The near impossible task of the finances to have a family
#11
Sounds about right, we heard some horror stories in our NCT about parents with 3 girls wanting a boy and then having triplet girls. Don’t roll the dice.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#12
(10-30-2026, 11:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When you talk about cost Bertie you appear to be equating kids to an expense, something that will drain you of your funds with no return. Would it be better if you looked on the money spent on your kids as an investment with a non-financial return. I'm approaching 60 now and had kids young and there were times when we had nothing left at the end of a pay check, these were the days before the costs of phones or TV subscription or app subscriptions. I'm not complaining by the way, different generations have different struggles. I can tell you without any doubt that the joy I get from having kids and grandkids is greater than any return on investment seen in the traditional sense.

Then there is another angle, at some point in the future you will leave work and retire, and then what? You'll travel the world and do things as a couple - great, a worthy way of seeing out your days, something deserved and earned. However at some point one of you will pass and then without that family, without the kids and grandkids (and great grandkids) life will be lonely.

Family is everything, gather the biggest one around you that you can - it pays off in the end. And as for todays expense, you'll find a way.

This seems really ignorant of modern housing and childcare costs.
Reply
#13
(10-30-2026, 11:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When you talk about cost Bertie you appear to be equating kids to an expense, something that will drain you of your funds with no return. Would it be better if you looked on the money spent on your kids as an investment with a non-financial return. I'm approaching 60 now and had kids young and there were times when we had nothing left at the end of a pay check, these were the days before the costs of phones or TV subscription or app subscriptions. I'm not complaining by the way, different generations have different struggles. I can tell you without any doubt that the joy I get from having kids and grandkids is greater than any return on investment seen in the traditional sense.

Then there is another angle, at some point in the future you will leave work and retire, and then what? You'll travel the world and do things as a couple - great, a worthy way of seeing out your days, something deserved and earned. However at some point one of you will pass and then without that family, without the kids and grandkids (and great grandkids) life will be lonely.

Family is everything, gather the biggest one around you that you can - it pays off in the end. And as for todays expense, you'll find a way.

It's a gigantic topic and the post is purely on the effects on society and why it's needed for a balanced society.

I'm personally a very happy father. I am very close to both my kids. My post is merely pointing out what a weird  societal experiment we are having when half of women under 30 are childless and only a tiny minority can now make a decision that was second nature for previous generations.

I have a brother who has taken early retirement, has no family, but is a very small-minded and angry bloke despite having a lovely house paid off in a twee village. 

On paper he's worth 3 times as much as me, but my life has been 10 times richer.

It's all no reflection on people who don't have kids, as I wasn't that bothered. It's just a huge topic that I hear many families talk about but never seems to get a widespread airing.
Reply
#14
(10-30-2026, 11:04 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: Over the years I've been increasingly bewildered by the lack of help in this country to help decent families, by decent I mean ones where the parents want to add to society.

Most parents of schoolkids I know have a mixture of unbelievable stress or unbelievable debt, or both pushing them to breaking point.

It's a topic seldom mentioned, but it's little wonder that birthrate is at an all time low and broken families at an all time high.

The cost of raising two kids, mine are young adults out of education now, has been exhorbitant. They reckon it's £200k or so per kid. I get it.

This article, if you can get through the firewall, is one of the first to  address the issue I've read in a long time. https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columni...-0vqhtqqxh

The cost for me of having two kids has been I will probably certainly work to 67, if AI allows me to work, I will probably have to downsize to something a lot more modest than my current 3 bedroom semi, and I'm doing my upmost to scramble some kind of pension pot together.

My factory worker dad bought a house on his wage in 1970 now worth about £350k. That couldn't be done now.

Most people I know, honest about their finances in a similar position to me, have spoken to me of crippling debt. At one point we had £25k on credit, which we've now paid off. It wasn't for fancy holidays or leased cars either. It was just to keep a roof over our head.  I do just wonder why this massive crisis is so underspoken about.

People without kids have absolutely no idea whatsoever how difficult it is. They really don't! In fact I find it hard to relate to those who haven't gone through this, whilst certainly not making judgement on them.

Interested to hear thoughts of others on here.

This is down to one thing, and one thing only - the cost and availability of housing. We have not built enough homes in the right places for 50 years. 

Owner occupation is a distant dream unless you have the Bank of Mum & Dad. The rental market is so distorted by shortages, regulation and taxation that rents have gone sky high. In Dudley Borough you're looking at 50%+ increases in just 5 years.

