Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-06-2026, 02:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (10-06-2026, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.
Why would they? I asked Jenny Davis out 3 times before I got the message 40-odd years ago.
Maybe Israel has got the message. October 7th seemed to ram it home.
It is remarkable that even after that you think Israel would want to come to the negotiating table.
Do you honestly think Israel slaughtering Palestinian men, women and children every single day indefinitely while keeping them in bantustans is a solution? Israel either needs to give the Palestinians a state and that means full control over all borders in including air and sea as opposed to what happened to Gaza airport post withdrawal, or they need to give all Palestinians full Israeli citizenship. Which, considering they are already very demographically anxious about the Arab-Israelis/48 Palestinians they will never ever do.
In your many, many cries of "What should Israel do?", you never seem to understand how much worse things are for Israel on the international stage as a direct result of their actions. Jordan is pretty much the only Arab country to make peace with Israel and attempt to have a working relationship with them. Yet only last week said "No one in this Assembly should assume its ambitions stop at Palestine. This Israeli government's expansionist appetite is now a regional threat. And today, Syria is the warning the international community is choosing not to see,"
Israel's entire policy is that everything will stay the same, but that really isn't the case. They also have increasingly stupid and deranged people near the levers of power who will sooner or later do something as foolish as attack Turkey. The fact they directly egged on the US attacking Iran will also not have gone unnoticed, either.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(10-06-2026, 02:43 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-06-2026, 02:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (10-06-2026, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.
Why would they?
Realpolitik.
(10-06-2026, 01:56 PM)Jacko Wrote: (10-06-2026, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Who passed the German Emergency Acts, which Civillian Authority amended the German constitution? Pretty sure it wasn't the Allies. Did you bother to look up the Deutschlandvertrag when West German sovereignty and independence was formally established and accepted by the allies, which is why I referred to 1952? Reserved powers were not used by the allies in West Germany beyond that date. And I brought up Canada because it was functionally independent and sovereign after 1931, not 1982 when reserved powers that Westminster held but were never used were removed. And you have decided to assert that control over foreign troop movements under NATO command implies occupation ergo making that implication again.
And 6 months to form power structures with no transitional support to enforce control is not a transition. The PA being overthrown didn't happen overnight, did it? South Africa took four years to transition out of Apartheid, Eastern Croatia took 3 years and both of those had a formal transition of power to establish democratic legitimatacy.
Who passed the Emergency Acts? West Germany, they were forced to pass them because the Allies held reserved powers over them. The Deutschlandvertrag explicitly stated in Article 5 that Allied reserved intervention powers would remain active until West Germany passed internal emergency laws satisfactory to the Allies. Passing those acts was the literal price the Allies demanded to relinquish that specific piece of occupation authority, it took Bonn 23 years to comply.
You like a question, so here's mine, if West Germany became fully sovereign in 1952, why did the USA, UK, France, and USSR have to sign the Two Plus Four Treaty in 1990 to explicitly "terminate their rights and responsibilities in relation to Berlin and Germany as a whole" and restore full sovereignty?
Your Canada Strawman, the 51 year delay was down to internal Canadian politics, Britain wasn't asserting imperial control, the best way to describe the situation is we were the benign custodian of their constitution until such a time they could come to an agreement internally. It's just not comparable to the conditions Germany were under between 1952/55 and 1990. We had no international veto power over Canada, we didn't place thousands of troops in Ottawa to ensure compliance. It's a bad faith argument.
I also never asserted that NATO command itself implies occupation, so stop putting words in my mouth. Modern NATO members voluntarily host foreign forces under standard bilateral agreements that they can terminate at will. West Germany did not have that choice. Conflating standard NATO stationing with retained Allied occupation rights is just another attempt to blur the reality of the situation.
Back to Gaza, these goalposts are covering some ground. You went from claiming the PA was given "no warning" and told "here's the keys" to now arguing that 20 months of notice plus 2 full years on the ground wasn't enough time because "South Africa took four years." For the record, South Africa is another Strawman and false equivalence.
Claiming the PA had "no transitional support" is another easily disproved claim. Presumably you've heard of the USSC? They and international allies spent millions training, equipping, and structuring PA security forces starting in 2005. The PA had international backing, billions in aid, US training, and tens of thousands of armed personnel.
They didn't lose power in Gaza because they lacked time, notice, or training. They lost because Hamas was better armed, more ruthless, and defeated them in a civil war that lasted less than a week, I've no idea how many times this needs to be reiterated? A four-year "negotiated transition" written down, wouldn't have changed the firepower on the ground in 2007, it's pie in the sky to think it would now in the West Bank. The people that you are suggesting the Israelis should be at the table with are being propped up by the IDF to survive. Make it make sense.
Because East Germany was completely separate and West Berlin was not a de-jure part of West Germany.
