Isaac Price
#11
(10-13-2026, 05:42 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He's been with us for one full season. And in that full season the whole team fell off a cliff, not just Price. Harsh to say that is a consistent trend!

Exactly and during that period he was used as a right winger, a right wing back, a central midfielder, and he was flogged for 90 minutes in league and cup and for NI.

Price has very good all this season, the rest of the team has not performed.

If we continue to play Price on the left, he will continue to contribute. We just need to be more dynamic, and more clinical as right now we are struggling as a team to create anything of note.
Reply
#12
'all season' after 9 league games tickles me!

Your general point is bang on, though.
Reply
#13
The rest of the team have not performed makes me laugh.
I think O’Leary, Styles and Diakate might have something to say about that also Mepham and Campbell.
Reply
#14
These threads are always a bit odd. When performances are poor we always expect our better players to be betterer. I'm more interested in the shitter players being less shit.

Nat Phillips is well up my list of spacegoats just now, having cost us two defeats in two matches. Alarmingly caught out of position several times, mostly rescued by O'Leary but eventually conceding a penalty. He seems to combine Bartley's slow reactions and lack of mobility with Ajayi's lack of concentration. He must be a nightmare to play alongside. Campbell must step in tonight with Mepham, shirley? It's interesting that Phillips doesn't get the armband when Campbell isn't playing. A sign of his mental fragility?
Reply
#15
Interesting choice tonight. Does he go with Phillips to combat Kiefer Moores aerial ability? I'd be tempted to drop him after recent displays
Reply
#16
I think the Phillips spacegoating is a little OTT IMO.

Against Wolves, yes it was an error but for me Molumby deserves just as much blame for the hospital pass back across him. The team know Phillips isn’t a ball player, putting him under pressure in that position was idiotic. A better MC turns and plays the ball forward, but Molumby sold his man short.

Against a Blues it wasn’t a penalty for me. It’s a fleeting moment of contact that happens week in, week out. I doubt 90% of similar situations will result in a pen this season and that’s being generous.

Phillips has been fine this season, but the whole defensive set up from front to back needs massive improvement. It’s very lazy to just blame the CB when the rest of the team are conceding too many chances. If it wasn’t for MOL we’d be in the bottom 4-5 positions.
Reply
#17
I'm guilty of spacegoating Phillips. I genuinely believe he isn't very good and that we'd be better off dropping him, but dropping him won't suddenly make us more defensively sound - that requires a collective team effort.

I don't particularly blame him for the Wolves defeat. We were so poor as a team that day we could easily have lost 5-0. That said, if he doesn't fuck up, do we just ride our luck and nick a point?

I'm more concerned about the other goals we've conceded. Re-watching goals conceded it's often Phillips' man reacting quicker to a save or block, or him losing his marker positionally. He's at fault for more goals and chances than people talk about.

He's great at heading and blocking, but his positional IQ is low. He obviously can't pass, but he's a centre-back - I'm not going to criticise a defender for lacking on ball ability when that isn't their primary job.
Reply
#18
Third least goals conceded in the league so far this season.
Reply
#19
(10-13-2026, 02:45 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think the Phillips spacegoating is a little OTT IMO.

Against Wolves, yes it was an error but for me Molumby deserves just as much blame for the hospital pass back across him. The team know Phillips isn’t a ball player, putting him under pressure in that position was idiotic. A better MC turns and plays the ball forward, but Molumby sold his man short.

Against a Blues it wasn’t a penalty for me. It’s a fleeting moment of contact that happens week in, week out. I doubt 90% of similar situations will result in a pen this season and that’s being generous.

Phillips has been fine this season, but the whole defensive set up from front to back needs massive improvement. It’s very lazy to just blame the CB when the rest of the team are conceding too many chances. If it wasn’t for MOL we’d be in the bottom 4-5 positions.

I read this critique of Molumby at the time, so I watched the highlights very carefully. Phillips had every opportunity to meet the ball and either carry it through a gap between the two Wolves players or clear it. Instead he backed away in horror, leaving himself nowhere to go. Even then his back pass could have been played wide instead of across the goal. Molumby's error was in not realising how shit Phillips is in possession of the ball. Molumby himself had a Wolves player on his back - Phillips could and should have helped him out. I suppose whenever Jayse plays it's his fault. FACT.

I'm in the Josh camp on this subject, Phillips really isn't very good.
Reply
#20
(10-13-2026, 02:53 PM)MGalea Wrote: Third least goals conceded in the league so far this season.

Yep. On course to let in 46 goals this season, only 1 team did better than that last season and that was Coventry with 45 goals conceded.

The defence is not the issue. Phillips is a solid championship defender, one of three that we have.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: