how much scoring was an issue.

My only issue with the defence is with one man down already, we are an injury and suspension from a real problem. But I think that's an issue the majority of clubs in the championship have.

Some criticism…. from Josh. Who is renowned for not having a fucking scooby doo about anything and pretending to be at the game, whilst posting minute by minute meltdowns on the match Fred. The big Bilbo Baggins.
Reply
#4
It's a little paradoxical, as generally we're well organised and defend well as a team. But we do give far too many sloppy goals away, and it needs to be fixed somehow. We can't keep conceeding at least 1 goal per game and expect to get away with it as we have been. Sooner or later it will catch up with us, you'd think.

2 clean sheets against a very poor Deby team, and Watford at home, is not good enough. We must get back to keeping clean sheets on a relatively regular basis. It's unrealistic to expect them every game, of course, but we do need to get back to being difficult to score against.

It's pretty much the only criticism I have of the team as a whole so far this season. Well, that and poor set pieces.
Reply
#5
We seemingly only concede two types of goal - wide ball into the 6 yard box that is not dealt with, and unchallenged runner from deep to the edge of the penalty area. Yesterday's goal against was a variation on the second, albeit from a current international and via a deflection.

I think the annoyance is we've gone from being pretty solid at the back at the end of last season with plenty of clean sheets to a seemingly Masonesque ability to concede from every opposition shot (first twenty against Blackburn).

I think the criticism is reasonable, but the stats provided suggest it shouldn't be entirely unexpected for a second tier team with a thin squad. Campbell's form is probably the difference. As mentioned, an injury or two might mean several places difference come the end of the season. Less of a big deal now 8 finish in the playoffs?
Reply
#6
Yesterday's goal in isolation, I could hold my hands up and say 'fair enough, it's Bowen, and he's quality ', but it's that type of stand off defending, and lack of concentration, that has contributed to many of our goals. It wasn't a one off, it's part of a worrying theme in the bigger picture. Also, having watched the replay this morning Max should be doing better there. He's been excellent so far this season, and making a mistake in a 1-3 win is as good a time as any to make an error.

That sloppy goal was the only blot on an excellent performance. 0-3 wouldn't have been a flattering score.
Reply
#7
Weirdly both arguments are right. We are both good defensively but poor at keeping clean sheets. We are second in terms of the number of goals conceded against our xG conceded (-5.05). Interestingly we are also second for shots conceded inside our penalty area. Whilst we are 4th best in terms of goals conceded inside the box.

Our defence is actually really good at stopping stuff. We just give up too many good positions to the opposition which means we have often conceded what seems like sloppy goals. It's worth noting we haven't conceded any goals on 'fast breaks' this year.

I think this shows we have been a little deep with our defensive block at times and as mentioned a few times we are sloppy in possession in the middle third too often which means we get punished on transition when we don't get our counter press right, which is something we try and do which is showed with us being second for number of tackles made and 3rd for number off high turnovers.

We are often the master of our own fate with goals conceded and it's playing silly passes in the middle. And then our defensive line being under too much pressure in our third.

Good news is I think it's more tactical/execution rather than poor individuals.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#8
Not saying my opinion is right, but it's that - my opinion. Also, I'm not claiming to be some defensive expert, but just using my eyes and seeing the game how I do it feels like we're actually really well organised, but simultaneously just fuck up with silly goals conceded.

It's the team equivalent of Matt Carbon. Excellent for 85 mins, then have 5 mins where you just go AWOL!
Reply
#9
(11-01-2026, 11:26 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Not saying my opinion is right, but it's that - my opinion. Also, I'm not claiming to be some defensive expert, but just using my eyes and seeing the game how I do it feels like we're actually really well organised, but simultaneously just fuck up with silly goals conceded.

It's the team equivalent of Matt Carbon. Excellent for 85 mins, then have 5 mins where you just go AWOL!

Youre not wrong, Josh. We are not keeping enough clean sheets, which makes a decent defence pointless. But I think the problems are not where you might think. For example you pointed out styles not being close enough and MoL doing better etc. Styles did well and was close enough in fact to block Bowens shot and MOL had no chance after the deflection. 

IMO the problem came from sloppy play in CM and not getting the counter press right. Price, if anyone was a little to blame off the ball as he should have been more aggressive when the ball dropped in CM as he was facing the play. But after that if was rotten luck that Bowen got a deflection that whizzed passed MOL off his near post.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#10
(11-01-2026, 09:54 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(11-01-2026, 09:16 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: has come in for some criticism, but only 3 teams have a better goals conceded record, and they are all tied on 1 goal conceded less than us.

Do we make mistakes in defence, yes we do, everyone does, but generally I think we defend well as a team. Wolves and second half at Boro are perhaps the only occasions where I would say our defending fell significantly below the standard required.

If there was a weakness in the team it was in scoring goals, the last 4 games have seen an uptick in that department, but we remain the lowest scorers in the top 8, which probably shows how previous to the Wrexham game how much scoring was an issue.

My only issue with the defence is with one man down already, we are an injury and suspension from a real problem. But I think that's an issue the majority of clubs in the championship have.

Some criticism…. from Josh. Who is renowned for not having a fucking scooby doo about anything and pretending to be at the game, whilst posting minute by minute meltdowns on the match Fred. The big Bilbo Baggins.

In fairness to Josh, whose last post is read about Price was on the money, I was using his criticism of the defence, to start a thread praising the defence, who I have think been the bedrock of our good start to the season. Out of  possession we defend well as a team
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)