The Deutschlandvertrag also explicitly stated that West Germany was now a sovereign and independent nation no longer under occupation. Which, you know, is my point? If you want to play a game of legal bullshit then you'd best not ignore the foundational document establishing West German sovereignty that clearly outlines the end of the occupation of West Germany. That is why West Germany was able to amend their constitution, occupied countries cannot legislate to amend their constitutional frameworks as they're under occupation. That is why I brought up Canada which was functionally independent and no longer a dominion or colony despite Westminster retaining reserved powers.
And do you read everything literally? Have you heard of hyperbole? Do you seriously think that the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza involved then literally handing keys over? Fucking hell man, learn to read subtext, the point is that the PA were not able to establish control via established structures to enable a transition to a consolidated administration and that is what created a power vacuum which is what Hamas exploited. Coups happen because there is a power vacuum that is being exploited. It doesn't matter if you are armed if you're not transitioned into power, control and power isn't to have fucking weapons.
And I don't think you know what a straw man is. You can't straw man yourself. Giving examples of things is not a straw man. I'll give you an example of a straw man, for the record, you deliberately distorting what I'm saying about not enough time to establish control and governance by quoting out of context.
Panic, deflection and pedantry. Sometimes it's easier to just accept you're wrong and bow out. The future prospects for a two-state solution are not at all analogous to Germany and France after WW2. I've dismantled your argument at every turn and you have shifted the goalposts or introduced further non-analogous examples that I have also dismantled. You must love shoe.
Shouting 'hyperbole' when your claims about Israel's withdrawal get pulled apart and shown to be clearly false isn't an argument.
I'm going to go through it again, if you want you can imagine me reading it to you very slowly.
First, on Germany: the 1952 Convention on Relations as amended by the 1954 Paris Protocols only granted conditional sovereignty, because Articles 2, 4, and 5 explicitly reserved Allied rights over Berlin, foreign troop stationing, emergency protection of those forces, and "Germany as a whole" (meaning reunification required Four Power agreement). Furthermore, Allied emergency intervention rights regarding force security lapsed only once West Germany passed the 1968 Emergency Acts. Bonn couldn't end that limit on its own terms, but only by legislating in the form the treaty specified.
A country where foreign military powers retain emergency intervention rights, maintain West Berlin under Allied occupation status, and hold legal authority over national reunification is not fully sovereign in practice. That is precisely why Article 7 of the 1990 Two Plus Four Treaty had to explicitly terminate Four Power rights and responsibilities in relation to Berlin and Germany as a whole. If West Germany had complete, unconstrained sovereignty in 1955, the 1990 treaty wouldn't have been needed to terminate those reserved rights.
Second, on Gaza: hiding behind "it was hyperbole" after getting caught presenting a completely false timeline about Israel's withdrawal is convenient.
You claim the PA couldn't establish control because they were "not transitioned into power." This is revisionist history. The PA had been administering parts of Gaza since 1994 and maintained the civil service, ministries, and an official security apparatus of over 40,000 armed personnel, backed by international aid and USSC logistical support.
Hamas didn't seize Gaza because of an administrative "power vacuum" or a lack of paper transition protocols. They launched a violent military takeover, executed PA commanders, and routed security forces in a week of bloody street fighting. Claiming that weapons, tactical ruthlessness, and military force don't dictate control during an armed civil war is completely detached from how power works in the real world.
Finally, regarding your South Africa comparison and why I said it was a Strawman: you pretended I claimed two years is enough time to build a fully mature democracy, and then proceeded to knock that down by pointing out South Africa took four years to negotiate a political settlement, completely ignoring the reality of what happened in Gaza. South Africa was a negotiated political transition; Gaza ended in an armed civil war. So which of us doesn't know what a Strawman is?
Posts: 6,717
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(10-06-2026, 02:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (10-06-2026, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.
Why would they? I asked Jenny Davis out 3 times before I got the message 40-odd years ago.
Maybe Israel has got the message. October 7th seemed to ram it home.
It is remarkable that even after that you think Israel would want to come to the negotiating table.
She did have good tits did Jenny.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(10-06-2026, 05:11 PM)Squid Wrote: (10-06-2026, 02:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (10-06-2026, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Israeli government have not come to the table since Olmert.
Why would they? I asked Jenny Davis out 3 times before I got the message 40-odd years ago.
Maybe Israel has got the message. October 7th seemed to ram it home.
It is remarkable that even after that you think Israel would want to come to the negotiating table.
Do you honestly think Israel slaughtering Palestinian men, women and children every single day indefinitely while keeping them in bantustans is a solution?
No.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Some of the posts in this thread, who honestly has that much time to Google things in order to make themselves feel knowledgeable on a message board. Jeeeeeez
Posts: 17,071
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
May i interject, there is no workable solution, there never will be during our lifetime. I doubt even our kids or their kids will see peace in the area.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(10-06-2026, 03:01 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (10-06-2026, 11:27 AM)Protheroet Wrote: Anyway, back to the OP. How about those nasty Greens? Who'd have thought allowing entryists into the party would breed rampant extremism. That hasn't happened under a populist left wing leader before has it? Oh....
