The near impossible task of the finances to have a family
#51
“experience being passed on”  Big Grin

I have no skin in the game but that made me laugh.

I’ve started posting now so I’ll offer my tuppeth. 

There was a no ‘right time’ to have kids for almost everyone.

Maybe we shouldn’t get too concerned with slowing birth rate (not YET population decline), as a whole, when the world population has grown by 10% (c.800m) in 10 years and we’re seriously fucking the planet up…

But the decline in population is likely and, for an economy to survive, we will need to rethink this country’s attitude to IMMIGRUNTS.

Most of B1’s points are good but the idea that you can dip in and out of private childcare when relatives can’t help (and are probably still working) is outdated. The shortage of supply that Boring mentioned is very real and if you’re not committing to regular hours I suspect it’s impossible these days (it was 15 years ago in Brum)

Anyway, you two, FODTPB
Reply
#52
(10-30-2026, 06:25 PM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: It does appear to true that many potential parents are choosing not to have kids due to the limitations of their own financial situation. The really unfortunate part imho is that these are precisely the type of people that the country needs to be parenting future generations i.e. sensible people that are aware and concerned about their ability to successfully raise a child. Instead they go out to work and end up funding others who may live on benefits and have absolutely no qualms about creating another life irrespective of whether they can afford to or not. Instead some of these use it as a way of securing council houses etc and just assume the state will take care of matters regardless. My wife works in social housing and deals with many such people on a daily basis.

Obviously a broad brush generalisation and every situation is different but with even a mild truth in this, it results in a transition from a nation raising well looked after and balanced children to ones where they are more on their own from the outset.

I totally agree there should be more support for working families and I have no issue paying tax to assist in this process.

Good post.
Reply
#53
(10-30-2026, 06:04 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 05:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 05:50 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 05:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm not the one missing the point here pal, you're in outright denial at the extent of the issue of housing and childcare costs against historical norms and the barrier that is to people having kids while assuming I've not looked at personal and professional sacrifices to have one just because I want a stable living situation and not have to leave them at home unattended in early childhood. The current plan is for us to move fucking country if you want to talk about being "prepared" to make sacrifices.

You do seem to be getting a bit narked here 'pal'. Again misquote me all you like but good luck with your endeavours in having a child, you'll find that all the prep in the world won't be enough or at the same time needed.

Someone's annoyed at being condescendingly talked down to? Quelle suprise?

You'll have to point out the condescension, or which the older generation call experience being passed on. I've said all along, you are not in a unique situation of having tough times when looking at bringing a kid into the world, stop looking for reasons not to and find a way if that's what you want. Sorry if i'm not sympathetic enough for you but i'm just saying that people find a way from experience.

Your advice is not helpful to me. I know there are risks in having kids, I know there are financial and personal sacrifices involved. I know the opportunities and experiences of having children are rewarding and can outweigh varying levels of security. Do you think I don't know this? We could be forever childless, we'd be significantly better off financially if we did. I also know that if we choose to have kids here we are in a privileged position nationally with respect to the rest of my generation in that we live close to my parents to manage out-of-work childcare and live in a lower cost of living area relative to a lot of the same generation while being well paid relative to most of the country regardless of generation. We have already weighed it up, the childcare options elsewhere during working hours and better quality of life make it a better place to raise kids in spite of the lack of family safety net and job insecurity due to employment visa restrictions. I am not talking about myself.

This isn't about my personal or your personal circumstances, it's about the two biggest barriers to having children which are deferring decisions to have children across the board for people that want children. We as a country have moved towards a service economy and two-income household model, the former concentrates productive labour generally into specific economies and that drives up demand for services in those areas, in this case housing and childcare, and often making it harder to rely on family networks if people move sufficiently far away which is becoming more of a reality as more jobs are centred on fewer but stronger economic centres. Obviously that was present when you had kids - especially the two-income household point - but the wider trend has made it more of a pronounced shift more generally. People generally, not in every case, want some level of stability before making major life decisions which having children is one of. Average age of a first time buyer and peak age of fertility (i.e. the age they're most likely to give birth) for women generally correlate to one another and have done historically, in 1980 it was around 26 for both, in 1990 it was around 28 for mothers and 29 for house buyers, in 2000 it was 29/30 for mothers and 30 for first time buyers, now it's mid-30s for mothers and 34 for first time buyers. You also see boom times generally having more births than recessions, that's why the baby boomer (postwar economic boom) and millennial (1980s and 1990s economic boom) cohorts are more populous than Gen X (1960s and 1970s decline) and younger Gen Z and Gen Alpha (2008 financial crash and slow recovery), when people's financial circumstances are stronger and more stable generally to be able to take greater risks. Housing costs are at an all time high both in real terms (recently surpassing the housing boom of 2005-2008) and relative to incomes (due to low wage growth) and childcare is stupidly expensive in this country due to regional demand pressures outstripping supply in areas with younger populations, lack of historic government support for free or subsidised childcare, a general shift away from multiple generations of family living close to each other due to the aforementioned economical trends and stuff like extremely restrictive legislation relative to peer countries.
Reply
#54
Being in the right financial situation to have children when they cost estimates of £150k- £200k up to 18 per child means only a tiny fraction of the population will ever have them.
Acting like kids are as relevant as a poodle for the economy is just ridiculous, as unless we have a radical change in the system then we’ll have to rely on immigration, that hot topic for the nation.
I’ve had 2 kids and I’m rare amongst my friends. 6 of us were our a few weeks ago and 4 of the guys, all now around 60, had no kids. The other mate had 1 kid.
All these 6 came from families where they had kids in the 60s-70s and 3-4 siblings, where the mum was at home to look after them.
Needing 2 incomes to keep a roof over your head now has meant many decent people who would have been great parents can’t have them.
It’s an incredibly complex situation but we could look to Norway and Denmark to see how it could be done. Of course we won’t though and idiots will still bemoan immigration, which will be needed to clean our arses in our nursing homes as we go ga ga.
Reply
#55
I’ll go back to what I said at the start - find a way and you will reap the benefits before you are too old. I can’t say my eldest was planned but we made do with neighbours and friends as we weren’t close, location wise, to our family, we scrambled and found a way by but waited 7 years until our 2nd because we really did struggle.