Planning needs to be liberalised massively. Housebuilders need to be able to build affordably, rather than affordability being throttled by constant additions to the building code. Local authorities need to be able to sell housing bonds to those who'd otherwise invest in BTL.

But you'll need 20 years and the political will to do it. And for most people to stop being such fuckwitted NIMBYS about every scrubby field.
Reply
#15
(10-30-2026, 12:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 11:04 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: Over the years I've been increasingly bewildered by the lack of help in this country to help decent families, by decent I mean ones where the parents want to add to society.

Most parents of schoolkids I know have a mixture of unbelievable stress or unbelievable debt, or both pushing them to breaking point.

It's a topic seldom mentioned, but it's little wonder that birthrate is at an all time low and broken families at an all time high.

The cost of raising two kids, mine are young adults out of education now, has been exhorbitant. They reckon it's £200k or so per kid. I get it.

This article, if you can get through the firewall, is one of the first to  address the issue I've read in a long time. https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columni...-0vqhtqqxh

The cost for me of having two kids has been I will probably certainly work to 67, if AI allows me to work, I will probably have to downsize to something a lot more modest than my current 3 bedroom semi, and I'm doing my upmost to scramble some kind of pension pot together.

My factory worker dad bought a house on his wage in 1970 now worth about £350k. That couldn't be done now.

Most people I know, honest about their finances in a similar position to me, have spoken to me of crippling debt. At one point we had £25k on credit, which we've now paid off. It wasn't for fancy holidays or leased cars either. It was just to keep a roof over our head.  I do just wonder why this massive crisis is so underspoken about.

People without kids have absolutely no idea whatsoever how difficult it is. They really don't! In fact I find it hard to relate to those who haven't gone through this, whilst certainly not making judgement on them.

Interested to hear thoughts of others on here.

This is down to one thing, and one thing only - the cost and availability of housing. We have not built enough homes in the right places for 50 years. 

Owner occupation is a distant dream unless you have the Bank of Mum & Dad. The rental market is so distorted by shortages, regulation and taxation that rents have gone sky high. In Dudley Borough you're looking at 50%+ increases in just 5 years.

Planning needs to be liberalised massively. Housebuilders need to be able to build affordably, rather than affordability being throttled by constant additions to the building code. Local authorities need to be able to sell housing bonds to those who'd otherwise invest in BTL.

But you'll need 20 years and the political will to do it. And for most people to stop being such fuckwitted NIMBYS about every scrubby field.

I know we conversed about this many a moon ago but it seems idiotic that this option for LAs and people in general is not very high up the agenda.
Reply
#16
Without getting into tinfoil hat territory, there is definitely a case that allowing second salaries on mortgages had a horrendous impact on things. House prices naturally rose to take account of the extra spending power, meaning both partners now had to work, childcare costs came into play and got crazy expensive as they became an industry and then mortgage terms eventually become extended and so on.
Reply
#17
(10-30-2026, 11:54 AM)Fido Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 11:45 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: Try having twins!

A lad I worked with had two daughters and he and his wife really wanted a boy. She then got pregnant with twin girls and they ended up buying an old Transit as their family car to carry all the shite around with them!

I didn't know you worked with Henry the VIII.
Reply
#18
(10-30-2026, 12:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 11:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When you talk about cost Bertie you appear to be equating kids to an expense, something that will drain you of your funds with no return. Would it be better if you looked on the money spent on your kids as an investment with a non-financial return. I'm approaching 60 now and had kids young and there were times when we had nothing left at the end of a pay check, these were the days before the costs of phones or TV subscription or app subscriptions. I'm not complaining by the way, different generations have different struggles. I can tell you without any doubt that the joy I get from having kids and grandkids is greater than any return on investment seen in the traditional sense.

Then there is another angle, at some point in the future you will leave work and retire, and then what? You'll travel the world and do things as a couple - great, a worthy way of seeing out your days, something deserved and earned. However at some point one of you will pass and then without that family, without the kids and grandkids (and great grandkids) life will be lonely.

Family is everything, gather the biggest one around you that you can - it pays off in the end. And as for todays expense, you'll find a way.

This seems really ignorant of modern housing and childcare costs.