When you talk of entryism what you are actually describing is a quadrupling of its membership in a year. Who would have thought that political parties would seek to increase the number of people who support it. Maybe the Conservatives are the exception with shadow ministers making speeches in front of half empty conference halls, and that’s being generous.
The problem with the Greens is they are too loose with their internal procedures. To get to vote on this motion all you need to do was buy a ticket for that particular session of the conference where the vote takes place. Even more alarming is that motions passed by conference become party policy. It's easy to see how a small determined group could get their particular hobby horse policy adopted as party policy.
Worth noting that approximately 0.5% of the membership voted in favour of this motion. I hope and expect this motion to be reversed at the Spring conference.
But it remains the case that whilst this motion remains party policy I would find it difficult to vote Green. Just as well that I don't live in Holborn and St Pancras, not sure I would be going to the polling station
When I talk of entryism, this is what I'm getting at:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckm23709pjz7o
Just as the Greens become remotely electable they let people like this in, and with their deranged constitution allow her motion to become Party policy.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(10-07-2026, 06:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (10-06-2026, 03:01 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (10-06-2026, 11:27 AM)Protheroet Wrote: Anyway, back to the OP. How about those nasty Greens? Who'd have thought allowing entryists into the party would breed rampant extremism. That hasn't happened under a populist left wing leader before has it? Oh....
When you talk of entryism what you are actually describing is a quadrupling of its membership in a year. Who would have thought that political parties would seek to increase the number of people who support it. Maybe the Conservatives are the exception with shadow ministers making speeches in front of half empty conference halls, and that’s being generous.
The problem with the Greens is they are too loose with their internal procedures. To get to vote on this motion all you need to do was buy a ticket for that particular session of the conference where the vote takes place. Even more alarming is that motions passed by conference become party policy. It's easy to see how a small determined group could get their particular hobby horse policy adopted as party policy.
Worth noting that approximately 0.5% of the membership voted in favour of this motion. I hope and expect this motion to be reversed at the Spring conference.
But it remains the case that whilst this motion remains party policy I would find it difficult to vote Green. Just as well that I don't live in Holborn and St Pancras, not sure I would be going to the polling station
When I talk of entryism, this is what I'm getting at:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckm23709pjz7o
Just as the Greens become remotely electable they let people like this in, and with their deranged constitution allow her motion to become Party policy.
Come on proth are you trying to tell me that other parties have party members that they would prefer not to have . When you have a party membership that is in the tens of thousands it is inevitable that some of your members are going to be undesirable... some of them go on to be elected representatives of the party, hello jared.
I preferred the slow but sure growth that the Greens were enjoying under previous leaders, rather than this explosion in membership that the party has experienced under Polanski's leadership. I think there is a decent chance that unless things change that the Greens have less MPs after the next GE than they do now. But highlighting individual members and trying to say that they are typical of all members is facile politics.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(10-07-2026, 08:44 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Come on proth are you trying to tell me that other parties have party members that they would prefer not to have . When you have a party membership that is in the tens of thousands it is inevitable that some of your members are going to be undesirable... some of them go on to be elected representatives of the party, hello jared.
I preferred the slow but sure growth that the Greens were enjoying under previous leaders, rather than this explosion in membership that the party has experienced under Polanski's leadership. I think there is a decent chance that unless things change that the Greens have less MPs after the next GE than they do now. But highlighting individual members and trying to say that they are typical of all members is facile politics.
The growth in the Greens membership is entirely down to a populist position on Israel, and an insane populist position on things like rent controls and wealth taxes.
I can make a very strong guess that the many in that number have exactly the same views and are in many cases exactly the same people that caused the EHRC to investigate Labour under Corbyn.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-04-2026, 08:01 PM)Øssian Wrote: It’s taken decades for green politics to shake off at least some its lunatic fringe reputation and to have acquired some respectable level of representation and a coherent voice; Polanski seems determined to turn back the clock. It’s exasperating for somebody whose priorities should naturally align with those of The Green Party, but mostly don’t.
I can’t be arsed going into chapter and verse, any more than anyone else would want to be arsed reading it (yet again!), but when our own Natural History Museum’s study ranks the UK just outside the bottom 20% in terms of its global biodiversity index (and if you removed Scotland we’d be in the bottom decile) it’s pretty clear the messages aren’t landing.
By the way, biodiversity isn't fluffy, it's anything but: it's habitat erosion, species loss, fire, flood, food security, you name it... Polanski seems completely tone deaf.
With increasingly unnatural weather patterns and energy volatility, now would actually be a great time for a properly Green party to try and shift the Overton Window towards making actual changes. We need the Green Party to be the Green Party as opposed to a Labour alternative.
|