There will always be a reason why not to BB but looking at stats alone won’t help, especially floored stats that focus on one reason to justify, ifor example, f you think baby boomers were down to economic reasons and not the ‘we survived the war, fuck it’ reasons, I’ll guarantee you that my MIL born in 1950 (number 2 of 6) was not born into a family ready to have kids.

You have to look at the bigger picture and not just about finances, which is where your whole argument is based, kids and grandkids bring so so much more than you can ever expect no matter how much money you have ready for it.

I’ve basically tried throughout this to say don’t worry, it will work out, and you’ve taken that as ‘stop being a pussy and go for it’ and responded with ‘don’t tell me what to do, the stats tell me I can’t afford it’. Like I say, good luck, when you are older and not so defensive you might understand what I was saying.
Reply
#56
(10-30-2026, 06:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Being in the right financial situation to have children when they cost estimates of £150k- £200k up to 18 per child means only a tiny fraction of the population will ever have them.
Acting like kids are as relevant as a poodle for the economy is just ridiculous, as unless we have a radical change in the system then we’ll have to rely on immigration, that hot topic for the nation.
I’ve had 2 kids and I’m rare amongst my friends. 6 of us were our a few weeks ago and 4 of the guys, all now around 60, had no kids. The other mate had 1 kid.
All these 6 came from families where they had kids in the 60s-70s and 3-4 siblings, where the mum was at home to look after them.
Needing 2 incomes to keep a roof over your head now has meant many decent people who would have been great parents can’t have them.
It’s an incredibly complex situation but we could look to Norway and Denmark to see how it could be done. Of course we won’t though and idiots will still bemoan immigration, which will be needed to clean our arses in our nursing homes as we go ga ga.

An aside but I do feel the immigration point is one that requires actual sensible debate where the relative merits can be discussed without the usual emotional baggage from either side. 

Clearly not all immigration is the same - some is good and very helpful, fulfilling roles that we struggle to produce as a nation. But it is also true that some forms of immigration aren't helpful and are just placing a greater strain on an already strained society. I'd much rather the resources poured into that area are re-directed into helping the existing population.
Reply
#57
(10-30-2026, 06:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I’ll go back to what I said at the start - find a way and you will reap the benefits before you are too old. I can’t say my eldest was planned but we made do with neighbours and friends as we weren’t close, location wise, to our family, we scrambled and found a way by but waited 7 years until our 2nd because we really did struggle.

There will always be a reason why not to BB but looking at stats alone won’t help, especially floored stats that focus on one reason to justify, ifor example, f you think baby boomers were down to economic reasons and not the ‘we survived the war, fuck it’ reasons, I’ll guarantee you that my MIL born in 1950 (number 2 of 6) was not born into a family ready to have kids.

You have to look at the bigger picture and not just about finances, which is where your whole argument is based, kids and grandkids bring so so much more than you can ever expect no matter how much money you have ready for it.

I’ve basically tried throughout this to say don’t worry, it will work out, and you’ve taken that as ‘stop being a pussy and go for it’ and responded with ‘don’t tell me what to do, the stats tell me I can’t afford it’. Like I say, good luck, when you are older and not so defensive you might understand what I was saying.

Some good experience, being passed on, that
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#58
(10-30-2026, 07:38 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 06:59 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I’ll go back to what I said at the start - find a way and you will reap the benefits before you are too old. I can’t say my eldest was planned but we made do with neighbours and friends as we weren’t close, location wise, to our family, we scrambled and found a way by but waited 7 years until our 2nd because we really did struggle.

There will always be a reason why not to BB but looking at stats alone won’t help, especially floored stats that focus on one reason to justify, ifor example, f you think baby boomers were down to economic reasons and not the ‘we survived the war, fuck it’ reasons, I’ll guarantee you that my MIL born in 1950 (number 2 of 6) was not born into a family ready to have kids.

You have to look at the bigger picture and not just about finances, which is where your whole argument is based, kids and grandkids bring so so much more than you can ever expect no matter how much money you have ready for it.

I’ve basically tried throughout this to say don’t worry, it will work out, and you’ve taken that as ‘stop being a pussy and go for it’ and responded with ‘don’t tell me what to do, the stats tell me I can’t afford it’. Like I say, good luck, when you are older and not so defensive you might understand what I was saying.

Some good experience, being passed on, that

Arf, I see I’ve opened the door to more of this with a throw away comment. Appreciate it CC
Reply
#59
I’llbore myself out, soon enough  Big Grin
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#60
(10-30-2026, 05:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Someone's annoyed at being condescendingly talked down to? Quelle suprise?

You are a chippy fucker at the best of times.

I was brought up with the thick end of fuck all. I didn't appreciate how little until I was much older. Parents find a way you see.

B1 isn't being condescending, he's just telling you something you don't want to hear.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)