Interesting take, when my eldest was just about walking and went out with my wife pre-school, she didn't have the 20p needed to turn a ride outside a shop on. We had a rental that was that damp it nearly killed him and he needed hospital treatment, he manages asthma to this day. Childcare costs are nothing new and as I have two granddaughters and a regular conversation about nursery costs and how many days my wife needs to have the kids for (one day each at the moment with the other set of grandparents having them 1 each every other week as well).

I'm not at the sharp edge of childcare costs obviously but am far from ignorant of them. I could accuse you of being ignorant to childcare costs in the 70s, 80s and 90s. The rosy picture of us all being able to afford everything back in the day, and our parents even more (my MIL had a council house, 3 kids and an absent father which meant she worked three jobs and had to rely on the eldest babysitting the youngest when she couldn't get a neighbour to have them) is simply rose tinted view on the olden days.
Reply
#19
(10-30-2026, 12:32 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 12:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 11:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When you talk about cost Bertie you appear to be equating kids to an expense, something that will drain you of your funds with no return. Would it be better if you looked on the money spent on your kids as an investment with a non-financial return. I'm approaching 60 now and had kids young and there were times when we had nothing left at the end of a pay check, these were the days before the costs of phones or TV subscription or app subscriptions. I'm not complaining by the way, different generations have different struggles. I can tell you without any doubt that the joy I get from having kids and grandkids is greater than any return on investment seen in the traditional sense.

Then there is another angle, at some point in the future you will leave work and retire, and then what? You'll travel the world and do things as a couple - great, a worthy way of seeing out your days, something deserved and earned. However at some point one of you will pass and then without that family, without the kids and grandkids (and great grandkids) life will be lonely.

Family is everything, gather the biggest one around you that you can - it pays off in the end. And as for todays expense, you'll find a way.

This seems really ignorant of modern housing and childcare costs.

Interesting take, when my eldest was just about walking and went out with my wife pre-school, she didn't have the 20p needed to turn a ride outside a shop on. We had a rental that was that damp it nearly killed him and he needed hospital treatment, he manages asthma to this day. Childcare costs are nothing new and as I have two granddaughters and a regular conversation about nursery costs and how many days my wife needs to have the kids for (one day each at the moment with the other set of grandparents having them 1 each every other week as well).

I'm not at the sharp edge of childcare costs obviously but am far from ignorant of them. I could accuse you of being ignorant to childcare costs in the 70s, 80s and 90s. The rosy picture of us all being able to afford everything back in the day, and our parents even more (my MIL had a council house, 3 kids and an absent father which meant she worked three jobs and had to rely on the eldest babysitting the youngest when she couldn't get a neighbour to have them) is simply rose tinted view on the olden days.

Your first paragraph has confirmed that you're ignorant of modern housing costs. Do you want to look at the inflation adjusted rental and house prices in the 1970s, 80s and 90s vs today? Housing costs for under 40s equate to been a third and half of post-tax income these days depending on where people live, it was less than 10% in the 1970s. It is a catastrophic problem and is a huge reason why the age of first time parents keep slipping later and later for the couples that want to have kids.

Your second paragraph seems to completely ignore the dynamic of modern working patterns. How am I and my partner supposed to get our parents to look after young children when they're also both working full time and her parents don't live near us? And I'm fortunate to live near my parents, most of my friends live in London for work and they don't have that, what are they supposed to do? Move back to the Midlands away from their jobs? Informal childcare provisions are much rarer now because of our modern economy and working patterns. And childcare costs have massively outstripped wage growth and inflation, it was up 60% between 2010 and 2020 alone, I believe only the Swiss have more expensive childcare provisions in Europe and we're about 4 times more expensive than Denmark.
Reply
#20
The best we can do, as parents, is try and teach them the value of money and not fall into the trap of trying to give them "everything I never had". I was brought up poor, but happy, and never had the latest trainers or shit, but, it never bothered me because I saw how hard my mom n dad worked and they took the time to explain to me why they couldn't afford it. My dad would work 6-6 in the week, 6-12 on Saturday, then still take me to the match. That time was more precious than money and I've tried to do the same with my daughter. She never got spoiled financially, even if we could afford it, but she did get our time, and she has turned into a wonderful young woman. She works full time and saves like a squirrel. Loves to shop in charity shops and never falls for the latest trends. Upshot is she has more cash in her savings at 18 than I had in my 30's.
Too many parents, in trying to be the "best parent ever" create the impression that everything is instant and disposable and that attitude becomes hard to shake once they reach adulthood and ends up seeing them in debt just to have the latest phone, car, clothes etc. yet without a penny to their name.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)